Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be worried about school shootings/guns?

166 replies

Nogbreaks · 10/01/2023 10:00

DW, American, has the opportunity to take a great job in a US East coast city. She's keen, having lived her for 20 years, to go for a few years ( maybe more) with the kids. She was approached for this role, wasn't seeking it, nor have we be planning on ever living in the USA, though it has come up from time to time.

Apart from the obvious - we'd be uprooting our 11 and 13 year olds who are very happy, settled in school, I'd have to find a job ( though could get a green card as we're married), we have a fantastic community and network around us which I find particularly helpful as I do the most of the 'wife work' on top of my FT time job as DW is the main earner by a long chalk, we'd be moving to a city where we know no-one at all...

I'm really GENUINELY worried about the safety of our kids going to a school in the US. I don't want them to have shooter drills and all that comes with it. I don't want to take them on what we could dress up as an adventure where we have to worried about the gun culture in the city were in. As an East coast city it does have stricter gun laws, but pretty much anyone can still have a weapon.

Is that a daft reason to refuse to go? My career and aspirations there are 2nd as I could maybe maybe transfer with my current company, and I'm acutely aware of all DW has given up to live in the UK all this time with me.

OP posts:
dreamingbohemian · 10/01/2023 13:29

Nogbreaks · 10/01/2023 12:46

I'm just going to add that I really, really like the States! I think it's an amazing, fascinating country and I have travelled extensively, like to 40 States over the years and made some great friends and had wonderful experiences.

I'm just not sure I want to raise kids there, even for a few years.

I know the US can seem nuts, but it's as if we took the whole of Europe made it one country and then started comparing one area to another.

Thank you for saying that : )

I guess I would just look at it like this, right now there are Americans wondering if they should take up a new job in the UK (I see this on other expat sites I'm on) and people are like, are you crazy, the UK is falling apart, nothing works, you'll die before you get medical treatment, knife crime, county lines, corrupt and incompetent government, etc etc

Yet this is the country you live in and presumably manage very well in, are happy in, can raise your children in. For you at least, the reality is different from the perceptions.

I think the main concerns about going (once you know you are going somewhere LGBT-friendly) would be your children's education and healthcare, but if you can send them to a British school and have excellent health insurance, that is a huge relief.

GeekyThings · 10/01/2023 13:08

I'm originally from the USA and I've lived in the UK for a while now. I wouldn't want to move back, in part because of the gun laws, but actually more because of the healthcare (having coverage now, while you're young and healthy, isn't the same as when they inevitably cut you off when you're old and decrepit and actually need it, never mind the crappy coverage for dependants); and equally because my kids are old enough but young enough that the interruption to their lives would be greater than as babies or adults.

I think you should probably be worrying less about the guns and more about the impact on your kids of moving country. I can tell you from firsthand experience it's harder to move country when you're in school than when you're an adult, I've done it both times. And for some reason people seem to think that because the language is pretty much the same that must mean that things are more similar culturally than they actually are. I think if they're used to things in the UK then they will struggle moving there.

Nogbreaks · 10/01/2023 12:57

@BrownDaisy it is awful, and it leaves many, many people feeling unsafe there.
A 6 year old has just taken his mum’s gun into school and shot his teacher.
in what world should a 6 year old be able
to get a gun?

OP posts:
BrownDaisy · 10/01/2023 12:47

@Nogbreaks
"Guns are now the #1 killer of children in the USA - 100 children a week are killed because of a firearm. And that's not including those injured."

That's a shocking statistic.

16 children were killed in Dunblane and this country completely changed it's gun laws.
A Dunblane massacre happens every day of every week of every year in the US and nothing happens.

Nogbreaks · 10/01/2023 12:47

@AnxiousPancreas Did you or your kids attend?

OP posts:
Nogbreaks · 10/01/2023 12:46

I'm just going to add that I really, really like the States! I think it's an amazing, fascinating country and I have travelled extensively, like to 40 States over the years and made some great friends and had wonderful experiences.

I'm just not sure I want to raise kids there, even for a few years.

I know the US can seem nuts, but it's as if we took the whole of Europe made it one country and then started comparing one area to another.

OP posts:
AnxiousPancreas · 10/01/2023 12:39

Nogbreaks · 10/01/2023 12:37

'Boston and kids will go to British School of Boston?'

It could be, and they could do. Living location is fairly flexible.

If it is this then, yes, definitely do it. I take back my last post!

Nogbreaks · 10/01/2023 12:37

'Boston and kids will go to British School of Boston?'

It could be, and they could do. Living location is fairly flexible.

OP posts:
2021s · 10/01/2023 12:33

I would go. Life is short

dreamingbohemian · 10/01/2023 12:33

MindatWork · 10/01/2023 12:16

@dreamingbohemian you seem to be taking this thread quite personally. I don't think anyone is'turning their nose up' at the opportunity, just discussing their opinions, personal experience and what they would consider to be deciding factors in a major move abroad.

Not taking it personally as such, it just does get very tiresome seeing thread after thread where people talk about how horrible the US is, often based on massive assumptions and generalisations.

If you are living in a Boston suburb, you really don't have to worry that much about crime, you can assume most households do not have guns, the schools are excellent, etc.

That's why I do wish people would be specific on relocation threads so you don't get people going on about gun culture in Texas or meth heads in Ohio or whatever. It's a huge and diverse country.

youdialwetile · 10/01/2023 12:22

Is it Boston and kids will go to British School of Boston? I would recommend that 100%

Nogbreaks · 10/01/2023 12:20

'If it is a 10/12 hour drive from the state you are thinking about to her parents isn't it quicker from UK to fly to them?'

No, it's a long flight followed by a long drive ( takes best part of 24 hrs to get there with immigration, car pick up etc. and is exhausting) but more importantly VERY expensive for the 4 of us, ranges from £5k - £10k depending on time of year with car hire. Plus going for less than 10 days isn't worth it etc.

Petrol for that kind of drive in the US is far cheaper, plus the option of cheap internal flights that would get us there in no time. Or meeting half way. Or taking vacation trips together in the US.

We would definitely see them more, and other family & friends too in the US.

OP posts:
BigFatLiar · 10/01/2023 12:20

One of the other things that puts me off the States is the really poor employment rights.

MindatWork · 10/01/2023 12:16

dreamingbohemian · 10/01/2023 12:09

Yes this is what is so interesting

This is a chance to live in one of the nicest cities in the US, with lots of money, kids in international school, excellent healthcare, already speak the language, you can always leave if you don't like it.... I mean, it's a better life than probably 95% of Americans or British people, but still something to turn your nose up at apparently.

They would probably end up in some tony east coast suburb yet people think they'll be surrounded by guns and gangbangers and meth heads.

@dreamingbohemian you seem to be taking this thread quite personally. I don't think anyone is'turning their nose up' at the opportunity, just discussing their opinions, personal experience and what they would consider to be deciding factors in a major move abroad.

vvvvb · 10/01/2023 12:14

Also a 12 and 14 year old (next year) are awkward ages to change lives completely

How happy would you be if one or both said they wanted to stay over there when you want to come back to UK?

Would you stay there too or come back?

Would you rent out your home so you know you have a base to come back to or sell it then buy another home again when you return?

After putting your stuff in storage for 2 years or however long you are away for?

Or would you sell it all or give it away or take everything with you by shipping it over?

midsomermurderess · 10/01/2023 12:11

PoolBreachWatch · 10/01/2023 10:09

Can you confirm what “wife work” is?

You ibis full well. It’s used all over here. This sort of disingenuousness is tiresome.

UnknownElement · 10/01/2023 12:10

I was given the chance to move to America in my early twenties as my brothers had emigrated and were happy to sponsor me or whatever it’s called. One lives in the suburbs of Chicago, a very nice suburb. This was 30 years ago. When I was visiting him there was a news report on how many children had been killed in the previous year by guns, the stat was no where near as high as now but was still shocking and that was one of the main reason I decided not to go. My brother was going to even get me a decent job, he was really high up in a global company.

There was a shooting at the Highland Park 4 July parade last year it is a really nice suburb. I have shopped and been out to lunch in that place a few times over the years as my brother lives not so far from it. He was not involved as had gone to Boston with his wife to see his DD. I remember feeling really sick until I managed to get hold of him. I knew the whole family were together for July 4 but was unsure who was travelling to see who.

It would be a hard no form me, plus moving children at that age is tough on them. But your wife is actually American so I can see why she just isn’t in the same headspace as you.

dreamingbohemian · 10/01/2023 12:09

NashvilleQueen · 10/01/2023 12:02

This thread is a great illustration in the way that we make assumptions about people (and not just 'wife work')!

Personally I would be on the next plane notwithstanding the real concerns outlined here. Guns and opioids are not fanciful worries and they would play on my mind. But I would also see it as a great opportunity to live overseas near(ish) to the greatest city in the world and to experience a whole new way of life. It's the most 'secure' way you could do it given the excellent support package your wife will have and if you hate it you can always all return.

Could you children attend an international school?

Yes this is what is so interesting

This is a chance to live in one of the nicest cities in the US, with lots of money, kids in international school, excellent healthcare, already speak the language, you can always leave if you don't like it.... I mean, it's a better life than probably 95% of Americans or British people, but still something to turn your nose up at apparently.

They would probably end up in some tony east coast suburb yet people think they'll be surrounded by guns and gangbangers and meth heads.

vvvvb · 10/01/2023 12:08

If it is a 10/12 hour drive from the state you are thinking about to her parents isn't it quicker from UK to fly to them?
I would worry about gun crime in USA with teenagers going to school but also socially just going into the city alone or with their friends, just out and about iyswim

RandomMess · 10/01/2023 12:05

How old are your parents, if you end up staying in the US because you don't want to uproot you DC again then they don't want to move back - what about them aging and you not being in the UK?

TBH the more you have said about guns in homes, on the street, deaths per week the more I'd not want to go.

UsuallySuze · 10/01/2023 12:03

School shootings would not be a factor for me in this decision. Although the number of shootings is horrifying, statistically the risk is still extremely small.

I think you need to think through how permanent a move you expect this to be and the knock-on effects on your children (esp re eg university applications). But I'd do it, in your shoes. Sounds like a great opportunity for your wife and an adventure for you all.

NashvilleQueen · 10/01/2023 12:02

This thread is a great illustration in the way that we make assumptions about people (and not just 'wife work')!

Personally I would be on the next plane notwithstanding the real concerns outlined here. Guns and opioids are not fanciful worries and they would play on my mind. But I would also see it as a great opportunity to live overseas near(ish) to the greatest city in the world and to experience a whole new way of life. It's the most 'secure' way you could do it given the excellent support package your wife will have and if you hate it you can always all return.

Could you children attend an international school?

Beees · 10/01/2023 11:56

Actually, living in the UK was never her plan. She was happy in the USA until we met and I couldn't move to the US at the time, as our same sex partnership wasn't recognised so she moved here instead so we could live together.

Fair enough but the point still stands that she made that choice. You can't make a choice that important and then get annoyed that the other people affected by the choice don't agree years later if you change your mind.

It sounds like a good opportunity but she doesn't sound like she's putting the children first or considering key things like how important a support network is it all feels likes she's looking at the opportunity with some very rose tinted glasses.

SleeplessInEngland · 10/01/2023 11:54

To be honest there's no point in asking MN for advice on this. It's something very few have had to seriously consider and they don't know your kids like you do. I would have a family discussion weighing up the pros and cons. You've already said your eldest seems up for it.

MarshaBradyo · 10/01/2023 11:53

Op is this thread changing your mind either way? What do you think you’ll do

Swipe left for the next trending thread