Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want a girl?

267 replies

Namechanged2023 · 09/01/2023 20:27

Another thread like this, I know.

Two boys, 7 and 4. Both hard work in different ways, although lovely of course too. Both daddies boys, none of this mummy’s boy stuff which I would love.

I never ruled out a third, but DH isn’t keen as he is almost 40, I’m 5 years younger. I would really like a daughter. I know there’s no guarantee but I know plenty who’ve followed the old fashioned methods and managed it.

DH dead against it, it just feels a bit unfair that the one who doesn’t want another gets the final say, especially when he’s fine with his 2 boys, and he knew I was younger when we got married!

OP posts:
SpentDandelion · 09/01/2023 22:16

No you don't want a good girl as in people pleaser, plus she could very likely be as free spirited as her siblings. Young boys are full of energy but that stage doesn't last for ever. It's pointless comparing your friends children, be grateful your children are healthy and happy. It's just a false image you have in your mind as to how you think having a daughter will be. Enjoy your boys because before you know it they will be all grown up and introducing you to the new love in their life. Parenting boys can challenging but it is also a priverledge.

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 09/01/2023 22:14

You are not being unreasonable @Namechanged2023 It is perfectly normal for people to want one particular gender. And - I would say post 1980s - it is very common, for people to want a girl. (In the western world/ Europe/ UK/ America/ Canada especially...

It's mostly women who want a girl, but some men do too. More women wants a girl than the amount of men who do, but some men DO want a girl. I believe people who want a girl, are happy if they have 2 or 3 boys as long as they have at least ONE girl. As has been said a lot on here, most gender disappointment is when it's not a girl.

I know boys are revered in eastern parts of the world and other various continents ... But certainly in Western Europe and particularly UK, America, Canada, etc, girls are very highly desired by a lot of women/mothers.

I just have one girl born in the 1990s. I wanted a girl - I was desperate a daughter. DH desperately wanted a daughter too. We both have our reasons. We were blessed, and had a daughter. Never wanted any more children after that. Just wanted that one girl. Best thing that ever happened to us.

If I had had a boy, I don't know what I would have done. May have tried to have another one. But if I had two boys, I'm not going to lie. I would be disappointed. Not proud of that, but I would have been. And I know quite a number of people who ARE disappointed they never had a daughter. Quite sad really. I guess people have their reasons. I know me and DH have ours.

I am pretty sure that we would have loved a boy as much as we love our dear daughter, and we would never ever have let him know that we wanted a girl, but yeah, we did want a girl. You cannot help how you feel.

I have to say, of all the people I know who have just daughters, they are not disappointed that they had no sons. But, as I said, some people who had all sons, ARE disappointed they never had a daughter.

Notplayingball · 09/01/2023 22:11

You could have a girl who later wants to become a boy🤷 It happens. She could have nothing in common with you. I am not close to my own DM, or MIL.

I have four DC - all boys. I didn't find out what I was having for DC3 and 4. I just wanted children.

My eldest is almost 16yo, I have some great conversations with him, we share a love of dogs, music gigs and have a lot of other similar interests.

It's best to not be fickle only imagining dressing a girl up in tutus, playing Barbies, etc. That's a short lived part of their childhoods. They become individuals in their own right regardless of XX or XY chromosome formation.

If your DH doesn't want anymore children you need to respect him there. My DH is almost 49 and our youngest is almost 6yo. It's been a hard slog at times for DH because of his age.

BashfulClam · 09/01/2023 22:07

Ha ha yeah ‘girls confirm’, utter rubbish. Are you sure you are 34? You sound about 12.

I know someone with 4 boys due to his wife’s quest for a girl…it ended their marriage. She wanted to try fir number 5 he said no and he wanted a vasectomy, she said if he did she would divorce him. They were struggling to support themselves.

Ansjovis · 09/01/2023 22:05

Why exactly is it "unfair" that your husband gets the final say here? Your youngest is 4 and you're out of the baby stage. It is completely reasonable for your husband not to want to go back there again. Yes it's unfortunate that your family size is smaller than you would want but I'd argue that forcing him to have a third child he doesn't want is less fair.

Having a child is a two yes, one no situation. Anything other than that really is unfair.

SmileWithADimple · 09/01/2023 22:04

YANBU to have a preference for a girl - I like having different sexes so I know what you mean.

But YABVU to have another child of either sex if DH doesn't want one. In this situation the person who says no gets the deciding vote I'm afraid!

x2boys · 09/01/2023 22:03

Namechanged2023 · 09/01/2023 21:55

Also I would like to have the different experience. My DS’ are very different so I know it’s not all about gender. But whatever anyone says, it’s a different experience raising boys and girls. Girls learn to conform. I would give anything for a “good girl” who had an easier time at school.

And what if you don't get a " good girl" who doesn't have an easy time at school?
children are individual regardless of sex .

Lcb123 · 09/01/2023 21:59

Those methods are a load of rubbish - pure coincidence. Sorry but please don’t have a third in case it’s a boy as you clearly will be disappointed

Reindear · 09/01/2023 21:59

You really think all girls behave and conform?! I have a boy 10 and a girl 7. My boy has always been extremely well behaved- my daughter has never conformed to anything in her life 😂 she’s only just starting to settle aged 7. She is gorgeous but bloody hell she’s a handful! You seem to have an image of an angelic little girl - it is very unlikely. Also my dd is a total daddy’s girl

ClubhouseGift · 09/01/2023 21:59

The fact of the matter is if he says no, he doesn’t want another, that’s the end of it.

Of course the person who doesn’t want another trumps the one who does, and particularly in this circumstance you wouldn’t be having another for appropriate reasons.

Beees · 09/01/2023 21:57

Also my boys are just bloody hard work! DS1 is a complete non conformist and does the opposite of what he is meant to do, and DS2 is just a hilarious and very cute demon. All my friends’ DDs are well behaved.

Is this tongue in cheek? Your friends daughters are clearly not all well behaved and certainly no more well behaved than your children simply because they are female.

Namechanged2023 · 09/01/2023 21:55

Also I would like to have the different experience. My DS’ are very different so I know it’s not all about gender. But whatever anyone says, it’s a different experience raising boys and girls. Girls learn to conform. I would give anything for a “good girl” who had an easier time at school.

OP posts:
Namechanged2023 · 09/01/2023 21:51

It’s not so much about thinking I’ll get a best friend, it’s more shared gender experiences. I am semi close with my own DM but she keeps us at arms’ length a bit, however she is a strong feminist and I love that. Also my boys are just bloody hard work! DS1 is a complete non conformist and does the opposite of what he is meant to do, and DS2 is just a hilarious and very cute demon. All my friends’ DDs are well behaved.

Ideally I wouldn’t want to have a child with another man 😆DH far from perfect as am I. He is a great dad.

OP posts:
2FelisCatus · 09/01/2023 21:49

This will be an unpopular opinion but I'd only go for a third if you were to choose a girl and do ISI in the US or Cyprus. If I hadn't had a girl second I'd 💯 have chosen a girl for the next one.

Mistysmom · 09/01/2023 21:46

Namechanged2023 · 09/01/2023 20:37

No I would stop at 3 either way as I often wanted 3 children. I have gone through fantasies of having three little boys in the past so I wouldn’t love a boy any less, in the same way that once DS2 was here, I wouldn’t change a hair on his head even though he’s a nightmare child! The fact that I have two boys means that there’s a bonus chance of having a girl if we were to have a third.

The point about being younger is that I have plenty of time at 34, to have a third.

Unfortunately it's not as simple as that. Your odds are still still even chances even with two previous boys. I had two DS with my ex husband. Met my new husband in 2018 and I conceived last year and thought my chance of a girl would be higher as he has a DD too. Our DS was born in November and everyone thought I was disappointed but I wasn't. I love my boys and they are all mammys boys at heart. I don't miss what I've never had and we won't be trying again to see if we had a girl

Tallulasdancingshoes · 09/01/2023 21:43

This sort of post never goes down well on mumsnet. But I can see your point of view. I had ds first and was over the moon, but when I got pregnant with dc2 I hoped I was having a girl and I did. Of course I would have loved a second boy, but was overjoyed to have a girl.

OliviaFlaversham · 09/01/2023 21:27

Completely unreasonable. I think your views are toxic and I’m sure your boys must pick up on it.

KitchenDiscos · 09/01/2023 21:24

YANBU and you can’t help how you feel, but if your husband doesn’t want any more children, I’m afraid you’ll have to make your peace with that. Can you create some 1-on-1 time with each of your sons to do something together that you’ll both enjoy? Something that can be just your thing?

Aussierose2 · 09/01/2023 21:18

I had three boys and wasn't disappointed at all I don't really understand the obsession people have with having a certain gender but i will just say I have a great relationship with my boys and an awful one with my mother and know several people on the same situation having a girl doesn't mean you will best friends or anything near that

Emmamoo89 · 09/01/2023 21:13

YANBU x

Giveaschitt · 09/01/2023 21:13

Namechanged2023 · 09/01/2023 20:45

No I would stop at 3 either way as I often wanted 3 children. I have gone through fantasies of having three little boys in the past so I wouldn’t love a boy any less, in the same way that once DS2 was here, I wouldn’t change a hair on his head even though he’s a nightmare child! The fact that I have two boys means that there’s a bonus chance of having a girl if we were to have a third.

The point about being younger is that I have plenty of time at 34, to have a third.

Ha, tell that my gran - my dad is one of seven boys...

McPlant1 · 09/01/2023 21:11

I know there’s no guarantee but I know plenty who’ve followed the old fashioned methods and managed it

You know plenty of people who took a 50:50 chance and got the outcome they wanted, and, with the benefit of hindsight, put it down to their own genius. It’s all luck.

Not wrong to want a third, but wanting a girl assuming it’ll give you a better relationship and experience to your DS’ is unreasonable.

Suziesz · 09/01/2023 21:09

The fact that I have two boys means that there’s a bonus chance of having a girl if we were to have a third.

That’s not how it works. You are actually slightly more likely to have the same gender for child 3.

The point about being younger is that I have plenty of time at 34, to have a third.

I still don’t get the relevance of this. Do you mean with your husband or a new partner?
Ultimately your DH doesn’t want a third plus feels too old so is unlikely to change his mind, however difficult that is for you.

ghostyslovesheets · 09/01/2023 21:07

What will you do when it's a boy?

I have 3 girls - always knew the chances of three being a girl where high - didn't care if it was a boy or a girl though

Please don't think girls are easier! Also 2 of mine are football playing daddies girls - all of them have interests of their own - not always mine. The one thing we did as a gang was riding and they all grew out of that!

You DH isn't keen - you need to consider this as well

wishingitwasfriday · 09/01/2023 21:03

You say your husband knew you were younger when you got married, but by the same token, you knew he was older and so therefore might want to stop procreating sooner than you.
You might get pregnant and have a girl and she might be a real daddies girl. Would you then want to try for another girl?