Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want a girl?

267 replies

Namechanged2023 · 09/01/2023 20:27

Another thread like this, I know.

Two boys, 7 and 4. Both hard work in different ways, although lovely of course too. Both daddies boys, none of this mummy’s boy stuff which I would love.

I never ruled out a third, but DH isn’t keen as he is almost 40, I’m 5 years younger. I would really like a daughter. I know there’s no guarantee but I know plenty who’ve followed the old fashioned methods and managed it.

DH dead against it, it just feels a bit unfair that the one who doesn’t want another gets the final say, especially when he’s fine with his 2 boys, and he knew I was younger when we got married!

OP posts:
EndlessRain1 · 10/01/2023 12:46

I actually think the stronger you feel about a specific gender the more you should not try for one. Because that will leave the "wrong" gendered child at increased risk of being and feeling like a disappointment.

OP already talks about how hard work her sons are and that she wants a girl because they will be easier and not like her sons. That's a pretty big red flag in terms of favourism. She's picked her favourite before she is even concieved.

ZoeCM · 10/01/2023 12:41

I wanted a girl - I was desperate a daughter. DH desperately wanted a daughter too. We both have our reasons. We were blessed, and had a daughter.

So if you'd had a boy he wouldn't have been a blessing? Jesus Christ.

jolies · 10/01/2023 12:09

I hate this utter nonsense about how people 'tried' for a girl using a certain method and it worked. It's literally 50/50 so of course some will end up with a girl, it's absolutely nothing to do with certain methods.

Aldith · 10/01/2023 11:57

YANBU to want a girl but reading further I wonder if you should have a third child. If you have a third boy will you truly be happy and love your boys or will you want a fourth child because only a girl will do?
Are your boys already picking up on the feeling that they are not good enough?

Talk to your husband about why you want a third child and listen with open mind as to why he doesn’t. You may have to accept though that two boys is what you will have no matter what you want.

VioletaDelValle · 10/01/2023 11:37

Disagree, it's usually because people want to either replicate aspects of their childhood or completely rewrite their childhood and feel drawn to what they know. I know what it is to be a female, therefore I feel more at ease raising a female and could picture a similar childhood to that of my own.

It's not always that though is it? That might be your reasons but I've seen and experienced something different.

It doesnt affect you what other people imagine giving birth to. Plenty of people want girls and plenty of people want boys- who the hell cares.

There's a difference between imagining to yourself but then realising that you are just happy to be having a healthy baby and declaring publicly that you want a particular sex because stereotypical ideas - which is what the OP is doing.

I care when I have family members making such a big deal about have the 'wrong' sex that my own child starts to question whether I was disappointed he was a boy.
I care when my own nephew is upset because 'he's not the boy his dad always wanted'

These conversations and situations happen, I've seen and heard the unpleasant side of this. It's not nice and really shit for the kids involved.

HelloJan · 10/01/2023 11:28

it just feels a bit unfair that the one who doesn’t want another gets the final say

That's how it should be. Raising a child is a lot of work. If one parent doesn't want another child, then that's that.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 10/01/2023 11:24

You claimed that nobody is bothered when men want boys....I can tell you that it does bother me. It bothers me when people openly declare a preference for a particular sex because, in my opinion, this is purely based on stereotypes
Disagree, it's usually because people want to either replicate aspects of their childhood or completely rewrite their childhood and feel drawn to what they know. I know what it is to be a female, therefore I feel more at ease raising a female and could picture a similar childhood to that of my own.
It doesnt affect you what other people imagine giving birth to. Plenty of people want girls and plenty of people want boys- who the hell cares.

Squirespot · 10/01/2023 11:22

PMAmostofthetime · 10/01/2023 11:10

What happened to be Kind!

Op is not saying she does not love her boys nor that she will not love a 3rd son. What she is saying is that she planned for 3 children and the what if's that it could be a little girl that she yearns for is driving her move for the 3rd child.

Gender preference and Gender disappointment is real.

When I found out the sex of my baby- it was the sex that I had a preference for.
However I was still a little sad for the sex it wasn't as I had 2 children pictured in my head and the different things I wished for them and our relationship. Yes I am very aware that children do not conform to our dreams and expectations however we are all human and have dreams and aspirations for our children and their relationship with us.

As I said in my previous post I think OP needs to sit down with her husband and have a proper discussion in regards to a 3rd child, why she wants one why he doesn't to try and compromise or come to terms with their reality.

What happened to reading the OPs posts? She said she thought about three children, she said she would not be having a third if she had a girl?

How bloody kind is that to a third boy?

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 10/01/2023 11:21

Squirespot · 10/01/2023 10:03

But OP Is only having a third child in the hope for a girl, there would not be a third child if she already had a girl. It is more than a preference, she is saying that it's not the third child she wants, and if it is a girl that's great. She has stated if she had a girl, she would not be wanting a third child.

I'm sorry but this is a recipe for disaster IMO.

I agree, no way would I have had three children for any reason- but Im jumping on the people who are getting seriously irate at the very concept of a sex preference.

McPlant1 · 10/01/2023 11:19

DashboardConfessional · 10/01/2023 11:13

What happened to be Kind!

You mean the trite hashtag that's meant to shut down women and their valid opinions? Hopefully on its way to the bin where it belongs.

Funny how you never see #bekind on the clothes in the boys section, incidentally.

👏👏👏

DashboardConfessional · 10/01/2023 11:13

What happened to be Kind!

You mean the trite hashtag that's meant to shut down women and their valid opinions? Hopefully on its way to the bin where it belongs.

Funny how you never see #bekind on the clothes in the boys section, incidentally.

PMAmostofthetime · 10/01/2023 11:10

What happened to be Kind!

Op is not saying she does not love her boys nor that she will not love a 3rd son. What she is saying is that she planned for 3 children and the what if's that it could be a little girl that she yearns for is driving her move for the 3rd child.

Gender preference and Gender disappointment is real.

When I found out the sex of my baby- it was the sex that I had a preference for.
However I was still a little sad for the sex it wasn't as I had 2 children pictured in my head and the different things I wished for them and our relationship. Yes I am very aware that children do not conform to our dreams and expectations however we are all human and have dreams and aspirations for our children and their relationship with us.

As I said in my previous post I think OP needs to sit down with her husband and have a proper discussion in regards to a 3rd child, why she wants one why he doesn't to try and compromise or come to terms with their reality.

DietrichandDiMaggio · 10/01/2023 11:02

Namechanged2023 · 10/01/2023 08:02

@OnlyFoolsnMothers absolutely, find me a NT girl who is badly behaved at primary school and I’ll eat my hat! I’m sure cheekiness can start in the older years and secondary, but by then the “naughty” boys are beating each other so the girls’ behaviour pales in comparison.

Plenty of NT girls behave badly in primary school. Yes, year 6 girls may misbehave in different ways to boys, but they know perfectly well that they are not behaving appropriately, and often their behaviour is far more likely to have an impact on others.

BananaSpeel · 10/01/2023 10:53

Squirespot · 10/01/2023 10:03

But OP Is only having a third child in the hope for a girl, there would not be a third child if she already had a girl. It is more than a preference, she is saying that it's not the third child she wants, and if it is a girl that's great. She has stated if she had a girl, she would not be wanting a third child.

I'm sorry but this is a recipe for disaster IMO.

It’s actually quite common. Parents who have both sexes are more likely to stop at two while those with just one tend to go for the third.

Reindear · 10/01/2023 10:16

Namechanged2023 · 10/01/2023 07:09

Learn to conform = behave in a civilised manner, be polite and well behaved in school and other places where it’s required. Not be quiet wallflowers with no opinions. God knows I have never been the latter!

Those of you with “strong willed girls”, I would bet that 98% are well behaved angels at school, no? My eldest DS’ best friend is a girl, she is a strong willed character; but she is good in the main at school.

And I hate gender stereotypes, but they are real. Almost all my friends and family have children by now, the majority of the boys are boisterous and loud; the majority of the girls aren’t. Plenty of the girls love active play, running around; I’m not talking of the extremes of a girl sitting quietly with a cup of tea and saucer! But the ones who fight physically, who take it too far and get hurt or hurt others, they are almost always boys.

I’m glad not everyone seems to think the wishes of those who don’t want another child trump the others’. I know it’s not ideal, hence why we’re in a stale mate. I’ve been wondering about a third since my youngest DS was 13 months!

My strong willed girl has not always behaved in school, no. I was in and out for meetings for the first 2 years because she couldn’t listen and sit still. She is September born so one of the oldest in her year but has taken until now (year 2) to finally be able to sit and listen. My son is august born and has never found listening and sitting still difficult. I’ve never once had an issue with him in school (year 6 now) It’s personality not gender at all with mine. I’m not sure if it’s because dd has an older brother but she loves rough play with the boys. If you have a dd she might be similar with 2 big brothers

EndlessRain1 · 10/01/2023 10:12

Namechanged2023 · 10/01/2023 07:09

Learn to conform = behave in a civilised manner, be polite and well behaved in school and other places where it’s required. Not be quiet wallflowers with no opinions. God knows I have never been the latter!

Those of you with “strong willed girls”, I would bet that 98% are well behaved angels at school, no? My eldest DS’ best friend is a girl, she is a strong willed character; but she is good in the main at school.

And I hate gender stereotypes, but they are real. Almost all my friends and family have children by now, the majority of the boys are boisterous and loud; the majority of the girls aren’t. Plenty of the girls love active play, running around; I’m not talking of the extremes of a girl sitting quietly with a cup of tea and saucer! But the ones who fight physically, who take it too far and get hurt or hurt others, they are almost always boys.

I’m glad not everyone seems to think the wishes of those who don’t want another child trump the others’. I know it’s not ideal, hence why we’re in a stale mate. I’ve been wondering about a third since my youngest DS was 13 months!

OP you are serious disillussioned about what having a girl is like. I would say that DD is much harder work in many ways than DS. Sure, she might not run around carzily as much (although many girls do), but the drama that comes with girls is REAL. So is the teenage attitude, which has already started at 9.

It's also pretyt mean to say you want a girl because your sons are hard work. It's like you've already picked your favourite, one that doesn't even exist. Poor boys, they have my sympathy. And so does the potential 3rd disappointment boy.

VioletaDelValle · 10/01/2023 10:11

Of course it's not disgusting- I can tell you any initial disappointment is nothing to do with the actual child anyone has and they love the child they have.
It's ridiculous how angry people get about other people's preferences.
Did I want girls, yes- do I love and adore and am proud of my nephew, of course. Did my want for a girl affect you or your love for your sons, no.

You claimed that nobody is bothered when men want boys....I can tell you that it does bother me. It bothers me when people openly declare a preference for a particular sex because, in my opinion, this is purely based on stereotypes. Men want boys for stereotypical reasons ( just like women want girls for stereotypical reasons) and I've seen first hand when that doesn't got to plan and the damage it can do. My male cousin has a non existent relationship with his dad because he wasn't the the version of the long awaited boy his dad had wished for ( not into football, gay, professional dancer) my cousin is quite damaged by this and my sister's relationship with her son and husband is challenging as she feels stuck in the middle.

You can feel differently of course but I'm of the opinion that people who declare a preference for a particular sex when having a baby need to give their head a wobble.

PinkPink1 · 10/01/2023 10:10

@Namechanged2023
The fact that I have two boys means that there’s a bonus chance of having a girl if we were to have a third.

I think you’re more likely to have another boy if you already have two. I’ve seen so many families with 3+ sons and you just know the mum wanted to keep trying for a girl before giving up.

Also what ‘old fashioned methods’ are you talking about? It’s the man’s sperm that dictates if the baby will be a boy or a girl.

BunchHarman · 10/01/2023 10:04

You’ve called your first two kids ‘demon’ and ‘nightmare’. Do you think a third child is really a good idea? You clearly don’t want a third boy.

Often girls are ‘better behaved’ because society expects so much more of little girls from day-fucking-dot. They’re expected to be quiet, kind, academic, the peacemakers and they’re always, always expected to be the ones to make allowances for the behaviour of others. It’s sick. Meanwhile the fucking bullshit mentality of ‘boys will be boys’ lives on. As this thread demonstrates.

Squirespot · 10/01/2023 10:03

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 10/01/2023 09:58

I hate seeing men declaring they want a boy and seeing their disappointment when they find out they're having a girl. It's disgusting.
Of course it's not disgusting- I can tell you any initial disappointment is nothing to do with the actual child anyone has and they love the child they have.
It's ridiculous how angry people get about other people's preferences.
Did I want girls, yes- do I love and adore and am proud of my nephew, of course. Did my want for a girl affect you or your love for your sons, no.

But OP Is only having a third child in the hope for a girl, there would not be a third child if she already had a girl. It is more than a preference, she is saying that it's not the third child she wants, and if it is a girl that's great. She has stated if she had a girl, she would not be wanting a third child.

I'm sorry but this is a recipe for disaster IMO.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 10/01/2023 09:58

I hate seeing men declaring they want a boy and seeing their disappointment when they find out they're having a girl. It's disgusting.
Of course it's not disgusting- I can tell you any initial disappointment is nothing to do with the actual child anyone has and they love the child they have.
It's ridiculous how angry people get about other people's preferences.
Did I want girls, yes- do I love and adore and am proud of my nephew, of course. Did my want for a girl affect you or your love for your sons, no.

LaLuz7 · 10/01/2023 09:58

What if you 3rd is twins or a severely disabled kid?

Are you willing to take on these risks?

MRSDoos · 10/01/2023 09:58

I don’t think you’re a bad person for wanting a third child or hoping for a girl after having 2 boys. This is coming from someone who has had miscarriages and is pregnant with their first child. I’ve always had dreams about being a boy mum and I would of been happy with either gender (especially after losses) but had a preference for a boy which we were lucky enough to find out that we are expecting a boy.
I’ve always loved to have 3 children but DH wants 2. I understand that it is a bit of a hard pill to swallow but you can’t force someone to have a child that they do not want. Also, I’m not sure how statistics work out but I am sure having 2 boys mean that you are more likely to have another boy rather than a girl (I could be wrong)
Also even if you have a girl there is no guarantee that her personality or traits will match what you’re hoping for.
I don’t really know what advice to give x

VioletaDelValle · 10/01/2023 09:54

You are overly optimistic. Parents can soften the edges, but anyone with multiple children knows that you ‘discover’ more than ‘direct’ your child.

I think you are massively underestimating the role of parenting here.
I think that the environment a child is brought up in, the influences of parents, school, childcare, friends etc does far more than 'soften the edges'.

Squirespot · 10/01/2023 09:50

Namechanged2023 · 09/01/2023 21:55

Also I would like to have the different experience. My DS’ are very different so I know it’s not all about gender. But whatever anyone says, it’s a different experience raising boys and girls. Girls learn to conform. I would give anything for a “good girl” who had an easier time at school.

You would give anything for a good girl, really says it all!

It doesn't work like that.

Don't have another child, if it's a boy they will know they were only conceived in the hope they were a girl. Not nice.