Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think this is unacceptable of the school

437 replies

anerki101 · 09/01/2023 20:19

My DS has suspected ASC. We have been waiting ages for a meeting with the school to discuss - that's another thread!

But anyway, DS is 4. Started school in Septemeber. He is 100% toilet trained nothing day and night. Never has accidents. Accept at school. If he doesn't do his daily poo at home after school, then he poos his pants at school. Its becoming an almost daily occurance. This started at the beginning of December. In all that time the staff have only noticed ONCE that he has had an accident and changed him.

Today I found out DS had done a poo in his pants between 12 and 1. I picked him up at 4:15. He'd been sitting in his own poo for three to four hours.

AIBU to think this is totally unacceptable?

The school are aware of these accidents. I have had several discussions with his teacher about preventing, etc. Nothing has worked so far but the biggest issue is that they aren't noticing he's had an accident and leaving him to sit in it all day.

OP posts:
x2boys · 10/01/2023 20:11

Sherrystrull · 10/01/2023 20:07

I agree with this. Also an understanding from the government and parents that supporting children with toileting needs means that more money is needed to provide staff.

So why are the school not applying for an EHCP and a.1:1 for the child ?

Eyerollcentral · 10/01/2023 20:10

x2boys · 10/01/2023 20:06

Well.firstly not all children with disabilities and or SEN will have a diagnosis atv4/5 and secondly this child does have SEN
Do you really think it's acceptable to leave a small child knowingly sat in their.own waste products ??

Of course I don’t. I don’t think it’s acceptable for staff to have to change children in a mainstream school either, especially if it’s an ongoing problem.

Sherrystrull · 10/01/2023 20:07

Eyerollcentral · 10/01/2023 20:01

I don’t know how many people would be interested in early primary years education if the thought of having to deal with toileting needs was made part of the job, which many people on this thread seem to think they should blithely accept. I understand the need for all children to have access to education and completely support that, but I also think that many people seem to think it’s perfectly fine to ask a qualified professional to regularly change children of 4, 5 and older outside special needs education. This was certainly not the case even ten years ago barring the odd accident. I don’t have any answers but I think a key component here - the willingness or staff to do it and the reasonableness of asking them to do it - has been lost.

I agree with this. Also an understanding from the government and parents that supporting children with toileting needs means that more money is needed to provide staff.

x2boys · 10/01/2023 20:06

Eyerollcentral · 10/01/2023 20:01

I don’t know how many people would be interested in early primary years education if the thought of having to deal with toileting needs was made part of the job, which many people on this thread seem to think they should blithely accept. I understand the need for all children to have access to education and completely support that, but I also think that many people seem to think it’s perfectly fine to ask a qualified professional to regularly change children of 4, 5 and older outside special needs education. This was certainly not the case even ten years ago barring the odd accident. I don’t have any answers but I think a key component here - the willingness or staff to do it and the reasonableness of asking them to do it - has been lost.

Well.firstly not all children with disabilities and or SEN will have a diagnosis atv4/5 and secondly this child does have SEN
Do you really think it's acceptable to leave a small child knowingly sat in their.own waste products ??

Eyerollcentral · 10/01/2023 20:01

I don’t know how many people would be interested in early primary years education if the thought of having to deal with toileting needs was made part of the job, which many people on this thread seem to think they should blithely accept. I understand the need for all children to have access to education and completely support that, but I also think that many people seem to think it’s perfectly fine to ask a qualified professional to regularly change children of 4, 5 and older outside special needs education. This was certainly not the case even ten years ago barring the odd accident. I don’t have any answers but I think a key component here - the willingness or staff to do it and the reasonableness of asking them to do it - has been lost.

Zonder · 10/01/2023 19:57

Little snippet from an NASUWT document.

AIBU to think this is unacceptable of the school
Zonder · 10/01/2023 19:51

It’s my job to educate him. It’s not my job to make conditions perfect for him, in order to make that learning possible.

This is one of the most shocking misunderstandings I've seen a teacher say. I hope there's some good SEN inset coming up soon in that person's school.

Patineur · 10/01/2023 19:18

x2boys · 10/01/2023 12:05

According to the ERIC website if a school.knowingly leaves a child wet and or soiled it could be deemed as neglect .

Yes, they're right. And it's something Ofsted would have a field day with if they discovered it.

ThisGirlNever · 10/01/2023 15:04

x2boys · 10/01/2023 12:05

According to the ERIC website if a school.knowingly leaves a child wet and or soiled it could be deemed as neglect .

They don't know, because there isn't an intimate care plan in place. They can only ask the boy.

FoxCorner · 10/01/2023 12:17

Maybe you and the teachers could take him to see all the toilets in school as there might be one he'd be happy to use. You could then apply for funding for an extra person to be able to take him there when needed if he can show a card or something. Or if not to help him clean himself. The teacher and TA probably wouldn't be able to get away from the class to do that.

x2boys · 10/01/2023 12:05

Pumperthepumper · 09/01/2023 20:26

You need to get him to a GP then. It’s not the school’s place to clean up your kid.

According to the ERIC website if a school.knowingly leaves a child wet and or soiled it could be deemed as neglect .

User2346 · 10/01/2023 12:00

Patineur · 10/01/2023 11:55

Parents don't need lawyers. There is plenty of information and support out there, and over 90% of tribunal appeals are won by parents - only a relatively small minority of those are represented by lawyers.

Absolutely and a few of us have suggested IPSEA and SOSISEN I was just answering the other poster who feels there should be some kind of bespoke service for Ehcp’s and there is if you can afford to pay for it.

Patineur · 10/01/2023 11:58

OP, I would suggest you ask your GP for a referral for an ASC assessment. That shouldn't stop you doing it through the school as well, but it won't hurt to have two potential routes in place. In the meantime, you don't have to have a diagnosis to get an EHCP in place.

Patineur · 10/01/2023 11:55

User2346 · 10/01/2023 07:29

Oh there are , they are SEN lawyers plus private Ed Psychs etc and the LA’s employ barristers to fight parents to prevent them getting EHCP’s, If you have sharp elbows and deep pockets its there. What average parent can afford £20k for lawyers plus around £10k for Ed Psych etc reports?

Parents don't need lawyers. There is plenty of information and support out there, and over 90% of tribunal appeals are won by parents - only a relatively small minority of those are represented by lawyers.

Zonder · 10/01/2023 08:23

@anerki101 while going in at lunchtime is a good short time answer please do not take this on as a long term habit.

People have already mentioned bringing up the poo issue with the GP and that it's possible they might have a solution.

However I have worked with lots of schools and teachers who do not take responsibility for the SEN child on their roll. They have to work with you to find a solution and it can't be long term that you come in every lunchtime. This is a disability access issue as I've mentioned up thread. They can't just ignore it when it's not an impossible thing to monitor.

Posters getting mad at you for not going in every lunchtime even when you said early on that you would don't seem to understand the responsibility of the school. I'm saying this as an advisory SEN teacher who often has to remind schools of their responsibility.

NightTerrors · 10/01/2023 08:10

*let alone talk to some adults.

NightTerrors · 10/01/2023 08:08

Some of these comments from apparent teachers are terrifying, thankfully my teaching relatives assure me that it's not the norm for a child to be so blatantly neglected. This isn't a one off incident, this is a regular occurance so why haven't the school Senco been more pro-active? Something needs to be happening and the school should be working with the OP to help her child.

For those suggesting OP should have got a deferral - have you ever actually tried to get a deferral? They need to be approved and that's only done if it's seen to benefit the child. They don't just hand them out that easily, then there's the fact that her son is toilet trained everywhere other than school, a deferral might not even have helped so he'd be held back a year for nothing.

My child is due to start school I'm September, she is very intelligent and independent but she has huge problems with socialising, will refuse to even look at - let alone - some adults and won't communicate her needs at times. She is also toilet trained but has had accidents before when being babysat (people.she knows) because she didn't talk to express her needs ALL day. She also struggles with noise - even low level noise. She is OK at nursery thankfully but I have no idea how she will be at school which is much bigger and much louder. The lack of compassion and in some cases downright callousness from teachers in this thread are so worrying.

Mombie · 10/01/2023 07:30

@Eyerollcentral Many children are reluctant to go to school and it takes them a long time to settle in. Even the most academic highest flyer might struggle in another aspect of learning. Yes, they can go to the toilet and sit on the carpet like an angel but can they feed themselves, share, manage their emotions and arguably why aren’t they ripping around the class with the others? Why is a 4 year old sitting on the bloody carpet so compliantly? Would I ask those children to come back in another year? No. Just because this element of development is smellier and more inconvenient does not mean it can not be managed. It is the job of all of adults, parents included to do this. Neurodiversity in the classroom and in the wider world is a wonderful thing. You don’t stamp it out of tell it to come back at a more convenient time. I might sound like an airy-fairy EYFS dreamer but I’m happy to own that title.

I agree that more and more children are coming in not having been toilet trained. At our school, we have these conversations with parents during transition and settling in. We advise and signpost them to appropriate agencies, we have difficult conversations about how this may impact learning later on in the year and if need be we work with the Senco to support that child and make adjustments.

User2346 · 10/01/2023 07:29

Pumperthepumper · 09/01/2023 23:53

If schools are not prepared to support parents (which is not my experience at all) then surely that indicates a need for a specialised Parental EHCP Service? A helpful third party? Why isn’t that already in place?

Oh there are , they are SEN lawyers plus private Ed Psychs etc and the LA’s employ barristers to fight parents to prevent them getting EHCP’s, If you have sharp elbows and deep pockets its there. What average parent can afford £20k for lawyers plus around £10k for Ed Psych etc reports?

SnowlayRoundabout · 10/01/2023 00:53

Pumperthepumper · 10/01/2023 00:03

@SnowlayRoundabout please stop quoting my posts and ignoring follow-ups. It’s disingenuous and it makes responding to you totally pointless.

I've been responding to posts in time order. I haven't ignored one single follow-up of yours unless it is a point I or someone else have already answered.

TimeToFlyNow · 10/01/2023 00:52

My ds has asd and wasn't even out of nappies until he was 5 and we never had a problem with school changing him.

He's 9 now and never has accidents but also doesn't use the school toilets, says he just doesn't like to.

The school should be working with you on this. Can you email the second directly?

Eyerollcentral · 10/01/2023 00:52

SnowlayRoundabout · 10/01/2023 00:39

You haven't come up with a solution that doesn't depend on breaching the Equality Act one way or another. OP's child is entitled to start school at the same time as his peers, and in fact there is no reason to believe that keeping him out a year is going to resolve this given that he is fully toilet trained and the problem lies with the school toilets. So what happens if he goes back next year and the problem happens again? Is he supposed to go through life without any education at all?

The school isn't entitled to demand that parents come in to do their jobs for them; it is a massive bonus that OP is willing to, but schools really should be capable of dealing with this without that. This school is doing nothing to facilitate OP's help by phoning her when she is needed. Schools can't just let random parents come into school and haul their children out at odd times of the day, so you blaming OP for not taking matters into her own hands falls very wide of the mark.

What is really needed is a discussion with the SENCO, and that is what no-one is bothering to arrange.

Hmmm but it doesn’t seem to be benefiting the child to start school now. He is reluctant to go and is now soiling himself very regularly. Regardless of the child’s entitlement it doesn’t seem to be working for him.

SnowlayRoundabout · 10/01/2023 00:51

Pumperthepumper · 09/01/2023 23:55

No, it doesn’t. It’s my job to educate him. It’s not my job to make conditions perfect for him, in order to make that learning possible.

Schools have a statutory duty to use their best endeavours to meet the needs of their pupils. That includes covering all aspects of education which, as the SEND Code of Practice makes clear, is not limited to cognition and learning - it includes meeting communication, social, emotional and mental health needs, and sensory and physical needs. That certainly means doing what is necessary to provide the best possible conditions and environment. For example, if a child is sensitive to noise the EHCP may require a quiet environment, sensory breaks, and a quiet space the child can retreat to. If the child has tactile sensitivity, it may mean allowing uniform concessions so that they are not uncomfortable. And if the child is incontinent, it certainly means the school needs provision in place for cleaning and nappy/clothes changing.

If you haven't understood that to be the case and therefore haven't been supporting EHCP applications when the school is unable to meet those needs within its normal resources, I would suggest you start now.

SnowlayRoundabout · 10/01/2023 00:42

Pumperthepumper · 09/01/2023 23:53

If schools are not prepared to support parents (which is not my experience at all) then surely that indicates a need for a specialised Parental EHCP Service? A helpful third party? Why isn’t that already in place?

Well, there is SENDIAS, though I know that is of variable quality. Schools are also free to refer parents to charities like SOS SEN, IPSEA, NAS etc who offer a lot of support and help.

SnowlayRoundabout · 10/01/2023 00:39

Autumndays123 · 09/01/2023 23:49

I've read the thread, thanks. It truly pains me that we live in a society with so many parents lacking basic critical thinking skills and parenting ability. This is actually a really, really simple problem to solve and I'm completely at a loss as to why everyone is pandering to the OP when she has listed excuses in response to any solutions (until a very recent post where she did a complete 360). OP can take her son home at lunchtime to poo for starters.

And actually, I would say that keeping the child behind a year would be beneficial. He's clearly not ready for school, regardless of how academic he is and it's not fair on him or his teachers to have him shitting himself every day with no sign of stopping. I would however advise that you read the thread, as OP has said several times that she's spoken at length to the teacher about it, so I'm not sure where your comment "no one is bothering to discuss it with the OP" is coming from. You've just pulled that out of your arse to suit your narrative.

You haven't come up with a solution that doesn't depend on breaching the Equality Act one way or another. OP's child is entitled to start school at the same time as his peers, and in fact there is no reason to believe that keeping him out a year is going to resolve this given that he is fully toilet trained and the problem lies with the school toilets. So what happens if he goes back next year and the problem happens again? Is he supposed to go through life without any education at all?

The school isn't entitled to demand that parents come in to do their jobs for them; it is a massive bonus that OP is willing to, but schools really should be capable of dealing with this without that. This school is doing nothing to facilitate OP's help by phoning her when she is needed. Schools can't just let random parents come into school and haul their children out at odd times of the day, so you blaming OP for not taking matters into her own hands falls very wide of the mark.

What is really needed is a discussion with the SENCO, and that is what no-one is bothering to arrange.