Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want a girl?

267 replies

Namechanged2023 · 09/01/2023 20:27

Another thread like this, I know.

Two boys, 7 and 4. Both hard work in different ways, although lovely of course too. Both daddies boys, none of this mummy’s boy stuff which I would love.

I never ruled out a third, but DH isn’t keen as he is almost 40, I’m 5 years younger. I would really like a daughter. I know there’s no guarantee but I know plenty who’ve followed the old fashioned methods and managed it.

DH dead against it, it just feels a bit unfair that the one who doesn’t want another gets the final say, especially when he’s fine with his 2 boys, and he knew I was younger when we got married!

OP posts:
Phos · 10/01/2023 09:45

How is it any more unfair that the one who doesn’t want another gets the final say than the one who wants to try a bunch of old wives tales to satisfy her own, somewhat selfish, needs?

BananaSpeel · 10/01/2023 09:42

I hate to see boys being put in a certain category, mainly by grown women, ever thought they may pick up on this?

To be quite honest, I do think it’s tough to be a boy as there is a lot of negativity surrounding them.

But I’m not talking to boys (presumably) on this board but to other grown women. So at least here we should be frank about these very real problems instead of handwaving them away with ‘it’s all in how you raise them’ or (even worse) ‘girls are just as bad!’

MontyK · 10/01/2023 09:40

Hmm It's a big gamble to take. Imagine how gutted you are going to be if you end up with another boy, you're still not going to feel complete/satisfied. In fact, you'll probably feel worse.

Can you honestly say that if your second born had been a girl that you would have considered a third? Probably not.

Hence why it's not really about wanting the third child, it's wanting a girl - which brings me back to my first point - it's a huge gamble to take.

UndertheCedartree · 10/01/2023 09:38

I do understand where you are coming from. I really wanted a girl after I had my boy and was lucky enough to get that. Bringing up girls is different. But not massively. Yes, my DD is the typical 'good girl' at school (she's 10) but this often translates in having to deal with all the challenging behaviour at home. Also, she has been bullied by a couple of girls in the past so they're not all angels.

Talking about my 2, my DD is much more cheeky than my DS. She is more boisterous/clumsy than her DB.

In terms of 'daddy's girl'etc. I find it changes over the years so your DS's may be more bonded to you when older. My DS started as more a 'mummy's boy' then swapped, then back to me now. My DD has always been a 'daddy's girl' but now she's a bit older I get a look in too. Do you ever spend 1:1 time with your boys? Could you find something special to do from a shared interest?

It is hard to long for a baby that at the moment you can't have. Have you explained all this to your husband?

BananaSpeel · 10/01/2023 09:33

The whole 'boys will be boys' outlook is so damaging

Nobody here has this outlook. Boys should be raised to be considerate and kind, no one is throwing up their hands and saying we shouldn’t try—if we defer completely to nature the problem will be worse.

But we shouldn’t ignore nature either.

Thankfully humans are different to dogs!!

The point is that humans are not different from any other animal. We do have an innate nature, and it’s not so easy to change as we’d all like.

As a parent you have a huge influence on your child's behaviour and providing there aren't and SEND or ND issues then there is no reason why a boy would be more challenging than a girl

You are overly optimistic. Parents can soften the edges, but anyone with multiple children knows that you ‘discover’ more than ‘direct’ your child.

Also, you well know that boys jhave more SEN and behavioural issues than girls which makes it riskier to have boys, in that sense.

All you have to do is casually peruse MN to know that so many mothers struggle with their ND boys. This ofc is not to say that ND girls aren’t difficult (they are) but statistically it will be less likely from the POV of a parent-to-be

housemaus · 10/01/2023 09:31

it just feels a bit unfair that the one who doesn’t want another gets the final say
Having children should be a 'two yeses' situation - your alternative is to force someone who doesn't want another child to have one, how could that possibly be fairer???

especially when he’s fine with his 2 boys
They are also your boys. I hope you're not this blatant about them being such a disappointment to you that you consider them 'his' to them...

and he knew I was younger when we got married
Right, and you knew he was older.

Wheelz46 · 10/01/2023 09:22

You mention your husband knew you were younger when you got married, well you knew he was older when you married 🤷‍♀️

As a mother of only boys who had fertility issues, I am thankful everyday for my boys who are perfectly well behaved outside and inside of school. Obviously they have their moments just like any other girl or boy!

I hate to see boys being put in a certain category, mainly by grown women, ever thought they may pick up on this?

PMAmostofthetime · 10/01/2023 09:17

I think you need to both sit down and discuss the reasons why you want another and the reasons he doesn't and see if there is a compromise on one of your parts.

Did he know you wanted 3 children when you got married? If so then it is unfair and he's being unreasonable unless his reasons are that you can not afford, health issues erc.

I certainly think you need to discuss this as you may become resentful and it could damage your relationship.

X

VioletaDelValle · 10/01/2023 09:15

I don’t know exactly why, but statistics ofc say they overwhelmingly are and this is backed up by everyday experience, and is a pattern repeated in virtually every culture.

And there's the key word culture.
Gender stereotypes and societal expectations around how we treat boys and girls has a huge impact on behaviour.
The whole 'boys will be boys' outlook is so damaging.

Of course people should raise all their children to be kind and considerate. But the failures don’t always lie with the parent. It’s like blaming the dog owner for the bulldog’s nature.

Thankfully humans are different to dogs!!
As a parent you have a huge influence on your child's behaviour and providing there aren't and SEND or ND issues then there is no reason why a boy would be more challenging than a girl.

BananaSpeel · 10/01/2023 09:04

Why do you think men are more likely to be physically or sexually abusive

… I don’t know exactly why, but statistics ofc say they overwhelmingly are and this is backed up by everyday experience, and is a pattern repeated in virtually every culture.

How do we tackle this?

Of course people should raise all their children to be kind and considerate. But the failures don’t always lie with the parent. It’s like blaming the dog owner for the bulldog’s nature.

Do you believe boys are born to behave like this?

More likely to than girls, which is different from the above.

I fundamentally don’t believe in blank slate-ism, so I doubt you and I are ever going to see eye-to-eye on this.

Namechanged2023 · 10/01/2023 09:03

On the contrary I think I bend over backwards MORE to make sure my boys behave kindly and considerately because they are boys. I’ve had friends whose daughters have shoved and snatched but not told off, whereas when my DS retaliated I was expected to tell him off! On one occasion we all went swimming together and the DD was splashing my DS who was getting upset, friend did nothing - if my DS had splashed someone who clearly didn’t like it I’d always stop him there and then. Similarly, demanding girls = strong, know their own mind. Demanding boys = bratty, boisterous, rude.

No, had my second DS been a girl I probably would have felt that my family was complete more than I do now. But he wasn’t, if he was a girl he wouldn’t have been him. He is him, he is a real person and I adore him, and not for one second would I trade him for an imaginary girl. It’s not one or the other, you can adore the children you have and want another gender.

OP posts:
McPlant1 · 10/01/2023 08:54

BananaSpeel · 10/01/2023 08:52

I ofc think parents should do their best to raise kind, considerate boys.

But if their boy is difficult, I don’t think it’s fair to blame the parents if they did their best.

And if their girl is difficult? Is that down to parenting or just bad luck?

SleeplessInEngland · 10/01/2023 08:53

If your DH doesn’t want another one it’s all moot. You both have to be on the same page with that, at the very least.

BananaSpeel · 10/01/2023 08:52

MassiveSalad22 · 10/01/2023 08:33

Also I’ve put a lot of effort into my boys and you saying it’s just the way they are and nothing to do with parenting is gaslighting me 😉 also, society comes down to mass parenting doesn’t it?

I ofc think parents should do their best to raise kind, considerate boys.

But if their boy is difficult, I don’t think it’s fair to blame the parents if they did their best.

VioletaDelValle · 10/01/2023 08:52

Gosh that is so sad. Your poor boy!

We left pretty sharpish!

I was also told a number of times that I must be really strict as he's so well behaved! Like a well behaved boy is unusual.....

jem899 · 10/01/2023 08:51

Favour237 · 09/01/2023 20:30

And what if you had a third daddy’s boy? Or a daddy’s girl? Maybe try to be happy with the children you do have, obviously you can’t make your husband have another.

This is not helpful! The OP is allowed to want a girl, it doesn't mean she's an evil person. Mumsnet is full of horribleness like this!
OP I would go for it if you have the finances, you'd love a third despite the gender and you're up for the challenge. You might need need to talk your hubby round too though.. whatever you decide to do, good luck :-)

VioletaDelValle · 10/01/2023 08:49

We were all in school once and we remember who the badly behaved kids were—overwhelmingly boys.

I've worked in schools, I've taught kids of all ages. I've encountered badly behaved children of both sexes. What is clear to me is that the way society treats boys and girls is very much the root cause. And you are part of the problem as you seem to write boys off as a problem from before they are even born.

Sure, the girls were no angels but they weren’t going to physically or (later on) sexually assault you, now were they?

Why do you think men are more likely to be physically or sexually abusive? How do we tackle this?
Do you believe boys are born to behave like this?

BarbedButterfly · 10/01/2023 08:46

Wow. When I was teaching the girls were far more trouble at primary. There was one girl who was totally impossible

BananaSpeel · 10/01/2023 08:46

OP and Bananaspeel you should be ashamed of yourselves

I am not. Sorry, but then you are blaming parents (particularly mothers) for not raising their boys right. How is that ok?

I will push back. I don’t believe in blank slate-ism and there’s a reason why men are over-represented in criminal statistics.

if you look back at those men I would bet an overwhelming majority did not have a good home life

Sure but many of them do come from good situations.

so you might want to be reflecting on the home life you're creating with those views

I can’t tell you how many times I’ve read a thread right here on MN about boys who physically abuse their mothers. You could do a search and compare the amount of boys who do this vs girls and I’m sure it would look very stereotypical.

You want to blame the victim and pretend that it’s just bad parenting.

OP I’m very sorry I’m derailing your thread a bit … just know that your feelings are valid. Again it’s not about frilly dresses but in having a child that will go through the same experiences you had in life; experiences that males just cannot understand.

Whynobreadpudding · 10/01/2023 08:45

What if the third child has special needs? It happened to me. Totally derails everything.

HushLittleBabyDontYouCry · 10/01/2023 08:44

VioletaDelValle · 10/01/2023 08:40

Of course they do!

I hate seeing men declaring they want a boy and seeing their disappointment when they find out they're having a girl. It's disgusting.

I went to gender reveal party ( under duress as it was family) and we were asked to wear blue or pink to denote if we wanted a girl or boy. I wore white out of protest and made sure people knew why.

Seeing all the men in blue and women in pink made me feel sick.

I had my little boy with me and left early because I was disgusted to see women crying because it was a boy which prompted my son to ask me if I'd been disappointed when I found out he was a boy.

Gosh that is so sad. Your poor boy!

Nottodaty · 10/01/2023 08:43

I’m one of three girls - all completely different. My younger two sister very different but not easy at all - both my parents have a few more grey hairs due to them.

My uncle after 3 boys finally had his Daddy girl…nope she is as tough as the boys and whole lot more challenging! His wife wanted a little girl to go shopping and do her nails - she got a football loving girl. She also felt like she was only born because they wanted a girl so in her teenage years really hard. All ok as adults but she moved to a different country so no daughter to go shopping with and all the other dreams the mum had.

Have a third if you want but be prepared if you already have two spirited boys then a girl will be likely the same. And she may not be aware of a list of expectations you may have.

VioletaDelValle · 10/01/2023 08:43

@VioletaDelValle please enlighten me as I’ve tried everything with my DS.

Moving away from stereotypical ideas of how boys and girls behave would be a start.

VioletaDelValle · 10/01/2023 08:40

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 10/01/2023 08:32

No one cares that most men probably want a boy- who cares if women want girls- if they have boys of course they adore love and cherish them

Of course they do!

I hate seeing men declaring they want a boy and seeing their disappointment when they find out they're having a girl. It's disgusting.

I went to gender reveal party ( under duress as it was family) and we were asked to wear blue or pink to denote if we wanted a girl or boy. I wore white out of protest and made sure people knew why.

Seeing all the men in blue and women in pink made me feel sick.

I had my little boy with me and left early because I was disgusted to see women crying because it was a boy which prompted my son to ask me if I'd been disappointed when I found out he was a boy.

Spendonsend · 10/01/2023 08:37

I dont think its unreasonable to want a girl or a boy. I do think its unreasonable to have a third in the hope its a girl though.