Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What was your "this is over" moment in your marriage

358 replies

MadScottishBurd · 10/01/2023 15:01

Just what the title says, really.

He is a good man, hardworking, loyal, so I, in no way want to paint him to be the baddie. However, I cant stop tinking about something he said to me, and at that moment, I knew it was it, that I wanted more.

During the really bad weather before Christmas - snow, sleat, wind, heavy rain.. I had a meeting at 9am at my work. I was 20 minutes late for work (not a huge amount of time but still!). My work didnt know where I was and tried calling me to see if I was alright, as the person I was meeting with was waiting for me to arrive. They accidentally phoned my emergency contact who is my (soon to be ex) husband. They had told him that it was a mistake calling him as they were trying to call me as I hadnt turned up for work.

I then arrived, started my meeting asap, and was told about this call to my husband later on, which I totally forgot about until I went home that evening.

When I was home, and after we had our dinner and was watching TV, it popped in my head.. I asked "my work said they called you today, why havent you said anything"
him: "oh, I forgot about that, something about you didnt turn up"
me: "yeah, but why didn't you try contacting me to make sure I was alright, I could have been in an accident"
him "I was busy at work, they were going to contact you"
me "I know, but werent you concerned? What if I had been in an accident, wouldnt you feel guilty??"
him: "I'm sure the police would have contacted me, had you been in an accident".

I dont think I have ever forgiven him for that comment. He wasnt in a great place at the time however he did not care, not one little bit.

What was your eureka moment?

x

OP posts:
MadScottishBurd · 11/01/2023 00:02

Blastmydogintospace · 10/01/2023 23:56

*I dont think I have ever forgiven him for that comment. He wasnt in a
great place at the time however he did not care, not one little bit. *

Why wasn't he in a great place ?

He got promoted a few months before and was finding the job stressful and would often bring work home with him.

I don't understand why I am having to justify everything in my post 🥺 this was my eureka moment.

I only asked what everyone elses eureka moment was. I only commented how I disagreed with opinions when they were getting nasty or calling me high maintenance.

I didn't ask for opinions. I don't need people to tell me I was in the right and it wasn't okay because I know how I felt in the moment, my feelings are valid and I know my worth.

Actually baffled by these comments. I don't understand why I'm sitting here justify, explaining and providing more context. That was my moment, not anyone else's, deal with it. Don't agree? Think I'm nasty and think my feelings aren't valid? Move on and have a cuppa.

OP posts:
Mammyloveswine · 10/01/2023 23:57

Refuses to get a haircut or beard trim for my mams funeral and has now fucked off back to his parents despite my dad being seriously ill in hospital. Leaving me home with 2 young children wondering who on earth is going to leave them next.. 🤬🤬🤬🤬

I can't see how I can get back from this.

Blastmydogintospace · 10/01/2023 23:56

*I dont think I have ever forgiven him for that comment. He wasnt in a
great place at the time however he did not care, not one little bit. *

Why wasn't he in a great place ?

Blastmydogintospace · 10/01/2023 23:51

Backstreetsbackalrightdadada · 10/01/2023 23:29

This thread is so odd! If I got a call saying my partner hadn’t made it into work, I’d immediately call them to check they were ok!

Spending a whole day, not just the “not knowing” but not even trying to get in touch… that’s baffling.

Ok it’s a “small” incident but it is SO basic. OP I would do the same really. If a partner can’t care enough to confirm you’re alive, what is the point. Think they’ll care for your happiness or health? Nope!

Exactly for a relationship to break down so much as for one person not to care if they feel something bad may have occurred to the other usually means a detatchment has already been made.

It's almost as if the op wants reassurance that this is not ok.
You're right op it not ok for two people who love one another but I've found the person who usually detatches is the one not caring what others think precisely because they have been hurt so much.

Only people who are wanting to appear the 'good guy' still play the game, and the appearance of caring is one of them.

He was past that.
Sounds like he's been hurt.

MadScottishBurd · 10/01/2023 23:45

Blastmydogintospace · 10/01/2023 23:42

*We weren't in the midst of breaking up when this happened. Things
weren't perfect but I hadn't instigated a split or told him how unhappy I
was. *

You said soon to be ex, which yes this moment could have then been your Eureka moment, I just don't think it's particularly hurtful, especially as you wern't getting on.

Lack of care is very hurtful, very hurtful from someone who you thought were going to be sharing your life together forever, you clearly had other ideas.
Maybe he had detatched because he knew you were going to end it.

Yes, my soon to be ex husband NOW as we are seperating and going through the legal process!! He wasn't my ex then, we didn't have the separation chat then either. JESUS CHRIST. Some posters on this would start a fight in an empty room.

OP posts:
Backstreetsbackalrightdadada · 10/01/2023 23:43

To get the thread back on track - NOT judge OP - my last breakup, the eureka moment was when after our second anniversary I realised he’d never scheduled a date. Had asked him to, he never did.

So I raised it and he was cagey but he booked tickets to the nearest classical music recital near his work (very nice!). He was very proud of this, but not in an endearing way… like a “yes, I did it, you owe me way”. It was so weird! He even went on about quite how expensive the tickets were and how I should therefore pay for a (sounded like) very extravagant meal after. It was midweek but I managed to get out of work on time (7pm) for it, knowing that I’d have to work the weekend to catch up.

Then… just before the show, he was late to the event. I received the email from his secretary confirming the tickets (poor her, out of her working hours), and the chain showed she’d planned it, with no input from him, and he’d been rude to her in the emails and sounded uninterested in thinking of anything I would enjoy. He then turned up 30 mins late part way through the recital. (FYI we both had demanding jobs, except my hours were very long and his hours were 9-5 with free weekends) Also fyi… the tickets were 35 quid each and the meal he wanted me to pay for would have been several hundred.

I’ve never felt so free, sitting alone listening to incredible music. And decided I wanted to do more of that, but without him.

He joined late, was an arse disrupting everyone to get to his seat, was pretentious AF reading and re-reading the recital blurb, made me buy the drinks mid way through.

When I went to get his stupid drink, I emailed the restaurant to move the date of our meal. I broke up with him the next day, and took my best friend out instead.

The bad date was just ONE event but so indicative of fundamental problems. That was my eureka moment :)

Blastmydogintospace · 10/01/2023 23:42

*We weren't in the midst of breaking up when this happened. Things
weren't perfect but I hadn't instigated a split or told him how unhappy I
was. *

You said soon to be ex, which yes this moment could have then been your Eureka moment, I just don't think it's particularly hurtful, especially as you wern't getting on.

Lack of care is very hurtful, very hurtful from someone who you thought were going to be sharing your life together forever, you clearly had other ideas.
Maybe he had detatched because he knew you were going to end it.

MadScottishBurd · 10/01/2023 23:33

Backstreetsbackalrightdadada · 10/01/2023 23:31

Omg what is wrong with so many posters being so mean to the OP?! She said what was your eureka moment, not the sole cause of the breakup! Jeez what is happening today on this thread

People can't read.
And because I said positive things about my husband at the start... People have been getting into a state of confusion!

OP posts:
MadScottishBurd · 10/01/2023 23:32

Backstreetsbackalrightdadada · 10/01/2023 23:29

This thread is so odd! If I got a call saying my partner hadn’t made it into work, I’d immediately call them to check they were ok!

Spending a whole day, not just the “not knowing” but not even trying to get in touch… that’s baffling.

Ok it’s a “small” incident but it is SO basic. OP I would do the same really. If a partner can’t care enough to confirm you’re alive, what is the point. Think they’ll care for your happiness or health? Nope!

This thread is really odd!!
It's so divided over what I think is something so basic!

OP posts:
Backstreetsbackalrightdadada · 10/01/2023 23:31

Omg what is wrong with so many posters being so mean to the OP?! She said what was your eureka moment, not the sole cause of the breakup! Jeez what is happening today on this thread

MadScottishBurd · 10/01/2023 23:30

Blastmydogintospace · 10/01/2023 23:13

They accidentally phoned my emergency contact who is my (soon to be ex) husband.

The context is everything with this, he was soon to be your ex, sounds like he was grey rocking you to protect himself.

He is a good man, hardworking, loyal, so I, in no way want to paint him to be the baddie.

The word loyal jumps out at me, not often stated when a divorce is imminent, were you loyal op ?

I dont think I have ever forgiven him for that comment. He wasnt in a
great place at the time however he did not care, not one little bit.

Why was he not in a great place op, was it because he knew he was being discarded. I'm sorry it sounds to me this wasn't your Eureka moment it was your excuse moment, but it was hardly surprising if you were in the midst of leaving him.
Completely different context but yes it could be construed as hurtful if you're in a mutually loving relationship but not when there is discord and lack of care involved.

Was his lack of care worse than your lack of care, we don't know but you sound happy about the end result.

It just sounds to me you are re writing, making excuses and pinning a lot of reason on probably the wrong thing. Maybe you just didn't fancy him enough (you laughing at a previous post about someone getting the ick made you laugh) maybe you fancy someone else more and that is a more real reason or explanation of why you dislike this good, hardworking, loyal man.

Then again I might just be uncaring and an idiot.

And yeah I did find the post about the ick funny. It was a very funny, descriptive post... in my head I pictured the scene and found it hilarious! That poster should be a writer as it was written hilariously. Shoot me 🤷‍♀️

What's that to do with my post?!

You're a funny lot tonight 💁‍♀️

OP posts:
Backstreetsbackalrightdadada · 10/01/2023 23:29

This thread is so odd! If I got a call saying my partner hadn’t made it into work, I’d immediately call them to check they were ok!

Spending a whole day, not just the “not knowing” but not even trying to get in touch… that’s baffling.

Ok it’s a “small” incident but it is SO basic. OP I would do the same really. If a partner can’t care enough to confirm you’re alive, what is the point. Think they’ll care for your happiness or health? Nope!

MadScottishBurd · 10/01/2023 23:26

Blastmydogintospace · 10/01/2023 23:13

They accidentally phoned my emergency contact who is my (soon to be ex) husband.

The context is everything with this, he was soon to be your ex, sounds like he was grey rocking you to protect himself.

He is a good man, hardworking, loyal, so I, in no way want to paint him to be the baddie.

The word loyal jumps out at me, not often stated when a divorce is imminent, were you loyal op ?

I dont think I have ever forgiven him for that comment. He wasnt in a
great place at the time however he did not care, not one little bit.

Why was he not in a great place op, was it because he knew he was being discarded. I'm sorry it sounds to me this wasn't your Eureka moment it was your excuse moment, but it was hardly surprising if you were in the midst of leaving him.
Completely different context but yes it could be construed as hurtful if you're in a mutually loving relationship but not when there is discord and lack of care involved.

Was his lack of care worse than your lack of care, we don't know but you sound happy about the end result.

It just sounds to me you are re writing, making excuses and pinning a lot of reason on probably the wrong thing. Maybe you just didn't fancy him enough (you laughing at a previous post about someone getting the ick made you laugh) maybe you fancy someone else more and that is a more real reason or explanation of why you dislike this good, hardworking, loyal man.

Then again I might just be uncaring and an idiot.

We weren't in the midst of breaking up when this happened. Things weren't perfect but I hadn't instigated a split or told him how unhappy I was.

I'm not sure how many more times this must be repeated... this wasn't the reason we ended. This was MY eureka moment. There had been lots of little things before this but this moment stood out and things made sense to me.

You're post is full of lots of assumptions.

OP posts:
Blastmydogintospace · 10/01/2023 23:13

They accidentally phoned my emergency contact who is my (soon to be ex) husband.

The context is everything with this, he was soon to be your ex, sounds like he was grey rocking you to protect himself.

He is a good man, hardworking, loyal, so I, in no way want to paint him to be the baddie.

The word loyal jumps out at me, not often stated when a divorce is imminent, were you loyal op ?

I dont think I have ever forgiven him for that comment. He wasnt in a
great place at the time however he did not care, not one little bit.

Why was he not in a great place op, was it because he knew he was being discarded. I'm sorry it sounds to me this wasn't your Eureka moment it was your excuse moment, but it was hardly surprising if you were in the midst of leaving him.
Completely different context but yes it could be construed as hurtful if you're in a mutually loving relationship but not when there is discord and lack of care involved.

Was his lack of care worse than your lack of care, we don't know but you sound happy about the end result.

It just sounds to me you are re writing, making excuses and pinning a lot of reason on probably the wrong thing. Maybe you just didn't fancy him enough (you laughing at a previous post about someone getting the ick made you laugh) maybe you fancy someone else more and that is a more real reason or explanation of why you dislike this good, hardworking, loyal man.

Then again I might just be uncaring and an idiot.

Eyerollcentral · 10/01/2023 22:53

No worries, just said it was clear most people went off your first post which said your husband was great, so your response seemed disproportionate and then you did a 180 and showed him to be an ignoramus. Thinks that’s what’s confused a lot of people

Dontevenstart · 10/01/2023 22:52

Christ almighty - how many here who don’t understand that it does not fucking matter what the exact circumstances of said eureka moment are - the point is that it’s the fulcrum of everything that’s built up.

ClaryFairchild · 10/01/2023 22:52

@MadScottishBurd - ignore the posters who just don't get it.

For so many years you keep telling yourself you're DH is lovely and supportive because that's the image that they give to the world and what they keep telling you and you once believed it and you keep telling yourself it's true because to not believe it would be horrible.

There are, however, so many instances where they aren't lovely and supporting but they don't penetrate the false facade of loveliness. Then suddenly one teeny, tiny, inconsequential action (or lack of action) makes you suddenly see them in a different light. All of a sudden you can't pretend anymore that they are great.

And then that's it, the facade is gone. All you can see is the horrible person they really are and once seen you can't I see it.

MadScottishBurd · 10/01/2023 22:47

Eyerollcentral · 10/01/2023 22:43

@MadScottishBurd I was responding to someone else but you with those comments. I’ve been accused of being all sorts as you can see. That was in response to their comments.
I don’t get why you chose to respond to a reply to someone else and not my earlier post to you but I’ll leave it at that!

There have been too many responses and now I'm following on my phone. Apologies if you have asked me a direct question.

OP posts:
mycatsanutter · 10/01/2023 22:45

My eureka moment was at his sisters wedding , we were there with our dc - 7 and 3 and I was 8 months pregnant . He got so so drunk he walked past me sitting with the dc doing colouring trying to keep them amused and he totally ignored me.

Eyerollcentral · 10/01/2023 22:43

@MadScottishBurd I was responding to someone else but you with those comments. I’ve been accused of being all sorts as you can see. That was in response to their comments.
I don’t get why you chose to respond to a reply to someone else and not my earlier post to you but I’ll leave it at that!

MadScottishBurd · 10/01/2023 22:39

But it's not about being in constant contact. The weather was terrible. My work had contacted him and said I hadn't turned up. The bare, absolute bare minimum, is to send a quick text asking if someone is okay.

What's phones not being around got to do with anything 🤣 the only person mentioning constant contact is you!

OP posts:
Leakingtoilet · 10/01/2023 22:34

If my DP received a call from my work to say I hadn't arrived he would absolutely contact me to check I was ok, and vice versa. It's a standard part of caring about someone imo.

Mine was when me ex ruined a day out with the kids being in such a foul mood as he couldn't get stoned. The first thing he did when we got home was roll a joint and was then happy again.

That was my 'I am done' moment.

Eyerollcentral · 10/01/2023 22:31

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 10/01/2023 22:26

That was a response to what YOU said about how people are apparently not independent adults if they like their partner to check up on them under unusual circumstances!

Jesus you're hard work.

I’m really, really not. I’m just not someone who wants to be in constant contact with my partner. I also don’t fly in to a flap about everything. I wouldn’t have been worried if I was the husband or the wife in this situation. What do people think happened before mobiles? It wasn’t that long ago. Most people didn’t speak to each other from they left the house in the morning until they came home in the evening. Guess what? They weren’t all unfeeling brutes!

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 10/01/2023 22:26

Eyerollcentral · 10/01/2023 19:07

That if everyone died belonging to you, that’s the odd extreme.
Panic from the OP’s office, though let’s face it, they weren’t worried that she was stuck in a snow drift with life slowly ebbing away, they were pissed off because they’d a client sitting waiting for twenty minutes. Panicky ringing the wrong number I.e. the emergency contact - though in fairness they did say sorry rang you by accident, this confirming there was nothing for him to worry about.
As I say I wouldn’t end a marriage over it but the OP’s husband sounds awful so I wouldn’t have married him in the first place. As the saying goes ‘what do you expect from a pig but a grunt’

That was a response to what YOU said about how people are apparently not independent adults if they like their partner to check up on them under unusual circumstances!

Jesus you're hard work.

ShowsLikeThese · 10/01/2023 22:15

BillyNotQuiteNoMates · 10/01/2023 17:35

I don’t think the OP was asking for opinions on her own “moment”, the final straw can be anything, however trivial it appears to others.

For me, I struggled for a long time, knowing that I wasn’t a priority for him. But when he had a vasectomy, with no agreement from me, knowing how much I wanted another baby made it crystal clear to me how little he valued me. I still stayed for years, but the moment I truly knew it was over was when we were having sex and I saw his face in the mirror. Five years on, it still haunts me.

I've got to know... what did you sed in his sex face that made it the point of no return