Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we could make housing estates like Center Parcs re cars

809 replies

QuertyGirl · 10/01/2023 12:38

The USP of Centre Parcs is for many, the fact that they are mostly car free. Kids can play out and ride their bikes like I did when I was kid.

Can't do that now due to the amount of cars, speed and size of cars and, attitude of some car drivers.

People (including myself) pay a small fortune to holiday at CP.

Why can't we make housing estates more like that?

Communal car parks in walking distance, deliveries by small electric vehicles from a hub (like old fashioned milk floats), exemptions for blue badge holders and funding for electric mobility scooters for those that need them.

Yet, if the council suggests a couple of cycle lane and all hell breaks loose.

OP posts:
Aftersevens · 10/01/2023 14:04

Internetstranger · 10/01/2023 14:03

If it meant kids could play out in the street I’d be up for it, but there would be so many exemptions for elderly / disabled / builders / deliveries that it still wouldn’t be safe enough for kids so would be pointless.

Electric vehicles with 5mph speed limits.

housemaus · 10/01/2023 14:04

MzHz · 10/01/2023 13:57

With a bootful of shopping?

yeah right.

Surely the point is that people would change how they do things, though? Get a fold-down trolley that goes in your car's boot for shopping. Buy less at a time. Those who are able to, shop at smaller shops within the communities (10-minute neighbourhood style). Get it delivered. Demand would be there for more and better shopping delivery to communities set up like this, where there could be set slots each week for a particular 'estate' to minimise environmental impact and ensure delivery slots. Prices at smaller local shops would have to compete with these delivery services from big supermarkets, so the price difference wouldn't be huge and those unable to get deliveries for whatever reason could shop locally.

It's not like it's hard to imagine ways round it - I find it so strange that you couldn't think of a single alternative to 'have giant carful of shopping'. How do you think people who don't have cars or can't park close to their house do their big shop now!? I used to take a little old person shopping trolley (or hiking rucksack) on the bus to Lidl when I was a student. My mum, who has limited physical mobility and no car, gets hers delivered with next door's, so they share delivery costs between them.

CuteOrangeElephant · 10/01/2023 14:04

cadburyegg · 10/01/2023 14:01

Lol no. As a single parent I love CP and it's an easy-ish holiday for us but the only downside is having to drag the kids out early on leaving morning to walk 20 minutes, sometimes longer, to get the car. While everyone else is sensible enough to bring another adult so they can leave the kids behind 😂

It was particularly annoying when we went a month ago because it was absolutely freezing.

Wouldn't it be great if you could do the nursery run/school run without a car?

Roundandnour · 10/01/2023 14:03

OverTheRubicon · 10/01/2023 13:54

@Roundandnour Also fucked if you needed emergency services because car free zone

This isn't true - car free zones still require access for emergency services, e.g. pedestrian walkways wide enough to fit the vehicles, bollards with keys they can use etc. It's a planning requirement.

The car free estate i was on was built back when people didn’t drive.
Thankfully since then it’s been torn down and rebuilt.

Aftersevens · 10/01/2023 14:03

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 10/01/2023 14:01

I don't doubt it has, and as a permanent pedestrian I agree that some people's reliance on cars is ridiculous (once had a neighbour who took the Merc to the paper shop 2 minutes away).

🤣 I know a couple of people like that too!

Internetstranger · 10/01/2023 14:03

If it meant kids could play out in the street I’d be up for it, but there would be so many exemptions for elderly / disabled / builders / deliveries that it still wouldn’t be safe enough for kids so would be pointless.

badgermushrooms · 10/01/2023 14:02

I am 1000% in favour of designing housing developments to prioritise active travel over cars. But I recently brought my husband home from hospital after major surgery and he could barely make it from the street into our flat. A few days later I had to drive him the 5 minute walk to the GP surgery. We wouldn't get a blue badge as his "disability" is (hopefully) very temporary but he will be in no fit state to walk any real distance for several more weeks. Am I supposed to carry him on my back, in this post-car utopia? We need to allow for some car use, while providing more and better and safer alternatives.

cadburyegg · 10/01/2023 14:01

Lol no. As a single parent I love CP and it's an easy-ish holiday for us but the only downside is having to drag the kids out early on leaving morning to walk 20 minutes, sometimes longer, to get the car. While everyone else is sensible enough to bring another adult so they can leave the kids behind 😂

It was particularly annoying when we went a month ago because it was absolutely freezing.

Ontopofthesunset · 10/01/2023 14:01

I think lots of people are missing the point of the OP. It's not a suggestion to retrofit enormous carparks to current estates, leaving private driveways unused. It's an idea about designing new estates in such a way that cars can be parked on the outskirts. Lots of the objections here could easily be overcome - eg shelters in front gardens for bikes, trolleys, mobility scooters. And I don't think the OP was suggesting that every single person in the country would have to live in such an estate. We have designed our lives about car ownership in many cases, which is understandable, so our current lives wouldn't work without our cars.

We live in a big city where we often can't park my car where we can see it, so parking it in a car park out of sight isn't an issue for us. Now our children are young adults we rarely use our car, and use public transport or walk almost all the time. We constantly question whether we still need the car and whether we would be better off with a mixture of taxis and car clubs.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 10/01/2023 14:01

Aftersevens · 10/01/2023 13:56

Not a great example Mrs. D. Walking miles to access clean water is not particularly beneficial. Whereas fewer cars, fumes, congestion etc has many benefits.

I don't doubt it has, and as a permanent pedestrian I agree that some people's reliance on cars is ridiculous (once had a neighbour who took the Merc to the paper shop 2 minutes away).

Kitcaterpillar · 10/01/2023 14:01

People will come up with 1000 reasons why they can't be more than 5 steps from car to front door.

I have to park a few roads away. It's, at worst, occasionally a bit inconvenient. People are just used to facing no inconvenience at all, even if it would make life broadly nicer.

(Obviously I think not being able to walk a few roads is a valid exception)

daybroke · 10/01/2023 14:00

How would it work in a rural area where the shops and schools and doctors etc aren't all local?

CuteOrangeElephant · 10/01/2023 13:59

OverTheRubicon · 10/01/2023 13:55

We're not talking about places without water. We're talking about well off areas of London, or the Netherlands.

Right. I live in the Netherlands and would never move back to the UK. I hated being reliant on a car so much, especially when I was stuck with a newborn when my DH had to take the only car to work. I couldn't even go to a proper supermarket without a car and I lived in a big village (5000 people).

I can walk 2 minutes to my local shops (supermarket, butcher, baker, Wilko type shop) or cycle 10 minutes to the city centre.

If I want to go further afield I cycle 5 minutes to a train station where there is also a car from a car sharing club.

Oblongogo · 10/01/2023 13:59

if Schools, shops, nurseries and workplaces were within a bike-able / walkable distance then it works. We rarely use our car because we have great public transport and can walk or cycle to work, nursery etc. we probably only use it for a big shop / click and collect which would be a hassle. Returning from a holiday or trip and having to unload the car and carry for 10 mins would be annoying.

rather than go car free we just need to design new developments with amenities on site and decent cycle lanes. Nothing makes me more depressed than those big housing estates where you can’t walk to anything except a costa drive through.

Nosecan · 10/01/2023 13:58

This is starting to happen (as pp mentioned). Dh is in the industry and is always talking about it. He’s been citing cp as an example too for years op. I think it would be amazing, where practical.

daybroke · 10/01/2023 13:58

Do those of you saying mobility scooters have any idea what it's like for a disabled person to have to transfer to a car from a chair?

MzHz · 10/01/2023 13:57

QuertyGirl · 10/01/2023 12:46

Why not exactly?

A ten or 15 min walk to a communal car park would probably do most of us some good.

With a bootful of shopping?

yeah right.

Aftersevens · 10/01/2023 13:57

Harrysmummy246 · 10/01/2023 13:55

Oh I'd love you to tell me how that works with my job as a gardener when I have a lawn mower to load and a bunch of other stuff. Which would be multiple trips. Oh and 15kg of dog food? I'm strong but you're absolutely not being realistic.

Get an electric ride on lawn mower!
Problem solved.

funtycucker · 10/01/2023 13:57

user1468656818 · 10/01/2023 13:32

You could get shopping delivered?

Which then restricts people's choice of supermarket. You can't shop at Aldi or Lidl if you can only have your shopping delivered

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 10/01/2023 13:57

LordEmsworth

Perfectly put - I completely agree with you.

I also think that some people believe blue badges are something you can just send off a request for and they arrive by return post. It's (rightly) very difficult to get a blue badge. If everybody elderly and/or with mobility problems was allowed one, they'd lose their utility for those who are the most in need of them and thus should currently have one.

Also worth bearing in mind is that not everybody who is unable to drive will simply adapt and 'find a way' to cope; lots of people with disabilities and mobility problems currently don't cope at all - they just stay at home, making do, putting up and leading very restricted lives, because they have no other choice. Maybe this is why some people (incredibly, even those with some level of disability themselves, as here) assume that those folk don't exist, as they aren't visible in public.

Moreover, mobility scooters and wheelchairs are not the same thing. Some can use either or both, but many will only find one of them suitable for their needs. Is somebody expected to keep a scooter at their home, one wheelchair in their home and one in their car, and then simply hop between them in a way that disabled people generally find painful, extremely difficult and/or impossible (not to mention often undignified) to do?

Even if you do qualify for a blue badge, if you can't drive yourself, you still have to live with or close to somebody who can drive you around and has the time and resources to do so, which many, many people do not have the option of.

The whole thing about Center Parcs is that it's a choice to go there for your holiday, if what they offer/require suits your needs and preferences. If it doesn't, there are plenty of alternative options available. That's worlds apart from being told that everybody has to live a 15-minute walk from a car and tough if that ends up leaving you housebound.

MintLampShade · 10/01/2023 13:57

QuertyGirl · 10/01/2023 13:08

I suspect that a lot of these objections are really about time.

So many people have lives that are so loaded with stuff- full time jobs with long commutes, pressure to look insta-ready (hours in gym, salon etc) kids going to a dozen activities, houses needing to look perfect, huge sunk cost is massive car.

They need the car to get to the job to pay for the car in some cases.

You sound very judgy, OP. Whether you mean it or not. You think people spend hours in the gym to be insta-ready? Nothing to do with keeping fit and leading a healthy lifestyle then? Also, God forbid someone going to get their nails and hair done!

And as a matter of fact, just because you manage without a car, doesn't mean other people would want to. Not does it mean it's practice. And whilst it may be ideal on holiday, it would be most inconvenient day to day.

And before you think I rely on a car, I don't, as I didn't drive. But my bus stop is about 300 metres from my house and that's struggle enough some days to get my toddler down to. Yes, it is heaps easier when my husband is around and we use the car. No way I'd want to walk 15 minutes with a toddler and a butt load of shopping from a bus stop / car park when it's scorching hot / chucking down.

The solution is revising and enforcing stricter speed limits for residential areas. I too grew up peacefully playing outside, but it wasn't because people parked 15 minutes away. It was because cars drove extremely slowly around our streets.

Aftersevens · 10/01/2023 13:56

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 10/01/2023 13:54

you do realise that a decent % of people even in well off countries don't have access to a car, either at all or for a lot of the day?

People in a lot of countries also don't have access to clean water and walk miles to get it. I can't see suggestions we all start popping down to a communal tap being accepted, so why does it matter what people in other countries do as an example?

Not a great example Mrs. D. Walking miles to access clean water is not particularly beneficial. Whereas fewer cars, fumes, congestion etc has many benefits.

housemaus · 10/01/2023 13:55

daybroke · 10/01/2023 13:44

@housemaus I live in a rural village near where my ex lived all his life

We have zero public transport only the school bus in and out.

I am looking at moving now my youngest is left school as it's difficult for me but I can't afford to buy in town.

Yeah, this is a good point - being able to move according to need has to be affordable. And obviously, public transport has to be good. So many rural services have been reduced or stopped in recent years because (again!) we assume everyone has cars and have set ourselves up for that, when it's not true.

Harrysmummy246 · 10/01/2023 13:55

Oh I'd love you to tell me how that works with my job as a gardener when I have a lawn mower to load and a bunch of other stuff. Which would be multiple trips. Oh and 15kg of dog food? I'm strong but you're absolutely not being realistic.

PlanningTowns · 10/01/2023 13:55

Why not!

  1. people want to see their cars, they are territorial and can’t bare that they are out of site.

  2. convenience- parents, elderly etc.

  3. developers won’t do it as it doesn’t fit their standard model that they ‘market’ as living the dream (hence such little storage and space internally and externally).

  4. only suitable for new build estates where people sign up to it at the outset.

number 3 is your biggest stumbling point.

Swipe left for the next trending thread