Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we could make housing estates like Center Parcs re cars

809 replies

QuertyGirl · 10/01/2023 12:38

The USP of Centre Parcs is for many, the fact that they are mostly car free. Kids can play out and ride their bikes like I did when I was kid.

Can't do that now due to the amount of cars, speed and size of cars and, attitude of some car drivers.

People (including myself) pay a small fortune to holiday at CP.

Why can't we make housing estates more like that?

Communal car parks in walking distance, deliveries by small electric vehicles from a hub (like old fashioned milk floats), exemptions for blue badge holders and funding for electric mobility scooters for those that need them.

Yet, if the council suggests a couple of cycle lane and all hell breaks loose.

OP posts:
kdramaqueen · 12/01/2023 13:02

@QuertyGirl "Disability is the reason I don't drive"

Is the sub text that if you weren't, you would drive?
Why are you so judgy anyway? Not everyone goes to the gym to have "insta" bodies.
Would you be happy to contribute to the extra costs involved in insuring, cctv, securing and maintaining the estate CP even if you don't own a car?

It's not a daft idea per se, as the people who are willing to pay a premium for no cars on the estate will live there. Inflated house price, yes, because no builder will sacrifice building land to make a car park instead. Less return for builder so house unit price will be higher to cover revenue shortfall.

ivykaty44 · 12/01/2023 13:01

@Bideshi

People often don't like change, even if its positive change and they can be very suspicious of change. Unfortunately that is human nature.

As someone said up thread, cessation of smoking in public buildings was not welcomed and plastic bag charing was unpopular. Now though I bet most people don't even consider it a problem

ivykaty44 · 12/01/2023 12:56

Those living in a car-dependent area:

my best friend is blind and busses are infrequent at best. Works within walking distance but has to walk a strange way to work to allow for crossing at pedestrian crossing.

Relies on taxis and deliveroo, online shopping, chop chop, school bus - which doesn't always turn up and school get angry with her dd not attending...

Doesn't go out a great deal alone, struggles with pavement parking or abandoned vehicles in odd places they shouldn't be

QuertyGirl · 12/01/2023 12:45

@Mary54

I'm sorry for your Mum but she may have lost her independence a lot sooner in a dependent area.

My Aunt lived in an area like that; got macular degeneration and lost her license.

Housebound with no family nearby. Not fun.

There's been at least one other similar situation on this thread.

OP posts:
MooseBreath · 12/01/2023 12:40

QuertyGirl · 12/01/2023 12:15

Those living in a car-dependent area:

What would you do if you lost the car? It happens to a lot of people through age or declining health.

I am in a car-dependent area.

If my DH and I no longer had the ability to drive, we would be forced to move.

Mary54 · 12/01/2023 12:38

Mary54 · 12/01/2023 12:20

They do what most people who don’t drive have to do -pay for taxis or get help from friends and relatives.

Hit post too soon.

I hope OP realizes this is not only an issue in car-dependent areas but something that applies to many people. My answer is based on my DM’s experience.
Never learnt to drive. Lives in walking distance to shops. Has a bus service but no railway station nearby. Therefore this is neither a car-dependent area nor a car-dependent person.
Increasing mobility problems mean walking is getting more difficult and using the bus isn’t really an option anymore.
Travels further than she can walk only when necessary and usually by taxi.

GloomyDarkness · 12/01/2023 12:35

QuertyGirl · 12/01/2023 12:15

Those living in a car-dependent area:

What would you do if you lost the car? It happens to a lot of people through age or declining health.

It's happening to my parents now - it was rural growing up but now I say semirural now.

It's actually easier now than ever before to live without a car - so many places deliver - Specsavers new home services is fantastic, supermarkets and even smaller shops now do home deliveries.

Ideally I'd have liked them to move somewhere with closer services but they haven't but still in their 70 they can both use computers and internet so can still be independent. Having car right outside had meant DMum could get Dad to the car for much longer so they remained mobile for longer.

We don't drive and do rely on taxis on occasions - we live in a city having both grown up fairly rural and do spend more on train journeys which are frequently longer and more expensive than car journeys would be - but that's what it is we save on car running costs most of the time.

I would love better train and bus services for everyone - and at minute they are getting less reliable and more expensive - but even I'm getting fed us of this sudden and very pushed narrative that we need to make car drivers the enemy. Were as in reality what's need to make it easier to not dive so changes that deprioritising cars face less opposition as people have other options and know that.

Bideshi · 12/01/2023 12:32

I think the problem here is that people are thinking of the standard British housing development, whereas in fact, the ones that are designed to be car-free look very different - smaller, for a start, and more cohesive. It's a pity people have such closed minds. I do understand many of the issues raised here, but nevertheless, car-free estates don't seem to be a problem where they exist in other countries. Maybe they're not for everyone, but it would be nice to see some for the people who would love to embrace that sort of lifestyle.

QuertyGirl · 12/01/2023 12:30

And?

What I'm getting at, is that default mode of transport that we have (cars) is dependent on money and good health.

Better public transport, cycling and walking provision could give a lot of people their freedom back. Real freedom, not dependent on being able to run and drive a car. Freedom that almost anyone can have.

OP posts:
DailyCake · 12/01/2023 12:29

I totally understand people with certain disabilities needing to park next to their house but people who are completely able-bodied but terrified of a bit of rain 🙄

Oblivious of what the weather is like in Scotland. We often have high winds, horizontal rain and sometimes it's dark by 15:30 in winter.

Sleepyblueocean · 12/01/2023 12:24

That's the case for all people who cannot drive and cannot walk, cycle or use public transport.

QuertyGirl · 12/01/2023 12:22

So if you can't afford a taxi (cost a fortune round here) you rely on lifts?

That's a bit crap.

OP posts:
Mary54 · 12/01/2023 12:20

They do what most people who don’t drive have to do -pay for taxis or get help from friends and relatives.

QuertyGirl · 12/01/2023 12:15

Those living in a car-dependent area:

What would you do if you lost the car? It happens to a lot of people through age or declining health.

OP posts:
QuertyGirl · 12/01/2023 12:13

ScotsBluebell · 12/01/2023 11:51

Quite apart from the problems for people with mobility or other health issues who don't qualify for a Blue Badge, depending on the area, this could be a nightmare for women coming home alone late at night. I live in a very safe area, but I can think of far too many places where I wouldn't want to be walking alone at night. I know 'not all men' etc, but a small percentage are predators, and they would take advantage. Also family shopping. Garden stuff. Bags of potting compost anyone? Impractical. Pretty invidious pointing out what our mothers and grandmothers did. It was a different world.

Women who can't drive? Women who can't afford a car?

OP posts:
Biddie191 · 12/01/2023 11:57

I lived on an estate, probably built in the 60's, where all houses had access to the rear (roads between back gardens) but between houses in front it was pedestrian only - was really nice to sit out front and chat to neighbours / children could play out front etc, but could still get right to back gate / garages by car for unloading shopping etc. Houses were in rows of about 8, I think, so if you wanted to go round to the garden without going through it wasn't too far, but long enough out front for little ones to learn to ride a bike / bod about. I always thought it was a great layout, but many people clearly don't!

ScotsBluebell · 12/01/2023 11:51

Quite apart from the problems for people with mobility or other health issues who don't qualify for a Blue Badge, depending on the area, this could be a nightmare for women coming home alone late at night. I live in a very safe area, but I can think of far too many places where I wouldn't want to be walking alone at night. I know 'not all men' etc, but a small percentage are predators, and they would take advantage. Also family shopping. Garden stuff. Bags of potting compost anyone? Impractical. Pretty invidious pointing out what our mothers and grandmothers did. It was a different world.

ivykaty44 · 12/01/2023 11:46

user1468656818 · 12/01/2023 11:08

disabled people only rely on cars in car-dependent places because they have to. Mobility aids become more useful, and neighborhoods become more
accessible, when they are not centered around cars. Car-centric towns are more structurally ableist than accessible walkable towns.

In Cambridge (UK) 26% of disabled workers commute by bicycle

2/3 of disabled cyclists say cycling is easier than walking for them

In London 78% of disabled people say they can cycle but only 15% actually do cycle 'sometimes' or more, probably scared of those fucking cars.

For the majority of disabled people cycling is a tool for freedom just like it is for an able bodied person.

All stats from here: www.theguardian.com/cities/2018/jan/02/cambridge-disabled-people-cycling-rolling-walking-stick

this is so true but often overlooked at the detriment of many people with physical disabilities

Sleepyblueocean · 12/01/2023 11:33

"Why will he never be able to play out?"

He is severely learning disabled and autistic and can't cope with and has nothing in common with other children/ young people (he is now a teenager) apart from those he mixes closely with at special school.

user1468656818 · 12/01/2023 11:08

disabled people only rely on cars in car-dependent places because they have to. Mobility aids become more useful, and neighborhoods become more
accessible, when they are not centered around cars. Car-centric towns are more structurally ableist than accessible walkable towns.

In Cambridge (UK) 26% of disabled workers commute by bicycle

2/3 of disabled cyclists say cycling is easier than walking for them

In London 78% of disabled people say they can cycle but only 15% actually do cycle 'sometimes' or more, probably scared of those fucking cars.

For the majority of disabled people cycling is a tool for freedom just like it is for an able bodied person.

All stats from here: www.theguardian.com/cities/2018/jan/02/cambridge-disabled-people-cycling-rolling-walking-stick

ivykaty44 · 12/01/2023 10:57

The main benefit is reducing the need for parking, either at home, or town centres, hospitals, workplaces,

cars dominate local streets and pavements

thats why children can't play out, as its wall to wall cars & they've got bigger and bigger

Redblanky · 12/01/2023 10:46

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 12/01/2023 10:29

Something else that occurs to me is that people are advocating these places largely on the grounds of how wonderful and safe they are for children to play; but when anybody mentions disabled and elderly folk, they're just told that they can choose to live elsewhere instead - or presumably be forced out of their homes if they later become disabled or frailer as they age.

Where does that leave disabled people with children or kids who live with their grandparents? All these hard and fast draconian rules banning cars anywhere near to people's homes (as opposed to, say, strictly enforced 5mph limits) would also seem to be discriminating against the children of parents who aren't young and able-bodied, and who thus don't qualify for living in this magical utopia. Maybe those kids just don't matter....

The estates that were built that way round here aren't even safe places for children to play. They're so isolated the crime rate is v high.

usernamealreadytaken · 12/01/2023 10:36

QuertyGirl · 10/01/2023 12:38

The USP of Centre Parcs is for many, the fact that they are mostly car free. Kids can play out and ride their bikes like I did when I was kid.

Can't do that now due to the amount of cars, speed and size of cars and, attitude of some car drivers.

People (including myself) pay a small fortune to holiday at CP.

Why can't we make housing estates more like that?

Communal car parks in walking distance, deliveries by small electric vehicles from a hub (like old fashioned milk floats), exemptions for blue badge holders and funding for electric mobility scooters for those that need them.

Yet, if the council suggests a couple of cycle lane and all hell breaks loose.

Yup, I'd love to lug several £000 electronic equipment through the tipping rain, hoping not to get mugged, to get to my car to go to work.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 12/01/2023 10:29

Something else that occurs to me is that people are advocating these places largely on the grounds of how wonderful and safe they are for children to play; but when anybody mentions disabled and elderly folk, they're just told that they can choose to live elsewhere instead - or presumably be forced out of their homes if they later become disabled or frailer as they age.

Where does that leave disabled people with children or kids who live with their grandparents? All these hard and fast draconian rules banning cars anywhere near to people's homes (as opposed to, say, strictly enforced 5mph limits) would also seem to be discriminating against the children of parents who aren't young and able-bodied, and who thus don't qualify for living in this magical utopia. Maybe those kids just don't matter....

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 12/01/2023 10:20

The problem is it would be shouted down by a horde of people on here who are not disabled, so don’t need the car right outside the front door, and yet they see cars as a psychological extension of their psyche.
They see a car, parked as close as possible to the house, up on a kerb etc, as a human right. It gives “freedom” and “independence”, and having to walk three to four minutes to get into the car negates the whole experience.

You can say that about any modern invention that makes life much easier, though. What about all these lazy, non-disabled people who use washing machines - harming the planet with electricity use - when they could just shut up and grab their eco-friendly dolly tub and mangle? Everybody on this thread clearly happily makes use of a phone or computer - they don't run on moonbeams either.

Some people seem to want to be a martyr by rebelling against modern life - but only the bits that they are happy to do without. They're like Mrs Doyle - 'maybe they like the misery'.

At CP I believe blue badge holders can still drive around so if this were the case in these housing estates then that would help those with disabilities.

As has been clearly outlined on this thread, that helps some disabled people, but a whole load of other disabled people and those with mobility problems are just flung under the bus.

Swipe left for the next trending thread