Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we could make housing estates like Center Parcs re cars

809 replies

QuertyGirl · 10/01/2023 12:38

The USP of Centre Parcs is for many, the fact that they are mostly car free. Kids can play out and ride their bikes like I did when I was kid.

Can't do that now due to the amount of cars, speed and size of cars and, attitude of some car drivers.

People (including myself) pay a small fortune to holiday at CP.

Why can't we make housing estates more like that?

Communal car parks in walking distance, deliveries by small electric vehicles from a hub (like old fashioned milk floats), exemptions for blue badge holders and funding for electric mobility scooters for those that need them.

Yet, if the council suggests a couple of cycle lane and all hell breaks loose.

OP posts:
Mediocrates · 11/01/2023 17:57

It’s a miserable January night here. It’s dark, it’s pissing down, I’m still getting over the flu. I’d rather sleep in my car than walk uphill for 15
mins in the pissing rain just to get to my house, when I have a perfectly good driveway.

It’s all well and good having a 15 minute walk to your car when you’re on holiday - no work, no school runs, no appointments. It’s not practical for daily life for a lot of people. Sure, provision for blue badge holders is great but what about if you’re just unwell? Or if frankly you can’t be arsed after a day at work or a day of parenting?

We usually visit CP once a year, and while I enjoy the car-free aspect I absolutely would not choose to live like that.

user1468656818 · 11/01/2023 17:56

interested in how much exercise commenters here do. The thought of a 15 minute walk has gone straight to women will be murdered. Ladies please get fresh air and go outside if you can - the world is not such a bad place!

Yourcatisnotsorry · 11/01/2023 17:54

Endless inconvenience for everyone and more women would be raped and murdered. So no thanks. Using cars less when practical absolutely. I commute by train, walk kids to school, shops and visiting friends etc.

herbaltea21 · 11/01/2023 17:53

QuertyGirl · 10/01/2023 12:46

Why not exactly?

A ten or 15 min walk to a communal car park would probably do most of us some good.

Imagine a single mim having to walk 10-15 min with the food shop and two young children in tow 😵‍💫

user1468656818 · 11/01/2023 17:51

jannier · 11/01/2023 17:39

Seriously ..have you never been followed as a pedestrian had men leering at you, had your son threatened with a knife at 6pm whilst out with 3 other scouts? The odd horn blast isn't going to kill you....or are you going to come out with being the victim of road rage dragged from your car?

No I’ve never had a child threatened with a knife at 6p. - that is, fortunately, not the norm (unless you read the daily mail) but I’m sorry that happened to you. How terribly sad.

I have however had multiple scary encounters with creepy men in cars driving by, stopping, leering, shouting and honking. Also too many instances to count of seeing people who simply should not be driving, driving on pavement, aggressive driving, unable to follow basic road rules. Not to mention the unbelievable numbers who should no longer be driving but refuse to give in license. That (a vulnerable / unsafe person operating a ton+ of machinery) is all far more scary to me than any dark alley with possible bogeyman.

Angelil · 11/01/2023 17:45

YANBU OP. I live in the Netherlands. People don’t usually do a weekly shop - they do smaller ones every 2-3 days, with multiple small kids in tow, in all weathers. All thanks to buggies, cargo bikes etc. You do need good infrastructure though (e.g. proper cycle lanes that are separate from the main carriageway) and the ideal sort of ‘10-minute town’ where amenities are within a reasonable distance. This takes a radical change of mindset and of course investment, which the U.K. government is unwilling to countenance.

The weather is not an excuse in itself, at all. Dutch weather is very similar to U.K. weather. You just need a decent rain suit and pair of wellies and everyone is fine, even small kids.

I too find that people are far too car-dependent. I cycle to work (20-30 minutes each way) or get the bus (20 minutes) or tram (30-40 minutes). I am lucky enough to have amenities (doctor, dentist, supermarket etc) within walking distance (10-15 minutes tops) but even if I had to go into the town centre proper for those, it wouldn’t take any longer than my commute via public transport or bike. My son’s school and after-school club are also only 10-15 minutes’ walk away. He takes his scooter in the morning and my husband runs after him! I bring him home on the bike. He’s 4. When he was smaller I would just pick up bits and pieces of food shopping while we were out and about and shove them under the buggy. His baby brother is due soon and we will buy a buggy board and cargo bike. When it rains he just wears his rain suit and wellies. It’s really not that hard.

QuertyGirl · 11/01/2023 17:43

@jannier

I've had cars pull up to lear at me. I've had taxi drivers try it on.

I've had men in the street try it on with cars whizzing past. No help there.

The safest mode of travel I've found at night, is actually a night bus. Preferably crowded.

Second to that is a bike (badly driven cars are another matter)

OP posts:
QuertyGirl · 11/01/2023 17:39

@jannier

They tracked street crime in relation to numbers of residents and incoming workers, ie per capita.

There is no actual evidence that pedestrianisation increases crime, none.

There is evidence that it decreases it.

Please feel free to prove me wrong with some data.

OP posts:
jannier · 11/01/2023 17:39

user1468656818 · 11/01/2023 17:34

What about aggressive, anti social and dangerous drivers? I encounter far more of those than dangerous people on foot.

Seriously ..have you never been followed as a pedestrian had men leering at you, had your son threatened with a knife at 6pm whilst out with 3 other scouts? The odd horn blast isn't going to kill you....or are you going to come out with being the victim of road rage dragged from your car?

user1468656818 · 11/01/2023 17:34

jannier · 11/01/2023 17:13

Having cars drive past makes witnesses to crimes makes areas busier lonely deserted quiet areas make crimes easier.....many pedestrians do not stop to help ..I guess if you're old and don't look dirty or drunk it is more likely they will but many walk past take photos or stand watching. Society in general says don't get involved nowadays but you are more likely to be attacked or mugged if nobody is around.
Yes it is safer to be a passenger rather than a pedestrian the same as it's safer to lock your door at night and not be sleeping in a doorway. But it's not the car making you unsafe

What about aggressive, anti social and dangerous drivers? I encounter far more of those than dangerous people on foot.

sparklyWand · 11/01/2023 17:24

As a female who has been repeatedly subjected to stalking/weird men in the past I would be genuinely scared at the idea of having to walk 5-15 mins on my own to get home from work. Particularly as certain shifts involve finishing at 11pm at night (getting home around 11:45pm).

jannier · 11/01/2023 17:21

@QuertyGirl
The problem with the report is it hasn't looked at changes in pedestrian traffic as far as I can see. It's not saying previously 900 people went through the area in an hour that has now increased or decreased...if you have less passersby you have less crime. If people are parking and going into a shop the time they are walking as pedestrians they are obviously at risk of street crime (unlike in a car where it's road accidents) if you scare off pedestrians you will get a reduction of crime but the chances of any one individual being a victim don't go down ..and if it's people loitering looking for a victim your more likely to be one.

jannier · 11/01/2023 17:13

QuertyGirl · 11/01/2023 16:36

@jannier

Nobody in those cars got out to help him.

I think what you're arguing is that people should be inside cars to avoid being victims of crime?

What about those of us (me, that elderly man) who can't drive?

Having cars driving past certainly does not do anything to improve safety for those of us not in a car. Having cars driving past is unlikely to have helped in any of your examples.

This is interesting:

findingspress.org/article/19414-the-impact-of-introducing-a-low-traffic-neighbourhood-on-street-crime-in-waltham-forest-london

Having cars drive past makes witnesses to crimes makes areas busier lonely deserted quiet areas make crimes easier.....many pedestrians do not stop to help ..I guess if you're old and don't look dirty or drunk it is more likely they will but many walk past take photos or stand watching. Society in general says don't get involved nowadays but you are more likely to be attacked or mugged if nobody is around.
Yes it is safer to be a passenger rather than a pedestrian the same as it's safer to lock your door at night and not be sleeping in a doorway. But it's not the car making you unsafe

sleepyfelines · 11/01/2023 16:56

QuertyGirl · 10/01/2023 12:46

Why not exactly?

A ten or 15 min walk to a communal car park would probably do most of us some good.

No thanks. I'm not walking 10-15 minutes to and from my car, in the dark and cold, to go to work on long shifts. Not safe for the people or the cars!

Kinnorafron · 11/01/2023 16:45

Thewildling · 10/01/2023 23:11

Although not this exact thought.. Last time I was at centerparcs I had the thought that building small eco friendly villages, like a centerparcs set up in the outside world would solve an awful lot of issues. Low cost housing & living alongside nature.. what’s not to love.

Center Parcs is the antithesis of eco-friendly.

user1468656818 · 11/01/2023 16:40

jannier · 11/01/2023 16:28

Why am I anxious? I'm telling you what has happened in the 3 pedestrian towns around me this year ,it's fact, not anxiety. I could tell you of the time I stopped my car for an old lady walking along the pavement in her nighty at 3 pm. The realities are we live in a world where not everything is Rosey we risk access on the basis of where we are. I've happily walked through the red light district in Copenhagen on my own in an evening because I was told by locals it would be safe. Would I walk the Hyde park underground tunnels on my own? no.

Amsterdam, you say. A place in which (over a number of years) society has optimised infrastructure around bikes and pedestrians?! Putting people over machinery??! And it feels safe and nice to walk around?! How crazy!

QuertyGirl · 11/01/2023 16:36

@jannier

Nobody in those cars got out to help him.

I think what you're arguing is that people should be inside cars to avoid being victims of crime?

What about those of us (me, that elderly man) who can't drive?

Having cars driving past certainly does not do anything to improve safety for those of us not in a car. Having cars driving past is unlikely to have helped in any of your examples.

This is interesting:

findingspress.org/article/19414-the-impact-of-introducing-a-low-traffic-neighbourhood-on-street-crime-in-waltham-forest-london

OP posts:
jannier · 11/01/2023 16:28

user1468656818 · 11/01/2023 16:00

You sound incredibly anxious. I hope you are ok.

Why am I anxious? I'm telling you what has happened in the 3 pedestrian towns around me this year ,it's fact, not anxiety. I could tell you of the time I stopped my car for an old lady walking along the pavement in her nighty at 3 pm. The realities are we live in a world where not everything is Rosey we risk access on the basis of where we are. I've happily walked through the red light district in Copenhagen on my own in an evening because I was told by locals it would be safe. Would I walk the Hyde park underground tunnels on my own? no.

ivykaty44 · 11/01/2023 16:28

And then there is the cost side of things... I recently went to Sheffield. 2.5 hours by car at a cost of £65.- including park and ride for 2 people... train was over 4 hours (waiting times and changing) and around 80.- pp. And that's without the 40 minutes walk (one way) to the station or the cost of a taxi.

private car useage is heavily subsidised, so it’s going to be cheaper than public transport which is for profit

To think we could make housing estates like Center Parcs re cars
Toddlerteaplease · 11/01/2023 16:21

The estate near me that was a made with loads of footpaths and separate car parks is actually really dodgy because of its layout. Lots of dark paths and secluded corners. Blocks of garages are targets for vandalism. It feels very unsafe.

user1468656818 · 11/01/2023 16:00

jannier · 11/01/2023 15:54

They stopped they didn't run him over pedestrians helped ....issue is what?
Real life example....55 walking home through a pedestrianised town on his own at 10pm mugged by 4 young men ....real life example homeless man beaten in doorway . Realise example woman leaving train station followed by 2 men had to take refuge in mds then wait until mother could find someone to escort her through town centre to reach her 25 year old daughter...could have driven to door before pedestrianisation real life example ambulance delayed because vandalism of folding barriers meant they wouldn't go down could not reach collapsed 80 something in shop. ... they is from 3 local towns.

You sound incredibly anxious. I hope you are ok.

jannier · 11/01/2023 15:57

user1468656818 · 11/01/2023 10:50

well presumably you would not look to buy a house in this hypothetical village 🫤

And tough if you brought it before your disability and can't find a buyer at a price that lets you move or a landlord to take you on....or is Eutopia exclusive to the few that can afford a mortgage.?

Ylvamoon · 11/01/2023 15:55

I passed my driving test at age 18 and bought my first car age 25 because I needed one to get around.

I think the idea is great, but reality is very different.

I lived in several cities, some with a good infrastructure and affordable public transport and others not so much. I owned a bicycle to get around locally and a large backpack for shopping.

Would I want to go back to the good old days ? Absolutely not!

And then there is the cost side of things... I recently went to Sheffield. 2.5 hours by car at a cost of £65.- including park and ride for 2 people... train was over 4 hours (waiting times and changing) and around 80.- pp. And that's without the 40 minutes walk (one way) to the station or the cost of a taxi.

I don't think you're getting much support because in reality it's just not durable. It's not cost or time effective and not everyone is able to drag 3-4 large shopping bags through heat, rain and snow to their front door.

jannier · 11/01/2023 15:54

QuertyGirl · 11/01/2023 10:37

@jannier

I'm not getting this idea of cars making areas safe for pedestrians.

Real example:

An elderly man is clinging to a railing next to the junction. Many cars stop at the junction and stare at him. To be fair, they look concerned and positively relieved when a pedestrian goes up to help him.

Nobody got out of their car in the ten minutes or so he was there. None.

He was ok in the end, just a bit spooked.

They stopped they didn't run him over pedestrians helped ....issue is what?
Real life example....55 walking home through a pedestrianised town on his own at 10pm mugged by 4 young men ....real life example homeless man beaten in doorway . Realise example woman leaving train station followed by 2 men had to take refuge in mds then wait until mother could find someone to escort her through town centre to reach her 25 year old daughter...could have driven to door before pedestrianisation real life example ambulance delayed because vandalism of folding barriers meant they wouldn't go down could not reach collapsed 80 something in shop. ... they is from 3 local towns.