Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Taking a Switch out of a child’s life without it feeling like a punishment?

145 replies

Howtodothiswell · 10/01/2023 16:07

I am really stuck with this one. Older DS (8) got a Nintendo Switch for his birthday in the summer. I wasn’t mega keen, but all his friends have one so we did it. But younger DS (5) also got into the habit of playing. They play 1 hour each on a Saturday and a Sunday and that’s it. Never any extra time.

Younger DS is neurodivergent (we suspect) and he absolutely cannot handle the idea of the Switch being in the world without him playing with it. He talks about it nonstop. He dreams about it at night. He begs and begs for extra time. He steals it and plays when he’s not supposed to when we haven’t hidden it well.

It is making him utterly miserable! I think it’s pretty bad for his mental health. Apparently it’s all he talks about at school.

How do I remove it from his life without it seeming like a punishment?

He’s almost 6 and is just not ready.

My parents’ advice was “say he can only play it a day when he’s been good all day - something you know he can’t do - so then he’ll never get it again.” (I hate the words “good” and “naughty”). I think doing this will just make him hate himself so I’m not doing this!!!

OP posts:
EarringsandLipstick · 10/01/2023 21:18

@Howtodothiswell

I've read most, but not all, of the thread & I've read your posts.

I think your points about regulation are interesting. I have 3 DC, eldest (DD) doesn't have any interest in gaming - loves her phone, TikTok etc. My 2 DS are utterly screen obsessed, fortunately also play loads of sport so are active. They were continually flouting the pretty generous limits, to the detriment of homework, chores & family life. My youngest (11) has become really aggressive, over-emotional & disregulated. In our case, it was the Xbox not Switch.

I tried very hard to come up with fair limits & not to be too restrictive.

However, last week, he was just impossible. Really badly behaved, jittery like an addict & lying about screen time. I completely removed all screens for a week, TV included. We are half wat through the week & the difference is incredible. He's calm, happy, behaving.

I think the reality is screens are not good for all children, and their ability to handle them will differ by age, personality and anything like ND.

I don't really have any solutions but I don't think you are wrong in the way some posters imply. I think it's a bit tough on DS1 & I do think your instincts to further limit Switch time for now might be correct.

However, perhaps spreading it out more across the week might work, and if you can, playing with him? So he's not waiting desperately all week to get time.

My DNephew is ND & his parents are utterly consistent about Switch limits. There's no extra for Christmas / weekends. It's the same amount of time regardless. They know that if they vary it, it's actually harder for him.

Good luck!

ArtixLynx · 10/01/2023 21:09

the rule in our house is that if a device/console belongs to one child, then they get to use it as/when they like.

If the other wants it, they need to wait until the other is finished.

If the owner then wants it back, then they have to ask politely, and the other child is expected to name a reasonable time on the clock to have finished with it by.

Yes i do referee if either get shitty about it, and i also, again, use the threat that if the one who it doesn't belong to doesn't give it back within a reasonable time, they won't be allowed it next time they ask to use it.

So for instance if DS tells DD he'll be done with the switch by 2pm, if he is Still on it at 2.05 and doesn't hand it over, he's not getting it next time he asks for it.

You want to use the other persons thing, you follow the rules and don't take the piss.

and no, i don't put up with the owner only giving the other person 10 mins before asking for it back.. if you let them use it, they get at least a couple of hours play time.

i promote sharing alongside respecting that something doesn't belong to you.

Howtodothiswell · 10/01/2023 21:08

Crunchingleaf · 10/01/2023 21:05

Do you have the parental controls activated on it? There is an app you can put on the phone. Once they go over the time then that is it unless you give them more time.

I didn’t know about this until it was mentioned here and upthread - I will get that!

OP posts:
NoBoatsOnSunday · 10/01/2023 21:05

Hours spent on devices are hours that could be used doing something creative, or reading
Hours spend on devices can themselves be hours of creativity and/or reading.

I don’t see why playing with legos is somehow more virtuous than playing Minecraft, for example. They’re basically the same thing except the latter is more complex.

Then there’s the visual novel category of games, which are basically books with an additional degree of interactivity (usually a few puzzles, or maybe a branching story).

I think some people have very narrow ideas of what ‘video games’ actually encompass.

Crunchingleaf · 10/01/2023 21:05

Do you have the parental controls activated on it? There is an app you can put on the phone. Once they go over the time then that is it unless you give them more time.

Howtodothiswell · 10/01/2023 21:01

Welpthereitis · 10/01/2023 18:10

Has the older one done anything wrong or behaved in a way that he is not allowed his prized possessions for the very limited time allowed?

No, but he doesn’t seem to much care. He likes it but isn’t obsessed with it like his brother. I let him play on play dates etc when his brother isn’t there, and by all accounts that’s all he does at his best friend’s house. He doesn’t ask me for more access - he has other hobbies he’d rather do at home.

I am definitely feeling more sorry for him now after reading these replies though! I am going to be more mindful of it now.

OP posts:
Climbles · 10/01/2023 21:00

Neither of my children would do anything else if I didn’t restrict their screen time. I don’t think people with NT children understand how obsessive and stimulating computers can be for some ND kids. If it was my son and the computer was broken it would be ‘when will it be fixed’ a million times daily so lying may not help.
I had to ban the iPad completely. DS was upset for a few days but got over it. You don’t have that option because the switch is his brothers. It’s a tricky situation, I really feel for you.

Hankunamatata · 10/01/2023 20:56

I have the app on my phone for switch and set parental limits.
Could you use switch together like family race game or one of the games where have move about

Howtodothiswell · 10/01/2023 20:56

NoBoatsOnSunday · 10/01/2023 18:01

This was one of the problems flagged by the OP:

The other reason why I think it’s misery-making is that he spends a lot of the time he’s on it crying / sounding frustrated because he wants to play the games his brother plays, but is too young.

I don’t understand why, instead of finding games that would be suitable and positive for him to play, or be a fun bonding activity for the whole family, you’d resort to banning it.

We have mario kart (and a few other games), but he wants to play Zelda (his brother’s favourite game).

But I like the idea of trying to turn it into a family activity and play Mario kart together!

OP posts:
ArtixLynx · 10/01/2023 20:55

Howtodothiswell · 10/01/2023 20:51

Two hours seems very restrictive. What’s your reasoning?

because when he has unrestricted access to screens, he’s an absolute nightmare to himself and everyone around him. His mood is all over the place. And he would play, I think, every single hour he has available to him. (Having said that - I am takin people’s comments on board! And might try a spread-out approach.)

His cousins have daily screen time and they’re absolutely fine. Ds(8) would be too. I am really struggling to find the balance of keeping it fair and doing my best for him.

His moods (when he’s on a screen come down) are also explosive and awful for the whole family, tbh. Hitting, scratching, biting. He’s only 5 - I wouldn’t have even gotten my neurotypical child a Switch at age 5.

It may be worth your looking into some of the transition help for ND kids that helps them learn how to move between activities.

Timers, verbal queues on expectations, countdowns..etc.

My ds can be evil when we need him to do something else, but the more time/work we put into transitioning him out of one activity into the next, the better and more smooth it is.

Malvasylvestris · 10/01/2023 20:54

I'm with you OP, I have a similar issue. 2 boys, the older is ok with any limits I set, the younger is desperate to play as much as he can and will push boundaries.

They are allowed 2 hours on Saturday and Sunday, a bit more relaxed in the holidays. Hours spent on devices are hours that could be used doing something creative, or reading, or learning how to be at peace with no external entertainment.

Then they want to watch nonsense videos about gaming on YouTube which is a separate issue🙄

It definitely affects the younger's behaviour negatively. I don't ever frame it as a reward for good behaviour, but I have explained to them my reasons for not wanting them to be on it all the time.

Sometimes I fantasise about the internet going down....

Howtodothiswell · 10/01/2023 20:53

Coffeesnob11 · 10/01/2023 17:36

For all those suggesting it gets broken how is that fair on the child who actually uses it responsibly and whose gift it was?
Its much harder now you have let his brother use it. You could have said no access until you are 8 from the start. Or a once a month treat as it isn't yours.
It would be different if it was a joint present but it doesnt sound like it is.
Does he do any clubs that his brother doesn't? Could your 8 year old play it whilst the younger one is at a hobby? Do they go to bed at the same time? Could the older one have some time once he has gone to bed?

I really wish I’d started better - and said not until you’re 8.

But that’s great advice about doing other clubs without his brother and letting him play. It is his after all!

OP posts:
NoBoatsOnSunday · 10/01/2023 20:52

Flamingogirl08 · 10/01/2023 20:42

The obsession with screen time is ridiculous 🙄

Yup.

As long as children are engaging in a range of activities, I don’t see why you need to get the stopwatch out each time a screen gets turned on.

Howtodothiswell · 10/01/2023 20:51

Two hours seems very restrictive. What’s your reasoning?

because when he has unrestricted access to screens, he’s an absolute nightmare to himself and everyone around him. His mood is all over the place. And he would play, I think, every single hour he has available to him. (Having said that - I am takin people’s comments on board! And might try a spread-out approach.)

His cousins have daily screen time and they’re absolutely fine. Ds(8) would be too. I am really struggling to find the balance of keeping it fair and doing my best for him.

His moods (when he’s on a screen come down) are also explosive and awful for the whole family, tbh. Hitting, scratching, biting. He’s only 5 - I wouldn’t have even gotten my neurotypical child a Switch at age 5.

OP posts:
Flamingogirl08 · 10/01/2023 20:42

The obsession with screen time is ridiculous 🙄

Howtodothiswell · 10/01/2023 20:42

EndlessRain1 · 10/01/2023 16:55

The thing is if it has a negative impact on him increasing it won't help.

DS (5) can't handle YouTube. Watching it (YouTube kids) makes him crazy. It's like drugs to him and he often freaks out when it's taken away and will obsessively ask for it. It ALWAYS puts him in a bad mood. We tried reducing it, it was the same. Now he doesn't have any.

This is exactly my worry! It’s what he did / does with tv. I have trialled more tv (and got covid then the flu and there was however much tv he wanted!) and it made him worse. He doesn’t walk away or get bored, he watches nonstop.

But since most posters are telling me I’m giving him too little I am going to have a really big think about this!

And you’re right about my older child - I do let him play more when he has play dates, which I arrange when his brother is on play dates out somewhere else.

My strictness is with the younger. It’s because I thought knowing his limits (which helps him in life in general) will stop him being tortured by the idea of maybe getting it if he asks a lot.

DS(8) (who is neurotypical) can handle whatever with screens. None, or a little, or loads - his mood changes slightly but not much. He has always been like this. His brother is manic when he watches!

OP posts:
BrewersFaye · 10/01/2023 20:38

Howtodothiswell · 10/01/2023 16:30

It was definitely his brother’s, but we didn’t think it was fair (at the time) not to let him.

His brother is old enough, can handle ir, would like more time but does not have a disordered relationship with it at all.

Jesus Christ for this alone YABU

its decisions like this that usually make NT children resent their ND siblings

it was your oldest child’s present, how awful of you to decide to make it a joint gift.

baffledcoconut · 10/01/2023 20:36

QueenCamilla · 10/01/2023 18:04

Yes, there's only two Highly successful people from my school : one stood at nearly 7ft tall and emigrated to play basketball for NBA.

The other, my ND classmate, went from obsession with chemistry at 7yo, to gaming, to programming and on to silicon Valley. Shocked us all by being the first to buy a car, buy a huge house, have children... All before 22. I'm still shocked, tbf 😁

I believe the saying is ‘the geek shall inherit the Earth’

baffledcoconut · 10/01/2023 20:34

My child plays a game that has allowed them to meet lots of people in real life and made a host of new friends. They all can interact with common interests so it doesn’t matter about age or being NT or whatever. They all play for the sheer love of this game.

Gaming isn’t evil!

freespirit333 · 10/01/2023 20:22

Gosh this has been eye opening! DS7 got a Switch for his birthday last month, he and DS3 played most days in the holidays but now we’re back in school I have said weekends only, Friday-Sunday. I will say an hour each day although it’s usually more relaxed and depends what else we’ve done that day. I did notice in the holidays that DS7 (also ND, there’s so many of them about 💪) wasn’t occupying himself as much and kept whining for the switch when play time was up, but it was short lived.

I feel guilty and that I should let him play on it more! He’s been great at sharing with DS3 too who must be immensely frustrating to play Mario Kart with as he’s so useless.

OP, I have no idea what you should do, but if you do want to stop your 5 year old playing, what about removing the TV playing option so only your older DS can play on the handheld? And distract 5 year old with something he loves, movie or game
etc?

FWIW YouTube is the same in this house - banned!

toocold54 · 10/01/2023 18:40

Tell the younger one it’s broken and then let the older one play on it when he’s in bed.

If you choose to reintroduce it then have set rules for it before he gets it and I personally would let them play it every day for a set amount of time.

My DD has ASD and ADD and after we’ve got home from afterschool club she will go straight on her games whilst I make dinner.
She uses it to regulate herself and once she’s played it and had her dinner she’s in a much better place and then does her homework etc.

You may find that your DS needs to use it after dinner or at a time that is the least disruptive.

I get your reasons for wanting to remove it completely and there may be things that you do have to remove completely.
But I find that if it’s not this obsession it will be something else and so removing things can sometimes be ineffective.

NoBoatsOnSunday · 10/01/2023 18:37

ArtixLynx · 10/01/2023 18:26

just as a note, the UK gaming industry is currently worth 4.7billion (just on bbc news) these are games MADE here in the uk.

Gaming doesn’t just lead into jobs in the industry either - I went on to become a lawyer after having my interest sparked by a game.

GeneticallyModifiedGrump · 10/01/2023 18:34

I don't know any parents irl as restrictive with technology as mn parents!
I said this on another thread and I'll say it again, kids are at risk of being ostracised by their peers if they aren't allowed by parents to keep up with games/TV etc, it's what they talk about during the school day!
I'm not advocating unfettered access but 2 hours a week is miserly especially on a device you paid around £300 for in the first place (as a main birthday gift? I wouldn't have bothered!) I do think some parents on her need to unclench.

ArtixLynx · 10/01/2023 18:26

just as a note, the UK gaming industry is currently worth 4.7billion (just on bbc news) these are games MADE here in the uk.

ArtixLynx · 10/01/2023 18:25

i mean.. my ND is AuDHD.. i bought myself a switch last year.. i played one game i bought with it OBSESSIVELY for about a month.. and then haven't touched it since because i got bored with the game, and don't have any others currently.

Sometimes, letting them have at it, and letting it burn itself out is the best way to deal with it.. but be aware, if it IS adhd, he'll just switch to another one and you'll be in the same boat with the next thing.