Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we could make housing estates like Center Parcs re cars

809 replies

QuertyGirl · 10/01/2023 12:38

The USP of Centre Parcs is for many, the fact that they are mostly car free. Kids can play out and ride their bikes like I did when I was kid.

Can't do that now due to the amount of cars, speed and size of cars and, attitude of some car drivers.

People (including myself) pay a small fortune to holiday at CP.

Why can't we make housing estates more like that?

Communal car parks in walking distance, deliveries by small electric vehicles from a hub (like old fashioned milk floats), exemptions for blue badge holders and funding for electric mobility scooters for those that need them.

Yet, if the council suggests a couple of cycle lane and all hell breaks loose.

OP posts:
user1468656818 · 10/01/2023 14:31

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 10/01/2023 14:23

Weaponising the idea of people with disabilities against active travel is ableism.

There’s loads of people, especially in towns and cities who have disabilities and do not use cars.
There’s people who walk, cycle, other use wheeling for transport or exercise or both.

And there are also plenty of disabled people who cannot easily travel somewhere without a car. Surely you don't think that all disabilities and how they affect all individuals are exactly the same?

No. It has been covered in OPs post on blue badges. My point was majority of posts in this read ref disabilities read as if cars were the only way people with disabilities were able to travel - entirely untrue and perhaps sad reflection of opportunities offered to people through current infrastructure to date.

SpacePotato · 10/01/2023 14:29

On the space it would take up to have a car park large enough for all residents (especially when many households have more than one vehicle) and parcel hub, you could have a park, play area, green space with trees, skate park, sports pitch etc etc.
Or even a community centre with a youth club. Somewhere teens can feel safe and help prevent antisocial behaviours.

I have a car because it makes my life easier. That includes the convenience of parking outside my house.

daybroke · 10/01/2023 14:29

QuertyGirl · 10/01/2023 12:51

I manage shopping and a child without a car. I don't drive due to disability.

My mother and grandmother did it too.

What's changed?

This "I don't drive due to disability" it's gatekeeping. She might for eg have epilepsy.

user1468656818 · 10/01/2023 14:29

No. It has been covered in OPs post on blue badges. My point was majority of posts in this read ref disabilities read as if cars were the only way people with disabilities were able to travel - entirely untrue and perhaps sad reflection of opportunities offered to people through current infrastructure to date.

QuertyGirl · 10/01/2023 14:28

What has any of that got to do with this thread?

OP posts:
BradfordGirl · 10/01/2023 14:28

@WishIwasElsa You have to walk and carry weekly food shops.

This would only be possible if it was actually impossible to drive down those streets. There have been streets built like this, they always cost less to buy than streets with vehicle access.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 10/01/2023 14:28

So what would happen if this kind of estate were brought in just as an option for people to move to? Would it just be accepted that anybody who became disabled, or even just elderly, would be expected to move away from their home and start afresh?

It could end up being a very transient neighbourhood, with very little in the way of the 'community' atmosphere that comes from people setting down long-term roots.

Squamata · 10/01/2023 14:27

HadEnough798 · 10/01/2023 14:14

I use a lot of heavy gear and equipment for my job. I load it from my house into the van, then back from van into the house, every time. It takes me about 7-8 trips to do one load as it's all very heavy. If I carry anything remotely heavy for too long (heavy laptop included on my back) I get a migraine.

I'm nowhere near blue badge, I am on the face of it very healthy, active etc. But If I am forced to carry stuff it leaves me incapacitated for days.

How should I make that work with your plan?

@HadEnough798 Sympathies for your health problems, but I don't think problems like that can't be overcome with some ingenuity. I'd imagine you'd need a wagon of some sort. If there was enough demand, van manufacturers could make vans with built-in slide-out trolley/wagon things. With little motors if the stuff was that heavy. Or tool makers could make tools a bit lighter. It wouldn't happen overnight but necessity is the mother of invention.

ToffeeEl · 10/01/2023 14:27

Some of the replies to this are so funny to me.

You've suggested some new estates featuring this, and it's unleashed panic like it would be law. I really agree with the sentiment and that we're all too reliant on cars now (me included, a self-confessed lazy cow!)

Would do a lot of people a lot of good to rethink their attitude towards cars (obviously those who are able)

WishIwasElsa · 10/01/2023 14:27

What about taking large items to and from home or doing a big food shop how is tha supposed to work. Never mind any other reasons. Me and my kids would have to leave even earlier and return home later if we had to walk to and from car to house morning and night. And it flat out wouldn't work on football training evening as I just wouldn't have enough time full stop between school pick up and start of training.

Kinnorafron · 10/01/2023 14:26

Sirzy · 10/01/2023 13:32

Having access only for certain groups wokld actually risk making it more dangerous for children playing out etc because they wouldn’t be expecting any traffic and so may not be as careful.

what we need is to make sure we are protecting green spaces and safe play areas and making sure they stay accessible.

This is a good point - the twice I've been to CP I couldn't properly relax because despite the "car ban" there are always maintenance and housekeeping vans zooming around and they didn't seem to have any concept of a speed limit.

I like OP's idea but it would need to be closer to "all or nothing" - and I do worry it would be excessively exclusionary for disabled people.

daybroke · 10/01/2023 14:26

I'm asking because you keep saying you don't drive due to being disabled.

But there are lots of different types of disabilities that mean you can't drive and people may be differently affected to you because you can walk or cycle better than them or because you have a school close to you or because there's a good public transport system where you are or a good reliable local taxi company that isn't £50 each way to the local hospital

Mammajay · 10/01/2023 14:26

I grew up on a council estate in the 50s and 60s. When I went back to visit years later, the squares we played in were full of cars and the swings had been changed into a car park. I think middle ground is needed. Children need to be able to play outside..all children, not only those with private gardens and even those would benefit from playing independently.

WhatNoRaisins · 10/01/2023 14:24

Thing is with good local shops and transport links more people would just leave the car at home on the drive when it's not needed. If we use our car it's always because there either isn't another transport option or because we need to go door to door to transport something.

QuertyGirl · 10/01/2023 14:23

@daybroke

Not sure what point your trying to make here?

You get a blue badge so you could live on this fantasy housing estate and park your car on the drive, if you wanted too.

Or, you could live in a tiny hamlet on the Yorkshire moors and drive a Land Rover and this whole thread would be irrelevant to you.

It's almost as if I'd suggested banning cars. Or was that what you think my OP meant?

OP posts:
WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 10/01/2023 14:23

Weaponising the idea of people with disabilities against active travel is ableism.

There’s loads of people, especially in towns and cities who have disabilities and do not use cars.
There’s people who walk, cycle, other use wheeling for transport or exercise or both.

And there are also plenty of disabled people who cannot easily travel somewhere without a car. Surely you don't think that all disabilities and how they affect all individuals are exactly the same?

EmmaEmerald · 10/01/2023 14:22

BradfordGirl · 10/01/2023 14:21

@Jaxhog You say it as if being worried about security is a trivial matter. As I said this has been tried before in housing estates in Britain. It just led to a large rise in car crime.
And the police do nothing about car crime.
Introduce it first in a nice middle class area before experimenting again on people in poorer areas. But middle class people would not accept it.

Oh has it been tried?

agree security issues as a lone woman. Or indeed lone man, as they are the most targeted for muggings etc I think.

fnfnf · 10/01/2023 14:22

user1468656818 · 10/01/2023 14:08

Car free streets would be safer for many.

Weaponising the idea of people with disabilities against active travel is ableism.

There’s loads of people, especially in towns and cities who have disabilities and do not use cars.
There’s people who walk, cycle, other use wheeling for transport or exercise or both.

Meanwhile people who can't safely pilot (or afford) a 2-ton vehicle but could use an e-bike, e-scooter or speed-restricted micro-car if safe infrastructure existed for it - guess they're shit out of luck.

Agreed. From "Transport: Disability and Accessibility Statistics, England 2020":

"Disabled people are more likely to be in a household without access to a car and in households with access to a car they are less likely to be a driver."

Safer streets benefit everyone. And of course, if more people who can use alternative means of transport do so, the roads will be less congested for those who do need to use cars.

BradfordGirl · 10/01/2023 14:21

@Jaxhog You say it as if being worried about security is a trivial matter. As I said this has been tried before in housing estates in Britain. It just led to a large rise in car crime.
And the police do nothing about car crime.
Introduce it first in a nice middle class area before experimenting again on people in poorer areas. But middle class people would not accept it.

EmmaEmerald · 10/01/2023 14:21

Jaxhog · 10/01/2023 14:18

It's a brilliant idea! Unfortunately, too many people want their cars at their house (laziness) and/or are worried about security in a 'remote' car park.

Hopefully we can do this in the near future though.

A fair concern to worry about your car.

also, I bet communal car parks will end up being a spot for smoking weed, kicking a ball around.

for which you could have instead ...parking outside your home!

Jaxhog · 10/01/2023 14:18

It's a brilliant idea! Unfortunately, too many people want their cars at their house (laziness) and/or are worried about security in a 'remote' car park.

Hopefully we can do this in the near future though.

EmmaEmerald · 10/01/2023 14:17

Good point made by PP re the space required by the car park

you could just...keep your car outside your home instead?

CuteOrangeElephant · 10/01/2023 14:17

Harrysmummy246 · 10/01/2023 14:15

Absolutely not relevant here. It's a village with little new development nor space to do so and it's a 2 form entry school. Next village is several miles away. You're making a lot of assumptions here. Oh and let's add in the fact there was a landslip a year ago that the council haven't fixed yet making it twice as long a journey just now

Then obviously the OPs plans don't apply to your village?

And obviously the school should have been enlarged if there are children that need to go miles away. Bit of forward planning from the govt wouldn't have gone amiss.

cadburyegg · 10/01/2023 14:16

BTW I spent 30 years growing up and living in big towns and cities where you couldn't park your car closer than 100m away minimum. You'd have to pay me a huge sum of money to go back to that. Not being close to your vehicle is a pain for safety reasons as a young woman at night but also hugely inconvenient for those with children, shopping, if you need to transport someone with mobility issues. I know people who can drive perfectly fine but can't walk any distance at all. Even more of an issue in bad weather

Harrysmummy246 · 10/01/2023 14:15

CuteOrangeElephant · 10/01/2023 14:12

Which is why the UK must have more vision around these things. Building housing estates without primary school provision should be illegal.

Absolutely not relevant here. It's a village with little new development nor space to do so and it's a 2 form entry school. Next village is several miles away. You're making a lot of assumptions here. Oh and let's add in the fact there was a landslip a year ago that the council haven't fixed yet making it twice as long a journey just now