Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell her to piss off

134 replies

Neuroillogical · 10/01/2023 19:17

Apologies in advance for the rant…

In the supermarket with family. DH leaves store to nip across the road in car for extra bits while we finish shop.

He goes to inch out of parking space only to discover random lady was in his blind spot walking to the store with her trolley. Warning sensors beeped - he stopped immediately. Said lady then proceeds to bang on the window and demand he get out and speak to her and a whole shit show of drama ensues.

She claims he ‘touched her hip with car’ and threatens to call police. HIGHLY unlikely for various reasons but DH apologetic anyway/asked if she was ok/does she need anything. DH is a ppl pleaser (unlike me 😌) & being nice only seemed to spur her on. She gives him long lecture about how to drive(he drives for a living). Then demands to see disabled badge b/cos he doesn’t ‘look disabled’. (It was a disabled + parent child bay). Then accuses him of lying about having kids. (DH explains they are in store so she asks to see the car seats!!)

Anyway she starts taking pics of car, number plate (and DH!!!) for ´evidence’. Says she isn’t hurt in any way but she doesn’t feel DH apology is sufficient or sincere. He asks how he can resolve & she says it’s up to him to ´convince her he’s sorry’. Repeatedly threatening to call police. DH offers to call them himself & as soon as he dials she disappears off into the shop. Erm ok.

We reunite & he tells me what happened. By this point DH is shaken (he’s a nervous guy) & starts to worry he is going to be in some sort of trouble if she makes an accusation at a later date. As luck would have it we bump into her later at the exit & she is with a manager. She starts CRYING & saying she needs to be escorted to her car b/cos she was run over & is scared of DH. WTH!!

My thoughts-

  1. She’s a drama queen
  2. Even if and it’s a big IF DH brushed her with car(more likely she was startled) she is equally responsible for walking in a cars blind spot in the dark in the middle of a car park (and not on the designated walkway). also it’s an SUV and she was about 5 ft 2 on a good day
  3. She wasn’t hurt so should have accepted apology and left it. If she was so tramautised & outraged she would have called police -not done her weekly shop after
  4. She is outrageous for demanding proof of disability/children. It’s irrelevant and rude. (Ironically all our children and myself are actually disabled). She is neither the owner of the car park or J.Sainsbury.
  5. she is a chancer who I suspect was hoping for an offer of cash or something similar (which is also why I think she complained to manager) Gift card anyone??

Anyway, I got tired of seeing DH grovelling to her so I may/may not have told her where to stick her trolley. 😏

Interested to know how other people would have handled it..

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
AnnieSnap · 12/01/2023 14:26

@Eyerollcentral 👏👏👏👏👏👏

Eyerollcentral · 12/01/2023 11:18

ToothHurtie · 12/01/2023 07:44

Hitting someone with your car and not realising even though you have parking sensors is definitely less likely than a scammer carrying out a known scam. Obviously.

Her behaviour is tell-tale of the scam.

  • no injury
  • doesn’t want police involved at the scene
  • Tried to get her version with a “witness”
  • Hysteria to cause fear and confusion
  • Gathering “evidence” that doesn’t prove anything
  • Refusing to accept an apology

The naive belief that no one lies about things is why so many idiots get scammed.

OMG, how many accidents do you think are caused by people reversing and not looking where they are going every day? It’s a HUGE amount. Of course it’s much more likely than a scam. Parking sensors are not a defence dear, neither are they infallible. You must check your blind spot before reversing.

Further, precisely none of your points above
‘proves’ anything. Please note:

  1. Parking sensors are a GUIDE. You cannot say well I didn’t bother checking there was no one behind me because I have parking sensors. The OP DH did not check his blind spot. You cannot rely on parking sensors
  2. The woman did not report an injury at the time. There is not a doctor on the planet who will say that means the woman is not injured. It is very common for muscular injuries in particular to only become apparent later.
  3. The police would not attend this incident. Plus how long do you think you would stand around waiting for them? This does not show anything. The police would only record what the parties say happened. They aren’t going to clamp irons on the woman and blue light her to an interrogation cell down the nick. A very bored officer just listens to the he said, she said, writes it down and more than likely cautions the OP DH that he must check his blind spot before reversing.
  4. By ‘witness’ do you mean the shop manager? He/she isn’t a witness, they didn’t see anything??? Was the OP DH’s trying to get a witness onside by telling her what happened?
  5. Hysteria!!!! What, telling someone they weren’t hit, they weren’t injured and to shove their trolley where the sun don’t shine? Oh that’s what the OP did. LOL. No one sounds afraid of this woman. They couldn’t possibly be confused either because she told the exact same thing to everyone she spoke to, that’s even according to the OP who admittedly isn’t the most reliable of narrators as she is DESPERATE for everyone to say her DH wasn’t at fault (he absolutely was) and this woman who was almost run down was on the make.
  6. What ‘evidence’? The woman was correct to take a picture of the registration of a car she says reversed in to her. I was a passenger in a car recently which glanced another car. Of course I got out and took copious pictures. That’s the sensible and sane thing to do.
  7. Refusing to accept an apology? M A D. What do you think this establishes? Impolite? Maybe. Depends how the ‘apology’ was made. Thrown in your face, called a liar and harangued by the OP? I wouldn’t accept it either.

It is without doubt FAR more likely that the OP DH did not look where he was going and reversed in to the woman. How do I know? Because the OP says he did not look.

The OP’s DH is very lucky he didn’t cause serious injury through his negligence. He could have easily killed this woman. You do realise you only have the OP’s second hand version of events on what happened. There is nothing to say the OP DH slammed on his brakes as soon as the sensors started. Far more likely again he stopped because he hit the woman - have you ever been in a car park reversing in a car w sensors? They start beeping as soon as you move, because there are obstacles all around you. I would be very upset if someone kept reversing an SUV in to me despite having the benefit of sensors, which I was likely able to hear, and I had to bang a back window to stop the moron killing me.

If we are going on flights of fancy (which you have), I would also say it’s much more likely the OP DH DOES know he hit the woman, that’s why a fully grown man was shaking and quivering until his bolshie wife turned up to try and shout her way out of the situation.

The naive one here is you. The woman hasn’t even made a claim for injury!!!! All the Miss Marples crowing on about well she was able to push a trolley round Sainsbury so CLEARLY wasn’t injured…I walked around on a broken bone for a week, I suspect many people have, doesn’t mean it wasn’t broken.

I don’t know how half the people on this thread get out of bed in the morning with all the SCAMS they must fear operating all around them, not to mention their total failure to apply any reasoning at all.

ToothHurtie · 12/01/2023 07:44

Eyerollcentral · 11/01/2023 22:30

You are right. Much more likely than a man reversing a big car in to a small woman when he hasn’t checked his blind spot. Call interpol

Hitting someone with your car and not realising even though you have parking sensors is definitely less likely than a scammer carrying out a known scam. Obviously.

Her behaviour is tell-tale of the scam.

  • no injury
  • doesn’t want police involved at the scene
  • Tried to get her version with a “witness”
  • Hysteria to cause fear and confusion
  • Gathering “evidence” that doesn’t prove anything
  • Refusing to accept an apology

The naive belief that no one lies about things is why so many idiots get scammed.

Dowhahdiddy · 12/01/2023 00:52

Definitely a scam, she wanted money from your DH.

Eyerollcentral · 11/01/2023 22:30

Chickenly · 11/01/2023 22:22

Do you live in a land where people can’t lie? That’s the entire premise of the scam…

You are right. Much more likely than a man reversing a big car in to a small woman when he hasn’t checked his blind spot. Call interpol

Chickenly · 11/01/2023 22:22

Coffeecreme · 11/01/2023 22:20

She claims he ‘touched her hip with car’ @Chickenly

Do you live in a land where people can’t lie? That’s the entire premise of the scam…

Coffeecreme · 11/01/2023 22:20

She claims he ‘touched her hip with car’ @Chickenly

Chickenly · 11/01/2023 21:53

Coffeecreme · 11/01/2023 21:47

that is an american link.
anyway, he did hit, or at least, touch her, with his car.

So what if it’s an American link? It’s still a known scam.

How do you know she was hit?

Coffeecreme · 11/01/2023 21:47

that is an american link.
anyway, he did hit, or at least, touch her, with his car.

Chickenly · 11/01/2023 21:42

www.cbsnews.com/amp/newyork/news/you-hit-me-scam-alert/#app

It’s a scam.

Willyoujustbequiet · 11/01/2023 21:37

The blind spot is his responsibility not hers, don't be ridiculous and stop making excuses.

RunnerBum · 11/01/2023 21:33

I’ve only skimmed the thread so sorry if this has already been said but I couldn’t spot it. I’d be shocked if it hasn’t though.

This is a pretty well-known scam. You need to contact the police, your insurance and the store. Ask the store for CCTV footage. Tell the police and insurance that she walked behind your vehicle after it began moving, you did not speed up and slowed down when you saw her and that you did not, at all, make contact with her at any stage - and she confirmed that she was uninjured.

Dailydripfed · 11/01/2023 21:27

Interesting to see how many people think a ‘genuine’ apology is a £20 note 😂

user1473878824 · 11/01/2023 18:10

Parrotid · 10/01/2023 20:15

A very similar thing happened to me. The woman concerned was very uppity and i think thought I’d back down as she accused me of hitting her car. I hadn’t. Not even a bit. And there was literally nothing to see. She got out and said she was going to take photos. I said I would too then, and told her to
smile as I was filming her. I admit I got a bit excited and was all “that’s right love, turn to me, straight into the camera, now, look away into the distance, ohhh lovely.” I was also laughing. She told me to fuck off and I laughed harder, and said I was going now, but if there was any damage to my car when I got back, we would all know who did it. And laughed more. Bullying bitch.

You’re clearly the very nasty bully in this story.

daisychain01 · 11/01/2023 18:06

ElaOfSalisbury · 11/01/2023 07:02

I would have completely called her bluff. Phone the Police, they would likely call for an ambulance to check her over, checked CCTV, etc. Give her enough rope…If she is making it up or exaggerating, her lies would likely come out.
Agree she sounds like a possible chancer.

You are kidding!!

This is a non event and you're advising someone to ring the Police and possibly get the emergency services involved.

unbelievable.

AnnieSnap · 11/01/2023 16:44

@Eyerollcentral you know this is mumsnet, so they won’t listen. Anyone who disagrees will be ‘wrong’ and told to f*ck off. There are a lot of very aggressive (behind their keyboard), intolerant people on here, who appear to be unable reflect on experiences of views that don’t match their own. Replies to this post will, I expect illustrate that.

Eyerollcentral · 11/01/2023 14:42

Kennykenkencat · 11/01/2023 14:13

What’s interesting to me is the leaps people are willing to make here. This woman may well be a chancer but equally she could be entirely truthful. Tbf to her as well she hasn’t indicated she has any intention of pursuing a claim

What do you think the “doesn’t feel the apology is sufficient or sincere” actually meant.

She was after cash and because the Dh didn’t open his wallet then she went to see what she could get from the Supermarket.

I know people like this. Will try anything on to get something from someone

Well given the OP’s interaction with her tbh it doesn’t scream a genuine apology to me. It sounds like she was told nothing happened and she was a liar. As I say maybe she is a chancer but statistically speaking it’s much more likely she wasn’t. What on earth could she possibly get from the supermarket?

EcoChica1980 · 11/01/2023 14:29

Remind her that the whole thing is very likely to be on CCTV so if she thinks the video will back up her account she should
knock her self out and call the police. Then tell her to go f herself

Kennykenkencat · 11/01/2023 14:13

What’s interesting to me is the leaps people are willing to make here. This woman may well be a chancer but equally she could be entirely truthful. Tbf to her as well she hasn’t indicated she has any intention of pursuing a claim

What do you think the “doesn’t feel the apology is sufficient or sincere” actually meant.

She was after cash and because the Dh didn’t open his wallet then she went to see what she could get from the Supermarket.

I know people like this. Will try anything on to get something from someone

daybroke · 11/01/2023 13:34

@Kennykenkencat because the op says she not the uk and the only other country that has sainsburys is Ireland?

Eyerollcentral · 11/01/2023 13:18

Kennykenkencat · 11/01/2023 12:54

My thoughts exactly

Reminds me of when a woman in a car had stopped to let a young guy cross the road and the guy crossing them through himself onto her bonnet and rolled onto the road and was rolling around like he had been injured
The woman got out of the car and started shouting how she had a dash cam so he got up and ran away

There are some people who will do anything if they think they can get a few quid off you.

Eh??? The example in this thread is absolutely nothing like the example you have given??? The circumstances are entirely different.
What’s interesting to me is the leaps people are willing to make here. This woman may well be a chancer but equally she could be entirely truthful. Tbf to her as well she hasn’t indicated she has any intention of pursuing a claim.
I think it’s telling the OP hasn’t responded re the age of the woman. I might be totally wrong but this sounds very much to me like she was an older woman. Most older people, especially women who typically suffer from low bone density at a higher rate as they age, are cautious about falls and accidents because the effect on them is hugely different to that on a younger person. Even if this person was younger, ok they caused a bit of a fuss but some people are sensitive, most people in society can’t turn on the waterworks at the drop of a hat and wouldn’t dream of it for the sake of a few quid. I am astounded by the OP’s reaction. Maybe she genuinely did want a real apology from your husband.

CalishataFolkart · 11/01/2023 12:58

Starlitestarbright · 10/01/2023 20:59

  1. Your dh is a shit driver, my dh is a HGV driver never hit anyone or anything,he certainly didn't pull out on someone.
  1. Never heard of Disabled/Child spaces. Disability spaces are priority, child spaces are a convenience. He had neither reason to use them.
  1. She sounds like a drama queen clearly shook up. But you don't sound like a peach yourself

He has disabled children though? That’s why the family was parked in that particular space.

Kennykenkencat · 11/01/2023 12:54

ReformedWaywardTeen · 11/01/2023 11:44

Did you intend to come across as patronising?

No win no fee lawyers don't care whether the claim is valid or high paying, they get paid regardless.

I also meant the police would have a log showing they were aware of her suggestions of having been injured but none seen and no ambulance requested.

The fact that the only log of this incident is the CF taking photos of her DHs car, and her verbal bullshit to the store manager puts them at risk of her lies. She already got the manager on side enough to walk her to her vehicle. I know categorically she will take this further, because my Gran used to do things like this all the time, and she earned money several times and would brag how it paid for her holiday. She would find a patch of slippery stuff on a supermarket floor and seeing no sign she would "slip" and claim. It caused me embarrassment to the point I wouldn't go out with her as she would parrot "where there's blame there's a claim".

My thoughts exactly

Reminds me of when a woman in a car had stopped to let a young guy cross the road and the guy crossing them through himself onto her bonnet and rolled onto the road and was rolling around like he had been injured
The woman got out of the car and started shouting how she had a dash cam so he got up and ran away

There are some people who will do anything if they think they can get a few quid off you.

Eyerollcentral · 11/01/2023 12:52

ReformedWaywardTeen · 11/01/2023 11:44

Did you intend to come across as patronising?

No win no fee lawyers don't care whether the claim is valid or high paying, they get paid regardless.

I also meant the police would have a log showing they were aware of her suggestions of having been injured but none seen and no ambulance requested.

The fact that the only log of this incident is the CF taking photos of her DHs car, and her verbal bullshit to the store manager puts them at risk of her lies. She already got the manager on side enough to walk her to her vehicle. I know categorically she will take this further, because my Gran used to do things like this all the time, and she earned money several times and would brag how it paid for her holiday. She would find a patch of slippery stuff on a supermarket floor and seeing no sign she would "slip" and claim. It caused me embarrassment to the point I wouldn't go out with her as she would parrot "where there's blame there's a claim".

Did you mean to post so much incorrect information?
Solicitors acting under a cfa, commonly known as a no win, no fee arrangement will be able to recover the costs from the client or a third party if they have been referred. A 6 month rta injury currently attracts compensation of £400. No one is chasing this kind of injury.
Again, many injuries are not immediately apparent. Ever woken up one day with a bruise and pain and wondered how you did it? Not calling an ambulance or the police proves absolutely nothing.
‘The fact that the only log of this incident is the CF taking photos of her DHs car, and her verbal bullshit to the store manager puts them at risk of her lies.’ The woman was totally correct to take pictures of the car she said hit her, if a car hit you would you not do the same? What other log of the incident could there be?
Getting the manager ‘onside’ is going to do precisely nothing. He didn’t see the accident.
I’m sorry you had such poor role models growing up. You do understand that not every single person pursuing a personal injury claim is faking though don’t you? You are letting your sad childhood experiences colour your interpretation of these events.

Kennykenkencat · 11/01/2023 12:49

daybroke · 11/01/2023 05:58

I've genuinely never seen a combined child and parent and disabled space in a sainsburys car park in Ireland.

I must check this out on Thursday because I'd say that's a if European Union law and you and your DH would be advised to take legal advice on this.

If in the U.K. why would a European Union law apply?

Swipe left for the next trending thread