Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we could make housing estates like Center Parcs re cars

809 replies

QuertyGirl · 10/01/2023 12:38

The USP of Centre Parcs is for many, the fact that they are mostly car free. Kids can play out and ride their bikes like I did when I was kid.

Can't do that now due to the amount of cars, speed and size of cars and, attitude of some car drivers.

People (including myself) pay a small fortune to holiday at CP.

Why can't we make housing estates more like that?

Communal car parks in walking distance, deliveries by small electric vehicles from a hub (like old fashioned milk floats), exemptions for blue badge holders and funding for electric mobility scooters for those that need them.

Yet, if the council suggests a couple of cycle lane and all hell breaks loose.

OP posts:
tigger1001 · 12/01/2023 16:10

Devoutspoken · 12/01/2023 15:11

Tigger1001 - so having your xhopp8ng delivered is more expensive than running a car?

I need a car to get to work.

WhatNoRaisins · 12/01/2023 15:52

We've stopped doing supermarket deliveries after we've found they often don't have the cheapest own brand stuff. Most of the time we actually do walk to our local supermarket with a rucksack but there's a limit as to what either of us feel up to hauling back. Once in a while we'll need that massive bag of spuds or box of washing powder and that's when we drive and do a big shop maybe once a month.

In this no cars neighborhood would you have to wait for your shopping to be delivered to the communal car park and carry it all home?

Devoutspoken · 12/01/2023 15:34

Oopsanotherone, no one is asking you to be a martyr, its about opening your thinking to reducing car use, not banning - rain coats work well in the rain and supermarkets deliver

OopsAnotherOne · 12/01/2023 15:28

As long as this is not mandatory and the current ability to park beside your house remains in many areas, I can't see a problem with people wanting to opt for this lifestyle buying houses in areas built for this purpose. I can imagine this is a lifestyle that some people would enjoy but it isn't for everyone.

I personally would not want to live somewhere where my car was a 15 minute walk from my house. I work long hours, am also studying for a degree, as well as having the rest of the daily life/chores/admin/cooking/cleaning to do, as well as finding time to simply rest! I can get a lot done in 15 minutes (or multiples of 15 if I've had to do more than 1 trip from my car with whatever luggage/shopping I've got to carry), and I wouldn't want to have to do that in all weathers.

On the two evenings a week I go to sport clubs, I have a 20 minute turnaround from arriving home at work to leaving again. In that time I have to get changed, get my kit ready, cram some food down my throat and then rush out the house again. A 15 minute walk added to this would not allow me to arrive in time to those clubs.

People say "no one wants to give up their conveniences", and they might be correct, but why should we? I am more than active enough, I am healthy, I don't need the enforced exercise. I pay for my own car, my own driveway and my insurance is more affordable because my car is kept on my drive. I often get home from work and have to go back out to all sorts of places - if it's raining and my car is 15 minutes away, I am drenched when I get home and then drenched again by the time I get back to the car. Why would this be preferable over remaining dry? I'm not a martyr, I like being comfortable, I like being able to nip back to my car to grab something I've forgotten, or do 2+ trips when bringing in shopping.

Plenty of people do manage without cars and that is their choice. I prefer to have access to a car without having to do a 30 minute round walk to access it and that works better for me. My lifestyle isn't everyone's cup of tea but this proposed lifestyle certainly isn't mine. All of that being said, I would have no objections to other people living in that way.

neighboursmustliveon · 12/01/2023 15:12

I absolutely agree we need to stop people driving needlessly.

I work in a school. I have colleagues who lives in the same street practically that we are based on, it would take them 3 mins max to walk from their door to the car park of the school. Yet they often bring their car!

I am 1.5 miles from work which is just that bit too far for me, especially as I have to bring my lap top to and from work but also, I often get called out to visit other schools which are spread over different towns, even counties so not having my car with me isn't practical.

We do live in the town centre though so on a weekend we walk to talk and local supermarket when we need to and only take the car if we are going for a heavy shop.

Devoutspoken · 12/01/2023 15:11

Tigger1001 - so having your xhopp8ng delivered is more expensive than running a car?

whatkatydid2013 · 12/01/2023 15:00

It’s a great idea for some places. Others it would be harder to make it work. We should try though. We need to do something to make it less automatic to just constantly use cars for everything. So many people drive kids to/from school where I live and return home. It’s a 5-6 min drive vs a 7-8 min walk so they are saving themselves possibly a whole 10 minutes a day. It’s utter bollocks most people do it because they have to or they are disabled. They basically do it out of habit. I used to as well and then I realised how silly it was and I stopped

Devoutspoken · 12/01/2023 14:55

Kdrama - you can get shopping delivered, and not drive to the gym, run, cycle?

user1468656818 · 12/01/2023 14:53

jannier · 12/01/2023 14:42

Love to see people who can't move their legs to walk peddle a bike what utter rubbish if you can climb stairs, walk, or move without pain how can you peddle a bike? So the biking disabled don't need a blue badge mobility is not their disability.

There are many different types of disabilities, both temporary/short-term or permanent/long-term. People are not always going to have or even want the perfect mobility aid for any particular purpose.

Allowing for individuals of all ability levels to do all the things they can is an argument in favor of design that allows for cars of some sort, but it is a much stronger argument for comprehensive safe bike lanes and pavements and an argument against car-only or car-centric design.

SweetSakura · 12/01/2023 14:50

SavoirFlair · 12/01/2023 13:26

So many close minded people on this thread who would use any possible reason to justify car ownership.

I have a car, but I’m not defined by having a car. It’s not my “freedom”, it’s not my “independence”.

It wasn't mine ... My legs were my freedom and my independence.... Then through no fault of my own I developed a debilitating neuromuscular junction disorder. If I move too much my body stops sending any messages from my brain to my muscles. This happened to me today. I thought I would manage the few hundred metres on a site visit. By the time I was done I couldn't walk properly, speak properly or swallow safely.

I now see how lucky I was to not be dependent on a car.

But yeah, keep implying disabled people are lazy or can use a bike.

pinneddownbytabbies · 12/01/2023 14:49

I used to live in a flat, and the car was parked a hundred yards away. That was bad enough, with having to lug several shopping bags in the British weather, quite often needing two trips, and I didn't even have dc at the time either.

Sorry OP, but it is a terrible idea.

jannier · 12/01/2023 14:42

user1468656818 · 12/01/2023 11:08

disabled people only rely on cars in car-dependent places because they have to. Mobility aids become more useful, and neighborhoods become more
accessible, when they are not centered around cars. Car-centric towns are more structurally ableist than accessible walkable towns.

In Cambridge (UK) 26% of disabled workers commute by bicycle

2/3 of disabled cyclists say cycling is easier than walking for them

In London 78% of disabled people say they can cycle but only 15% actually do cycle 'sometimes' or more, probably scared of those fucking cars.

For the majority of disabled people cycling is a tool for freedom just like it is for an able bodied person.

All stats from here: www.theguardian.com/cities/2018/jan/02/cambridge-disabled-people-cycling-rolling-walking-stick

Love to see people who can't move their legs to walk peddle a bike what utter rubbish if you can climb stairs, walk, or move without pain how can you peddle a bike? So the biking disabled don't need a blue badge mobility is not their disability.

Dotjones · 12/01/2023 14:20

bottledgrapes · 12/01/2023 13:57

If me and DH wanted to go car free we would save around £500 a month
What? How on earth does running a car cost you £500 every month?

You could easily spend £500 a month if you are on a leasing plan.

bottledgrapes · 12/01/2023 13:57

If me and DH wanted to go car free we would save around £500 a month
What? How on earth does running a car cost you £500 every month?

tigger1001 · 12/01/2023 13:54

QuertyGirl · 12/01/2023 12:15

Those living in a car-dependent area:

What would you do if you lost the car? It happens to a lot of people through age or declining health.

If it happened due to age, hopefully I would be retired. So work would hopefully not be an issue. If it happened when I was working, I wouldn't be able to carry on working unless I could work from home. Shopping would need to be delivered, but that makes it more expensive - by the choice of the shop and the delivery charge. Buses are not ideal.

What happens currently with my mil is family members do her main shop and she tops up at the local shop. She doesn't go out much at all any more, but needs lifts if she does.

DailyCake · 12/01/2023 13:53

SavoirFlair · 12/01/2023 13:26

So many close minded people on this thread who would use any possible reason to justify car ownership.

I have a car, but I’m not defined by having a car. It’s not my “freedom”, it’s not my “independence”.

There is no public transport where I live; a peaceful rural area surrounded by farms. My car is synonymous with freedom and independence. I know that as soon as I can no longer drive I will have to sell up and move into some built up area with walking distance facilities.
I feel that I am very lucky to be able to live where I do now, even if with the downside of compulsory car ownership and no mains gas connection.

WhatNoRaisins · 12/01/2023 13:48

For many people not having their car would make their lives more limited and more expensive. I get the negatives of too many cars but let's not pretend we'd return to some idealised version of the past.

And yes 2 miles might not be far to walk or cycle but on a twisty road with no pavement it would be bloody terrifying.

Grumpybutfunny · 12/01/2023 13:44

SavoirFlair · 12/01/2023 13:26

So many close minded people on this thread who would use any possible reason to justify car ownership.

I have a car, but I’m not defined by having a car. It’s not my “freedom”, it’s not my “independence”.

So I am an able bodied woman I work 20 miles from home. On a morning I have to leave by 7:40 to start work at 8:30 but need to drop DS at breakfast club at 7:45 1st. Only bus which will get me to work for 8:30 leaves ours at 7:10, DH leaves for work at 7 so can't do the school run either. He then has to be picked up by 17:45 if not at grandmas bus wouldn't get me back until 18:30 and DH gets in around 18:00. So my commute + childcare means I can't do my job unless we have a car. We both work weekends and buses don't run early enough on a Sunday to make that possible.

Getting everywhere is quicker by car vs bike/bus/walking which frees up more time for social activities like DS's clubs and me getting the gym 4miles away from home. I wouldn't give up the freedom and time saving of having a car for the £300 a month it would save. If me and DH wanted to go car free we would save around £500 a month but would need to employ a nanny at 2k a month! Kids don't need to play in the street that's what green spaces and garden are for. The issue is more our determination to get rid of cars instead of going down the suburbs route to commute to work by cars (duel carriageways to link the areas without pedestrian crossing that slow down traffic)!!

kdramaqueen · 12/01/2023 13:35

Daffi · 11/01/2023 21:44

People are completely addicted to their cars and it's getting worse. I have a car but only use it for work. I walk, cycle or bus, very rarely when I am not working. 71% of car journeys are less than 2 miles yet people believe they are essential. PS yes I know some people are disabled and need to drive but that's a tiny percentage of the population. People need to break this trend for their good and the good of their children, health and environmental issues.

A comment coming from a position of privilege. I am dependent on my car because I live in a semi-rural area. Supermarket and doctor are on the other side of a busy dual carriageway, gym is 5 miles away on twisty road with no pavements. No cross country buses, so school which is 9 miles away in the city would take 15 min walk down a steep hill to nearest bus stop and require a change of bus. Some people are not addicted, but dependent on their car.

SavoirFlair · 12/01/2023 13:26

So many close minded people on this thread who would use any possible reason to justify car ownership.

I have a car, but I’m not defined by having a car. It’s not my “freedom”, it’s not my “independence”.

glowfrog · 12/01/2023 13:22

Sleepyblueocean · 12/01/2023 11:33

"Why will he never be able to play out?"

He is severely learning disabled and autistic and can't cope with and has nothing in common with other children/ young people (he is now a teenager) apart from those he mixes closely with at special school.

Well, that's fair enough and must be very difficult but plenty of other children are able to play outside and would benefit. No one here is talking about absolutely every single housing development being transformed in this way - although there have been already examples of set-ups that wouldn't require anything like 10mn walk to get to a car.

WhatNoRaisins · 12/01/2023 13:18

The rear of the property idea could have legs with decent garages that things could be taken through to. Most of us have seen too many badly thought out developments done on the cheap so we're going to be cynical about anything really.

ivykaty44 · 12/01/2023 13:13

All the cars are in the garages or beside the garage, grass between the front doors and a large grass area in the middle of the horseshoe shape

no cars outside any front doors

To think we could make housing estates like Center Parcs re cars
To think we could make housing estates like Center Parcs re cars
ivykaty44 · 12/01/2023 13:06

Doesn't always work though.

doesn't mean it shouldn't be done where it can work, and LTN are being rolled out in more and more places.

I live in a town where they build an entire estate based on LTN and grass in the front of peoples houses and garages at the back of each house - so not only where they LTN they were easy to park cars and close to the house, just at the rear of the property

Lisbon37 · 12/01/2023 13:03

I don't think it would necessarily have to be one massive car park 15 mins away from housing requiring security! I'm sure a scheme could be designed with several smaller car parking areas that are maybe just a few minutes walk to housing but which would still allow car free zones. I think it would really help foster a sense of community as well as allowing children to roam about safely.