Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we could make housing estates like Center Parcs re cars

809 replies

QuertyGirl · 10/01/2023 12:38

The USP of Centre Parcs is for many, the fact that they are mostly car free. Kids can play out and ride their bikes like I did when I was kid.

Can't do that now due to the amount of cars, speed and size of cars and, attitude of some car drivers.

People (including myself) pay a small fortune to holiday at CP.

Why can't we make housing estates more like that?

Communal car parks in walking distance, deliveries by small electric vehicles from a hub (like old fashioned milk floats), exemptions for blue badge holders and funding for electric mobility scooters for those that need them.

Yet, if the council suggests a couple of cycle lane and all hell breaks loose.

OP posts:
glowfrog · 12/01/2023 09:56

Sleepyblueocean · 12/01/2023 06:46

"But that's nothing compared to being able to let the kids go out and play with their friends all around the houses"

Having parking close to my house is more important to me than my son who will never be able to play out, being able to play out.

Why will he never be able to play out?

Kazzyhoward · 12/01/2023 08:23

HidingUnderARock · 12/01/2023 00:04

I've seen ideas for the future of electric and driverless cars where it won't park on your drive but take itself off somewhere to charge after dropping you off and then you'd call it when you want to go somewhere. A bit like a driverless Uber.

Doesn't this double the number of car journeys in the residential area?

Yep, I've said the same about self-driving cars and also about taxis. They actually increase the number of journeys! The main benefit is reducing the need for parking, either at home, or town centres, hospitals, workplaces, etc as cars will either be parked up elsewhere presumably in huge out of town car parks, or in the case of taxis, being used for other journeys.

With your own car, once you're home, the car stays at home. With self driving or taxis or whatever, there's another "journey" when it goes back to base or car park. Highly unlikely that the taxi will get another job from somewhere near where it dropped you to where it "parks", so the return journey is an extra, unnecessary, journey.

Kazzyhoward · 12/01/2023 08:18

Sheerdetermination · 11/01/2023 22:35

Totally agree, OP. Cars have become a menace. We manage without one. As you said, our grandparents did too. And we enjoy walking everywhere and using public transport. And we have a toddler. It’s good for the child to see more of life at a slower pace. Slow down and stop rushing everyone. Do less, and enjoy it more.

You do realise that no everyone is within easy walking distance of a bus stop with buses that go to where they want to go, don't you?

In our village (8000 inhabitants so not small), there are NO bus stops at all in the centre of it, no bus routes through the centre at all. The last few services were chopped around 2005. The only bus route is along the by-pass road at the edge of the village, so just about walkable for those living at that side, but not for those living on the opposite side of the centre. And it just goes between towns A & B, not the big town C where most people work and shop and where the hospital is, so you have to get the bus to town A and then change at the bus station for a bus to big town C. So what could have been a 15 minute drive to, say, the hospital, becomes a 2 hours slog, it's only one bus per hour which doesn't even synchronise with the A-C bus so you also have a 30 minute wait at the bus station changeover - none of the buses are direct, so you are sat wasting time as they dawdle around housing estates and a big detour around the out of town supermarket!

Fair enough in London and other bigger cities with frequent and integrated public transport systems, but forget it if you live in smaller towns and villages etc.

Devoutspoken · 12/01/2023 08:15

Sceptre86, you're wrong, there are car free areas in plenty of cities across the world where children can play, including the uk. Low traffic neighbourhoods and pedestrianisation are increasing, however much people stay entrenched in their carcentric bubbles

Kazzyhoward · 12/01/2023 08:10

@Propertysourcingguy

I do like what they have done in some areas although not the right roads, where they basically make them a no through road to stop the rat run traffic

Doesn't always work though. We live on a cul-de-sac, so no "rat run" traffic, but it's still not safe for the kids to play on the roads. The road is a dog-leg, and cars/vans come round the blind corner far too fast. They're not going anywhere and will have to turn at the end or go into drives, so speed is pointless as it does them no good - just a bad habit they've got into. One of our neighbours is an absolute maniac - he has one of those Audi sports cars (Quattro?) and must be doing 40/50 around the blind corner, every single time - when he sets off in a morning, it's wheel spin time! Once when he came home, he misjudged it and slammed straight into the garage door, but he didn't learn from that and continued driving like a lunatic. Same with delivery vans - I actually saw one coming around the corner so fast it looked like it's nearside wheels were almost off the ground - just why - it had nowhere to go!

As for "rat runs" through housing estates, they're often caused by traffic calming/one way systems/traffic lights etc on other roads - typical road planners not considering the consequences of their "improvements". I used to live on a "through" road in a more traditional housing estate with the criss-cross road pattern rather than cul-de-sacs and closes. I played out daily on the road, very few cars and there was good visibility as the road was straight. The road planning lunatics put a bus lane, traffic calming and traffic lights on what was then the "main" road by-passing our estate and virtually overnight we lived on a rat-run. What did the muppets think would happen when they purposely and deliberately reduced the usable width of the road and put in measures which would obviously cause delays and queues?

Comedycook · 12/01/2023 08:00

If you want this sort of lifestyle then I think you need to look at the whole culture of a country. In the UK, we work long hours...it causes people to be stressed and rushed all the time. If we overall had a more relaxed lifestyle people would be more amenable to an occasional walk

Sceptre86 · 12/01/2023 07:50

No thanks. Who's going to pay for 24 hour security? How would you make sure guests have somewhere to park? What about households with multiple cars taking up too many spots? There will always be cf around to take advantage. We live on an estate and it already has speed bumps, each house has a decent sized garden front and back. There is no reason kids can't play in their gardens than out on the street. There is signs about telling people to reduce their speed. The cost of upkeep would fall to the residents and I already own a drive.

It might work in a city centre but then kids wouldn't be playing on the streets anyway. It might encourage residents to walk or use public transport which is decent in most city centres bit many people would push back as they pay a premium to live in the centre of town anyway.

HammergoHammer · 12/01/2023 07:45

I find it bonkers the attitude in the UK that you have to park next to your house. In my family's part of Europe, parking ten minutes walk from your front door is normal and it's actually good to walk, also makes you think twice about jumping in the car as if you're already walking half a mile you might as well walk the whole way to your destination. But that might be part of the lifestyle (generally healthier in my opinion) plus shopping little and often so no huge 'weekly' shop. Also purely designed for city's and suburbs, rural is different.
I would love for kids to roam freely. People just need to see the light!

Devoutspoken · 12/01/2023 07:41

Crosspusscrossstitcher, less traffic and pollution is good for everyone, sometimes the greater good trumps individual needs however much your driveway cost

Devoutspoken · 12/01/2023 07:37

Bicycles go right up to your front door

Sleepyblueocean · 12/01/2023 07:23

Lots of blue badges are discretionary which means that if you don't write or say the right things you won't get one. This will include my severely disabled son when he moves to PIP.

MooseBreath · 12/01/2023 07:07

I can see how this would work in places like London with good infrastructure and lots of public transportation.

But...
I am in a small town. The nearest grocery store is a 45 minute walk and there is no bus. I have a toddler and a baby. If I couldn't use my car, I would never have chosen to live where I do. In fact, I bought a car when I moved here because I couldn't function without one. The last place I lived, DH and I didn't have a car and used public transportation.

daybroke · 12/01/2023 07:05

@ivykaty44 where I live I can only get a blue badge if I'm in receipt of PIP for mobility.

I was just as disabled before I got my blue badge - it took months to get pip I had to go to tribunal.

I can't walk without crutches. I will soon need a wheelchair. I am in constant pain. I'm worried because I'm due to reapply for pip soon and if it's taken off me I'll be housebound. Or I'll be parking in parent and chose spaces and getting told off by parents (I can't get in or out of the car without having the door fully open)

So, that sort of disability doesn't always have a blue badge.

Sleepyblueocean · 12/01/2023 06:46

"But that's nothing compared to being able to let the kids go out and play with their friends all around the houses"

Having parking close to my house is more important to me than my son who will never be able to play out, being able to play out.

glowfrog · 12/01/2023 06:32

To all those who say it's impractical to have the parking away from where you are - I happen to live on an estate that's kind of like what the OP is wishing for, although it's crescent-shaped so the parking is at most 1mn walk away.

Is it less practical than opening your front door and having your car right there? Sure. Our house is pretty much in the middle so we know know the problem, including when you have 2 very young kids and lots of shopping in the car. But that's nothing compared to being able to let the kids go out and play with their friends all around the houses, especially in London where we are. In a normal terraced house, they would be confined to a garden and not all gardens are equally sized.

ivykaty44 · 12/01/2023 05:08

Disability. Not all disabilities qualify for a blue badge.

which disability doesn’t qualify for a blue badge?

Dowhahdiddy · 12/01/2023 03:07

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

🥱 Reported

Crazylove2 · 12/01/2023 02:30

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

tonystarksrighthand · 12/01/2023 02:26

crosspusscrossstitcher · 10/01/2023 12:58

No thanks.
I've paid enough for my house with a drive and garage, and enough for my car too.

Snap, and I have a 30min school commute, don't want to add another 15mins to it.

What about emergency vehicles?

Ridiculous idea.

Centre Parcs is wanky anyway (and I enjoy going for 4 days)

Dowhahdiddy · 12/01/2023 02:22

Some people have never lived without a car, and it shows 😆

nostaples · 12/01/2023 02:13

Agree OP. Couldn’t drive until my dcs were over 4 and was never fitter. Here we are now like the Americans: drive everywhere including the gym instead of building in exercise yo daily life.

the disability thing is the usual red herring. Blue badges would make it an exception plus advantages for disabled people if not being hurried across roads by cars.

bit depressing really that parents would put the instant gratification convenience of car next to house over advantage to childhood of safe playing out,

Most Londoners and many city dwellers aren’t able to park outside their houses. Their communal parking = the tube.

agree with others that this could be a greater good mindset change like plastic bags, smoking and now disposable plastic cutlery. I remember tutting the first time I realised I had to buy a carrier bag in Aldi, now I reuse my plastic bags like everybody else and think that’s right and proper and not inconvenient at all. Could be the same. Also think recycling centres at the end of every road would be better and more attractive than bins outside houses.

BlackeyedSusan · 12/01/2023 01:18

QuertyGirl · 10/01/2023 12:46

Why not exactly?

A ten or 15 min walk to a communal car park would probably do most of us some good.

Disability. Not all disabilities qualify for a blue badge. There is the grey zone between being fully functioning and disabled enough for a blue badge. Some days I can't walk round my flat without being in pain. Other days can manage to shop in Aldi and carry stuff up lots of stairs. (But then suffer for it the next day)

HidingUnderARock · 12/01/2023 00:04

I've seen ideas for the future of electric and driverless cars where it won't park on your drive but take itself off somewhere to charge after dropping you off and then you'd call it when you want to go somewhere. A bit like a driverless Uber.

Doesn't this double the number of car journeys in the residential area?

Nameneeded · 11/01/2023 23:24

UndertheCedartree · 10/01/2023 12:55

I agree with this. We need to change our mentality around car being king. They have a lot of Shared Space too in the Netherlands which means cars driving slowly and giving way to pedestrians. It's so much safer for children. But they tried it in my city and car drivers just do not play ball.

We have very different attitudes to 'the greater good' than countries like Sweden. If there's a way round a rule in England we'll find it. This would never work here. People in our council estate drive at 40mph and throw their Mcdonalds wrappers out their car windows. Do you think they'd care about creating a car free space ?

bluesuitcase · 11/01/2023 23:05

Daffi · 11/01/2023 21:44

People are completely addicted to their cars and it's getting worse. I have a car but only use it for work. I walk, cycle or bus, very rarely when I am not working. 71% of car journeys are less than 2 miles yet people believe they are essential. PS yes I know some people are disabled and need to drive but that's a tiny percentage of the population. People need to break this trend for their good and the good of their children, health and environmental issues.

I agree with this (I don’t have a car).

At CP I believe blue badge holders can still drive around so if this were the case in these housing estates then that would help those with disabilities.

I find it shocking how reliant many people are on cars for every single journey, no matter how short. Cars are terrible for the environment and for health, we should all be looking to cut down on using them. Many people manage without.