Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we could make housing estates like Center Parcs re cars

809 replies

QuertyGirl · 10/01/2023 12:38

The USP of Centre Parcs is for many, the fact that they are mostly car free. Kids can play out and ride their bikes like I did when I was kid.

Can't do that now due to the amount of cars, speed and size of cars and, attitude of some car drivers.

People (including myself) pay a small fortune to holiday at CP.

Why can't we make housing estates more like that?

Communal car parks in walking distance, deliveries by small electric vehicles from a hub (like old fashioned milk floats), exemptions for blue badge holders and funding for electric mobility scooters for those that need them.

Yet, if the council suggests a couple of cycle lane and all hell breaks loose.

OP posts:
ivykaty44 · 11/01/2023 10:18

Its what is trying to be developed in Oxford, and there are people incandescent with rage about being prisoners. There are conspiracy theories about this action of trying to reduce pollution by keeping everything within 15 minutes walk.

It is how people lived for several hundred years, its only in the last 100 years that this has changed, many of the affects of the change are negative to human life span. Trying to change back is seen as a backward.

I have set up most of my life to be car free, I don't have to use my car for 80% of my life. Its great but it doesn't mean I don't use a car, it seems for many objecting that it has to be an either or.

WhatNoRaisins · 11/01/2023 10:04

The other thing that strikes me is the traffic jams at these car parks given that there will inevitably be peak times with people coming and going from the same location.

daybroke · 11/01/2023 10:00

I've been musing on it overnight as well.

So if disabled people get exemptions to put their cars on their drives. Every house would have to have a drive. Because you've no way to know who is disabled when buying a house, much less who will become disabled in the future.

Then there needs to be additional land for a car park 15 mins walk away. The average person walks 3-4 miles an hour so that's a mile away which is pretty far.

It would only work in very urban areas where everything a family would need on a regular basis would be inside that one mile circle. So. School, shops (and decently priced ones), doctor and pharmacy and play park and outside space for the kids.

WhatNoRaisins · 11/01/2023 09:56

Sleeping on this what strikes me is this sort of proposition is a stick. A lot of people actually really don't like driving and wouldn't do so with the right carrots in place.

Is a load of cars in a car park really better than those same cars on driveways if the cars aren't being used as much because there are decent alternatives that work to replace at least some car journeys? We only really drive if we need to go door to door for logistical reasons or there isn't an alternative.

Devoutspoken · 11/01/2023 09:46

Jannier - so because of that one area, your entrenched belief is now that pedestrianisation = crime? Also what you seem to be describing is the death of the high street in one area, which is a different issue, although not disconnected. High streets can thrive without cars.

jannier · 11/01/2023 09:31

Devoutspoken · 11/01/2023 09:21

Jannier - so you want more cars on our streets to keep women safe? Can the increase in cyclists and pedestrians help keep the place 'busy'? traffic is a far bigger danger than sexual assault.

In our town the opposite happened fewer people walked through shops closed and it became a no go area with drug addicts and dealers hanging around even boots and w h smiths and Iceland closed the only shops left are MC D's and betting shops...that have been robbed several times.
Making pedestrian only areas makes rat runs not safe for anyone....I've never said just women. Most people would not walk down alleys at night making a road width alley is no different. Deserted quiet areas are not safe they are targets.

icanneverthinkofnc · 11/01/2023 09:29

The problem with OPs idea is our model of how we like to live. Her vision in itself of the small village style development sounds ideal, but it's the infrastructure required to make it work that is the problem. Unfortunately, our planners and builders would just cram as many in as possible without any infrastructure around to maximise profits.

There is a lot of 'whataboutery' on here though. As shown on here people can and do manage.

I liked the Wii village too, on the exercise game.🤣 open green space, lots of exercise space.

Some friends do live on an estate, built on 60s,early 70s when working class council tenants were not really expected to have cars, with small car parks on the periphery, it's rat runs and parking space is too small as the car usage has far outstripped the original provision. There is very little outside house parking. They still have to manage there.

We do rely on cars heavily, but majority car ownership is relatively new. As children, we did walk everywhere, shopping on a Saturday for the week by catching the bus into town was normal. Kids went to the closest school, walking there.
I lived on a out of town estate. Milk was delivered, veg man drove round Saturday afternoon and we bought straight from the van. There was corner shop for odd stuff and post office, chippy, hairdressers.
DGF had a car, it was used for him to go to work only. Only one friends dad had a car.

Devoutspoken · 11/01/2023 09:21

Jannier - so you want more cars on our streets to keep women safe? Can the increase in cyclists and pedestrians help keep the place 'busy'? traffic is a far bigger danger than sexual assault.

FredaFox · 11/01/2023 09:15

Nw22 · 10/01/2023 12:46

There is a plan to do something like this in the centre of Manchester. There would be a hub for parcels to be delivered to and for people to park their car.

What?! Where are my parcels going?!
To be fair I get all parcels sent to my mum as living in a flat I don't trust when they will come and if I'm home so depending where it is it could work I guess
What if I get a Tesco home delivery or a taxi?!

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 11/01/2023 09:12

We live on a lovely estate where the kids play at the dead end of the street. Maybe make it so parking on the road is illegal and all new build estates have to be dead ends. Also I find the kids go in and out of each other gardens to play on toys rather than play in the actual street.

Makes a lot more sense to me - I don't see why it has to be one extreme or the other.

EatYourVegetables · 11/01/2023 08:02

YANBU.

The obsession with cars is killing our planet (and our bodies).

mozzyworries · 11/01/2023 08:01

20 metres not minutes!

mozzyworries · 11/01/2023 08:00

Lovely idea OP but not practical. I live in a house which is only accessed by footpath, but can park my car about 20 minutes away on the road. It's a huge pain for bringing shopping home, not to mention having anything large delivered or having work done to the house.

Grumpybutfunny · 11/01/2023 06:37

We live on a lovely estate where the kids play at the dead end of the street. Maybe make it so parking on the road is illegal and all new build estates have to be dead ends. Also I find the kids go in and out of each other gardens to play on toys rather than play in the actual street.

Emily19944 · 11/01/2023 05:49

I do agree that some people drive without due care and attention, and some road users are overly aggressive.

However I also find that children seem to have no road sense nowadays - where I live half the time they ride straight onto the road on bikes without looking, parents are oblivious because they’re stuck to their phones, and kids are playing in the road instead of the pavements with no supervision.

lilyipad · 11/01/2023 00:46

I've lived in a block where I used to have to carry my full shop and baby from car to flat. No thanks. Never again. Park in my garage now.

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 10/01/2023 23:22

One thing that occurs to me, that would help with the issue of people using their cars, would be if developers have to plan services into their estates - or at least contribute to them.

Where I live, we have a lot of building going on - someone on our community FB page reckons that every blade of grass around our village is owned by developers who want to build houses on the edge of a popular village. So we are seeing lots of houses being built - but just houses - no shops, no extra provision in the already overstretched schools, GP surgery and dentist - just dormitories. Even if people wanted to walk to the shops, they are not close by - only the really fit would be able to nip to the co-op for milk without getting in the car.

The Scottish government has a new policy of building communities for living - where the things you need will be within 10 minutes walk - but this is not filtering down to the local authority planning departments who are happily approving more and more estates with just houses.

BradfordGirl · 10/01/2023 23:22

CuteOrangeElephant · 10/01/2023 23:06

I know two elderly people who do a 5 mile journey to their son 3 times a week on a mobility scooter. Good infrastructure is not just for the abled or for people with a car!

I think OPs idea a bit extreme. But there's nothing wrong with a pedestrian/cyclist focussed estate where cars can take a back route to behind the houses/parking a couple of minutes away.

I would not risk that. They must have very good scooters.

Thewildling · 10/01/2023 23:11

Although not this exact thought.. Last time I was at centerparcs I had the thought that building small eco friendly villages, like a centerparcs set up in the outside world would solve an awful lot of issues. Low cost housing & living alongside nature.. what’s not to love.

CuteOrangeElephant · 10/01/2023 23:06

jannier · 10/01/2023 22:55

But if she needed to go further like a hospital 3 bus rides away how could she independently do it? If she was of working age should her job prospects be limited to her battery life and speed? Has she been for a 20 minute joy ride in the recent cold weather, snow or rain? .not all disabled people have someone to ask or wish to live lives dependent on others.

I know two elderly people who do a 5 mile journey to their son 3 times a week on a mobility scooter. Good infrastructure is not just for the abled or for people with a car!

I think OPs idea a bit extreme. But there's nothing wrong with a pedestrian/cyclist focussed estate where cars can take a back route to behind the houses/parking a couple of minutes away.

jannier · 10/01/2023 23:01

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 10/01/2023 22:03

Not all people with mobility issues are registered disabled it can take months and sometimes years to get that rubber stamped.

Exactly. So many able-bodied people seem to think that there are only two groups: blue badge-holders and people without any disabilities or mobility problems.

It's also very common for those who are lucky enough to live enough to get old to struggle with their mobility, even though they may not technically count as disabled.

I don't think anybody responded to the point that I raised earlier, about people being forced to move out of their homes and neighbourhoods when they get older or if they become disabled. Even if it's a choice as to where you live (i.e. once you're old and/or disabled, it's your 'choice' to go away from the home where you might have lived for decades), you know exactly what will happen to the demand for and prices of the homes in areas that do allow the cars that such people will need access for.

Unfortunately many don't care about disability.....you wouldn't be getting on a bus around this eutopia for eco mummies with super big buggies and trolleys refusing to give up the disabled space and especially walking to the stop before if they saw you waiting.

celticprincess · 10/01/2023 22:57

Terrible idea. I usually get annoyed when I can’t get outside my house and have to walk the full street from the car. Especially with my weekly shopping or as a teacher my several bags of resources and books to mark. Even worse if you have small children - not practical to leave them in the car whilst you walk home with all the bags and not practical to take them home and leave them there whilst you go and get the bags. I also can’t see the supermarkets and other big delivery companies using milk float type vehicles. Then the wheelie bin folks, how do they get done to empty all the bins??

jannier · 10/01/2023 22:55

KickHimInTheCrotch · 10/01/2023 19:51

My 94 yo Grandma has recently traded in her car for a mobility scooter. It's removed the worry of maintaining a car and interestingly given her more freedom. She can now park right outside the library/shop/GP surgery before zipping off to her knitting circle instead of having to battle for a parking space, pay for parking on her mobile phone (which is not within her comfort zone) and walk the last 100 yards with a stick.

But if she needed to go further like a hospital 3 bus rides away how could she independently do it? If she was of working age should her job prospects be limited to her battery life and speed? Has she been for a 20 minute joy ride in the recent cold weather, snow or rain? .not all disabled people have someone to ask or wish to live lives dependent on others.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 10/01/2023 22:03

Not all people with mobility issues are registered disabled it can take months and sometimes years to get that rubber stamped.

Exactly. So many able-bodied people seem to think that there are only two groups: blue badge-holders and people without any disabilities or mobility problems.

It's also very common for those who are lucky enough to live enough to get old to struggle with their mobility, even though they may not technically count as disabled.

I don't think anybody responded to the point that I raised earlier, about people being forced to move out of their homes and neighbourhoods when they get older or if they become disabled. Even if it's a choice as to where you live (i.e. once you're old and/or disabled, it's your 'choice' to go away from the home where you might have lived for decades), you know exactly what will happen to the demand for and prices of the homes in areas that do allow the cars that such people will need access for.

Squamata · 10/01/2023 22:00

MoiraDavidson · 10/01/2023 20:52

OP, I always think this when I’ve been to Center Parcs. A housing development where kids are free to play and ride bikes would be brilliant. Also think it when I’ve been to little seaside villages with narrow streets and no pavements, dominated by massive cars - there should be a carpark on the outskirts for people who are mobile and then they walk in. We’ve got so accustomed to dutifully jumping out of the way for enormous cars.

Some cities try this 'park and stride' but the surrounding areas that get huge car parks built in them don't exactly love it!