Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be sick of cashless society

612 replies

Ihatepcos · 10/01/2023 09:31

I prefer to use cash, I always have.

I find budgeting and spending so much easier. If I am tapping away on my card I think nothing of constant £3 £6 etc being spent on things I probably wouldn't buy if I was spending cash.

More and more places simply don't take cash and it's driving me mad.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Sparklingbrook · 10/01/2023 12:41

TroysMammy · 10/01/2023 12:40

However hard I try supermarket trolleys don't release themselves from the one in front with the tap of a card.

No, you need a trolley token for that.

TroysMammy · 10/01/2023 12:40

However hard I try supermarket trolleys don't release themselves from the one in front with the tap of a card.

Badbadbunny · 10/01/2023 12:40

closingloop · 10/01/2023 12:36

Nobody mentioned local bank transfers, I have no idea why you would, costs of moving money internationally are insane, I have no idea if any bank would only charge 2%.

I was talking about a simple card transaction, put card in the machine, a small charge is made each time by the bank. These small charges add up and the original value of the £20 'disappears'.

One of my clients is a convenience store, who very roughly are 50:50 between cash and card sales. Their monthly bank charges are more than their credit card charges, and it costs them a lot in bank charges to bank the cash they take. It's over the relatively small amounts covered under normal bank charges, so they're on a pretty high "handling" fee by their bank. The owner is looking forward to more sales by card as it will reduce his bank charges (and save him a shed load of time in cashing up, travel to the bank, risk of forged notes, etc).

BradfordGirl · 10/01/2023 12:39

Badbadbunny · 10/01/2023 12:25

40 years ago was 1983. We had personal home computers such Sinclair ZX80, 81 and Spectrum. Schools were being given "BBC" computers and starting to teach computing. (Some already had been using Commodore PETS - I had computing as an O level option back as far as 1988! though the school only had one PET which had to be shared back then so it was mostly theory rather than practical!). I started work in 1983 in a small firm (just 10 people) that was fully networked and we had a desktop computer each, all using floppy disks. The revolutionary IBM "PC" was launched in 1981!

Did you go to a private school?
My school had no computers in early 1980s. About 1884/5 they got one computer. There was a big push to get one computer in every school in the country. I never got to use it.
At university in the mid to late eighties all essays were handwritten. There was a computer suite that was only for students doing computer studies. 1989 my first job and offices all still had secretaries and word processors. It was not until 1995 I got a computer at work. I moved to a new job a couple of years later and found myself in an office with a shared secretary and no computer. Had to wait until 1998 for my next computer.
There are always go ahead firms that introduce technology early. But computers have really only been commonplace in offices for about 25 years and are far more recent in the home. For a long time only gamers and those interested in computing had home computers. They were expensive.

Plenty of elderly people can do the very basics such as send an email or use facebook but can't manage anything more complex.

PlaitBilledDuckyPuss · 10/01/2023 12:39

bringmetheheadofpastaalfredo · 10/01/2023 12:27

What rot. AS if the people banging on about cash aren't using the banks just as much, aren't using the ATMs, paying with direct debits and standing orders and doing all the rest.

If you're that paranoid about some imaginary Big Brother poring over your bank account to see if you went to Costa yesterday, you're too far gone anyway. Plus anyone who wanted to know would have ten other ways to find out anyway. Your every move is on CCTV, your phone can track everywhere you go and eveyting you do.

You're completely missing the point. Every time you hand over your bank details, you are creating a route into your money, you are handing over data - and we all know how easily data can be breached, how there are lists of card numbers for sale on the dark web.

No, it can't be avoided altogether. But there's a difference between paying by card in, say, Sainsburys; where you would hope there'd be good controls in place, and paying by card at some tiny outlet - a random food van, say, where you have no idea whether it's legitimate or not.

As for my phone tracking me - we are not all slaves to our phones. Mine spends most of its time sitting at home, with the blue tooth and mobile data switched off. I don't need to be online all day, thanks. If I had to pay for things with my phone I might no longer have that choice.

Neveranynamesleft · 10/01/2023 12:39

I feel sorry for the elderly or vunerable people living alone with no one to help them.
It's wrong to presume everyone understands and has access to the internet. Simple things like going to the cash point, paying bills over the phone by debit card, paying by card in the supermarket, direct debits etc etc.. all of these totally baffle my elderly parents even though I help.

Badbadbunny · 10/01/2023 12:37

BradfordGirl · 10/01/2023 12:27

@Badbadbunny They have to let lots of stuff go. Not trivial £5 things. So with inheritance tax, you can basically lie about assets with price of shares and assets listed as way lower than they are worth. Unless you have an enormous estate it is very unlikely anyone will look at it.
Resources are spent on fraud in welfare benefits for small amounts. But tax evasion is rarely tackled and is tacitly accepted e.g. covid schemes set up in a way that everyone said would lead to widespread fraud.

People said that a few years ago re undeclared property lettings where there were huge numbers of people with a second (or multiple) properties they were renting out without declaring the income. HMRC had a long term "task force" looking at property transactions via Stamp Duty returns and Land Registry records, then started to cross reference house sales against the tax returns of those listed as the seller, both to check capital gains tax had been paid and also that property rental profits had been declared. People who thought they'd "got away with it" or who simply didn't think they had to declare anything suddenly found themselves the subject of formal tax enquiry and had to pay back the tax they'd not declared!

Same happened with IR35. Things happening in the background, research and data being analysed from multiple sources, then "wham bam" lots of contractors working in a particular firm received enquiry notices. Easy picking for HMRC - they did a "trial" case against one particular contractor working in a particular firm, deemed caught by IR35, so they hit all the other contractors working there under the same contract!

There's lots going on behind the scenes to "maximise" the results/outcomes of their resources rather than the old fashioned inefficient scattergun approach. You really don't know (no one knows) what data they've got and what "cases" they're putting together. Their new intelligence computer database system (linked to other governmental agencies such as DVLA, land registry, etc) is pretty new.

As for inheritance tax returns, I do know that at least some are checked against land registry records, as usually when a property is involved, the executors/beneficiaries will sell it to raise funds within a couple of years or so, so whilst HMRC may not immediately check the IHT return, they are almost certainly checking subsequent property sale records (via land registry) at a later date. It's why addresses of property have to be put on IHT and CGT returns, so they can cross check later.

closingloop · 10/01/2023 12:36

Itschristmastimeinthecity · 10/01/2023 12:16

Which bank charges 2% for local transfers?

Nobody mentioned local bank transfers, I have no idea why you would, costs of moving money internationally are insane, I have no idea if any bank would only charge 2%.

I was talking about a simple card transaction, put card in the machine, a small charge is made each time by the bank. These small charges add up and the original value of the £20 'disappears'.

phoenixrosehere · 10/01/2023 12:35

Life savings are not in cash - they are in the bank - and once you have to start giving your bank account details for every petty little purchase, you are opening up that channel into the place you keep all you money.

Unless you have separate accounts which many people do for those things and aren’t using the same account for day to day purchases. Not every account gets a card and some have rules about access.

Most here are not saying to get rid of cash completely, more that they either don’t use it or it is easier for them to use another form of payment.

Cash is not going to be phased out anytime soon. They said the same thing about books being eventually phased out due to Kindles and such and obviously that didn’t happen.

Itschristmastimeinthecity · 10/01/2023 12:35

diddl · 10/01/2023 12:28

What are visitors from other countries supposed to do?

I doubt that the local pub would accept my card!

I hardly ever use cash when I go abroad. Most people don't

altmember · 10/01/2023 12:34

I'm trying to get my tweenage kids to learn about money and budgeting etc. It's really difficult because they don't handle the physical cash like we used to - now it's just tap their card or order stuff online. I can't give them regular pocket money in cash because I rarely have any on me to give them. So it tends to be bank transfers instead.

If adults struggle to cope with cashless money management then kids have no chance. And they'll grow up struggling even more.

My dd lost 3k of savings by transferring it piecemeal to my rotten, bankrupt ex and step mother - £50 at a time (sometimes several times a day). Spent it on drugs and takeaways probably. Of course they never paid it back, but despite the amounts involved dd still hasn't grasped the severity of it.

bringmetheheadofpastaalfredo · 10/01/2023 12:33

diddl · 10/01/2023 12:28

What are visitors from other countries supposed to do?

I doubt that the local pub would accept my card!

Why do you think cards don't work internationally?

I have 3 different cards, they all work almost anywhere. I've used my phone to pay in...I don't know, 15 countries at least?

Iamtheblacksheep · 10/01/2023 12:32

People that Twitter about cards being easier weren’t in the butchers with me on Christmas Eve when the dear precious souls couldn’t pay for their turkeys when the card readers failed.

I happily skipped in and paid with my cash. This is quite a remote area. They all had to get in their cars to go to the atm in the next town

JudgeJ · 10/01/2023 12:32

TooExtraImmatureCheddar · 10/01/2023 09:43

I love it. No more realising that you haven't got change for the bus or looking for a cashpoint or scrabbling in the kids' moneyboxes because of some random school collection. Cashless works well for the disorganised.

I like a mixture of the two though when I was driving up to the Humber Bridge with about £1 in change I was glad to see the 'cards only' sign!

Climbles · 10/01/2023 12:32

A cashless society make it harder for thieves, tax dodgers and drug dealers.
Get a starling or monzo account where you can have different ‘pots’ of money. It makes budgeting much easier.

BradfordGirl · 10/01/2023 12:31

Badbadbunny · 10/01/2023 12:27

No, you have your money in different places, surely? So, no, someone knowing your bank details in one bank won't know what other investments, bank accounts, pensions, etc that you have at other banks. I don't think I've ever encountered anyone with literally "all their eggs in one basket". That's madness for all kinds of reasons, not just paranoia.

Lots of people have all their money in one bank.

CatJumperTwat · 10/01/2023 12:31

diddl · 10/01/2023 12:28

What are visitors from other countries supposed to do?

I doubt that the local pub would accept my card!

Why not? I use my cards on holiday and have never had a problem.

BradfordGirl · 10/01/2023 12:30

Goldpaw · 10/01/2023 12:28

We had a computer club at our school in the early eighties, which was very much in the sticks. Only those good at maths got to join!

At that point we did not have one computer in our school.

Crumpleton · 10/01/2023 12:29

Beees · 10/01/2023 11:35

Recently had a meal in a Cafè where when I went to pay with my card I was asked if I had cash, fortunately I do carry a bit but do prefer to use my card as reward points are pretty good.
Same question was asked to everyone that made a purchase.

Thay sounds quite dodgy to be honest. Does that mean they didn't accept card at all, which should have been made clear to you before you ordered or that they did accept card but would prefer cash payment which would ring alarm bells.

They did have a card machine but caught me on the hop, not a question I've ever been asked before, wasn't mentioned before ordering.
Most people did infact pay via cash.
Meal wasn't nice so no return visits happening.

Not that I'd want to live in a cashless society as there are shops/markets where I only use cash and wonder why places with a healthy turnover of customers don't excepted cards at all. Dodgy indeed does come to mind.

diddl · 10/01/2023 12:28

What are visitors from other countries supposed to do?

I doubt that the local pub would accept my card!

Goldpaw · 10/01/2023 12:28

We had a computer club at our school in the early eighties, which was very much in the sticks. Only those good at maths got to join!

Badbadbunny · 10/01/2023 12:27

PlaitBilledDuckyPuss · 10/01/2023 12:21

That's exactly the point. Life savings are not in cash - they are in the bank - and once you have to start giving your bank account details for every petty little purchase, you are opening up that channel into the place you keep all you money.

No, you have your money in different places, surely? So, no, someone knowing your bank details in one bank won't know what other investments, bank accounts, pensions, etc that you have at other banks. I don't think I've ever encountered anyone with literally "all their eggs in one basket". That's madness for all kinds of reasons, not just paranoia.

CatJumperTwat · 10/01/2023 12:27

iwanttobelikegracekelly · 10/01/2023 12:03

So please don't accuse people of not caring about the vulnerable if they aren't attached to cash. It's a childish, reductive, and silly argument.
Literally nobody has said they're opposed to choice.
I'm sorry for what you went through and glad you escaped!

Don't call my lived experience views childish and silly. How patronising.
I have said that cash helped me escape that situation. Without it I could not have escaped.

If you support a cashless society, and do not support legislating to protect access to and spending cash, then you are opposed to choice.

Please don't do that. You know quite well I called your ARGUMENT childish and silly, not your experiences.

BradfordGirl · 10/01/2023 12:27

@Badbadbunny They have to let lots of stuff go. Not trivial £5 things. So with inheritance tax, you can basically lie about assets with price of shares and assets listed as way lower than they are worth. Unless you have an enormous estate it is very unlikely anyone will look at it.
Resources are spent on fraud in welfare benefits for small amounts. But tax evasion is rarely tackled and is tacitly accepted e.g. covid schemes set up in a way that everyone said would lead to widespread fraud.

bringmetheheadofpastaalfredo · 10/01/2023 12:27

PlaitBilledDuckyPuss · 10/01/2023 12:21

That's exactly the point. Life savings are not in cash - they are in the bank - and once you have to start giving your bank account details for every petty little purchase, you are opening up that channel into the place you keep all you money.

What rot. AS if the people banging on about cash aren't using the banks just as much, aren't using the ATMs, paying with direct debits and standing orders and doing all the rest.

If you're that paranoid about some imaginary Big Brother poring over your bank account to see if you went to Costa yesterday, you're too far gone anyway. Plus anyone who wanted to know would have ten other ways to find out anyway. Your every move is on CCTV, your phone can track everywhere you go and eveyting you do.