Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

We ride at dawn - for the NHS

142 replies

GloGirl · 10/01/2023 09:40

Seriously, are we the public going to do anything about this? Can we coordinate a mass protest/march? Mini protests outside hospitals? Has everyone been writing to their MP?

I can't read these headlines any more, it's breaking my heart. I was sure during covid it would force the govt to reconsider its treatment of the NHS - that it would force a change in priority for social care, pay, structures, staffing.

How did we hit a new low, and just keep going? Who is with me??

OP posts:
Spiralleddown · 10/01/2023 12:58

NowDoYouBelieveMe · 10/01/2023 12:20

That is NOT going to save the health service.

Do you think all that dieting is going to save someone in a car accident? Or the other million reasons why we need a functioning a and e?

Individualising the problem is not the answer.

How come people in literal dictatorships still go out and protest and topple governments, and we in this relatively liberal land have just given up?

If people put the effort into self care it would save the service for those who need it and can't self care.

High blood pressure leads to heart attacks, stroke, kidney disease... All can be prevented if you maintained a healthy diet and lifestyle. But no. People would far rather pop a pill because it's easier than recognising they need to overhaul their lives.

So much money could be saved in the NHS if people took a preventative approach to their wellbeing

Rosamunde · 10/01/2023 12:50

@Chippy1234 but the cost of pivoting to a system like France would be astronomical. Waste and pointless meetings are a feature of every business and health service: objectively the nhs is efficient compared to other systems.

Chippy1234 · 10/01/2023 12:46

Look at a new system including France etc. There is a reason we are the only country with it being 100% free to all regardless of what you have paid. I worked with the NHS for years as a supplier and the waste and mismanagement will make you cry. Cottage industries set up to present figures/charts etc, numerous people attending meetings about very little and then showing off to each other as to what their views were. No decisions ever made bar setting up another meeting.

You do know that 30% of taxes are paid by 1% of tax payers. What will be enought 40%, 50%?

The data you are quoting looks old as well. The NHS got a wedge of funding in the last year. What has been done with it??

Get people to look after their own health as well. Dont call ambulances for trival things (there is still a rumour that if you are brought in by a crew you will be seen much quicker). People on Facebook often mention this....

MichaelFabricantWig · 10/01/2023 12:35

MajorCarolDanvers · 10/01/2023 12:32

No point where I live.

Nicola Sturgeon isn't doing anything either.

Not just the Tories. SNP just as bad.

And she had the cheek to advise us to wear masks yesterday. Honest to God. I am doing no more to try and sort out the mess they made. Yes the NHS is a mess and it’s awful but it ain’t my doing or responsibility

Vinvertebrate · 10/01/2023 12:33

And don’t forget Labour in Wales @MajorCarolDanvers - a shitshow even worse than England. (I live on the border).

MajorCarolDanvers · 10/01/2023 12:32

No point where I live.

Nicola Sturgeon isn't doing anything either.

Not just the Tories. SNP just as bad.

MichaelFabricantWig · 10/01/2023 12:30

The NHS is a bottomless pit of money - more money won’t solve the issues. Ultimately we have what we (collective we - I certainly didn’t) voted for - Brexit and a Tory government. No, I’m not willing to pay more tax to shore up a health service which is in the state it’s in due to the public voting for the decisions which have led to that in the first place.

people during Brexit kept telling us “they knew what they voted for”. Well this was it. I just hope they don’t have the cheek to moan.

roarfeckingroarr · 10/01/2023 12:25

Vinvertebrate · 10/01/2023 10:36

The NHS got £219 billion in 2021. It might be a lot of things, but underfunded it isn’t. Badly run, maybe.

I don’t mind paying more for European-style healthcare, but I’m fucked if I’m willingly paying any more for this shitshow.

Agree with this

Cuppasoupmonster · 10/01/2023 12:24

MaryMcCarthy · 10/01/2023 12:23

Well Germany spends $6500 per patient per annum. The USA spends $10,900

France spend $5200, Ireland spend $5000.

The NHS spends $4200.

Enough to match some of those systems would be a start. We're lagging behind.

We are not as wealthy as Germany or USA though are we?

MaryMcCarthy · 10/01/2023 12:23

Moonmelodies · 10/01/2023 10:31

How much £, s, and d do you want thrown at the NHS ?

Well Germany spends $6500 per patient per annum. The USA spends $10,900

France spend $5200, Ireland spend $5000.

The NHS spends $4200.

Enough to match some of those systems would be a start. We're lagging behind.

midsomermurderess · 10/01/2023 12:20

We ride at dawn? Or at 8.30 for 9, ish

NowDoYouBelieveMe · 10/01/2023 12:20

Cuppasoupmonster · 10/01/2023 09:42

You could definitely organise a local one if you wanted to. But the Tories couldn’t give two fucks about protests, aren’t they passing laws to restrict striking action etc?

The best thing we can do as a public is take control of our own health issues where possible. Lose weight, stop smoking and drinking, eat healthily, try the pharmacy for minor issues before making GP appointments, try self care for any MH related issues etc. But nobody wants to hear that.

That is NOT going to save the health service.

Do you think all that dieting is going to save someone in a car accident? Or the other million reasons why we need a functioning a and e?

Individualising the problem is not the answer.

How come people in literal dictatorships still go out and protest and topple governments, and we in this relatively liberal land have just given up?

SafeMove · 10/01/2023 12:20

@Mummyford you are right. I research 'upstream' health interventions at a population level. Intervene early (and our studies are really early in the lifecourse, age 0-5) before the acute health episode is even on the horizon and it has been proven extensively that you save public money instead of firefighting with costly interventions. This applies to both physical and mental health.

If you have a population that is healthier for longer they contribute more to the social system - economically (you buy more things when you are healthy and alive and you tend to be able to work for longer the healthier you are) and in terms of social structures (healthier, living extended families provide care for longer is just one example). Austerity will have the biggest health impact in the next 50 years - if you reduce people's access to money they become less healthy. So they might be alive longer (due to advances in acute medicine) but if that body isn't healthy but is alive, it costs the social structure a lot. Poverty is a huge indicator of how long your healthy life is - but it is politically very unpopular to put in interventions that address poverty unfortunately. Collectively we don't want to give money to people we see as the undeserving poor. So firefighting it is.

xyhere · 10/01/2023 12:18

GloGirl · 10/01/2023 11:20

"Demanding a simple solution (like "better funding!") to a complex systemic problem is exactly why we're in this mess - we, the British public, allowed all of the political discussion of the NHS to be reduced to soundbites and slogans, when any sustainable solution must be far more nuanced and far-reaching than that."

I've clearly outlined that I want to support the NHS as a lay person. I don't have the answers.

I'm not a mechanic but when I drive past a car on the road and see it mangled and on fire, I can tell it's fucking broken.

I am NOT saying hard cash is the only solution. If I threw £10,000 at the burning car it wouldn't turn off it's flames and drive itself home. The only people wanging on about how "funding" wont resolve the NHS crisis are those trying to pretend that money wont help. I have said better funding. As per my first post, priority for social care, pay, structures, staffing. But I am not convinced by those who parrot that giving the NHS more money would be wasteful.

I wasn't necessarily disagreeing with you, I was just pointing out that more money isn't a sustainable solution when every other part of the system that the NHS relies on - from education to social care - is also woefully underperforming.

In fairness, I only quoted your post because you referred to funding; I was really talking about the fact that all political discussion is based on doing things to the NHS (whether it be reform, money or anything else) where the sustainable solution has to encompass everything else the NHS touches or relies upon too.

anonymousMuse · 10/01/2023 12:16

I would happily protest with you OP. I'm seriously considering starting a blog too. Publicity about what it's really like in the NHS at the moment, my own ideas to tackle the issues (not just more money, we're past that now), I have rejoined my local Labour Party (I don't want to hear it; I've been around long enough to know that Labour are not innocent in the current state but at least my Labour rep listens, as does the party leader. My Tory MP, on the other hand....). It's not just about making people accountable for their own decisions, it's about redesigning an entire system from the chaos that is currently both health and social care.

newcovidisolations · 10/01/2023 12:11

Just to make it clear when we are being told the hospitals are full of people who are medically fit for discharge that includes those who are paralyzed from a stroke as they were delayed arriving at a&e due to no ambulances. Medically fit does not mean able to care for themselves it could mean dying or needing full time life long care and there are very few nursing homes, rehab places left or even district nurses.

sittingonabranch · 10/01/2023 12:02

I would love to help do something about the crisis @GloGirl . I just don't know what that something is!

I am getting sick of the narrative on here though about people having to 'manage their own health', from the fat shamers, the people who disagree with antidepressants etc. God forbid these people are ever met with an illness that either causes obesity or for their MH to take a massive downturn. I wonder if they would appreciate the 'just eat a salad and get some fresh air' POV then!!

The situation with the NHS is scary, really scary, but the media love a shitstorm (look at covid) and will print heart wrenching headlines to cause mass panic. I am not downplaying the situation we are in, at all, I have read first hand accounts from Dr's and my best friend is a paramedic so I know it's dire.

I just wish there was something that we, the general public, could do that would actually make a difference. Feeling so powerless is soul destroying.

Mummyford · 10/01/2023 11:59

SafeMove · 10/01/2023 11:47

Interestingly I am about to start an apprenticeship within my NHS research role that is going to redesign some parts of the healthcare system - I am doing a PGDip in Systems Thinking in Practice (Professional) award. I have been recruited to redesign from within. A scorched earth approach is not always necessary as there are parts of the NHS that work well (particularly population level public health interventions) and implementing what works well and getting the uptake and spread right in the system is a step to improvement,

@SafeMove

That's really interesting. I participated very peripherally in the vaccine rollout (I work in the voluntary sector) and was beyond impressed by the organisation and goodwill and collective ability of an already-stretched health service. I can see that part functions incredibly well.

I often think part of the problem is a lack of wellness/preventive care service. Surely it costs much more to treat someone once they've already developed an illness or a long-term disability or condition? I disagree with the PPs who say people should use the system less--I actually think it should be set up so it's used more (and is more responsive) to head off preventable/treatable conditions. Surely if that functioned better the hospitals and A&Es would be freed up (although not discounting the bed-blocking, social care issues)?

I really notice in my work how the lack of front end care impacts people without resources. I'm often shocked when I see their age as they look so much older.

GloGirl · 10/01/2023 11:57

we just keep throwing money at it, never reforming it
anyone who even vaguely criticises the sacred cow is consider a Tory shill
this is all just ridiculous

And anyone who says it needs more money is just "throwing money at it, never reforming it".
Is reformation free?

Let's compromise - those on the left will stop accusing you of being Tory Shills for criticising the NHS. Will you stop saying we're wasteful by believing the NHS needs more cash?

OP posts:
iRun2eatCake · 10/01/2023 11:53

I work in Theatres. We have had 3 patients in the last week who nearly didn't make it.... and still are critically ill ..... because of A&E being rammed, no beds for them to go too... and no Theatre available to operate.

It is truly frightening currently

JusteanBiscuits · 10/01/2023 11:50

SafeMove · 10/01/2023 11:47

Interestingly I am about to start an apprenticeship within my NHS research role that is going to redesign some parts of the healthcare system - I am doing a PGDip in Systems Thinking in Practice (Professional) award. I have been recruited to redesign from within. A scorched earth approach is not always necessary as there are parts of the NHS that work well (particularly population level public health interventions) and implementing what works well and getting the uptake and spread right in the system is a step to improvement,

That is really cool! And you're right, it doesn't need wiping out and starting again.

One thing that always bugs me is the amount of time and resources that go into bidding for a service - especially against private firms - only for the process to start again. The NHS isn't a business, and that model really needs to stop.

Alaldlccmemsjzja · 10/01/2023 11:49

where does it all end though?

we just keep throwing money at it, never reforming it
anyone who even vaguely criticises the sacred cow is consider a Tory shill
this is all just ridiculous

as a precious poster said, the best thing we can do (imo) is try to limit our own need to use it. Lose weight, healthier choices, not calling 111 because you’ve stubbed your toe and exaggerate

SafeMove · 10/01/2023 11:47

Rosamunde · 10/01/2023 11:35

Imagine the cost of redesigning the nhs - the consultants, the redundancies, the procurement, the mistakes, the profits private companies need - and the level of service you would get while the redesign was being implemented.

Interestingly I am about to start an apprenticeship within my NHS research role that is going to redesign some parts of the healthcare system - I am doing a PGDip in Systems Thinking in Practice (Professional) award. I have been recruited to redesign from within. A scorched earth approach is not always necessary as there are parts of the NHS that work well (particularly population level public health interventions) and implementing what works well and getting the uptake and spread right in the system is a step to improvement,

Rosamunde · 10/01/2023 11:35

Imagine the cost of redesigning the nhs - the consultants, the redundancies, the procurement, the mistakes, the profits private companies need - and the level of service you would get while the redesign was being implemented.

GloGirl · 10/01/2023 11:33

JusteanBiscuits · 10/01/2023 11:30

Social care needs fixing before we move onto the NHS. When a sink is blocked, you have to unblock the pipe before you can clear the water and then clean the sink. Modern convalescent facilities for those that aren't quite able to live independently, but don't need high level hospital care is one small start

Completely agree

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread