Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be worried about school shootings/guns?

166 replies

Nogbreaks · 10/01/2023 10:00

DW, American, has the opportunity to take a great job in a US East coast city. She's keen, having lived her for 20 years, to go for a few years ( maybe more) with the kids. She was approached for this role, wasn't seeking it, nor have we be planning on ever living in the USA, though it has come up from time to time.

Apart from the obvious - we'd be uprooting our 11 and 13 year olds who are very happy, settled in school, I'd have to find a job ( though could get a green card as we're married), we have a fantastic community and network around us which I find particularly helpful as I do the most of the 'wife work' on top of my FT time job as DW is the main earner by a long chalk, we'd be moving to a city where we know no-one at all...

I'm really GENUINELY worried about the safety of our kids going to a school in the US. I don't want them to have shooter drills and all that comes with it. I don't want to take them on what we could dress up as an adventure where we have to worried about the gun culture in the city were in. As an East coast city it does have stricter gun laws, but pretty much anyone can still have a weapon.

Is that a daft reason to refuse to go? My career and aspirations there are 2nd as I could maybe maybe transfer with my current company, and I'm acutely aware of all DW has given up to live in the UK all this time with me.

OP posts:
Nogbreaks · 10/01/2023 11:52

'She chose to live in the UK and have children who were born and brought up in the UK. She hasn't sacrificed living in the US as that was never her plan.'

Actually, living in the UK was never her plan. She was happy in the USA until we met and I couldn't move to the US at the time, as our same sex partnership wasn't recognised so she moved here instead so we could live together.

OP posts:
Aloezebra · 10/01/2023 11:52

I wouldn’t personally want my children to go to school in America, it may be alarmist of me and I know it’s statistically unlikely they would be impacted but just the fact that they would have to think about the possibility let alone go through drills and god forbid actually be involved in one is enough for me to say no.

FarFlungFlamingo · 10/01/2023 11:50

The fentanyl crisis, too.

This is the shock for me. I lived in the Midwest for a few years and it's horrifying how many of my friends and colleagues from my time there are personally affected by it.

Snugglemonkey · 10/01/2023 11:50

I would have the same reservations. I don't think uprooting the kids is a terrible idea if they are very keen on it. If they didn't want to go, it would be off the table for me. I also would be really anxious about my children being in a school there.
I have a v small support network here, it makes things difficult. Honestly, unless everyone was wildly keen, it would be a no for me.

MindatWork · 10/01/2023 11:49

This is a good site for anyone interested in gun crime rates in the US: www.gunviolencearchive.org

It's a non-profit based in Washington DC. Their methodology seems pretty robust and according to their stats, 55 children under the age of 18 have been killed in gun incidents THIS YEAR.

Nogbreaks · 10/01/2023 11:48

'Surely with only a slight salary increase hut paying excesses on healthcare and school fees you're going to be worse off financially?'

With US taxes etc even after fees ( if we pay them) we'd be a bit better off. Work also covers ALL medical, incl out of pocket.

It's not about the money really. It would be an amazing job too, prestigious etc
But it's mainly that as her parents age she'd like to be closer.

OP posts:
butterfliedtwo · 10/01/2023 11:47

MavisMcMinty · 10/01/2023 11:43

Even apart from the guns, can you imagine moving over there and a year later Donald Trump winning the presidency again?!?

Exactly. Yikes.

The fentanyl crisis, too. Terrifying. I don't think I could, regardless of liberal bubble.

MavisMcMinty · 10/01/2023 11:43

Even apart from the guns, can you imagine moving over there and a year later Donald Trump winning the presidency again?!?

Beees · 10/01/2023 11:43

She didnt 'give up' a load of stuff, she made a choice to settle and have children in one country.

This is worth highlighting again as it's so true. She chose to live in the UK and have children who were born and brought up in the UK. She hasn't sacrificed living in the US as that was never her plan.

I think at the end of the day the children should be put first. Moving them may well be a lovely adventure or a complete fucking nightmare that screws up their friendships, educational prospects and possibly their exam results. They won't have any risk of that if they stay where they are so it seems selfish to move them in the hope everything will be fine when it was never on the cards.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 10/01/2023 11:41

Surely with only a slight salary increase hut paying excesses on healthcare and school fees you're going to be worse off financially?

Nogbreaks · 10/01/2023 11:40

'I am sorry if this sounds ignorant but this thread has intrigued me. I know about the school shootings but I often figured that it was sensationalized like 'knife crime in London'. I don't have teens but I would not move children out of London because of knife crime which is in very specific locations and often with a very specific demographic.'

Every American with kids I know ( family and colleagues) are ALL very worried about guns. Not just school shootings - although that terrifies them and they HATE that their children have bulletproof backpacks and are being traumatised by 'shooter drills' - but guns in general.

The fact anyone could have one. Including kids/teens.
Guns are now the #1 killer of children in the USA - 100 children a week are killed because of a firearm. And that's not including those injured.
When their kids go for sleepovers they assess whether there's a gun in that house, and is it likely to be properly locked up? from my experience, no.
DW family is from a hunting state, every one has guns, hardly any of them are kept in gun safes or lockers.

USA schools have their own police because of guns. The guy you argue with at the traffic lights could have a gun. You just don't know.

So I do think it's different, because this gun culture is everywhere - some states more than others, Texas = everyone and their granny has semi-automatic, hands guns, or rifles. Maine - less semis more hunting rifles, some hand guns.

Knife crime in London is still very much contained within areas, gang related... but 100 kids a year aren't dying because of gang crime in the US.

OP posts:
GCAcademic · 10/01/2023 11:39

Just one consideration: if your children want to go to university in the UK, you will need to have been resident here for the previous three years, otherwise you pay international fees and don't have access to student loans.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 10/01/2023 11:37

I wouldnt do it. She didnt 'give up' a load of stuff, she made a choice to settle and have children in one country. I dont think those ages are very easy to move, when you're that age your friends are everything and fitting into a new culture / country and friendship group may not be easy. And if they do fit in and love it then they wont come back so it may be a permanent move.

The benefits dont sound worth the payoff. It's only a slight increase in salary, she is still a 10 hour drive from her parents (how is she going to fit that in with a 50 hour week), surely it isnt much longer to fly to them now. Unless your kids are desperate to try it I wouldn't.

I'm speaking as someone who moved at a similar age for a parents opportunity.

dreamingbohemian · 10/01/2023 11:34

Nogbreaks · 10/01/2023 11:16

'That's quite a nasty thing to say about Baltimore.'

My DSIL is an EMT in Baltimore, her DP is a firefighter there too... And I have been to Baltimore. Sorry if it seems harsh saying we wouldn't think of living there, but it has been hit incredibly hard by the opoid crisis, the police are incredibly corrupt, and their crime rate is one of the worst in the country. Their violent crime stats are very high, and not just the usual gang/crime stuff either.
I can't think of anyone I know in the USA who would relocate to Baltimore with their family.

Well I would, for 200K!
Not to dismiss your family's experiences but first responders always see the worst of any city. Not all of Baltimore is a total hellhole, and it's a great city in so many other ways.
People used to say the same things about DC (when I lived there) but it was entirely possible to live there with no problems and now it's one of the safest and most popular places to live on the East Coast.

Anyway you're probably talking about Boston or DC so it doesn't matter. I'm just thinking that if you're willing to write off an entire city you may not be prepared for city life in the US in general. Even in the safer cities you have to be much more street smart than in the UK.

Shame for your wife though, who can never live in her home country again.

fyn · 10/01/2023 11:32

I went to high school in America on the in the early 2000s, I can’t say that I ever thought much of the shooter drills. We practised hurricane drills too which seemed more likely to happen in a southern state on the East Coast.

We lived in quite an affluent area and whenever a crime happened within a few miles of the school (like a robbery) all of the school doors automatically locked. We had our own school resource officers too. I always felt pretty safe!

Clymene · 10/01/2023 11:32

@TheMagicSword makes a very good point re holiday allowance. If your wife isn't going to be on much more money, she's effectively taking a massive pay cut when you take US vs U.K. holiday allowances into account.

Once you add on the cost of school fees - which will be over $100k a year for two kids in senior school - it seems an absolutely crazy thing to do.

Nuggsmuv · 10/01/2023 11:32

I was uprooted when I was 13 to a country where I didn't speak the language, let alone know the culture, have friends etc... I had to build all that from scratch. I won't say it was easy, but looking back it definitely enriched my life in ways that I am grateful for.. and gave me compassion for people who are not living in their home country (I now work with asylum seekers).

We are also considering moving to the states in the next year or two.. DH is English and I am from the states. We're also concerned about a lot these issues in the states at the moment... but as someone else said, I think statistically the likelihood of shootings is smaller than we think.
Also there are many benefits to living in the states (for us personally, to be closer to my family is a big one), and also other things like more opportunities for big adventures.. Americans are good at the road trips, hiking, mountain biking, rock climbing, surfing, backpacking, camping adventures etc. that we really want our kids to experience.. and which isn't so integrated into life here in England (at least not in the same level of 'wildness' as in the states).
Also I think Americans often get a lot of bad rep, but generally they are very enthusiastic and open people, and I found the kids to be more warm and welcoming than kids in England throughout primary school. I think this can also be very enriching for kids...In the short period I lived in the states as a young teenager, my introvertedness and shyness was seriously challenged, and I became a more open and adventurous person myself... because that is what I experienced around me.

I would miss a certain sense of stability if we left the UK... however, everywhere has it's benefits and downsides... and the USA isn't an exception. There are some great benefits imho.

Muddledbutwellmeaning · 10/01/2023 11:30

Irrelevant but I’d move to Paris at the drop of a hat. I love New York, but the kids education ifs the most important thing, and I think you’d have to move quite far out to get that. As I say, Long Island or somewhere.

Which would mean a crazy commute.

Or a school an exclusive school in Manhattan where values would almost certainly be skewed, shall we say.

Chickenvoicesinmyhead · 10/01/2023 11:30

The job found your DW rather than her seeking it out, and you weren't planning on making a move, so unless her work can be accommodated in both countries I would dismiss it for now.

However, as it's piqued your interest a bit you can always consider it when the kids are older.

Nogbreaks · 10/01/2023 11:30

'Is your wife able to mix her work between here and there? She's already doing long hours.'

She wouldn't want to be separate from the kids. She works long hours but 3 days at home so is around at breakfast, dinner, weekends etc.
Travel a week here and there is one thing but she wont leave the children for extended periods of time, nor would I. She travelled a lot (2-3 weeks in a month) when the children were babies/toddlers and one of her biggest regrets now is missing out on that time with them.

OP posts:
socialmedia23 · 10/01/2023 11:29

I am sorry if this sounds ignorant but this thread has intrigued me. I know about the school shootings but I often figured that it was sensationalized like 'knife crime in London'. I don't have teens but I would not move children out of London because of knife crime which is in very specific locations and often with a very specific demographic.

TheMagicSword · 10/01/2023 11:28

I think you need a really good discussion to bottom out just how important this is to your wife. Has she been pushing towards it, or has it come up because an opportunity happens to have come up. All the factors discussed so far look different if staying in the UK would make her miserable and resentful.

MarshaBradyo · 10/01/2023 11:28

Nogbreaks · 10/01/2023 11:11

The older one wants to go, has romantic notions of the US ( we go 2x a year for holidays/family) the younger one we haven't mentioned anything to yet as it would still be 6 months away if at all.
Both kids make friends at the drop of a hat, and have sports that are transferable to US. In fact, that would be an advantage. Their sports are very well supported in US, more so than here.
Schools - we'd probably use a British School as we are planning on coming back but that would be TBC. But that means any extra money is sued up on fees, and out kids here are in state school. In general we don't believe in a 2-tier school system.

I don't know. We've been able to go this whole time and have never bitten the bullet. I know that crime and drugs have affected so many US family members, directly or indirectly, it's left me feeling I wouldn't want to live there.
However - on a certain salary - quality of life in the US can be amazing.

The reality is DW is American, kids are half American and can really tell her we can't try living in her home country when she's lived in mine, because if me, for 20years??

Is it that much better when you take into account living costs and school fees?

So hard when you want different things. I know we’re too settled here but then it sounds like your DW is very keen

Nogbreaks · 10/01/2023 11:24

'Would you be moving to a state where women have the right to decide what happens to their own bodies?'

Yes, and that's not likely to change. We'd be in our liberal bubble. As a gay family, our safety and rights are #1 factor in where we travel, holiday, live

OP posts:
byvirtue · 10/01/2023 11:23

The US is nice to visit but I wouldn’t want to live there.

What Year Is your 13 year old? Are they starting year 10 in September? I think you’ve really missed the boat if they are.

There is still time to move out there when they are university age which isn’t that far off really.

Swipe left for the next trending thread