Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we could make housing estates like Center Parcs re cars

809 replies

QuertyGirl · 10/01/2023 12:38

The USP of Centre Parcs is for many, the fact that they are mostly car free. Kids can play out and ride their bikes like I did when I was kid.

Can't do that now due to the amount of cars, speed and size of cars and, attitude of some car drivers.

People (including myself) pay a small fortune to holiday at CP.

Why can't we make housing estates more like that?

Communal car parks in walking distance, deliveries by small electric vehicles from a hub (like old fashioned milk floats), exemptions for blue badge holders and funding for electric mobility scooters for those that need them.

Yet, if the council suggests a couple of cycle lane and all hell breaks loose.

OP posts:
GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 10/01/2023 18:56

EmmaEmerald · 10/01/2023 18:49

Ah, so you see it as convenience for off loading the kids you wanted? Mmkay.

Thing is, it would be beneficial if kids could play out, like they used to in the past. It’s not natural for them to be dependant on screens and their parents for entertainment.

However there are lots of very valid reasons on this thread why it may not work, mainly that it seems every initiative in this country is done in a way that makes it crap, and if that failure isn’t built in, we seem to manage to make it crap ourselves

LordEmsworth · 10/01/2023 18:56

CuteOrangeElephant · 10/01/2023 18:27

The OP is not saying that all housing estates should be converted or that people in rural villages should give up their cars. Some people are taking this in a really extreme way. OP is also not saying that the cars should be a 10 minutes walk away 🙄. Some people really like to get wound up about nothing.

The OP literally said that cars would be parked at least 10 minutes' walk away - "10 to 15 minutes".

The OP has not at any point specified "well this would only apply to urban areas which have plenty of good public transport infrastructure, nearby shops offering reasonably-priced food, and local schools / GPs / other services that have space for all the local people." So not exactly unreasonable to point out that if you live in a small town in the middle of Lincolnshire with 2 buses a day, if you're lucky, then you might not think it's a brilliant idea.

And frankly the OP's statement that it's a shame that people who aren't able-bodied "feel" stigmatised and shouldn't feel that way, beggars belief. The OP has clearly never been through the DLA assessment process, and never heard of Fiona Pilkington & her daughter.

Just to be clear - I mostly travel by bike and on foot, in an area badly served by public transport, and I agree that the infrastructure is diabolical and needs improvement. However shipping off middle-class, able-bodied people like me to live in this lovely little community, while leaving poorer, less able-bodied people where they are to muddle along, is not the utopia the OP seems to think it would be.

EmmaEmerald · 10/01/2023 18:50

CunTea · 10/01/2023 18:47

This is the absolute most middle class thing I have ever heard. Hilarious.

IKR?

on the bright side, you'd know where to go to get some weed immediately, as opposed to keeping up with what street they're on today.

EmmaEmerald · 10/01/2023 18:49

Lisbon37 · 10/01/2023 18:42

I actually think it's a great idea OP!

Transporting heavy shopping solved by carts/wheelbarrows stacked in car park. (Though understand this wouldn't work with disabilities)

I live in London without off street parking- it's not at all unusual to have to park on a different street as not enough on street parking - you just get used to managing it! Not everyone needs to park immediately outside their house!

The benefits of kids just going out to play massively outweigh a bit of minor inconvenience. Sending kids out to play - so much easier than constantly arranging play dates or just letting them watch too much TV as they're bored at home.

Ah, so you see it as convenience for off loading the kids you wanted? Mmkay.

WhiteFire · 10/01/2023 18:49

CuteOrangeElephant · 10/01/2023 18:39

What makes you think that successful designs from Scandinavia and the Netherlands can't be copied to the UK?

Because it has already been proved not to work, because they don't, for all the reasons stated by the poster I quoted.

We have those types of estates already in the UK (maybe it is just in a corner of NE England) and they are generally not great places to live.

CunTea · 10/01/2023 18:47

This is the absolute most middle class thing I have ever heard. Hilarious.

daybroke · 10/01/2023 18:47

CuteOrangeElephant · 10/01/2023 18:27

The OP is not saying that all housing estates should be converted or that people in rural villages should give up their cars. Some people are taking this in a really extreme way. OP is also not saying that the cars should be a 10 minutes walk away 🙄. Some people really like to get wound up about nothing.

She is. She said she lives on an old estate the subject of the thread.

Lisbon37 · 10/01/2023 18:42

I actually think it's a great idea OP!

Transporting heavy shopping solved by carts/wheelbarrows stacked in car park. (Though understand this wouldn't work with disabilities)

I live in London without off street parking- it's not at all unusual to have to park on a different street as not enough on street parking - you just get used to managing it! Not everyone needs to park immediately outside their house!

The benefits of kids just going out to play massively outweigh a bit of minor inconvenience. Sending kids out to play - so much easier than constantly arranging play dates or just letting them watch too much TV as they're bored at home.

EmmaEmerald · 10/01/2023 18:40

CuteOrangeElephant · 10/01/2023 18:36

Ok granted 10 might be excessive. I used to live 3 minutes walk from my car. Even with a newborn it wasn't as big of a deal as people on here are making it out to be.

Both my brothers live a 5 minute cycle/10 minutes away from their car, because they live in a city centre and don't want to shell out for a permit. Does it suck sometimes? Absolutely. But they just deal with it.

Same when I had a car and parking permit - it was for a zone so I often parked streets away!

what I'm wondering is why anyone would intentionally build that set up, or impose it on people. But OP isn't going to answer those questions, it seems.

CuteOrangeElephant · 10/01/2023 18:39

WhiteFire · 10/01/2023 18:36

I can only think that the people who think this is a wonderful idea have never seen the actual reality which is exactly as above. As far as I can recall the ones I know were designed by a Scandinavian architect, it simply hasn't worked in the UK.

What makes you think that successful designs from Scandinavia and the Netherlands can't be copied to the UK?

CuteOrangeElephant · 10/01/2023 18:36

EmmaEmerald · 10/01/2023 18:31

The 10 min walk was OP second post.

Ok granted 10 might be excessive. I used to live 3 minutes walk from my car. Even with a newborn it wasn't as big of a deal as people on here are making it out to be.

Both my brothers live a 5 minute cycle/10 minutes away from their car, because they live in a city centre and don't want to shell out for a permit. Does it suck sometimes? Absolutely. But they just deal with it.

WhiteFire · 10/01/2023 18:36

NeverDropYourMooncup · 10/01/2023 12:50

Ever been on a dodgy rabbit warren Estate? That's exactly what they're like and it really isn't pleasant for the tenants. No disabled access, no means of seeing or preventing theft and vandalism, risky dark walks from parking areas, deliveries refused.

It's an utterly awful idea.

I can only think that the people who think this is a wonderful idea have never seen the actual reality which is exactly as above. As far as I can recall the ones I know were designed by a Scandinavian architect, it simply hasn't worked in the UK.

Peasepuddingbloodycold · 10/01/2023 18:36

OP YANBU.

We seem to structure our whole lived environment around vehicles. What if we centred people? What if we centred children? Once you start imagining it, it's hard to switch off.

For example, picture a T junction, with a minor road on to the major road. What if the pavements continued at the same height, and the cars were expected to go up and down? This would be more convenient for the pedestrians, and slow the vehicles down, making it safer.

EmmaEmerald · 10/01/2023 18:34

QuertyGirl · 10/01/2023 14:14

I live on an old, average housing estate- ie the subject of this thread.

This suggests converting existing estates.

CuteOrangeElephant · 10/01/2023 18:32

Also it is unhealthy how the UK is so dependent on cars. Even in cities the situation is dire.

There's lots of people that can't drive. Be that because they are too young, too old, too poor, disabled or because they just don't want to. By making the UK so car-centric essential services and shops are not reachable cycling/walking you are excluding them.

EmmaEmerald · 10/01/2023 18:31

CuteOrangeElephant · 10/01/2023 18:27

The OP is not saying that all housing estates should be converted or that people in rural villages should give up their cars. Some people are taking this in a really extreme way. OP is also not saying that the cars should be a 10 minutes walk away 🙄. Some people really like to get wound up about nothing.

The 10 min walk was OP second post.

CuteOrangeElephant · 10/01/2023 18:27

The OP is not saying that all housing estates should be converted or that people in rural villages should give up their cars. Some people are taking this in a really extreme way. OP is also not saying that the cars should be a 10 minutes walk away 🙄. Some people really like to get wound up about nothing.

jtaeapa · 10/01/2023 18:27

QuertyGirl · 10/01/2023 12:46

Why not exactly?

A ten or 15 min walk to a communal car park would probably do most of us some good.

My school run takes 20 mins there and 20 mins back. I do it twice a day. A 15 min walk to and from my car each time would steal an hour a day from me.

my db has a broken ankle with metal in it. If I can’t drive up to the door, I can’t get him to hospital.

LordSugarTits · 10/01/2023 18:23

"Do I leave my kids in the car while I traipse back and forward with all my shopping!?"

No they're all whizzing around on bikes living their lives through the OPs rose tinted glasses 🤣

daybroke · 10/01/2023 18:23

Rural town.

The town my kids go to school in. If I want to buy knickers or shoes my only choice is a small Tesco.

The buses are rubbish outside of school hours.

There's no decent restaurants. No cinema. Nothing for kids.

About 5 farm supplies shops and 27 coffee shops though (but they all close at 5pm)

Bogasphodel · 10/01/2023 18:22

jannier · 10/01/2023 17:52

In the 70s I played on our street cars were infrequent so football on the road was fine....the car park you lived by wouldn't be quiet at anytime now, not big enough and dangerous at night.

I meant that it had been built in the 70s, I lived there 3 years ago….

jannier · 10/01/2023 18:20

housemaus · 10/01/2023 14:04

Surely the point is that people would change how they do things, though? Get a fold-down trolley that goes in your car's boot for shopping. Buy less at a time. Those who are able to, shop at smaller shops within the communities (10-minute neighbourhood style). Get it delivered. Demand would be there for more and better shopping delivery to communities set up like this, where there could be set slots each week for a particular 'estate' to minimise environmental impact and ensure delivery slots. Prices at smaller local shops would have to compete with these delivery services from big supermarkets, so the price difference wouldn't be huge and those unable to get deliveries for whatever reason could shop locally.

It's not like it's hard to imagine ways round it - I find it so strange that you couldn't think of a single alternative to 'have giant carful of shopping'. How do you think people who don't have cars or can't park close to their house do their big shop now!? I used to take a little old person shopping trolley (or hiking rucksack) on the bus to Lidl when I was a student. My mum, who has limited physical mobility and no car, gets hers delivered with next door's, so they share delivery costs between them.

So now not only do you have to find more time each week to shop more regularly in more expensive local shops with less stock but if you do have a delivery it has to come on the time slot and day your given not when you need it having been in hospital or holiday a few weeks.

People who don't have cars either can't afford them so are already forced into inconvenience and expensive shops or have made that lifestyle choice built their lives around it, are physically able and are either not scared to wander around in dark lonely places at night happily watching cars get vandalised and people being attacked or stay in after dark.

CeriB82 · 10/01/2023 18:17

I absolutely loved lock down. Frankly because people stayed away. No people no cars.

but people are lazy. My nearest village has a carpark. Right in the middle as its one road, terraced houses . Yet they oark on the road , and a very narrow one too.

its being lazy. Makes the village untidy

tigger1001 · 10/01/2023 18:16

QuertyGirl · 10/01/2023 18:00

What's a rural town? That's just a town.

No it isn't.

No or very limited infrastructure. Few if any shops. Limited public transport. Limited employment opportunities.

I used to help out with a charity and one of the buzz phrases when applying for grants is "we stay in an area of rural deprivation"

In Scotland, where I am, a rural settlement is one with less than 3,000 people. So a rural town.

ChateauMargaux · 10/01/2023 18:15

I think this is a great idea! My sister lives in a co housing development, shared cars with charging points at the end of the pedestrian street, bulk food deliveries, trollies to take things and kids from one end to the other, communal play spaces indoor and outdoor, for different ages. It's not utopia and it is not for everyone, but it is nice.