Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell her to piss off

134 replies

Neuroillogical · 10/01/2023 19:17

Apologies in advance for the rant…

In the supermarket with family. DH leaves store to nip across the road in car for extra bits while we finish shop.

He goes to inch out of parking space only to discover random lady was in his blind spot walking to the store with her trolley. Warning sensors beeped - he stopped immediately. Said lady then proceeds to bang on the window and demand he get out and speak to her and a whole shit show of drama ensues.

She claims he ‘touched her hip with car’ and threatens to call police. HIGHLY unlikely for various reasons but DH apologetic anyway/asked if she was ok/does she need anything. DH is a ppl pleaser (unlike me 😌) & being nice only seemed to spur her on. She gives him long lecture about how to drive(he drives for a living). Then demands to see disabled badge b/cos he doesn’t ‘look disabled’. (It was a disabled + parent child bay). Then accuses him of lying about having kids. (DH explains they are in store so she asks to see the car seats!!)

Anyway she starts taking pics of car, number plate (and DH!!!) for ´evidence’. Says she isn’t hurt in any way but she doesn’t feel DH apology is sufficient or sincere. He asks how he can resolve & she says it’s up to him to ´convince her he’s sorry’. Repeatedly threatening to call police. DH offers to call them himself & as soon as he dials she disappears off into the shop. Erm ok.

We reunite & he tells me what happened. By this point DH is shaken (he’s a nervous guy) & starts to worry he is going to be in some sort of trouble if she makes an accusation at a later date. As luck would have it we bump into her later at the exit & she is with a manager. She starts CRYING & saying she needs to be escorted to her car b/cos she was run over & is scared of DH. WTH!!

My thoughts-

  1. She’s a drama queen
  2. Even if and it’s a big IF DH brushed her with car(more likely she was startled) she is equally responsible for walking in a cars blind spot in the dark in the middle of a car park (and not on the designated walkway). also it’s an SUV and she was about 5 ft 2 on a good day
  3. She wasn’t hurt so should have accepted apology and left it. If she was so tramautised & outraged she would have called police -not done her weekly shop after
  4. She is outrageous for demanding proof of disability/children. It’s irrelevant and rude. (Ironically all our children and myself are actually disabled). She is neither the owner of the car park or J.Sainsbury.
  5. she is a chancer who I suspect was hoping for an offer of cash or something similar (which is also why I think she complained to manager) Gift card anyone??

Anyway, I got tired of seeing DH grovelling to her so I may/may not have told her where to stick her trolley. 😏

Interested to know how other people would have handled it..

OP posts:
ReformedWaywardTeen · 11/01/2023 11:44

Eyerollcentral · 11/01/2023 10:52

This is a load of absolute nonsense. The police won’t and can’t record NO INJURY. They can only say doesn’t appear to be injured. The police aren’t qualified to say whether she is injured or not. Also ambulance chasers? Give me strength, do you know what minuscule amount of compensation people get now to deal with minor injuries? No one is chasing this injury. The one thing you are correct about is that the OP should inform her insurer as technically she is obliged to under the terms of her policy

Did you intend to come across as patronising?

No win no fee lawyers don't care whether the claim is valid or high paying, they get paid regardless.

I also meant the police would have a log showing they were aware of her suggestions of having been injured but none seen and no ambulance requested.

The fact that the only log of this incident is the CF taking photos of her DHs car, and her verbal bullshit to the store manager puts them at risk of her lies. She already got the manager on side enough to walk her to her vehicle. I know categorically she will take this further, because my Gran used to do things like this all the time, and she earned money several times and would brag how it paid for her holiday. She would find a patch of slippery stuff on a supermarket floor and seeing no sign she would "slip" and claim. It caused me embarrassment to the point I wouldn't go out with her as she would parrot "where there's blame there's a claim".

Eyerollcentral · 11/01/2023 10:54

JustMaggie · 11/01/2023 07:15

OP says the lady was walking to the store with her trolley, so if he did hit anything while reversing out of his spot it would have been her trolley and not her hip.

How do you know it would have been her trolley not her hip? You are assuming that the lady had just started to cross the back of the vehicle. Doesn’t appear that even the OP DH has denied that was the case. Clearly he hasn’t looked over his shoulder before reversing. The OP DH’s word isn’t any more reliable than the pedestrian’s here.

Eyerollcentral · 11/01/2023 10:52

ReformedWaywardTeen · 11/01/2023 06:53

Sounds like a scam to get a payout, especially including the store manager as she did on the way out. You/your DH should have called Police anyway, it's telling that she didn't ring them and walked away when he dialed. Smacks of she knew it was bullshit and knew the police would offer advice and go on their way and you would've had a record of no injury occurred.
By not contacting police, you are in danger of her going to one of those abhorrent ambulance chaser style claims people. It may be an idea to alert your car insurance company.

This is a load of absolute nonsense. The police won’t and can’t record NO INJURY. They can only say doesn’t appear to be injured. The police aren’t qualified to say whether she is injured or not. Also ambulance chasers? Give me strength, do you know what minuscule amount of compensation people get now to deal with minor injuries? No one is chasing this injury. The one thing you are correct about is that the OP should inform her insurer as technically she is obliged to under the terms of her policy

CockSpadget · 11/01/2023 10:23

JustMaggie · 11/01/2023 07:15

OP says the lady was walking to the store with her trolley, so if he did hit anything while reversing out of his spot it would have been her trolley and not her hip.

Unless she was already well behind the car when he started reversing.

vivainsomnia · 11/01/2023 09:17

We reunite & he tells me what happened
It doesn't sound at all that he told you how it exactly happened! Her telling him that she's not injured but insist on an apology after he apologised a few times already? Doesn't sound credible at all. I expect his interpretation of the event is very different to what hers would be.

It happened, no big deal, you move on.

Dogscanteatonions · 11/01/2023 08:28

She sounds like a nightmare and after some kind of compensation.

However the onus is always on the driver to take as much care as possible, no amount of 'they should have been looking where they're going' is going to repair damage to a human body. Also any decent driver reverses into parking spaces. It is so much safer. Pedestrians in carparks are preoccupied, there are small kids around, trollies being pushed, other cars not necessarily posting enough attention etc etc.

etc

EatYourVegetables · 11/01/2023 07:57

@Neuroillogical I am not 5ft2, but neither do I make fun of people who are. I am however allergic to bad SUV drivers and their arrogance.

hoppityscotch · 11/01/2023 07:25

She was probably quite shocked and scared and it took her a while to calm down. I don't think telling her where to shove her trolley or whatever would have helped. So YABU for that. But it does sound like she was over reacting a bit - but we don't know her history, maybe she has been hit by a car before and it triggered her.

Coffeecreme · 11/01/2023 07:22

i would keep an eye on your local facebook communty page

daybroke · 11/01/2023 07:20

I would ring the police and report it now just in case and contact your insurance company too

IwtHs · 11/01/2023 07:18

I think she was after some $$$.

It may have genuinely shook her up but once she realised your DH was nervous and apologetic, she took advantage of that.

Keep an eye on your local newspaper!

JustMaggie · 11/01/2023 07:15

OP says the lady was walking to the store with her trolley, so if he did hit anything while reversing out of his spot it would have been her trolley and not her hip.

ElaOfSalisbury · 11/01/2023 07:02

I would have completely called her bluff. Phone the Police, they would likely call for an ambulance to check her over, checked CCTV, etc. Give her enough rope…If she is making it up or exaggerating, her lies would likely come out.
Agree she sounds like a possible chancer.

Coffeecreme · 11/01/2023 06:59

how was it resolved?
pretty bad that she took photos

EarringsandLipstick · 11/01/2023 06:57

DH should have got back in the car when she started her shit and reversed over her good and proper, really give ger something to complain about.

That's not even vaguely funny.

ReformedWaywardTeen · 11/01/2023 06:53

Sounds like a scam to get a payout, especially including the store manager as she did on the way out. You/your DH should have called Police anyway, it's telling that she didn't ring them and walked away when he dialed. Smacks of she knew it was bullshit and knew the police would offer advice and go on their way and you would've had a record of no injury occurred.
By not contacting police, you are in danger of her going to one of those abhorrent ambulance chaser style claims people. It may be an idea to alert your car insurance company.

noooope · 11/01/2023 06:47

My DH had an encounter with a cyclist last year where he signalled to turn left and as he was doing mid way, a cyclist overtook him from the right, went into the left into DH who was turning left where my DH nearly hit him as he was exiting the main road despite the cyclist being further back but as Dh slowed down to turn, the cyclist tried to overtake him turning to the left as well . DH immediately stopped and didn't touch the cyclist not even close, there's sensors everywhere, the cyclist stopped and hit DH's front bonnet with his hands and started to push his bike and forth into DH's car. Dh got out, went what the fuck. Cyclist shouting all sorts of abuse filming Dh with his phone, then Dh went and slapped his hand where the phone flew and got smashed into pieces., the cyclist was left shaking and backed off immediately and dh drove off and never heard from him. We looked at the dash cam footage and dh was more than a metre away from the cyclist when he stopped. It could have been a lot worse but you don't overtake a vehicle when his path is clear to turn and then jump infront of him into the turning into the same road.

When you apologise, people think they are right. When I'm in a supermarket I always look at reversing lights and stop for the car to pull out because I take personal responsibility and don't expect cars to take that responsibility for me even if it means I'm right but I'm in the blind spot and not every car has a parking cam and sensors. I've had few minor encounters in the past and when they start shouting abuse, I get out the car and shout back even if I'm not proud and then they back off. Your DH most likely nearly touched her trolley as her trolley would be in front of her anyway and she's trying her luck. Next time reverse park but don't apologise and most sensors will beep beep beep for warning and then beeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeep if you've touched. I always stop at the first beep and I'm sure your DH has anyway.

Coffeecreme · 11/01/2023 06:46

if he drives for a livng, he should hae reversed in
problem solved
i hate car parks in supermarkets

daisychain01 · 11/01/2023 06:32

Mountain out of a molehill.

The woman has not sustained any injury, your DH didn't touch her with the car and there is no tangible evidence.

i wouldn't add fuel to the fire by telling her to piss off, just let it go.

in this situation there is no need to report anything to your insurance company because it was a non-incident. If she tries to enact a claim, deal with it at the time by being firm that nothing happened and no damage or injury occurred to either the car or the woman.

Tell the truth and she will be the one to tie herself in knots over nothing.

RedHelenB · 11/01/2023 06:30

Mirroredlove · 10/01/2023 19:32

She isn’t responsible for walking in a cars blind spot, the driver should be checking the blind spot before moving.

Depends if he actually hit her. You don’t he didn’t so yabu.

This.

Feelingmehmehmeh · 11/01/2023 06:29

i never drive into spaces, always reverse in and drive out. It’s easier to park well that way too but shame we don’t all have old beetles with the engine in the back and the boot at the front

Namaste6 · 11/01/2023 06:25

Moral of story and biggest lesson OP - reverse park, always!

If she was still standing and able to rant off like that she sounds like a bunny boiler desperate for attention to me TBH.

Taking pics etc is totally irrelevant - no damage - no injury and no witnesses?

Tell your husband not to worry and in future, reverse park!

Feelingmehmehmeh · 11/01/2023 06:21

I had an incident in my 20s where I was edging out of my driveway and as I was looking to the right and inching out an older man walked in front and I only saw him as I looked left again. At this point he’s chosen to go in front of my car and then threw himself on my bonnet like I was going at least 30mph. Really upset me and shook me up. He said he was going to the police. Never heard anymore about it. Some people are just unhinged I’m afraid.

daybroke · 11/01/2023 06:12

Sorry "that's a breach of"

daybroke · 11/01/2023 05:58

I've genuinely never seen a combined child and parent and disabled space in a sainsburys car park in Ireland.

I must check this out on Thursday because I'd say that's a if European Union law and you and your DH would be advised to take legal advice on this.