Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think this is unacceptable of the school

437 replies

anerki101 · 09/01/2023 20:19

My DS has suspected ASC. We have been waiting ages for a meeting with the school to discuss - that's another thread!

But anyway, DS is 4. Started school in Septemeber. He is 100% toilet trained nothing day and night. Never has accidents. Accept at school. If he doesn't do his daily poo at home after school, then he poos his pants at school. Its becoming an almost daily occurance. This started at the beginning of December. In all that time the staff have only noticed ONCE that he has had an accident and changed him.

Today I found out DS had done a poo in his pants between 12 and 1. I picked him up at 4:15. He'd been sitting in his own poo for three to four hours.

AIBU to think this is totally unacceptable?

The school are aware of these accidents. I have had several discussions with his teacher about preventing, etc. Nothing has worked so far but the biggest issue is that they aren't noticing he's had an accident and leaving him to sit in it all day.

OP posts:
Patineur · 11/01/2023 08:25

Eyerollcentral · 10/01/2023 20:26

Yes TAs who are employed as 1:1s. That’s not the case here or for many other TAs who have to deal with these issues.

What do you mean? If a child needs help with toileting and does not have an EHCP, the school cannot ignore that fact.. Unless the school has a nurse or welfare assistant - which is unusual - helping such children will, in primary schools at least, be a normal part of TAs' job descriptions.

NewYearNewCareer · 11/01/2023 08:12

If you don’t understand perhaps you should visit a local school. Some classes have 50% SEN and a lot of classes have poor behavior which isn’t SEN related.
Teachers are run ragged with chairs being thrown, kids fighting and being rude and disruptive.

How can anyone be expected to work in these conditions and produce high level outcomes?

Zonder · 11/01/2023 07:27

And of course not every school will have that same figure. And some SEN can be supported without needing lots of extra money. It totally depends on what the SEN is. For example VI children may just need larger font or different seating arrangements. It's not that clear cut really.

Zonder · 11/01/2023 07:24

@ThisGirlNever well they will be getting more SEN funding than some schools because it's based on the number of SEN in the previous year. Plus there's something of a correlation between PP and Sen (not totally obviously) so they may well have more PP money than many schools.

The funding still won't be enough though because of the huge cuts over the years.

ThisGirlNever · 11/01/2023 07:22

Can any education system fund 30% SEN (in a regular school), as per @PeacockMansion's previous post?

Zonder · 10/01/2023 23:07

@ThisGirlNever the issue isn't abuse of the EHCP system. The issue is the reduction in funding of schools in real terms over the course of the Tory government. Hence no money for replacing TAs, harder to recruit a senco and harder to recruit teachers. Who wants to do the job when in real terms the salary has reduced massively in real terms?
On top of that the government have put more and more pressure on schools to "perform" and produce greater sats results while at the same time running down the profession by criticising them constantly.
Covid did for a lot of teachers. Constant changes at very short notice, high expectations with no support... Schools desperately trying to pick up the pieces.

ThisGirlNever · 10/01/2023 22:51

@PeacockMansion

That sounds awful.

Is the EHCP system being abused/misused?

I don't understand where all these kids are appearing from. Why are there suddenly so many kids needing so much support?

Are they kids that would have just managed in the past? Now the system is expected to accommodate them, rather than the kids fitting into the system?

GHRT · 10/01/2023 21:53

@anerki101 If you feel a EHCP is needed are you aware that you can apply without school support? Organisations such as Sunshine Support can help.

PeacockMansion · 10/01/2023 21:13

Schools are slowly being choked of resources. My school has no SENDCo (no staff willing to train and no applications after two rounds of advertising), no site manager, two long term supply teachers, two supply TAs, 30% SEN aware (no funding) and limited ehcp funding. The school budget is in deficit and 5 TAs have left leaving 4 behind. No plans to recruit as the budget can't stretch. Mixed year group classes and several children that had very high behaviour needs so Headteacher and other adults are with them almost all day to stop harm to others. LA will not support suspensions at this point. So here we are. Staff cry regularly despite a supportive head. That's the reality for us and colleagues in a number of schools report similar circumstances. We cannot minimise the pressures faced by school staff at this time. It's appalling your child isn't being changed and you cannot get a meeting. But it is most likely not apathy or lack of compassion, but a broken system being held up by the sheer determination of staff to keep turning up every day to hope that they can make a difference and keep going just a bit longer.

Dippydinosaurus · 10/01/2023 21:06

The school will have an intimate care policy. Meet with the teacher and senco and ask them to help you in line with this

ProhibitedSteps · 10/01/2023 20:46

@ouch321 It's not for 30 kids ffs! This child has suspected ASD! They have to make adjustments by LAW!!!!!

Somuchgoo · 10/01/2023 20:42

Eyerollcentral · 10/01/2023 20:32

I have only ever said every child deserves the right to access education. Where children have medical conditions or special needs they need to be supported. I’ve also said I haven’t got all the answers. I simply said that it’s all well and good saying x, y and z should happen but it’s unfair to ask people who haven’t signed up to that job to expect them to deal with personal care. It’s an unpopular position here I know but I think many people don’t understand what it’s actually like to have 30 small children and at best two pairs of hands to deal with them. Surely people can see that as well as acknowledging that children are entitled to education. You have said your daughter’s needs are easy to manage so I’m not sure why you have taken personal offence at what I have said.

Her physical conditions yes, but she will have a poo 'accident' between 1-4 times a day.

It's unpleasant, but it would be excessive and unfair to her, to take her out of mainstream for that alone. It would take away valuable resources from children that need the specialist provision.

Thankfully her future school is totally on board with doing personal care where needed.

Mombie · 10/01/2023 20:41

I agree that parents and staff do need to have a better understand on what happens in Early Years. We have had staff come in thinking it’s all playdough and singing and then leave because they couldn't handle how busy it is. We have parents come in and ruin the beautiful outdoor provision that we have set up for children because they don’t value the learning behind it. As a qualified professional I don’t think it is beneath me to change a soiled child and I have shared this job with my TA. The key thing is that you have SLT support to do your job. If it was the case that people just aren’t toilet training their children then we are firm with parents at the outset. However, this is a child with a need and a parent willing to engage in this case. I don’t love that part of Early Years but I know that as a parent I wouldn’t want my child sitting in poop all afternoon and as a Teacher, a child sitting in poop is not learning anything. How can I honestly then say that I did everything I can to help that child make progress?

As another poster pointed out, if you spend some time at the outset ironing outbuilding trusting relationships with the children and ironing out the issues, you can get on with everything else.

Sherrystrull · 10/01/2023 20:38

You're aware of the process as a parent of a child in a special school.

I'm explaining the issues that affect children in a mainstream school from the perspective of a class teacher who is trying to meet the needs of my class of 31 when I am alone in the classroom.

Without support and funding I cannot provide the right support but funding takes forever and so many children are waiting for it.

x2boys · 10/01/2023 20:33

Sherrystrull · 10/01/2023 20:29

@x2boys

Funding in schools is abysmal. We are trying to get support for children with severe learning difficulties or mental health needs. A child with no educational needs and only toileting needs would not be top of the list.

I've got 4 children in my class waiting for an ADHD diagnosis. One has been on the waiting list for nearly 2 years.

No funding = no support

I have a child in a special school with a full EHCP I'm aware of the process ,I realise some LEA,s are better than others in providing support ,but are parents being sign posted to th SENDIASS, the local offer etc?

Eyerollcentral · 10/01/2023 20:32

Somuchgoo · 10/01/2023 20:21

So where does my child go?

She's nowhere near disabled enough to go to the local special needs school, and they cater primarily for children with severe learning difficulties and complex and profound needs

There is specialist autism provision, but she does not have autism.

But she has a serious health condition and is currently not continent. Educationally she is best placed in mainstream. Socially sure is best placed in mainstream. Her other physical disabilities are easy for the school to manage.

Where exactly does she get an education according to you?

What about children whose only health condition is a bowel abnormality for example?

I have only ever said every child deserves the right to access education. Where children have medical conditions or special needs they need to be supported. I’ve also said I haven’t got all the answers. I simply said that it’s all well and good saying x, y and z should happen but it’s unfair to ask people who haven’t signed up to that job to expect them to deal with personal care. It’s an unpopular position here I know but I think many people don’t understand what it’s actually like to have 30 small children and at best two pairs of hands to deal with them. Surely people can see that as well as acknowledging that children are entitled to education. You have said your daughter’s needs are easy to manage so I’m not sure why you have taken personal offence at what I have said.

countrym0u53 · 10/01/2023 20:32

Gosh this is such a disheartening read.

As a former teacher and parent of a current asc reception child, I find it so sad the blame being landed at the foot of the parents.

My son is still not toilet trained. I have tried relentlessly, everything I can think of, followed every bit of advice from OT, paediatrician etc. but we still haven't mastered it. He's waiting on a referral to the continence team. Thankfully my sons ehcp includes a toileting plan.

I'm testament to the fact that you can try every damn thing and still not manage it.

Getting support and a diagnosis is an enormous battle. The notion that you can simply send your child to a specialist school is a myth. We were told my child would never get a place at a specialist school as his needs weren't great enough - despite the fact he isn't toilet trained

x2boys · 10/01/2023 20:30

Zonder · 10/01/2023 20:25

@Somuchgoo some people not me on here would suggest you have to go in throughout the school day to sort your child's toilet needs. I hope you don't have a job of your own!

And the ERIC website would point out that a school who asks a parent to go in to change a child could be considered neglectful.

Sherrystrull · 10/01/2023 20:29

@x2boys

Funding in schools is abysmal. We are trying to get support for children with severe learning difficulties or mental health needs. A child with no educational needs and only toileting needs would not be top of the list.

I've got 4 children in my class waiting for an ADHD diagnosis. One has been on the waiting list for nearly 2 years.

No funding = no support

Eyerollcentral · 10/01/2023 20:26

Patineur · 10/01/2023 20:16

These issues are normally dealt with on a day to day basis by TAs, and it tends to be made clear in job adverts and job descriptions. Indeed, some TAs are expressly recruited to provide 1:1 support for children known to need personal care. They're hardly going to object if that's the job they agreed to take on.

Yes TAs who are employed as 1:1s. That’s not the case here or for many other TAs who have to deal with these issues.

Zonder · 10/01/2023 20:25

@Somuchgoo some people not me on here would suggest you have to go in throughout the school day to sort your child's toilet needs. I hope you don't have a job of your own!

Somuchgoo · 10/01/2023 20:21

Eyerollcentral · 10/01/2023 20:10

Of course I don’t. I don’t think it’s acceptable for staff to have to change children in a mainstream school either, especially if it’s an ongoing problem.

So where does my child go?

She's nowhere near disabled enough to go to the local special needs school, and they cater primarily for children with severe learning difficulties and complex and profound needs

There is specialist autism provision, but she does not have autism.

But she has a serious health condition and is currently not continent. Educationally she is best placed in mainstream. Socially sure is best placed in mainstream. Her other physical disabilities are easy for the school to manage.

Where exactly does she get an education according to you?

What about children whose only health condition is a bowel abnormality for example?

Patineur · 10/01/2023 20:20

Eyerollcentral · 10/01/2023 20:15

Because presumably the child hasn’t been officially recognised as having a SEN. The OP has said they’ve been trying to arrange an appointment with SENCO, a service highly under pressure because so many children are being referred to them. That’s not any child’s fault but I think it’s unfair to lay everything at the teaching staff’s door as a result of that. And let’s face it 9 times out of 10 it will be a poorly paid TA dealing the actual toileting issue. It’s a complex issue but I’m merely pointing out that people saying it’s fine and staff can deal with it are being really unfair to the staff. It’s not the job they signed up to do.

You don't have to have an official diagnosis for an EHCP.

I think you may be confused about SENCOs. They aren't a service, they are people which every maintained school, academy and free school must have on their staff, normally qualified teachers, who have responsibility for working with teachers to identify children in the school with SEN and provide the right support for them. As such, they should be reasonably freely available to parents like OP.

Patineur · 10/01/2023 20:16

Eyerollcentral · 10/01/2023 20:01

I don’t know how many people would be interested in early primary years education if the thought of having to deal with toileting needs was made part of the job, which many people on this thread seem to think they should blithely accept. I understand the need for all children to have access to education and completely support that, but I also think that many people seem to think it’s perfectly fine to ask a qualified professional to regularly change children of 4, 5 and older outside special needs education. This was certainly not the case even ten years ago barring the odd accident. I don’t have any answers but I think a key component here - the willingness or staff to do it and the reasonableness of asking them to do it - has been lost.

These issues are normally dealt with on a day to day basis by TAs, and it tends to be made clear in job adverts and job descriptions. Indeed, some TAs are expressly recruited to provide 1:1 support for children known to need personal care. They're hardly going to object if that's the job they agreed to take on.

Eyerollcentral · 10/01/2023 20:15

Because presumably the child hasn’t been officially recognised as having a SEN. The OP has said they’ve been trying to arrange an appointment with SENCO, a service highly under pressure because so many children are being referred to them. That’s not any child’s fault but I think it’s unfair to lay everything at the teaching staff’s door as a result of that. And let’s face it 9 times out of 10 it will be a poorly paid TA dealing the actual toileting issue. It’s a complex issue but I’m merely pointing out that people saying it’s fine and staff can deal with it are being really unfair to the staff. It’s not the job they signed up to do.

Swipe left for the next trending thread