Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we could make housing estates like Center Parcs re cars

809 replies

QuertyGirl · 10/01/2023 12:38

The USP of Centre Parcs is for many, the fact that they are mostly car free. Kids can play out and ride their bikes like I did when I was kid.

Can't do that now due to the amount of cars, speed and size of cars and, attitude of some car drivers.

People (including myself) pay a small fortune to holiday at CP.

Why can't we make housing estates more like that?

Communal car parks in walking distance, deliveries by small electric vehicles from a hub (like old fashioned milk floats), exemptions for blue badge holders and funding for electric mobility scooters for those that need them.

Yet, if the council suggests a couple of cycle lane and all hell breaks loose.

OP posts:
daybroke · 10/01/2023 19:47

There is one bus A day to my village in and out and it's rammed. It's a school bus back and forward.

But sure. Everyone else is saving the planet FOR ME and that wasn't a horrible ableist post aimed at me at all.

KickHimInTheCrotch · 10/01/2023 19:47

I love the idea of reducing our reliance on cars and having communities built around pedestrians, bikes etc. But you'd be up against a brick wall due to the mentality of people in this country. If anything we are headed in the other direction and becoming more like America where you have to drive everywhere and pedestrians and cyclists are not even an afterthought. The decimation of our high streets and public transport systems continues apace while out-of-town retail areas boom. Sad.

WalkthisWayUK · 10/01/2023 19:47

XenoBitch · 10/01/2023 19:44

Well don’t live there then if you have to have a car! And people with disabilities do have other forms of transport than cars, they can get down to their car in a scooter if they want to live somewhere like that. You are really picking at this now. No system is perfect, but advantages are huge. Including for disabled people. There could be better community support systems

I know a lovely lady who is 99% reliant on her little mobility scooter. The 1% is left for the times she goes from scooter to toilet, or hoists it up into her car, and she has to slowly hobble to the driver's seat.
A little scooter that can fit in her car wont be able to carry all her shopping etc from car to house in OP's little idealic world.

Well she could choose not to live there then. Why is OP being ‘little idealistic’ when it would work for so many others! Why would you put that down and belittle it?

daybroke · 10/01/2023 19:46

@WalkthisWayUK I can't afford to move.

I'm also physically disabled. I can't walk without crutches and I'm heading for a wheelchair.

I don't have other options than to use my car.

XenoBitch · 10/01/2023 19:44

Well don’t live there then if you have to have a car! And people with disabilities do have other forms of transport than cars, they can get down to their car in a scooter if they want to live somewhere like that. You are really picking at this now. No system is perfect, but advantages are huge. Including for disabled people. There could be better community support systems

I know a lovely lady who is 99% reliant on her little mobility scooter. The 1% is left for the times she goes from scooter to toilet, or hoists it up into her car, and she has to slowly hobble to the driver's seat.
A little scooter that can fit in her car wont be able to carry all her shopping etc from car to house in OP's little idealic world.

Devoutspoken · 10/01/2023 19:44

Drmarciafieldstone, do you have a rain coat?

EmmaEmerald · 10/01/2023 19:44

"Especially if we are saving the planet for you."

oh my god.

WalkthisWayUK · 10/01/2023 19:43

daybroke · 10/01/2023 19:36

If you think it's just as easy as getting to their car on a scooter you have NO IDEA what it's like for a disabled person to transfer from mobility scooter to car. And you've no idea about the weight and size of a mobility Scooter or the requirements to store them without them being stolen whilst still being available to those who need them when they need them

It's a daft idea.

Well you are so problem focused that you are never going to look at solutions. So don’t live there then! If it’s IMPOSSIBLE not to have a car. But telling other people that it could never work is just very bah humbug and also so car centric. And plenty of disabled people negotiate transferring onto buses etc from scooters etc, it’s just where there is a will there definitely is a way.

But if you don’t want to, why be so negative about others that do? Especially if we are saving the planet for you.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 10/01/2023 19:42

And you've no idea about the weight and size of a mobility Scooter

Yes, I always think when I see those TV adverts for the ones that 'only' weigh 20kg when folded - 3 stone or so isn't that much for a fit, able-bodied young-ish person, although you have to be able to lift it high and into the boot; but the typical user of a mobility scooter (and also their spouse if their main reason for needing it is age) could really struggle with that, if they don't have somebody with them to help every time.

BradfordGirl · 10/01/2023 19:41

What about doing what Switzerland do. Underground car parks with security built with most housing.

86Emily · 10/01/2023 19:40

QuertyGirl · 10/01/2023 12:51

I manage shopping and a child without a car. I don't drive due to disability.

My mother and grandmother did it too.

What's changed?

My grandmother has never worked. My mother didn't work for most of my childhood. They shopped daily with no car. It's easy enough to carry a day or two's worth of shopping, less easy to carry a week's worth of shopping.

SpaceMonitor · 10/01/2023 19:40

DrMarciaFieldstone · 10/01/2023 12:49

God no. It’s raining sideways today, not a chance I’d want my car parked further than my driveway.

How do you think people in cities who don’t have cars manage?

People in rural and suburban areas are far too dependant on their cars. I live in a city centre. The distance I walk from the shops is probably more than the distance OP is suggesting between home and car park. People have become extremely lazy and pampered.

WalkthisWayUK · 10/01/2023 19:39

HotDogJumpingFrogHaveACookie · 10/01/2023 19:33

And then from a safety perspective, I wouldn't really be in a rush to advise women to be walking alone to and from cars 15 minutes away. I certainly wouldn't want to be walking to my car at 5am.

Do you know how many accidents occur from pedestrians and roads? You are way more likely to get harmed walking on a pavement at 5am by a car than you are being attacked by a random stranger. And taxis would probably be allowed on those kind of estates anyway, so you know, what is your issue?

jannier · 10/01/2023 19:39

Bogasphodel · 10/01/2023 19:31

I think you’ve included some very sweeping generalisations there! I think you should be able to read from my original post that it was a courtyard of houses looking out onto fells. So a very lovely development. I’m not sure the age has major impacts on culture of an area. you’ve assumed a lot from “70s” without knowing the area, population density, crime stats etc. I have no idea where you live so I would never set off to preach what it’s like?

That's why I didn't say anything about your estate most 70s buildings were a failure thrown up mold ridden etc. Even the shopping centres tore down wonderful old buildings and put up cold windy brutalist concrete

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 10/01/2023 19:38

If anything, what could make most sense might be a backwards cul-de-sac - where the fronts of all the houses face out into the road (with drives). Then, you could ban all vehicles in the section behind the back of everybody's houses and make a big communal garden/play area (in addition to or instead of individual back gardens) where children could safely play and people could sit out and enjoy a traffic-fume free space.

Other than the very odd exception - maintenance vans or vehicles delivering turf, fencing or whatever, which could need a special permit or regular short allowable slot - nobody would have any need to use a vehicle there at all.

Devoutspoken · 10/01/2023 19:37

Lots and lots of people raise kids without a car, this country is so car centric its ridiculous

daybroke · 10/01/2023 19:36

If you think it's just as easy as getting to their car on a scooter you have NO IDEA what it's like for a disabled person to transfer from mobility scooter to car. And you've no idea about the weight and size of a mobility Scooter or the requirements to store them without them being stolen whilst still being available to those who need them when they need them

It's a daft idea.

Bargoed · 10/01/2023 19:36

We just need good cheap public transport so it's cheaper and easier to leave the car home most of the time along with community car share schemes and housing estates having to have a play area to get planning permission.

WalkthisWayUK · 10/01/2023 19:36

HotDogJumpingFrogHaveACookie · 10/01/2023 19:31

If a developer buys land to build on, no way are they going to reserve a sizeable quantity of it to create a carpark. People don't want to lose front gardens and paths so houses would still occupy broadly the same footprint, but would be substantially more expensive to buy.

Some people don't drive but rely on taxis to get to wherever they need to be due to disability, but they don't possess a blue badge and nor does their taxi driver.

Trades carrying out work aren't going to park up and walk 10 minutes with their tools, so getting someone to do work would be a nightmare.

Some people have a lot of kit they take to and from work and it just wouldn't be manageable.

Carrying large quantities of shopping would be difficult. Juggling said shopping with children would be troublesome.

Places with very little road traffic already exist.

In Center parcs do you think tradesmen walk up with their tools?

Do you think cars in a car park take up more space than big roads and car parking spaces in front of houses? Like in Center parcs?

Do you think people in center parcs carry shopping?

No! Tradesmen and deliveries could get in. It still vastly reduces the traffic to almost zero.

daybroke · 10/01/2023 19:34

I'm sorry that my ex is a farmhand and feeds the country. Completely unrealistic of me to want to stay in the location where my kids were settled and at school and I had friends and family for support what with being disabled and all.

Obviously.

SnackSizeRaisin · 10/01/2023 19:34

Ylvamoon · 10/01/2023 12:52

Sounds lovely...

Except what about shopping, small children/ babies ect?

How do you think half the population of the country manages without a car? How do the majority of people the world over manage? Babies in a pram. Small children in pram or buggy board or scooter. I live a brisk 20 minute walk from our nearest town. I do it almost daily with 2 children under 4. One is in a pram. The 3 year old walks or scoots. If it rains we sometimes get the bus part of the way. Shopping goes under the pram or in a rucsac. It's completely fine for every day life. The few thousand saved by not having a second car means I don't have to work as many hours. More time with children, healthier lifestyle.
It would be tricky with no car parking nearby loading up for holidays. Apart from that no issue.

HotDogJumpingFrogHaveACookie · 10/01/2023 19:33

And then from a safety perspective, I wouldn't really be in a rush to advise women to be walking alone to and from cars 15 minutes away. I certainly wouldn't want to be walking to my car at 5am.

WalkthisWayUK · 10/01/2023 19:33

daybroke · 10/01/2023 19:25

That was for @WinterSnowing

Well don’t live there then if you have to have a car! And people with disabilities do have other forms of transport than cars, they can get down to their car in a scooter if they want to live somewhere like that. You are really picking at this now. No system is perfect, but advantages are huge. Including for disabled people. There could be better community support systems.

Indeed in Denmark older people, many disabled, are living in just such places as in other areas of the world, where it is a car free estate or complex and bicycles or electric wheelchairs can move around freely without having to negotiate parked cars on kerbs etc.

And that still doesn’t mean it isn’t a good idea. I’d move there in a flash!

Bogasphodel · 10/01/2023 19:31

jannier · 10/01/2023 19:04

Most 70s estates have been deemed so dangerous for pedestrians people are scared to go out, some even in the day the pedestrian walkways are scary. My local town was made a pedestrian zone nobody goes through it after dark if they know the area the police are always being called.

I think you’ve included some very sweeping generalisations there! I think you should be able to read from my original post that it was a courtyard of houses looking out onto fells. So a very lovely development. I’m not sure the age has major impacts on culture of an area. you’ve assumed a lot from “70s” without knowing the area, population density, crime stats etc. I have no idea where you live so I would never set off to preach what it’s like?

HotDogJumpingFrogHaveACookie · 10/01/2023 19:31

If a developer buys land to build on, no way are they going to reserve a sizeable quantity of it to create a carpark. People don't want to lose front gardens and paths so houses would still occupy broadly the same footprint, but would be substantially more expensive to buy.

Some people don't drive but rely on taxis to get to wherever they need to be due to disability, but they don't possess a blue badge and nor does their taxi driver.

Trades carrying out work aren't going to park up and walk 10 minutes with their tools, so getting someone to do work would be a nightmare.

Some people have a lot of kit they take to and from work and it just wouldn't be manageable.

Carrying large quantities of shopping would be difficult. Juggling said shopping with children would be troublesome.

Places with very little road traffic already exist.

Swipe left for the next trending thread