Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be sick of cashless society

612 replies

Ihatepcos · 10/01/2023 09:31

I prefer to use cash, I always have.

I find budgeting and spending so much easier. If I am tapping away on my card I think nothing of constant £3 £6 etc being spent on things I probably wouldn't buy if I was spending cash.

More and more places simply don't take cash and it's driving me mad.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
SirMingeALot · 11/01/2023 13:30

Badbadbunny · 11/01/2023 12:50

Not sure why you think a business owner should have to count cash in front of the TV just because you want to pay in cash, when you could easily pay by card and save her the trouble!

As for their quiet times, perhaps it would be more beneficial for the business owner to spend the time researching cost saving options, or marketing, or negotiating with suppliers, etc., i.e. things that would improve the business rather than spending that time on a wasteful and pointless task like counting money!

Yeah, people really can't decide someone's labour has no value because the work they're doing happens to be for their own business!

Florawest · 11/01/2023 13:26

I prefer cash too, defo makes me think more about spending where as tap can be without much thought.

Also it’s nice to be able to give a few euro ( Eire) to children and any charity collection, restaurant tips etc.

Cash is my favourite. €€££$$

Badbadbunny · 11/01/2023 13:16

BradfordGirl · 11/01/2023 13:09

And that is a major issue. Although you can deposit cash at a Post Office.

Post offices are closing down now too. Often being replaced by "counters" in shops, pharmacies, etc that only deal with postal items and don't handle banking services due to there being no security screens, safes, etc. Our village "post office" is a small counter in the corner of the chemists - all you can do there is buy stamps and hand over parcels/letters for postage - nothing else at all. The next village along is the same, post office "counter" in their convenience store. Nearest "proper" post office where you can do banking is several miles away in the same town where there's a bank branch!

BradfordGirl · 11/01/2023 13:10

Any business I have ever worked for is on a High Street, so there is always somewhere close by to deposit cash. We also used cash without banking it. The cleaner was paid in cash - and yes through the books.

BradfordGirl · 11/01/2023 13:09

countrygirl99 · 11/01/2023 13:07

And how many businesses are within walking distance of a bank? Where I live they are all at least an 8 mile drive.

And that is a major issue. Although you can deposit cash at a Post Office.

AtLastShrugs · 11/01/2023 13:07

Marmunia10661975 · 10/01/2023 13:25

I try to use cash where possible. I do think the government is pushing a cashless society. I have clients in China whose lives are controlled on their mobile phones. If you buy beer for example on a Friday via your card which is stored on the WeChat app, you will not be able to buy more on a Saturday. The QR code turns red. Similarly, on the social credit system if your score drops below a certain point you are not able to take public transport etc....

Also this kind of comment is... a lie? Or at least a misunderstanding. I mean, I wouldn't pay for anything illegal with Wechat pay (e.g. after-school tutoring is now being stopped so people often pay tutors in cash) but alcohol, sex toys, whatever normal but "naughty" items you can buy from shops/online does not affect your "social credit".

countrygirl99 · 11/01/2023 13:07

BradfordGirl · 11/01/2023 12:46

@Tomikka In a small business they are no big deal. Our insurance policy covered the small amounts we were handling anyway. The bank was very close and the owner popped there in a break. And staff sorted money and the owner did a lot of books and admin during quiet times. Every business has quiet times.
You also need to do checks for staff with cards. Fraud such as skimming cards for example. Any handling of monies in whatever format needs robust safeguards.

Bigger shops have more costs from cash handling than small shops because small shops can do so much informally. Even when the owner had to take cash home to sort out, I know she did it in front of the TV. She wasn't paying someone to do it.

And how many businesses are within walking distance of a bank? Where I live they are all at least an 8 mile drive.

AtLastShrugs · 11/01/2023 12:59

I live in China and, with the exception of a red packet as a wedding gift for a friend, I haven't seen physical cash in about 3 years. I think most businesses legally have to accept it (and also presumably cards) but literally everyone exclusively uses 2 major payment apps. I like it: it's cleaner, fast, very convenient, and I don't need to carry a wallet. I can see how it might be difficult for elderly people or others who can't use phones, but those people would always have someone with them/taking care of them who can do the paying.
Cash should be an option but I don't really see why you'd prefer it.

Tomikka · 11/01/2023 12:51

Cash or card of course remains both a personal preference of the customer and of the business

To a business there are costs to any option or mix of options, I help out a couple of friends with their businesses.
Both take cash or card, and prefer one or the other

Card payments go directly into their accounts and are available to spend with suppliers and pay bills.
It costs to bank cash and takes longer to be available

But one of them also provides shop space to multiple traders, any money banked has to be seperate - and therefore more charges.
Where cash is taken then the famous £50 note can be accounted in the till & books and paid out to the trader with no fees (until that trader banks it - but no fees to the shop)
She also deals in collectibles, and when away at a show all the traders are doing deals with each other trading items - at the end of the day x owes y £, and hopefully they have taken enough in cash to pay that balance

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 11/01/2023 12:50

OnSecondThoughts · 10/01/2023 21:11

Tut tut....Excuse me, supervisor - I see the Mumsnet user "XYZ123" has just made a comment that trans-women shouldn't be allowed in cis-women's changing rooms"
"OK, that's a £500 fine and all card payments declined for 30 days. Excecute the code for that, please"
"Done".

That's China today.
That's us in...5 years? OK, a bit of an exagerration maybe...10 years?
Enjoy your cashless society, citizen.

Unless you only deal in cash i.e., are paid in cash and never put it in a bank, how to does cash help stop your example from happening?

Do you also genuinely think any UK government is going to commit to the level of investment required to make your example a reality and execute it in just 5-10 years?? You must have way more faith in our politicalians ability than me.

And for those referencing PayPal and the like you do realise that payment services like PayPal, Visa, Mastercard ,etc, and commercial banks are private companies and are therefore free to provide / withdraw their services to whoever they wish for whatever reason they wish (within the bounds of the law)?

Badbadbunny · 11/01/2023 12:50

BradfordGirl · 11/01/2023 12:46

@Tomikka In a small business they are no big deal. Our insurance policy covered the small amounts we were handling anyway. The bank was very close and the owner popped there in a break. And staff sorted money and the owner did a lot of books and admin during quiet times. Every business has quiet times.
You also need to do checks for staff with cards. Fraud such as skimming cards for example. Any handling of monies in whatever format needs robust safeguards.

Bigger shops have more costs from cash handling than small shops because small shops can do so much informally. Even when the owner had to take cash home to sort out, I know she did it in front of the TV. She wasn't paying someone to do it.

Not sure why you think a business owner should have to count cash in front of the TV just because you want to pay in cash, when you could easily pay by card and save her the trouble!

As for their quiet times, perhaps it would be more beneficial for the business owner to spend the time researching cost saving options, or marketing, or negotiating with suppliers, etc., i.e. things that would improve the business rather than spending that time on a wasteful and pointless task like counting money!

Badbadbunny · 11/01/2023 12:46

BradfordGirl · 11/01/2023 12:03

London is different. Travel outside and we still have places with poor connectivity. Plenty of places in North Yorkshire only take cash for this reason or say - try and see if it will accept the card but it may not.

That's fine, those businesses with poor connectivity can still accept cash if they want to. It's one of the many factors that a business will consider when they make decisions about cash and/or card acceptance. Just like they make decisions on opening hours, what goods to stock, selling prices, etc. Everything they do is based on whether it's "worth it" to them upon consideration of costs versus benefits.

But poor connectivity will be an ever reducing problem as broadband and mobile signals are improving all the time with new infrastructure etc. There are fewer and fewer places with neither one nor the other. There are plenty of local initiatives in rural areas to improve connectivity when the "big" firms havn't got round to it yet, such as radio based internet, independent organisations running their own private cabling network, etc., which provide the most appropriate infrastructure for their own particular local problems.

BradfordGirl · 11/01/2023 12:46

@Tomikka In a small business they are no big deal. Our insurance policy covered the small amounts we were handling anyway. The bank was very close and the owner popped there in a break. And staff sorted money and the owner did a lot of books and admin during quiet times. Every business has quiet times.
You also need to do checks for staff with cards. Fraud such as skimming cards for example. Any handling of monies in whatever format needs robust safeguards.

Bigger shops have more costs from cash handling than small shops because small shops can do so much informally. Even when the owner had to take cash home to sort out, I know she did it in front of the TV. She wasn't paying someone to do it.

Tomikka · 11/01/2023 12:41

countrygirl99 · 11/01/2023 08:45

Cash handling is expensive because it costs a lot of money. For a bank to handle cash they need a High Street presence, staff, high level physical security including ballistic walls around the tills, G4S collections etc. Do you think that lot costs pennies? And you still need all the computer systems to record the cash handling or we would be back to the old days when you could only take out cash from the branch that held your account without making arrangements beforehand.

In addition to the business banking charges involved in cash handling, there are also the indirect costs of time spent cashing up, sorting the amounts to be banked & retained as float, carrying it to the bank (which may or may not need to be in time while it’s open depending on out of hours deposit points), the risk of setting a pattern (to be mugged with your secure cash box, or supposedly anonymous carrier bag) etc

There may be indemnity costs and/or a level of record checking of staff to cover cash handling & insurance requirements etc

GreenManalishi · 11/01/2023 12:23

senua · 11/01/2023 08:39

Hmm, let's think for a minute. Who is it that sets bank charges?Hmm
Cash-handling is expensive because banks wish it to be so.

Cash handling is expensive before you've even got it to the bank, you have to rota staff to collect it from the till points, take it to back office, count it, bag it, drive it to the bank, this needs to be two people if it's significant amounts, and stand in line. The alternative is paying for specialist collection services, but it still needs to be processed internally to get to the point of pick up. This is all before the bank have even touched it. Not saying that banks aren't in the business of making money, of course they are, but practially card payments are so much easier for small business especially. Cash has always been expensive to handle, this is not a recent thing.

ClubhouseGift · 11/01/2023 12:19

TheChinkOfaGlass · 11/01/2023 12:17

Whilst cash remains legal tender, it should be taken everywhere

I don’t think you understand what legal tender actually is.

Kinnorafron · 11/01/2023 12:18

AmazonsFuckedUpFreeMusicFeature · 10/01/2023 19:31

Identity theft could be solved by simple national id. No one in my native country had the issue. Meanwhile we are both in UK under CIFAS ffs

How did your country achieve zero identity theft? Which Country is it?

TheChinkOfaGlass · 11/01/2023 12:17

Whilst cash remains legal tender, it should be taken everywhere

foremostwilly · 11/01/2023 12:06

I put a £1 coin in the machine when I need air for my tyres. I don't use cash for anything else.

TarasHarp55 · 11/01/2023 12:05

A few weeks ago in our area, Virgin went completely down. The shops that used it were asking for cash. Just one example of how much we need it. We should never ever rely on computers for everything.

BradfordGirl · 11/01/2023 12:03

Pearlygates · 11/01/2023 11:49

Yeah, I was in Birmingham recently and a busker had a contactless machine ready to take payments, he even set it up to £5 minimum 😂

Even buskers know what the deal is!

The busker would get nothing from me then.

BradfordGirl · 11/01/2023 12:03

London is different. Travel outside and we still have places with poor connectivity. Plenty of places in North Yorkshire only take cash for this reason or say - try and see if it will accept the card but it may not.

TarasHarp55 · 11/01/2023 12:02

It will be a nightmare if we ever go completely cashless. We should resist as much as we can.

BloodAndFire · 11/01/2023 11:59

Pearlygates · 11/01/2023 11:49

Yeah, I was in Birmingham recently and a busker had a contactless machine ready to take payments, he even set it up to £5 minimum 😂

Even buskers know what the deal is!

Yes, most of the buskers in London have those little white cube machines. So do market traders, fruit and veg sellers, fairground ticket booths, etc

I'm amazed that so many people still use cash tbh.

What does worry me is most of the teenagers round here pay with their phones. If they lose their phones they've lost EVERYTHING - not just ID and contact but money too. I prefer having separate cards.

Pearlygates · 11/01/2023 11:49

BloodAndFire · 11/01/2023 11:42

Oh and some buskers do take cashless payments. I assume it's only a matter of time until dealers do too 😁

Yeah, I was in Birmingham recently and a busker had a contactless machine ready to take payments, he even set it up to £5 minimum 😂

Even buskers know what the deal is!