Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be worried about school shootings/guns?

166 replies

Nogbreaks · 10/01/2023 10:00

DW, American, has the opportunity to take a great job in a US East coast city. She's keen, having lived her for 20 years, to go for a few years ( maybe more) with the kids. She was approached for this role, wasn't seeking it, nor have we be planning on ever living in the USA, though it has come up from time to time.

Apart from the obvious - we'd be uprooting our 11 and 13 year olds who are very happy, settled in school, I'd have to find a job ( though could get a green card as we're married), we have a fantastic community and network around us which I find particularly helpful as I do the most of the 'wife work' on top of my FT time job as DW is the main earner by a long chalk, we'd be moving to a city where we know no-one at all...

I'm really GENUINELY worried about the safety of our kids going to a school in the US. I don't want them to have shooter drills and all that comes with it. I don't want to take them on what we could dress up as an adventure where we have to worried about the gun culture in the city were in. As an East coast city it does have stricter gun laws, but pretty much anyone can still have a weapon.

Is that a daft reason to refuse to go? My career and aspirations there are 2nd as I could maybe maybe transfer with my current company, and I'm acutely aware of all DW has given up to live in the UK all this time with me.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Aloezebra · 18/01/2023 17:45

From what I can see, (quick google) around 70 people are killed by sharks worldwide annually.

An average of 40,000 people in the US are killed by guns annually. Just over half are suicides so around 20,000 are murdered via firearm annually.

It is a very real concern

Herroyal · 18/01/2023 17:17

'it's a bit like saying you don't want to move to Australia because you might get eaten by a Great White Shark.
Or a crocodile or bitten by a poisonous spider or snake. That's Australia for you.😄'

Is it though - given the level of violent crime, gun crime and that guns are now the no1 killer of children in the USA? Not sure the two are comparable.
Every American I know is concerned about guns and gun crime - and that includes the ones who support the right to own them

BigFatLiar · 18/01/2023 16:30

it's a bit like saying you don't want to move to Australia because you might get eaten by a Great White Shark.

Or a crocodile or bitten by a poisonous spider or snake. That's Australia for you.😄

Nogbreaks · 17/01/2023 12:51

‘It could be the opportunity of a lifetime and a great time etc but it could also be profoundly difficult and knock them off kilter at a really important time and you may not have much control over that.’

thats what I’m worried about, although another discussion with DW ended with her calling me a coward for not being more positive towards the idea…
Out of the children, the oldest would love to go and the youngest doesn’t.

OP posts:
Thepeopleversuswork · 17/01/2023 12:39

I'm normally a big advocate for feeling the fear and taking the harder path etc... but having moved to the US ten years ago and moved back just over two years later I would approach with some caution.

Not because I wouldn't want to move to the US but because disrupting your kids at that critical time in their education and formation of social bonds is a real gamble. It could be the opportunity of a lifetime and a great time etc but it could also be profoundly difficult and knock them off kilter at a really important time and you may not have much control over that.

As much as I love America as well it's a pretty unforgiving place to move to in many ways, very sink or swim. Your DW will be fine but I wouldn't underestimate how hard it could be for you.

The school shootings thing wouldn't come into it for me. It's obviously horrific and far more common than it should be but statistically speaking it's a bit like saying you don't want to move to Australia because you might get eaten by a Great White Shark.

Nogbreaks · 17/01/2023 12:30

I'd be more concerned about checking the legal situation with custody if you split.
Afaik you wouldn't be able to take the DCs from USA without ex's permission.
Without your own citizenship there you have to go back to the UK alone wouldn't you?

No – because neither child has US citizenship or US passports. Born outside of the USA you have to apply for this, and we haven’t.

There’s no intention of doing so either at the moment.
Plus, we are solid as a family and a couple, and this move would be temporary, not permanent. Which is why I would ask my company ( who are actually a US HQ company) to move me rather than go down a green card route.

OP posts:
pinkhousesarebest · 15/01/2023 11:10

I have just sent my ds off to the US to uni. The positives outweigh the negatives, and the tiny possibility that there may be a shooting. I would go. I teach in a school where dc parachute in for a few years ( or less) and then move continent/ language system. Their skills build all the time and are infinitely transférable.

AuxArmesCitoyens · 15/01/2023 10:55

FWIW we don't have a record of school shootings in France but we do have active shooter / threat drills in all schools twice a year. I know some UK schools do them and I wouldn't be at all surprised if they became mandatory.

Aphrathestorm · 15/01/2023 10:48

I'd be more concerned about checking the legal situation with custody if you split.

Afaik you wouldn't be able to take the DCs from USA without ex's permission.

Without your own citizenship there you have to go back to the UK alone wouldn't you?

That's such a precarious position to be in.

Aphrathestorm · 15/01/2023 10:25

It’s a term from Delusions of Gender by Cordelia Fine (not sure if she coined it or just popularised it) that refers to the work done in a domestic setting that is traditionally done by the “wife” in a traditional, heterosexual marriage

No it's originally from this book, called wife work by Susan Maushart written in 2003. It predates DOG by 7 years.

https://www.amazon.co.uk/Wifework-Susan-Maushart/dp/0747561729

SpangledShambles · 15/01/2023 10:05

The move sounds great for your dw. But it would mess up your dc. I think anyone with thought for their kids would realise that slicing through the lives of kids this age with a giant culture change is going to have big ramifications. I speak from a nearly identical experience as a kid. The gun culture thing is not the big concern here.

purpledalmation · 15/01/2023 09:49

I think I'd let the children have a one third choice in this. At those ages they will effectively be teens growing up in the US and likely to form their own relationships they may not want to leave to return here. So returning may never happen unless you leave your young adult DCs there.

BigFatLiar · 15/01/2023 09:16

Just don't be a teacher, I see in Virginia a six year old took their mothers gun to school and shot the teacher.

Little kids getting hold of mum or dad's gun and shooting themselves or someone else seems yo be a common theme.

Nogbreaks · 14/01/2023 15:20

@Tescoland its all of it - guns in schools, guns in society, the violent crime rate is huge compared to U.K.

OP posts:
Tescoland · 12/01/2023 13:58

Everybody is mentioning school shootings. That’s the least of the problems over there. The big problem is general gun-ownership and the blasé attitude about owning guns. Everybody can be in possession of a gun and millions and millions of Americans are, a lot of whom are drug-takers and loco too. That would worry me more than school shootings.

Nogbreaks · 11/01/2023 13:40

'How often are you planning to make the 24 hour round trip to the in-laws?!)'

That's driving! Flying would be like flying from London to Paris.
I guess, on school breaks, Easter, Summer hols, Halloween, long weekends, Thanks Giving or Xmas... the usual.
Plus they are hail and hearty so more than capable of driving to us, or to somewhere halfway. Or we can holiday together near DSILs where it's hot and sunny all the time.
We also have other family, aunts, uncles, cousins there who DW would love to spend more time with than once a year at Easter or Xmas.

OP posts:
Nogbreaks · 11/01/2023 13:36

'The only benefit of moving seems to be the money'

We spend it on schooling, travel etc I reckon. We don't need/want more money.

The benefit, as DW sees it, is amazing, exciting role that would impress anyone, so therefore I suppose a good thing for future work down the line and being back in the USA for a while.

OP posts:
JulieMarooley · 11/01/2023 10:50

The only benefit of moving seems to be the money, but it sounds like you don’t need it. Especially as you have not been paying for private school to this point, you must be very comfortable on £250k and have loads of savings.

Therefore I’m not seeing any pull factors that would make it worth the risk and upset of uprooting everyone and disrupting the kids’ education. And yes school shootings would worry me too (although probably if you look at the stats it’s not warranted).

(How often are you planning to make the 24 hour round trip to the in-laws?!)

Nogbreaks · 11/01/2023 10:15

. also, can I just say, would anyone like to say what they’re saying about Baltimore to Anne Fine’s face?😂 She has has a lot of warmth for Baltimore and it transmits .. on paper! X'

I'm sure she's aware that the violent crime rate is 2 x 3x that of the average in a country that already has fairly high crime rates... I wouldn't move to Detroit either. There, I said it!
But we're also avoiding much of the South because we're a LGBTQ+ family ( and yes I have been there a LOT as DW is from the South) and I know that you have places like Austin in Texas, where it's pretty liberal, but then you have the rest of Texas... or Ashville in NC, but then there's the rest of NC...

OP posts:
Nogbreaks · 11/01/2023 10:07

Private school would be our last choice, and only considered for continuity of UK education as the plan would be to come back here in 2/3 years.
We're both WC backgrounds and our kids are currently in bog std UK state schools

OP posts:
MarshaBradyo · 11/01/2023 09:40

Nogbreaks · 11/01/2023 09:30

'Money information going up from $200k to $500k for her obviously changes things.'

I know this sounds stupid, but it's not the money. We are comfortably off here in the UK with both our jobs ( earn about £250k between us) and I know too many people earning that kind of money who really aren't particularly happy. A job paying you that much ( although half of the amount is bonus so not guaranteed) controls you, own you almost in my experience.

There is the option for this role to be Europe based, with the same salary deal.

This may be true but on $200 I don’t think private school would be doable

Nogbreaks · 11/01/2023 09:30

'Money information going up from $200k to $500k for her obviously changes things.'

I know this sounds stupid, but it's not the money. We are comfortably off here in the UK with both our jobs ( earn about £250k between us) and I know too many people earning that kind of money who really aren't particularly happy. A job paying you that much ( although half of the amount is bonus so not guaranteed) controls you, own you almost in my experience.

There is the option for this role to be Europe based, with the same salary deal.

OP posts:
Dotjones · 11/01/2023 09:03

School shootings are actually quite rare in America. A quick search suggests there were about 300 incidents last year but only 51 that resulted in injuries or deaths. So basically one a week that actually causes physical harm (I know, that doesn't take holidays into account). Given there are over 115,000 schools in the US that's a tiny percentage, about 0.04% of schools have an incident where someone gets injured or killed.

saraclara · 11/01/2023 08:43

I think your children are the wrong age for this, to be honest. The 13 year old especially.
I suppose a British School would help with regard to them following a UK curriculum and taking exams that are compatible. But then if they decided to stay in the US, would that be a disadvantage to them?

Just one consideration: if your children want to go to university in the UK, you will need to have been resident here for the previous three years, otherwise you pay international fees and don't have access to student loans.
Also a good point.

Do you think that your wife and kids would want to stay in the US permanently after this? How would you feel about that?

Tescoland · 11/01/2023 08:23

MarshaBradyo · 11/01/2023 08:17

Money information going up from $200k to $500k for her obviously changes things.

For £500k a year I would move to Siberia even! 😄