Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be worried about school shootings/guns?

166 replies

Nogbreaks · 10/01/2023 10:00

DW, American, has the opportunity to take a great job in a US East coast city. She's keen, having lived her for 20 years, to go for a few years ( maybe more) with the kids. She was approached for this role, wasn't seeking it, nor have we be planning on ever living in the USA, though it has come up from time to time.

Apart from the obvious - we'd be uprooting our 11 and 13 year olds who are very happy, settled in school, I'd have to find a job ( though could get a green card as we're married), we have a fantastic community and network around us which I find particularly helpful as I do the most of the 'wife work' on top of my FT time job as DW is the main earner by a long chalk, we'd be moving to a city where we know no-one at all...

I'm really GENUINELY worried about the safety of our kids going to a school in the US. I don't want them to have shooter drills and all that comes with it. I don't want to take them on what we could dress up as an adventure where we have to worried about the gun culture in the city were in. As an East coast city it does have stricter gun laws, but pretty much anyone can still have a weapon.

Is that a daft reason to refuse to go? My career and aspirations there are 2nd as I could maybe maybe transfer with my current company, and I'm acutely aware of all DW has given up to live in the UK all this time with me.

OP posts:
WhenIAmOldIShallWearPurple · 10/01/2023 11:23

I think I would also be worried about education standards, especially at that age. They could potentially return to the UK disadvantaged. Hasn't there been an issue recently with American schools giving service personal spouses jobs as teachers purely based on the fact they are military spouses and not experience / education? Or have I misunderstood that?

Nogbreaks · 10/01/2023 11:22

Oh, and DW has also just said that although the job preference is to be US based for the right candidate they could be based in the Paris office, and travel to US for big meetings...

So yes, she really does want to go to the US, as apparently France is off the cards for her...

OP posts:
Chickenvoicesinmyhead · 10/01/2023 11:22

For me, the DC's education and upheaval for them would be my primary concern over and above other worries.

If they were under 10 then it may work but not at your DC ages. Don't underestimate kids friends, roots and your happiness.

As you know they are entering a very important stage of education. You won't be able to come back and make the transition mid-way in GCSE's, so I guess it's now or once they've finished (i.e the whole secondary education in either the UK or USA).

Is your wife able to mix her work between here and there? She's already doing long hours.

MindatWork · 10/01/2023 11:22

I'd also be concerned about the backslide in women's rights in the US at the moment, and the rise of the conservative right (although sadly that's a problem we have here as well). Would you be moving to a state where women have the right to decide what happens to their own bodies?

Nogbreaks · 10/01/2023 11:16

'That's quite a nasty thing to say about Baltimore.'

My DSIL is an EMT in Baltimore, her DP is a firefighter there too... And I have been to Baltimore. Sorry if it seems harsh saying we wouldn't think of living there, but it has been hit incredibly hard by the opoid crisis, the police are incredibly corrupt, and their crime rate is one of the worst in the country. Their violent crime stats are very high, and not just the usual gang/crime stuff either.
I can't think of anyone I know in the USA who would relocate to Baltimore with their family.

OP posts:
ChiefWiggumsBoy · 10/01/2023 11:15

Nogbreaks · 10/01/2023 11:11

The older one wants to go, has romantic notions of the US ( we go 2x a year for holidays/family) the younger one we haven't mentioned anything to yet as it would still be 6 months away if at all.
Both kids make friends at the drop of a hat, and have sports that are transferable to US. In fact, that would be an advantage. Their sports are very well supported in US, more so than here.
Schools - we'd probably use a British School as we are planning on coming back but that would be TBC. But that means any extra money is sued up on fees, and out kids here are in state school. In general we don't believe in a 2-tier school system.

I don't know. We've been able to go this whole time and have never bitten the bullet. I know that crime and drugs have affected so many US family members, directly or indirectly, it's left me feeling I wouldn't want to live there.
However - on a certain salary - quality of life in the US can be amazing.

The reality is DW is American, kids are half American and can really tell her we can't try living in her home country when she's lived in mine, because if me, for 20years??

If a person can be told they can't move their children away to a different county to keep them where they have a support network etc. then yes I think you can (to answer just your last question).

Maybe I just have no sense of adventure, but I could never move countries without the 100% agreement of everyone in my family. Especially if I'd made a decision to emigrate and then decided I might want to move back.

Is DW really really enthusiastic about it considering it wasn't something she was actively chasing?

JamSandle · 10/01/2023 11:15

I admit I'd be scared to live and work in the US due to the gun crime though I love the country.

DarkShade · 10/01/2023 11:14

I moved at 13 and it was absolutely awful. I think it would be a bit much to move them at 11 and 13, and then back again at 14 and 16. The 16 year old in partricular will be gearing up for exams, will have an all-consuming social scene, school based hobbies, and so on. Moving back to the UK would be really hard on them I think, and their grades will suffer as the exams and content will be different. If I were you I would either keep the option on the table for 8 years' time, when everyone is off at uni, or move but plan to make it permanent. Be prepared for your children potentially deciding to stay, if you wait until their US schooling is over to move back.

I think that it could be a great opportunity for your family, and they're good ages in the sense that there is no schooling interrupted. But think carefully about the return ages.

MrsSkylerWhite · 10/01/2023 11:14

Couldn’t pay me enough to live in the US. It’s going backwards.

Winterpetal · 10/01/2023 11:13

My worry would be ,they are at an age where they may settle in UAS after education,gets jobs ,partners ,marry ,kids …and you end up having to stay there forever or end up bacon U.K. and your kids families are in USA

Nogbreaks · 10/01/2023 11:11

The older one wants to go, has romantic notions of the US ( we go 2x a year for holidays/family) the younger one we haven't mentioned anything to yet as it would still be 6 months away if at all.
Both kids make friends at the drop of a hat, and have sports that are transferable to US. In fact, that would be an advantage. Their sports are very well supported in US, more so than here.
Schools - we'd probably use a British School as we are planning on coming back but that would be TBC. But that means any extra money is sued up on fees, and out kids here are in state school. In general we don't believe in a 2-tier school system.

I don't know. We've been able to go this whole time and have never bitten the bullet. I know that crime and drugs have affected so many US family members, directly or indirectly, it's left me feeling I wouldn't want to live there.
However - on a certain salary - quality of life in the US can be amazing.

The reality is DW is American, kids are half American and can really tell her we can't try living in her home country when she's lived in mine, because if me, for 20years??

OP posts:
lottie198 · 10/01/2023 11:10

MandaLynn · 10/01/2023 10:35

I'm an American, grew up on the east coast - now living in the UK.

I wouldn't go.

Partly due to the upheaval of your children and their schooling, leaving an established community of support, etc. But I would never go back to the states when my children are school age, particularly due to concerns around guns and school shootings.

I still remember being 10ths old, brought into an assembly after the Columbine shooting. Being told what had happened and that we would start having active shooter drills. I remember how terrified I was each time, hiding under our desks or in closets while the Principal would walk through the hallway jiggling the classroom door handle to check it was locked. I feel a bit traumatised from the drills, let alone the possibility of an actually shooting event

How terrifying. No child should ever have to go through that xx

Muddledbutwellmeaning · 10/01/2023 11:08

I think I’d stick with holidays as long as you can manage, and wait until your youngest is at Uni/apprenticeship. @TheMagicSword gosh the asking your Childrens’ matés’ parents whether they have guns and where they keep them is something I hadn’t thought about before. But yes, so much potential for accidents. Especially so because kids get over-excited on play dates/hang outs.

I worry about ponds/ upstairs windows etc when there are little (guest) kids running about, but that worry will never go away if there’re guns in the house.
Shudder.

lottie198 · 10/01/2023 11:08

It seems like you are happy in the UK and have a good life here. Also with your children being the ages that they are, I'd stay here. Have you sounded it out with the children and how they would feel?
Also, what does your wife want to do?
I would also be terrified sending my kids to school in the US. I know school shootings are probably statistically unlikely as someone else said, but they still seem pretty common.
I know others have said don't let that be the deciding factor , but if it's going to worry you from day to day, it's an important factor.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 10/01/2023 11:03

I wouldn't. I would have considered it 20 years ago before I had children but not now. But my situation is that I don't have family ties.

Is it anywhere near to her family? Because to me that is the deciding factor really. If it's moving and will be closer to her family, then I'd consider it more than if it were a move to California but all her family are in New York, for example.

I'm not sure I think the cultural/expand your horizons benefits outweighs the negatives. Especially if it might mean that longterm my children settle in a country I'm not comfortable living in.

TheMagicSword · 10/01/2023 11:01

We’re a UK/US household which could have a considerably higher income in the US (but also considerably higher outgoings and precious little vacation time). We have agreed that, all other factors aside, guns are why we will never live there with our children. It’s not just the chance of an actual shooting, it’s the day to day stress of it - searches, drills, etc. Having to ask the parents of your children’s friends about guns in their house before you let your children visit (not everyone believes in keeping them locked up). We’re not anti-gun at all, but we spend enough time in the US and have enough friends and family there to know that the situation there now is just not one we’re willing to live in.

Id also suggest that while 11 and 13 are reasonable ages to move school, in 2+ years it’ll be a really bad time to move back to the UK. I know if we were to move at that age it would end up being a more or less permanent move due to the cycle of exams, college, etc.

Sling · 10/01/2023 10:56

I just moved teenagers internationally, it was not done lightly - it is proving very challenging as we expected, but in some aspects even worse than expected.

So regardless of salary and location

  1. how will your kids react? Honestly even the most resilient teen is going to find it tough.
  2. if you move them now - would you move them again or are you committed to 7 years there and possibly them staying for Uni
Muddledbutwellmeaning · 10/01/2023 10:55

What are the chances of getting into a good school in NYC @Nogbreaks ?

Am sure you know already but you could be talking a 1.5 hour commute from parts of LI for eg.

thuytien · 10/01/2023 10:52

I would go for it. Although I had just this instant read about a vigilante customer in a Texas restaurant shot 9 times to kill a robber who used a fake gun to get money and was leaving. Nothing new. Yesterday a six year old pupil shot and injured his teacher.

I would not actively seek to live in America but when opportunities like this arose you should take it to broaden your life experiences.

MindatWork · 10/01/2023 10:50

Honestly OP I'd feel the same as you. My DH works for a large silicon valley tech company and we could realistically move to California for a secondment. I'd have been really keen pre-DC but now we have a 4 year-old DD I don't think I could do it.

I've seen TikToks about US parents sending their children to school with bullet proof backpacks and talking about shooter drills etc. I know social media isn't representative of the real situation and you shouldn't believe everything you read, etc, but the whole gun culture in the US absolutely confounds me and I think I'd struggle to feel comfortable.

We've travelled extensively in the US and I'll never forget driving through Louisiana and seeing numerous sections of the highway renamed as memorials for police officers who'd been shot and killed in the line of duty...

MarshaBradyo · 10/01/2023 10:50

I think you both have to be happy with the move

If it were me and the offer was there with all the life we’ve built up and what you mention, I wouldn’t go

Swimswam · 10/01/2023 10:47

Honestly ? I would go. It’s a chance to broaden horizons, experience something new.

MavisMcMinty · 10/01/2023 10:46

I loathe the gun situation in the US, and it’s one of the things that stopped me ever wanting to work there, but realistically tens of millions of children don’t get gunned down at school. How do your children feel about it? You know that “a few years” will pass in the blink of an eye, but for children time goes much slower, “a few years” of being unhappy and homesick will seem very much longer to them.

golfwidow88 · 10/01/2023 10:45

I mean, it sounds like an amazing opportunity. But I would also be cautious re the gun laws and school shootings.

Will they be attending a private school? I am not sure if that is any 'better' in terms of shootings...

Also, they are such tricky ages! They might not want to come back to the UK after a few years as they would have met new friends etc? Have you both spoken to them about it yet?

Choconut · 10/01/2023 10:45

Terrible idea at your kids ages when they are settles and happy.