Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we could make housing estates like Center Parcs re cars

809 replies

QuertyGirl · 10/01/2023 12:38

The USP of Centre Parcs is for many, the fact that they are mostly car free. Kids can play out and ride their bikes like I did when I was kid.

Can't do that now due to the amount of cars, speed and size of cars and, attitude of some car drivers.

People (including myself) pay a small fortune to holiday at CP.

Why can't we make housing estates more like that?

Communal car parks in walking distance, deliveries by small electric vehicles from a hub (like old fashioned milk floats), exemptions for blue badge holders and funding for electric mobility scooters for those that need them.

Yet, if the council suggests a couple of cycle lane and all hell breaks loose.

OP posts:
jannier · 13/01/2023 13:10

CuteOrangeElephant · 13/01/2023 12:37

Where am I saying Dutch carers only have 3 clients a day?
Where am I saying you have to follow a mobility scooter to the hospital for 6 miles? You are doing a lot of extrapolating of things I have never said.

No your saying carers could ride between clients like in the lovely flat Netherlands I'm saying carers have more than just visiting a house ..they take people out.....and if I took my bike I'd have to follow a scooter...
Your also assuming that it's a nice light job with a few clients close by...the professional carers I know it's lots of clients time slots that are one end of town 5 miles plus then the other then another direction all run run run...not the Netherlands picture you portray of medical students summer jobs....you have to have an NVQ to be a carer now so it's not likely you just pick it up for a month or two here anyway.

CuteOrangeElephant · 13/01/2023 12:40

tigger1001 · 13/01/2023 12:33

"Lots could be done in rural locations though that's not being done. I used to live in quite a rural village, which had some facilities of it's own but the GP, bigger supermarket, health visitor appointments, gym, swimming etc was a village over 3 miles away. Options for cycling were either a very busy road or a broken canal path. Buses weren't great.

If the council had made a proper separated cycle path along the busy road I would have bought a bike and my life would have been easier (no more relying on DH who took the only car with him to work).

You know who would have had the biggest benefit of this? Teenagers. They wouldn't have had to be stuck in a village with not much to do."

I don't disagree with what you are saying but I suspect local geography (as well as money) will influence whether there could be cycle paths etc - where I am I suspect that's not hugely practical but can see how it would work in other places.

Cycling for me on a personal level locally, (busy road aside) isn't helpful due to the distance required.

I am in Scotland and teenagers up to the ages of 22 now get free bus travel. And while the bus service isn't great due to its limited service, it does give them more independence. He uses it to go to stuff after school and I then collect him on the way home from work. Ironically what is true locally is rural kids use the bus, despite limited services where as kids in the bigger town with better public transport get lifts places.

As always, it comes down to money. Local services are already being squeezed and basic services are being affected. So I suspect things like this are in the "nice to have" list but not a priority. All the while bus services face cuts, which increases the use of cars etc.

Completely agree it's impossible now under the current system. The change has to come from higher up.

It's disgusting what's been done to council budgets in the UK.

Princesspollyyy · 13/01/2023 12:37

My car is expensive and cost a lot of money, i would not want to park it out of sight, where there's more opportunity for it to be stolen.

CuteOrangeElephant · 13/01/2023 12:37

jannier · 13/01/2023 12:25

None of the things you say are impossible now...but not many can walk or cycle but hang on to those few ...by carers I mean us unpaid lot the real carers and when I get there 3 miles one way back 2 miles other direction then 2 back to first house then check in on number 3 before home for lunch and work then out again..to houses 1, 2 and 3 I have to be physically able to help them to lift wash meds get them out to appointments ...6 mile cycle to hospital following a disabled scooter.( Shit it's tipped over run out of charge, Christ it's raining and that's just invalidated the rescue service) ...I'm 60 this month and still working just gone down to a 44 hour week ..when have I got time and physical strength to cycle unaffordable electric bike or not ( husband does cycle mountain bikes and road bikes every day to work he's 61 so we know how expensive they are).
Carers in England would laugh at having 3 clients a day by the way ....that's a holiday...which is why they start putting to bed at 4pm. When my mum had one they got her up at 8 she was second on the round some still waiting at 10. Once you need lifting it's harder as with a hoist they still need 2 ....but I'm sure with all the lifting and physical work they do a nice gentle cycle ride is just the tonic.
I used to walk 5 miles to school ....nowadays no parent would let their child through the underpass of the M4 they would have to cross or past the asylum hostel with men drinking outside it.

Where am I saying Dutch carers only have 3 clients a day?
Where am I saying you have to follow a mobility scooter to the hospital for 6 miles? You are doing a lot of extrapolating of things I have never said.

tigger1001 · 13/01/2023 12:33

"Lots could be done in rural locations though that's not being done. I used to live in quite a rural village, which had some facilities of it's own but the GP, bigger supermarket, health visitor appointments, gym, swimming etc was a village over 3 miles away. Options for cycling were either a very busy road or a broken canal path. Buses weren't great.

If the council had made a proper separated cycle path along the busy road I would have bought a bike and my life would have been easier (no more relying on DH who took the only car with him to work).

You know who would have had the biggest benefit of this? Teenagers. They wouldn't have had to be stuck in a village with not much to do."

I don't disagree with what you are saying but I suspect local geography (as well as money) will influence whether there could be cycle paths etc - where I am I suspect that's not hugely practical but can see how it would work in other places.

Cycling for me on a personal level locally, (busy road aside) isn't helpful due to the distance required.

I am in Scotland and teenagers up to the ages of 22 now get free bus travel. And while the bus service isn't great due to its limited service, it does give them more independence. He uses it to go to stuff after school and I then collect him on the way home from work. Ironically what is true locally is rural kids use the bus, despite limited services where as kids in the bigger town with better public transport get lifts places.

As always, it comes down to money. Local services are already being squeezed and basic services are being affected. So I suspect things like this are in the "nice to have" list but not a priority. All the while bus services face cuts, which increases the use of cars etc.

jannier · 13/01/2023 12:32

QuertyGirl · 13/01/2023 11:44

@jannier

1, Nobody wants to ban cars

2, No single change will fix everything for every disabled person. We're a diverse group. Right now, we actively discriminate against anyone (disabled or not) who doe's have access to a car.

Do we? it's going to cost me £12 a day just to do the car for my family soon because I'll be paying Ulez to get to them (plus diesel etc) or be spending 3 hours twice a day doing the bus routes. I'm sure someone will tell me the £1000 or so grant will make the £6000 replacement affordable along with the £385 scrap value because nobody wants the old one. I get as an old man (I think that's what you said stuck by a road? ) You don't drive but do you think the world would be easier to get around just by having no main road to cross are you always going to manage getting to a shop or will you need lifts at some point?

QuertyGirl · 13/01/2023 12:31

@jannier

You need more support, that's not sustainable over the long term.

I don't think that your problems having anything to do with traffic control.

Hope you get some respite soon.

OP posts:
jannier · 13/01/2023 12:25

CuteOrangeElephant · 13/01/2023 11:49

For starters the ones that can not drive but can cycle or walk. They won't have to rely on carers as much if they can get themselves to the GP, supermarket or library.

Secondly people might have good days or bad days. It would be beneficial for people to have the option to walk to their local shops if they feel they are up for it. That will reduce costs and keep people fitter whilst having the option to leave the car at home.

It will help carers. In the Netherlands there are plenty of carers who do not have a car, they can cycle between clients. On an electric bike you can be almost as quick as in a car on short to medium distances and they are a lot cheaper to run. I had friends that were medical students that used to do this job during the summer holidays. They wouldn't buy a car for 3 months.

Children being able to walk or cycle to school by themselves will also benefit people who otherwise might struggle. I used to cycle 5 miles to school everyday. Almost no one was driven in. Even some disabled kids would cycle in. There was one girl with (I think) cerebral palsy who came on a trike. Not sure how far she had to go though.

None of the things you say are impossible now...but not many can walk or cycle but hang on to those few ...by carers I mean us unpaid lot the real carers and when I get there 3 miles one way back 2 miles other direction then 2 back to first house then check in on number 3 before home for lunch and work then out again..to houses 1, 2 and 3 I have to be physically able to help them to lift wash meds get them out to appointments ...6 mile cycle to hospital following a disabled scooter.( Shit it's tipped over run out of charge, Christ it's raining and that's just invalidated the rescue service) ...I'm 60 this month and still working just gone down to a 44 hour week ..when have I got time and physical strength to cycle unaffordable electric bike or not ( husband does cycle mountain bikes and road bikes every day to work he's 61 so we know how expensive they are).
Carers in England would laugh at having 3 clients a day by the way ....that's a holiday...which is why they start putting to bed at 4pm. When my mum had one they got her up at 8 she was second on the round some still waiting at 10. Once you need lifting it's harder as with a hoist they still need 2 ....but I'm sure with all the lifting and physical work they do a nice gentle cycle ride is just the tonic.
I used to walk 5 miles to school ....nowadays no parent would let their child through the underpass of the M4 they would have to cross or past the asylum hostel with men drinking outside it.

CuteOrangeElephant · 13/01/2023 11:49

jannier · 13/01/2023 11:37

How does it help disabled as in all disabled not just labelled ones

For starters the ones that can not drive but can cycle or walk. They won't have to rely on carers as much if they can get themselves to the GP, supermarket or library.

Secondly people might have good days or bad days. It would be beneficial for people to have the option to walk to their local shops if they feel they are up for it. That will reduce costs and keep people fitter whilst having the option to leave the car at home.

It will help carers. In the Netherlands there are plenty of carers who do not have a car, they can cycle between clients. On an electric bike you can be almost as quick as in a car on short to medium distances and they are a lot cheaper to run. I had friends that were medical students that used to do this job during the summer holidays. They wouldn't buy a car for 3 months.

Children being able to walk or cycle to school by themselves will also benefit people who otherwise might struggle. I used to cycle 5 miles to school everyday. Almost no one was driven in. Even some disabled kids would cycle in. There was one girl with (I think) cerebral palsy who came on a trike. Not sure how far she had to go though.

QuertyGirl · 13/01/2023 11:44

@jannier

1, Nobody wants to ban cars

2, No single change will fix everything for every disabled person. We're a diverse group. Right now, we actively discriminate against anyone (disabled or not) who doe's have access to a car.

OP posts:
jannier · 13/01/2023 11:37

CuteOrangeElephant · 13/01/2023 11:07

I am not saying we should ban cars.

I am saying we should make sure people can walk and cycle everywhere and that will help disabled people too.

How does it help disabled as in all disabled not just labelled ones

jannier · 13/01/2023 11:34

user1468656818 · 13/01/2023 11:18

To be honest, these are all reasons for better infrastructure and walkable cities! Cars do not equal freedom but I don’t think you are going to change your mind. It’s a bit like America and gun culture for some people.

No I don't mind walking and cycling being made easier but until you have a system that makes getting around possible (not just easier) for those with issues labeled, rubber stamped by a badge or not you can't make life harder for them as if they are worthless waiting to die and costing us money.....at the moment we are still building infa structure like railways that are not disabled friendly we still have a mental attitude such as prams on buses thinking they are as needy as disabled and not enough buses....you can't ban cars until you address the other issues and you can't address them while people are all saying there is no money, were not paying more taxes but I have 4 or in one case on here 7 holidays a year but need more free childcare. The problem is money is limited and disabled voices not as loud as eco worriers who can easily protest or parents who are needed to work.

user1468656818 · 13/01/2023 11:18

jannier · 13/01/2023 11:03

And your refusing to understand the various different disabilities and stages of diagnosis harping on about the magic 50% without understanding it's nothing like that number who do not need access to cars and many many more who do not meet benefits definitions of disability but are not able to walk.....if you get cerebral dementia you are not automatically classed disabled from day one of symptoms and may well still be unaware your not capable but nobody would expect you to make your own way anywhere and possibly your so effected that you could suddenly become a danger even if walking accompanied your carer needs a car....there are many many examples but it seems unless your struck down your blinkers are fully up.

To be honest, these are all reasons for better infrastructure and walkable cities! Cars do not equal freedom but I don’t think you are going to change your mind. It’s a bit like America and gun culture for some people.

CuteOrangeElephant · 13/01/2023 11:07

jannier · 13/01/2023 11:03

And your refusing to understand the various different disabilities and stages of diagnosis harping on about the magic 50% without understanding it's nothing like that number who do not need access to cars and many many more who do not meet benefits definitions of disability but are not able to walk.....if you get cerebral dementia you are not automatically classed disabled from day one of symptoms and may well still be unaware your not capable but nobody would expect you to make your own way anywhere and possibly your so effected that you could suddenly become a danger even if walking accompanied your carer needs a car....there are many many examples but it seems unless your struck down your blinkers are fully up.

I am not saying we should ban cars.

I am saying we should make sure people can walk and cycle everywhere and that will help disabled people too.

jannier · 13/01/2023 11:03

CuteOrangeElephant · 13/01/2023 10:47

Yes of course. But you are still not reading what I am saying and not arguing in good faith so I am not going to comment anymore.

And your refusing to understand the various different disabilities and stages of diagnosis harping on about the magic 50% without understanding it's nothing like that number who do not need access to cars and many many more who do not meet benefits definitions of disability but are not able to walk.....if you get cerebral dementia you are not automatically classed disabled from day one of symptoms and may well still be unaware your not capable but nobody would expect you to make your own way anywhere and possibly your so effected that you could suddenly become a danger even if walking accompanied your carer needs a car....there are many many examples but it seems unless your struck down your blinkers are fully up.

CuteOrangeElephant · 13/01/2023 10:56

tigger1001 · 13/01/2023 10:50

"I think this depends largely on where you live though? If you’re in a busy city then you’re going to have more traffic? We walk to school and my children will be able to walk to school safely. This isn’t the case for everyone though and making people in residential areas park 15 minutes away isn’t feasible in a city?"

I agree. My kids, until they went to secondary school, were able to walk to and from school. One very busy road to cross (typically the one the school is on) but that has a crossing and a lollipop lady.

They have been able to play out too. There has been a fair bit of derision about these of us who chose to live in a more rural location, as that does tend to mean we need cars more, but there is a payoff.

Lots could be done in rural locations though that's not being done. I used to live in quite a rural village, which had some facilities of it's own but the GP, bigger supermarket, health visitor appointments, gym, swimming etc was a village over 3 miles away. Options for cycling were either a very busy road or a broken canal path. Buses weren't great.

If the council had made a proper separated cycle path along the busy road I would have bought a bike and my life would have been easier (no more relying on DH who took the only car with him to work).

You know who would have had the biggest benefit of this? Teenagers. They wouldn't have had to be stuck in a village with not much to do.

user1468656818 · 13/01/2023 10:55

jannier · 13/01/2023 10:33

But parents don't let them walk or cycle anyway they don't let them out even the gardens in summer are empty. Parents don't want their little angels to get cold or wet walking to school...or busing...no amount of pedestrianisation will change the attitude that children even at 16 need to be kept safe from child snatchers and getting wet it's not the traffic parents are scared of.

what on earth! 😂🫣

tigger1001 · 13/01/2023 10:50

"I think this depends largely on where you live though? If you’re in a busy city then you’re going to have more traffic? We walk to school and my children will be able to walk to school safely. This isn’t the case for everyone though and making people in residential areas park 15 minutes away isn’t feasible in a city?"

I agree. My kids, until they went to secondary school, were able to walk to and from school. One very busy road to cross (typically the one the school is on) but that has a crossing and a lollipop lady.

They have been able to play out too. There has been a fair bit of derision about these of us who chose to live in a more rural location, as that does tend to mean we need cars more, but there is a payoff.

SweetSakura · 13/01/2023 10:47

bluesuitcase · 13/01/2023 10:32

If you read the next comment I elaborated as I realised it could be read that way; it meant not people with no disability who just can’t cope with rain or wind or the dark (there plenty of comments using this as a reason for it not being an option on this thread).

But how do you make a decision who has no disability and can't be bothered? I went 5 years without a diagnosis. 5 years being made to feel it was all in my head because my blood tests were normal. 5 years of finding it so hard to cope with moving to much or getting cold but beating myself up that I was somehow lazy. Then finally I was diagnosed with a neurological condition that is not just disabling but life threatening. I was just as ill with the condition in those preceding 5 years before I was diagnosed, in fact more so.

And my story so sadly is not at all unique.

CuteOrangeElephant · 13/01/2023 10:47

jannier · 13/01/2023 10:27

Those 50% don't own a car but most with physical disabilities will be driven by others because they can't drive what world are you living in where the blind and physically impaired can all just walk or cycle. Disability also includes mental ones of course if love a brain injured non coordinated individual with no spacial awareness cycling into grandad.

Yes of course. But you are still not reading what I am saying and not arguing in good faith so I am not going to comment anymore.

jannier · 13/01/2023 10:34

Blind person driving a car coming through.....

jannier · 13/01/2023 10:33

Devoutspoken · 13/01/2023 10:17

Procrastinating - low traffic neighbourhoods in cities make it safe for kids to walk and cycle to school

But parents don't let them walk or cycle anyway they don't let them out even the gardens in summer are empty. Parents don't want their little angels to get cold or wet walking to school...or busing...no amount of pedestrianisation will change the attitude that children even at 16 need to be kept safe from child snatchers and getting wet it's not the traffic parents are scared of.

bluesuitcase · 13/01/2023 10:32

Spikeyball · 13/01/2023 09:07

The problem with this thread is there are people with no experience of disability or a particular disability telling others with a disability/ carers for someone with a disability, what they can or cannot do.

This comment for example

"Allowances would be made for people who really couldn’t walk to their cars."

Who are you to make comments about "really couldn't". Are you saying that people should be in pain getting to their vehicle because that doesn't count as really couldn't. Or it is ok for someone to have meltdowns and get distressed on the way to their vehicle. Who gets all these mobility scooters into these sufficiently large vehicles.
It is also what is practical and in that persons best interests. We should be making vulnerable people's lives better not harder.

If you read the next comment I elaborated as I realised it could be read that way; it meant not people with no disability who just can’t cope with rain or wind or the dark (there plenty of comments using this as a reason for it not being an option on this thread).

Hardbackwriter · 13/01/2023 10:29

I lived on an estate like this. I quite liked it (though we only had one child when we lived there - I do think I'd have found it more annoying with a baby and toddler), but it was SUCH a nightmare when we came to sell - it was really clear and prominent in the listing but we still had so many waste of time appointments where viewers would turn up and instantly declare they couldn't possibly live there. I think people didn't quite believe the listing! The horror from family and friends about things that I didn't think were a massive deal - eg that I would put the baby in the sling to take him to the car - also made it very clear to me that this is not an option that very many people at all would willingly choose.

jannier · 13/01/2023 10:27

CuteOrangeElephant · 13/01/2023 08:14

I am saying nowhere that disabled people shouldn't have cars. A better balance should be struck between the situation as is, which is life is difficult without a car, regardless of disability, and having no cars.

50% of disabled people don't have a car, and I maintain my stance that their lives would be much improved if they have the option to safely walk or cycle somewhere.

Those 50% don't own a car but most with physical disabilities will be driven by others because they can't drive what world are you living in where the blind and physically impaired can all just walk or cycle. Disability also includes mental ones of course if love a brain injured non coordinated individual with no spacial awareness cycling into grandad.