Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we could make housing estates like Center Parcs re cars

809 replies

QuertyGirl · 10/01/2023 12:38

The USP of Centre Parcs is for many, the fact that they are mostly car free. Kids can play out and ride their bikes like I did when I was kid.

Can't do that now due to the amount of cars, speed and size of cars and, attitude of some car drivers.

People (including myself) pay a small fortune to holiday at CP.

Why can't we make housing estates more like that?

Communal car parks in walking distance, deliveries by small electric vehicles from a hub (like old fashioned milk floats), exemptions for blue badge holders and funding for electric mobility scooters for those that need them.

Yet, if the council suggests a couple of cycle lane and all hell breaks loose.

OP posts:
kdramaqueen · 13/01/2023 00:45

@ivykaty44 "it’s cheaper to buy on Amazon rather than supermarket for bulk items, toilet paper, pasta, coffee can be sourced on Amazon cheaper"

Not sure this is true, so I checked prices.
Lidl 250gms Chickpea fusilli at £1.49. (£5.96 per kilo); Amazon - £16.90 per kilo.
Lidl plain flour - 38p/kg; Amazon - £1.35/kg
Lidl 200gm freeze dried coffee - £1.99; Amazon's cheapest 200gm - £5.20
Lidl 2ply toilet paper - 22.8p each; Amazon cheapest is 24p each.

I guess it depends which supermarket you use. The coffee price difference is enormous at Amazon!

CuteOrangeElephant · 13/01/2023 00:27

You know what. I am giving up on this thread.

It's an injustice that so many people in the UK can not travel easily because there is a refusal to even entertain not using cars as much. 50% of disabled people don't drive but they don't seem to factor in this discussion.

I personally know a lot of people who would not have the freedom they would have now if they lived in the UK, versus living in my town in the Netherlands where they can go anywhere in town without having to buy, insure, tax a car and spend serious money getting a licence in the first in the place.

This includes my great-uncle who used a hand-propelled wheelchair, my two old neighbours in their mobility scooters and my brother's ex who had a seizure and wasn't allowed to drive.

I am really glad I left. Quality of life is so much better and it has cost me one secondhand bike to enjoy everything in a 10 mile radius.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 13/01/2023 00:20

....And, as Jannier very rightly points out, there are so many obstacles to disabled people having the opportunity to learn to drive (or afford it), that very strongly suggests that the remaining 45% don't all not want to drive.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 13/01/2023 00:18

You do realise only 55% of disabled people in England aged 17-64 hold a full driving licence

Or, to put it another way, more than half of all disabled people potentially rely on their cars as an absolute lifeline.

Of course, the real figure is likely much higher, as many disabled non-drivers will have a driving spouse, parent, adult child and/or carer who lives with them; or will regularly require taxis to take them door to door.

jannier · 13/01/2023 00:05

CuteOrangeElephant · 12/01/2023 22:06

My great-uncle had a severed spinal cord and went everywhere on an adapted bike. He used his hands to propel. I would see him all the time on my way to school. For him it was freedom, exercise and fresh air.

Other alternatives to peddling are e-bikes (you do have to peddle but a lot less) or mobility scooters.

Any physical movement can cause extreme pain to many hands or legs or even sat still....if you read the above you would see mobility scooters discussed...storage, weight, dismantling and rebuilding both physical effort requiring an additional person as well as the additional 30 minutes to do so, lack of being independent, unable to use in certain weather conditions. Issues of storage. Do you use one? Have you ever had to load one?

CuteOrangeElephant · 12/01/2023 22:06

jannier · 12/01/2023 14:42

Love to see people who can't move their legs to walk peddle a bike what utter rubbish if you can climb stairs, walk, or move without pain how can you peddle a bike? So the biking disabled don't need a blue badge mobility is not their disability.

My great-uncle had a severed spinal cord and went everywhere on an adapted bike. He used his hands to propel. I would see him all the time on my way to school. For him it was freedom, exercise and fresh air.

Other alternatives to peddling are e-bikes (you do have to peddle but a lot less) or mobility scooters.

Devoutspoken · 12/01/2023 19:58

Yeah bumper to bumper cars, much better

Bushgirl · 12/01/2023 19:40

Why on earth would anyone want to replicate CP. I can't think of anywhere worse for a holiday, I certainly wouldn't want it in my day to day life.

jannier · 12/01/2023 19:22

ivykaty44 · 12/01/2023 18:34

Firstly, shopping is so much cheaper if you can go to a big supermarket and buy bigger quantities (e.g. 1kg bag of pasta is cheaper per 100g than a 500g bag).

it’s cheaper to buy on Amazon rather than supermarket for bulk items, toilet paper, pasta, coffee can be sourced on Amazon cheaper

Yeah you can store you 50 loo rolls etc your hall door next to your disability scooter....can't get out of the house and the paramedic can't get in but your disabled so who cares you should have kept fit as an embryo

SweetSakura · 12/01/2023 19:22

Exactly @jannier

jannier · 12/01/2023 19:19

user1468656818 · 12/01/2023 17:37

You do realise only 55% of disabled people in England aged 17-64 hold a full driving licence, compared with 83% of non-disabled people (though disabled people are much more likely to travel as passengers in a car or taxi). therefore action to reduce unnecessary traffic would be good for disabled people who must use a car, and it would also improve the lives of those who don’t, be they disabled or not

Yes I'm well aware the mobility allowance is insufficient for many to get a motobility vehicle because they then have to be able to afford running costs....the additional monies now required mean that bigger wheelchair accessible cars or high cars easy to transfer to now require a higher financial contribution...that there are few adapted learner cars to learn in or instructors willing to do it, and that being the only fit enough driver for 4 disabled people living in 3 different home to mine means if there were less traffic I'd get the 3 or miles between them and to any of the 4 different hospitals a lot quicker....but I also understand other people need cars and have problems....and it still does not alter the argument that every physically disabled person would want the best most accessible transport and their independence they don't want to rely on others to drive them or to see others lift and load disability scooters more than needed because they now need it out in their hallway blocking access to drive down to their car where an able bodied weigh lifter has to load it before they start their journey....a nice additional half hour and back strain.

jannier · 12/01/2023 19:08

user1468656818 · 12/01/2023 17:27

People-centric infrastructure would, by definition be focused on the needs of the people, including sick and disabled individuals. This includes public transport with special adjustments for wheelchair accessibility.

I hope your nephews quality of life improves in the future.

Unlikely he's lived mostly in his room since he was 16 and is now 30 his wheelchair bound mum has cancer and also needs a bypass so his anxiety is only going one way. I guess it's going to be one less car for the anti cars to worry about but how in car free eutopia I would be able to drive to his door to get him out even to a GP I don't know..... irrelevant because Ulez is going to see me carless and jobless and my husband won't be able to replace his work van so we will be home claiming benefits....and my disabled brother housebound too as I drive him...were a real lucky family

ivykaty44 · 12/01/2023 18:34

Firstly, shopping is so much cheaper if you can go to a big supermarket and buy bigger quantities (e.g. 1kg bag of pasta is cheaper per 100g than a 500g bag).

it’s cheaper to buy on Amazon rather than supermarket for bulk items, toilet paper, pasta, coffee can be sourced on Amazon cheaper

user1468656818 · 12/01/2023 17:37

jannier · 12/01/2023 17:14

If you are truly disabled not a broken leg you do want the perfect mobility solution and independence.....is your opinion coming from a truly mobility impaired point of view or a bystanders guess?

You do realise only 55% of disabled people in England aged 17-64 hold a full driving licence, compared with 83% of non-disabled people (though disabled people are much more likely to travel as passengers in a car or taxi). therefore action to reduce unnecessary traffic would be good for disabled people who must use a car, and it would also improve the lives of those who don’t, be they disabled or not

WindUpPenguin · 12/01/2023 17:33

QuertyGirl · 10/01/2023 12:51

I manage shopping and a child without a car. I don't drive due to disability.

My mother and grandmother did it too.

What's changed?

I think what has changed most is the way people shop and live.

Firstly, shopping is so much cheaper if you can go to a big supermarket and buy bigger quantities (e.g. 1kg bag of pasta is cheaper per 100g than a 500g bag). If you are driving to the big supermarket, you want to make it worth the time and petrol money, so you want to buy a decent amount. Carrying back that amount with a small child or two even for 10-15 mins would be a nightmare.

Secondly, I feel that we live much 'faster' than I did as a child. It is rare to have a stay at home parent (in my circles at least). Children therefore must fit around jobs. If you are working from home, the 15 minutes to walk to the car to drop/pick up your child from nursery/childminder/school might be the one hour difference between being able to manage your childcare alongside a full time job, and that's assuming you are not also racing your child around in the school-dinner-scouts/swimming lesson-home in time for bed loop.

I think your idea is lovely, and I for one would embrace it, but it would be difficult to make it work in today's society.

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 12/01/2023 17:33

SavoirFlair · 12/01/2023 13:26

So many close minded people on this thread who would use any possible reason to justify car ownership.

I have a car, but I’m not defined by having a car. It’s not my “freedom”, it’s not my “independence”.

You are luckier than me then, @SavoirFlair. Without a car on the drive, I would have no independence or freedom. And that is not an excuse - it is the simple fact.

user1468656818 · 12/01/2023 17:27

jannier · 12/01/2023 17:04

But people who can walk or ride a bike are not the issue if you can't walk or need to use a disability scooter then load/unload it there is an issue with not parking nearby....coming from a family with a variety of disability some born with some injuries I'm well aware of the ranges they can take....the 90 odd percent of disable find it easier to ride a bike is the issue because if your counting disabilities that have no mobility issue it's not a fair argument in the context of this debate. Although my autistic nephew can just about manage the front door to the drive to go out...in the dark no lights on in car...he won't walk because people may see him as that upsets him sending him into anxiety.

People-centric infrastructure would, by definition be focused on the needs of the people, including sick and disabled individuals. This includes public transport with special adjustments for wheelchair accessibility.

I hope your nephews quality of life improves in the future.

jannier · 12/01/2023 17:17

SavoirFlair · 12/01/2023 13:26

So many close minded people on this thread who would use any possible reason to justify car ownership.

I have a car, but I’m not defined by having a car. It’s not my “freedom”, it’s not my “independence”.

Can you physically walk? Do you live somewhere where there is one bus in and one bus out a day ....arriving withing a 2 hour slot or no bus at all?

jannier · 12/01/2023 17:14

user1468656818 · 12/01/2023 14:53

There are many different types of disabilities, both temporary/short-term or permanent/long-term. People are not always going to have or even want the perfect mobility aid for any particular purpose.

Allowing for individuals of all ability levels to do all the things they can is an argument in favor of design that allows for cars of some sort, but it is a much stronger argument for comprehensive safe bike lanes and pavements and an argument against car-only or car-centric design.

If you are truly disabled not a broken leg you do want the perfect mobility solution and independence.....is your opinion coming from a truly mobility impaired point of view or a bystanders guess?

jannier · 12/01/2023 17:11

Devoutspoken · 12/01/2023 14:55

Kdrama - you can get shopping delivered, and not drive to the gym, run, cycle?

Why assume because you can go to a gym you're able bodied enough to walk or cycle....are you now excluding disabled from gyms? Have you heard of chair exercise, swimming for the disabled. Can a wheelchair user not lift weights ....your attitude to disability smacks of keep them in a home away from us.

ivykaty44 · 12/01/2023 17:08

but why should we?

because it causes the premature deaths of around 50000 people annually in U.K. from pollution

its not an all or nothing situation either, it’s a reduction and change. No one is suggesting banning private ownership

jannier · 12/01/2023 17:06

WhatNoRaisins · 12/01/2023 15:52

We've stopped doing supermarket deliveries after we've found they often don't have the cheapest own brand stuff. Most of the time we actually do walk to our local supermarket with a rucksack but there's a limit as to what either of us feel up to hauling back. Once in a while we'll need that massive bag of spuds or box of washing powder and that's when we drive and do a big shop maybe once a month.

In this no cars neighborhood would you have to wait for your shopping to be delivered to the communal car park and carry it all home?

Only on the day and time the supermarket picks apparently tough if your still at work

jannier · 12/01/2023 17:04

user1468656818 · 12/01/2023 14:53

There are many different types of disabilities, both temporary/short-term or permanent/long-term. People are not always going to have or even want the perfect mobility aid for any particular purpose.

Allowing for individuals of all ability levels to do all the things they can is an argument in favor of design that allows for cars of some sort, but it is a much stronger argument for comprehensive safe bike lanes and pavements and an argument against car-only or car-centric design.

But people who can walk or ride a bike are not the issue if you can't walk or need to use a disability scooter then load/unload it there is an issue with not parking nearby....coming from a family with a variety of disability some born with some injuries I'm well aware of the ranges they can take....the 90 odd percent of disable find it easier to ride a bike is the issue because if your counting disabilities that have no mobility issue it's not a fair argument in the context of this debate. Although my autistic nephew can just about manage the front door to the drive to go out...in the dark no lights on in car...he won't walk because people may see him as that upsets him sending him into anxiety.

ivykaty44 · 12/01/2023 17:04

@jannier One legged cyclists are a common occurrence with amputees, but they qualify for a blue badge due to walking issues

we used to have a one legged cyclist in town, but he used a wooden peg on the peddle.

kdramaqueen · 12/01/2023 16:55

@Devoutspoken I shop at Lidl and they don't deliver. I go to the gym because I have a spinal injury from 20 years ago, so to avoid having my spine wired, my surgeon agreed that I could continue Pilates to strengthen my core to hold my spine in place. As I got stronger (and older, I'm almost 70) over the years I've added strength, stability and swimming. The gym is 5 miles away and the road to it is twisty, National speed limit and the verge is actually the edge of fields. You would have a choice of knee high grass or take your chances dodging traffic on the road.
I haven't cycled since I was 14 and don't fancy my chances of wobbling, probably falling and breaking a bone, while attempting to cycle to the gym.
Sometimes you just have to believe people when they say that driving a car means freedom and independence. Confused

Swipe left for the next trending thread