Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want a girl?

267 replies

Namechanged2023 · 09/01/2023 20:27

Another thread like this, I know.

Two boys, 7 and 4. Both hard work in different ways, although lovely of course too. Both daddies boys, none of this mummy’s boy stuff which I would love.

I never ruled out a third, but DH isn’t keen as he is almost 40, I’m 5 years younger. I would really like a daughter. I know there’s no guarantee but I know plenty who’ve followed the old fashioned methods and managed it.

DH dead against it, it just feels a bit unfair that the one who doesn’t want another gets the final say, especially when he’s fine with his 2 boys, and he knew I was younger when we got married!

OP posts:
Rockingcloggs · 10/01/2023 17:15

Holly03 · 10/01/2023 16:24

I totally get it. I really wanted a girl too but I couldn’t help myself, I always wanted to do the girly things. I saw a tip on here about getting pregnant with a girl on your day of ovulation. It’s the day I fell pregnant with my daughter

And if your daughter didn't ever want to do the 'girly things' what would you have done? Swapped her for a girlier version?!

VioletaDelValle · 10/01/2023 16:43

I saw a tip on here about getting pregnant with a girl on your day of ovulation. It’s the day I fell pregnant with my daughter

I wouldn't bank on that! I got pregnant on the day of ovulation and had a boy!
And actually people are often told that having sex close to ovulation will actually increase your chances of having a boy.....although the reality is it's a 50/50 chance anyway.

Holly03 · 10/01/2023 16:24

I totally get it. I really wanted a girl too but I couldn’t help myself, I always wanted to do the girly things. I saw a tip on here about getting pregnant with a girl on your day of ovulation. It’s the day I fell pregnant with my daughter

ZoeCM · 10/01/2023 16:21

I work in a role that sees statistics on violence etc and there is upward trend in violence in young woman and a down ward trend in violence in young men over the last few years.

This may be partly because some crimes committed by men are now being recorded as having been committed by women.

Fundays12 · 10/01/2023 16:12

Namechanged2023 · 10/01/2023 07:09

Learn to conform = behave in a civilised manner, be polite and well behaved in school and other places where it’s required. Not be quiet wallflowers with no opinions. God knows I have never been the latter!

Those of you with “strong willed girls”, I would bet that 98% are well behaved angels at school, no? My eldest DS’ best friend is a girl, she is a strong willed character; but she is good in the main at school.

And I hate gender stereotypes, but they are real. Almost all my friends and family have children by now, the majority of the boys are boisterous and loud; the majority of the girls aren’t. Plenty of the girls love active play, running around; I’m not talking of the extremes of a girl sitting quietly with a cup of tea and saucer! But the ones who fight physically, who take it too far and get hurt or hurt others, they are almost always boys.

I’m glad not everyone seems to think the wishes of those who don’t want another child trump the others’. I know it’s not ideal, hence why we’re in a stale mate. I’ve been wondering about a third since my youngest DS was 13 months!

OP my dcs school is having a bigger issue just now with girls bullying than boys. These are primary age kids and some of the girls behaviour is awful. All my boys have been hit by girls at various stages one of my boys has been hit repeatedly and had stones thrown at him by a girl.

Also they all my boys do well in school and behave as that’s what I expect of them. If they don’t behave they have don’t get rewards or treats as these are earned through good behaviour. DS1 has a neurological condition that affects girls and boys so does struggle far more than the other 2 but does well in school with some support. Ds2 excels in school and gets excellent report cards and feedback from his teachers. DS3 does well and gets good feedback from his pre school nursery.

I don’t believe girls and boys generally behave better or worse but society encourages boys to be rough and tumble and girls to be “princesses” both stereotypes come with difficulties as boys that are not taught that being rough is unacceptable carry on doing it. Girls that are taught they at princesses or divas often become spoilt , entitled and demanding none of which are pleasant traits.

I work in a role that sees statistics on violence etc and there is upward trend in violence in young woman and a down ward trend in violence in young men over the last few years.

Cuppasoupmonster · 10/01/2023 16:11

ZoeCM · 10/01/2023 16:07

I really do believe gender disappointment would disappear if people started to see children as people in their own right, not objects who exist to make their parents happy.

But they sort of are ‘objects who exist to make parents happy’. Not objects obviously, but we all have hopes and ideals for our children rather than just 100% ‘letting them be themselves’. Look at the number of parents on here desperate to get their kids into high achieving schools despite the child being average, or moving to the country to bring them up in the hope they’ll ‘spend time outside and have a rural upbringing’. All parents hope their kids will be happy, healthy and reasonably bright. In part because it then makes it easier for us to raise them, and a happy and studious child will bring us as parents more joy than an unhappy stroppy nightmare who is off the rails.

ZoeCM · 10/01/2023 16:07

I really do believe gender disappointment would disappear if people started to see children as people in their own right, not objects who exist to make their parents happy.

CousinKrispy · 10/01/2023 16:03

OP I do think you will need to respect your partner's wishes if he is "done" having children. it is such a huge commitment of time, money, and energy and it's not to be taken lightly.

That said, if he's happy to have a 3rd child, that's fine. But please self-reflect enough to ensure you don't put pressure on any potential daughter to fill a particular role in your life. She might turn out to be really different from what you hoped or expected. It would be heartbreaking if she ever sensed or thought you were disappointed that she wasn't the "right kind" of girl.

Also, the fact that you've had 2 boys already--mathematically, probability does not mean that you're more likely to have a girl next time, though I know that seems counter-intuitive!

BunchHarman · 10/01/2023 15:52

RambamThankyouMam · 10/01/2023 15:31

Since male children are favoured in most places around the world, it's nice to redress the balance and have some love for baby girls.

Are you for real?

Squirespot · 10/01/2023 15:32

RambamThankyouMam · 10/01/2023 15:31

Since male children are favoured in most places around the world, it's nice to redress the balance and have some love for baby girls.

Two wrongs don't make it right!

RambamThankyouMam · 10/01/2023 15:31

Since male children are favoured in most places around the world, it's nice to redress the balance and have some love for baby girls.

salzburginthesnow · 10/01/2023 15:19

I have a very much wanted boy. He is gentle, kind and loving. I always wanted a boy. In fact I was nervous to have a girl, because I was the ‘nightmare’ growing up. It took me a long time to think she doesn’t need to make the mistakes I did. I’m now pregnant with a girl and I’m really excited. I want to teach her the pitfalls in life to avoid and how to stay on the right path.

I do really think you should reconsider your values before contemplating another child. Maybe have some counselling. Your attitude towards boys is very negative and I don’t think it’s healthy for them growing up knowing their mum considers them a nightmare. I say this kindly. I had to have a hard talk with myself as to why I was scared to have a girl, and realised a lot of it came from self-loathing. It took time to get over that. Maybe you have resentment towards men in general? which I think you should address since you have two boys.

Also if you really do want a girl and can’t get the idea out of your mind, I suggest considering IVF in the US. The absolute worst thing would be to roll the dice, end up with another boy and resent him just because of his gender.

BananaSpeel · 10/01/2023 14:18

Plus it’s perfectly natural to feel you have more to offer in terms of life experience and understanding to a child of the same sex as yourself

Yuuuup 🎯

Goldd · 10/01/2023 14:16

You’ve asked for opinions so I will answer, in the hope you are taking different opinions on board, NOT only absorbing the few posters who already agree with you.

Having a third child because you want a girl is the wrong motivation. You should not do this. There are two ways it could go:

  1. You get a third boy and are disappointed
  2. You get a girl, and your sons will be able to sense the preference you have for your daughter.

My sister has two girls, they were considering a third. Her husband hankered after a boy, he always pictured a son. He was actually the one to say “no”, the disappointment he’d experience if it was another girl would be so unfair on the baby and their existing girls. And he wouldn’t want the girls to feel like they kept trying until a boy was achieved. So they left it at two.

All the school behaviour/quiet girls/naughty boys/daddy’s boy/mummy’s girl stuff is total bullshit and noise. You are just trying to convince yourself that having a third child against your husbands will is okay.

You spoke about your distant relationship with your mother - you should probably go to therapy and address this rather than trying to fill the hole with a daughter.

VioletaDelValle · 10/01/2023 14:15

But they do generally behave differently, because of (as we’ve discussed) a mix of hormonal/chromosomal differences and societal conditioning. So she has a point doesn’t she? Of course her ‘daughter’ might be tomboy. But she’s more likely not to be. Her sons could end up dancing in swan lake and wearing dresses - but I would bet they won’t. It’s about chances and probability.

Tomboy - what does that even mean, isn't it just more outdated nonsense to describe someone who doesn't fit your stereotypical view of what it means to be a girl!
It really depends on where you sit on the nature/nature debate doesn't it really?

Plus it’s perfectly natural to feel you have more to offer in terms of life experience and understanding to a child of the same sex as yourself.

That's a different point entirely. That is understandable to an extent but it's completely different to saying I want a girl because I want a well behaved child who will conform.

Plus it’s quite ironic that so many posters say it’s about ‘stereotyping’ before saying ‘boys are great, girls are emotional nightmares’ etc.

I agree, it's just a bad.

Cuppasoupmonster · 10/01/2023 14:04

When people talk about gender disappointment on MN it is primarily linked to how they believe boys and girls behave differently and is typically linked to stereotypical views of boys and girls.

But they do generally behave differently, because of (as we’ve discussed) a mix of hormonal/chromosomal differences and societal conditioning. So she has a point doesn’t she? Of course her ‘daughter’ might be tomboy. But she’s more likely not to be. Her sons could end up dancing in swan lake and wearing dresses - but I would bet they won’t. It’s about chances and probability.

Plus it’s perfectly natural to feel you have more to offer in terms of life experience and understanding to a child of the same sex as yourself.

Plus it’s quite ironic that so many posters say it’s about ‘stereotyping’ before saying ‘boys are great, girls are emotional nightmares’ etc.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 10/01/2023 14:01

Oooh, my parents were like this - they wanted girls so that their kids would conform and they’d have an easier life. Unfortunately they got their way. Their kids are all fucked up in their own ways because we were expected and told to be “good girls” and never cause trouble or tell anyone if we had problems, unlike those wild free spirited handful boys who should be allowed to do what they liked to us because they were boys.

Honestly OP, it’s not wrong to want a girl but it’d be wrong to have one in your circumstances and with your views.

VioletaDelValle · 10/01/2023 13:57

But it’s not only naive but unproductive to deny personality differences are solely because of ‘girls and boys being given different toys’ for example.

I've not mentioned clothes or toys. That's you putting words into my mouth.
Nor I have I said it is all down to social conditioning - although I feel that plays a much bigger part that you are acknowledging.
I'm talking about wider expectations around behaviour, how particular behaviour is rewarded or punished in society and expectations around gender roles.
Which leads on to your next point......

If you want to argue that boys are less wanted in our society than girls, why do they display the same criminal behaviours as their counterparts in countries where boys are the desired sex?

I've not argued this at all BUT this isn't about which sex is the desired sex in a particular culture or country. It's about expected behaviour of a particular sex and there are clearly differences in how people expect boys and girls will behave.

Those countries/cultures where boys are the preferred sex aren't driven by whether girls are better behaved in school or not. Whether they are the desired sex or not isn't impacting on the societal expectation around the behaviour of a particular sex.

When people talk about gender disappointment on MN it is primarily linked to how they believe boys and girls behave differently and is typically linked to stereotypical views of boys and girls.
The OP admitted this herself! She wants a girl because ( in her opinion) they are more likely to conform and be better behaved.

uncomfortablydumb53 · 10/01/2023 13:55

I have 3 DS's
Personality is not defined by sex
There is no guarantee you'd have a girl
There is no guarantee you'd be closer to a girl
I wouldn't have a third if you'd be disappointed( which it sounds like you would.
Your DH does not want another

Cuppasoupmonster · 10/01/2023 13:40

Or do you think particular gendered behaviour is hardwired into our chromosomes?

I do, yes - in a general sense (before you harp on about a tomboy you know or a male ballerina). I think hormones do dominate personality traits more than we think, and not everything is down to ‘societal conditioning’ (even though it plays a slight role). That’s why we get PMS, why women experience personality differences during the menopause, and why men on the whole are more aggressive than woman. That doesn’t mean if you display ‘male’ characteristics you’re a man, as there are always exceptions and outliers. But it’s not only naive but unproductive to deny personality differences are solely because of ‘girls and boys being given different toys’ for example.

If you want to argue that boys are less wanted in our society than girls, why do they display the same criminal behaviours as their counterparts in countries where boys are the desired sex?

VioletaDelValle · 10/01/2023 13:37

So you think all the male behaviour on here is down to the fact their mum dressed them in blue or they had toy cars? Really?

I didn't say that did I?

What I said was that society views and treats men and women and boys and girls differently. This translates into different expectations around behaviour and the language used to describe that behaviour.

This helps shape a young persons view of the world and their place in it. This happens at a very young age.

Male (and female behaviour) is heavily influenced by society and the environment they grow up in.
Or do you think particular gendered behaviour is hardwired into our chromosomes?

Cuppasoupmonster · 10/01/2023 13:15

Men and women are viewed (and treated ) differently in wider society, not just on MN and isn't that part of the problem? Before children are even born we are subjecting them to stereotypical, sexist nonsense. Then we ponder as to why they behave differently. Surely you are only apprehensive about raising boys if you buy into the idea that men are born 'awful sexist monsters'?

So you think all the male behaviour on here is down to the fact their mum dressed them in blue or they had toy cars? Really?

VioletaDelValle · 10/01/2023 13:13

As for it being based on stereotypes, can anyone who says that look me in the eye (virtually speaking) and tell me there is no difference between the way Mumsnet views men and women? And why we have so many ‘men are awful sexist monsters’ type threads? And then tell me they don’t understand why women might be more apprehensive about raising men (not just little boys)?

Men and women are viewed (and treated ) differently in wider society, not just on MN and isn't that part of the problem? Before children are even born we are subjecting them to stereotypical, sexist nonsense. Then we ponder as to why they behave differently.

Surely you are only apprehensive about raising boys if you buy into the idea that men are born 'awful sexist monsters'?

Cuppasoupmonster · 10/01/2023 12:59

As for it being based on stereotypes, can anyone who says that look me in the eye (virtually speaking) and tell me there is no difference between the way Mumsnet views men and women? And why we have so many ‘men are awful sexist monsters’ type threads? And then tell me they don’t understand why women might be more apprehensive about raising men (not just little boys)?

Cuppasoupmonster · 10/01/2023 12:57

YANBU. Despite what people say on here about there being ‘no difference’ between the sexes before saying how awful men are on another thread I can absolutely understand why a woman would want a daughter, as a deep instinctive desire.

Even the most fiercely proud ‘boy mums’ (like Stacey Solomon and Siobhan Miller) who insisted they didn’t care which sex they had next went wild when they finally had a girl, it’s all ‘can’t believe ive got my girl’ ‘she’s completed our family’ and OTT celebrations compared to when their boys were born.

So don’t feel guilty, despite what anyone says. It might not be ‘justifiable’ in a rational sense, but then neither is having a baby in itself 🤷🏼‍♀️

Just be prepared for how you may feel if you do decide to try again and it’s another boy. Good luck whatever you decide.