Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What was your "this is over" moment in your marriage

358 replies

MadScottishBurd · 10/01/2023 15:01

Just what the title says, really.

He is a good man, hardworking, loyal, so I, in no way want to paint him to be the baddie. However, I cant stop tinking about something he said to me, and at that moment, I knew it was it, that I wanted more.

During the really bad weather before Christmas - snow, sleat, wind, heavy rain.. I had a meeting at 9am at my work. I was 20 minutes late for work (not a huge amount of time but still!). My work didnt know where I was and tried calling me to see if I was alright, as the person I was meeting with was waiting for me to arrive. They accidentally phoned my emergency contact who is my (soon to be ex) husband. They had told him that it was a mistake calling him as they were trying to call me as I hadnt turned up for work.

I then arrived, started my meeting asap, and was told about this call to my husband later on, which I totally forgot about until I went home that evening.

When I was home, and after we had our dinner and was watching TV, it popped in my head.. I asked "my work said they called you today, why havent you said anything"
him: "oh, I forgot about that, something about you didnt turn up"
me: "yeah, but why didn't you try contacting me to make sure I was alright, I could have been in an accident"
him "I was busy at work, they were going to contact you"
me "I know, but werent you concerned? What if I had been in an accident, wouldnt you feel guilty??"
him: "I'm sure the police would have contacted me, had you been in an accident".

I dont think I have ever forgiven him for that comment. He wasnt in a great place at the time however he did not care, not one little bit.

What was your eureka moment?

x

OP posts:
Benjispruce4 · 10/01/2023 17:08

@MadScottishBurd That last comment- you’re right, he’s horrible. That would have been the moment for me, not the one in the op.

MadScottishBurd · 10/01/2023 17:06

I remember reading a comment he wrote to his friend on fb. He had posted a picture of our dog with some nice scenary in the background. A friend commented asking how much for the dog - all of our friends love our dog, she is the cutest and he replied back "What dog? MadScottishBurd isnt in the picture"
I know thats a joke but I felt that was totally disrespectful

OP posts:
DorisParchment · 10/01/2023 17:06

Ex DP not DH. He went through the shopping list and crossed off everything he claimed not to eat, such as biscuits, flour, butter (but he ate the cake I made with them!) and gave me half the cost of everything else. I knew I couldn’t live with that tightness any longer.

Needanewnamebeingwatched · 10/01/2023 17:04

Getting up in the middle of the night for a wee, I misjudged the steps and stood out about three steps up and came crashing to the bottom.

I was in so much pain, exhusband helped me up and into another room, I asked him to call an ambulance the pain was excruciating, he replied " you know I don't like speaking to people" so I called my our ambulance.

I knew in that instance I would never forgive him, I stayed another 15yrs, but that was it over for me really.

MadScottishBurd · 10/01/2023 17:04

MN is weird.
I dont understand why everyone is so unkind to each other. Clearly there are many MN keyboard gangsters. If you think my reaction was over the top, fair enough, but there is no need to insult me. I'm still confused at the mentally unstable comment. I think its mentally unstable to NOT care if your partners work calls to say that they havent arrived. The fact it was a really bad weather day too makes it worst.

OP posts:
Maytodecember · 10/01/2023 17:04

I think the moment he said he was going to kill me , then said no I won’t I’ll just make your life so miserable you’d wish you were dead was a turning point.

butterfliedtwo · 10/01/2023 17:03

Want2beme · 10/01/2023 15:40

Have I read this before somewhere?

Yes. There was a thread when it happened.

SweetcornFritter · 10/01/2023 17:01

Morielle · 10/01/2023 16:51

I've noticed on MN there often seems to be some big rush to slate the OP no matter what the post is about. Some people just love to be unkind, unsympathetic or downright cruel.
The craven need for an argument rather than to feel some level of human empathy is sad.
If only all those rotten souls could group up together and leave the decent humans to it that would be great thanks

I agree. I only ever started one thread on here before and after several abusive replies I decided “never again!”

blobby10 · 10/01/2023 17:00

@MadScottishBurd mine was similar to yours - it was around 10 years ago now so my memories of the exact words are hazy but very similar situation. i hadn't gone home at the normal time and he Just Didn't Care! Oh and plus he said that his Dad dying at 50 was a far worse experience than it would be if one of our children died (then all aged under 10) made me realise he would never care for me like I needed him to and that our attitudes to caring were polar opposites. He's happily remarried now so i'm clearly the one in the wrong as I'm single still. I don't wish him ill - he's a decent bloke we just weren't one anothers soul mate/BFF.

SweetcornFritter · 10/01/2023 16:59

Foe me it was on our wedding anniversary. Our relationship had been rocky leading up to it, but a few days before I was hospitalised after an accident. I messaged him from my hospital bed on the morning acknowledging the day and wishing him a Happy Anniversary to which he did not reply. When he dutifully visited me later that day he came empty handed and still refused to acknowledge that it was our anniversary. That’s when I knew it was over.

Morielle · 10/01/2023 16:51

I've noticed on MN there often seems to be some big rush to slate the OP no matter what the post is about. Some people just love to be unkind, unsympathetic or downright cruel.
The craven need for an argument rather than to feel some level of human empathy is sad.
If only all those rotten souls could group up together and leave the decent humans to it that would be great thanks

Benjispruce4 · 10/01/2023 16:51

It would have been nice to text you but he forgot. I mean to do things then get sidetracked and forget. It’s being human.

Stunningscreamer · 10/01/2023 16:51

Some of these replies are so weird they must be trolls or they're people that are also pretty uncaring, so they are probably married to people who will one day have a 'this is over' moment. Calling OP mentally weak, high maintenance etc, so obviously over the top they're out into space.

I know OP it's obvious it was a final straw moment from your OP and that there's a back story. The whole point is that the event in itself isn't a big deal it just puts into sharp relief all the other, probably more serious issues, and shows a lack of basic care.

My one was when I was at a festival and I suggested it might be nice to go nearer the front to see the band better, and he walked off because I'd ruined it for him...

Benjispruce4 · 10/01/2023 16:48

Have only read your OP. I think your DH was right. He knew your work had your emergency contact and they hadn’t called back so safe to presume you arrived. He was busy and forgot. You were busy and forgot to let him know you were ok. These things happen . Obviously there’s much more wrong in your relationship than this minor disagreement in reaction.

SomethingOriginal2 · 10/01/2023 16:47

When he told me he'd kill me if I left. Apparently my brain went "lol I dare you!"
Honestly I felt like he was going to kill me either way, and at least it'd be harder if there was a locked door between us when I slept.

nc8975 · 10/01/2023 16:47

*see

nc8975 · 10/01/2023 16:47

And I could say why that felt like a defining moment amongst lots of others, it says a lot even though it appears small.

nc8975 · 10/01/2023 16:46

I don't think you're high maintenance at all OP. If I got a phone call from DH's work saying he hadn't turned up I wouldn't be able to go back to my day until I knew what was going on. I think that's quite a normal reaction, I'm pretty sure my otherwise very laidback, non dramatic DH would have tried to contact me too in the reverse.

MsMarch · 10/01/2023 16:43

Deathbyfluffy · 10/01/2023 16:33

Then it would have been a good idea to include more in your opening post - because that's exactly what it reads like!

Her subject line makes it clear that she's asking for that "final moment", which I think most people understand under all the other ways its been described on here - the tipping point, straw that broke the camel's back, last straw etc.

This is the most bizarre thread I've seen in a while.

MangoBiscuit · 10/01/2023 16:42

Oh FFS, OP getting a pasting because she asked a specific question, and only gave information pertinent to that in her OP.

She wasn't asking what all the small things that brought people to that moment were, just what the final straw was. Which often seems to be some small innocuous thing.

Xztop · 10/01/2023 16:40

I think sometimes it's a case of the straw that broke the camels back.

For me it was when dd was born and he didn't turn up at the hospital the next morning because he was 'tired'. I was terrified, it was the only time I'd ever needed him and he wasn't there. I tried to get over it but couldn't

Greensleevevssnotnose · 10/01/2023 16:38

MadScottishBurd · 10/01/2023 15:01

Just what the title says, really.

He is a good man, hardworking, loyal, so I, in no way want to paint him to be the baddie. However, I cant stop tinking about something he said to me, and at that moment, I knew it was it, that I wanted more.

During the really bad weather before Christmas - snow, sleat, wind, heavy rain.. I had a meeting at 9am at my work. I was 20 minutes late for work (not a huge amount of time but still!). My work didnt know where I was and tried calling me to see if I was alright, as the person I was meeting with was waiting for me to arrive. They accidentally phoned my emergency contact who is my (soon to be ex) husband. They had told him that it was a mistake calling him as they were trying to call me as I hadnt turned up for work.

I then arrived, started my meeting asap, and was told about this call to my husband later on, which I totally forgot about until I went home that evening.

When I was home, and after we had our dinner and was watching TV, it popped in my head.. I asked "my work said they called you today, why havent you said anything"
him: "oh, I forgot about that, something about you didnt turn up"
me: "yeah, but why didn't you try contacting me to make sure I was alright, I could have been in an accident"
him "I was busy at work, they were going to contact you"
me "I know, but werent you concerned? What if I had been in an accident, wouldnt you feel guilty??"
him: "I'm sure the police would have contacted me, had you been in an accident".

I dont think I have ever forgiven him for that comment. He wasnt in a great place at the time however he did not care, not one little bit.

What was your eureka moment?

x

My ex was an alcoholic. I had a small surgery and had to be monitored by someone at home for 24 hours. I asked him to get me some painkillers as we got out the taxi I went in the house. It was four hours before he came home with no tablets. I was fuming. We were undergoing IVF at the time and I decided there and then it was over.

rubyslippers · 10/01/2023 16:36

campingwidow · 10/01/2023 16:34

I'm still in my marriage. 2 young DDs so it's full on, hoping it gets easier with time etc.
But there have been a couple of things that have happened where I've thought, I'll never forget this and I'm not sure I can ever forgive it. Once was when DD1 was 10 months old, she had a medical issue and we were to take her to hospital for investigations (didn't require 999). Was snowing and couldn't get car out so had to walk approx 40 mins there. He let me walk with her in baby carrier with overnight bag on my back alone in ankle deep snow as he was working and "it wasn't a good use of HIS time to come too".

DD2 was a bit of a surprise but we weren't being careful so equally responsible. When I was about 7 weeks we were driving home from a holiday he accused me of "manipulating the pregnancy" "he wanted to be involved but wasn't sure in what capacity" and "wasn't sure he still loved me". Managed to get through this but it hurt and ruined what should have been a happy time.

We have ups and downs as most couples do. But I do find my mind going to these incidents (amongst others).

Both of those are very hurtful

SeemsSoUnfair · 10/01/2023 16:35

You knew your husband was contacted to say you hadn't turned up for work, but he never called back. How do you know he wasn't lying in hospital having suffered a heart attack! Yet, you didn't find out why he hadn't checked in with you. Did you not care enough?

It is something I wouldn't be surprised if dh or I did, we tend to shut off from home a bit once in work.

Your reason in itself alone, would not have been significant in a otherwise healthy relationship, it was just the tiny little straw the broke the camels back on a relationship that was already dead in the water.