Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think this is unacceptable of the school

437 replies

anerki101 · 09/01/2023 20:19

My DS has suspected ASC. We have been waiting ages for a meeting with the school to discuss - that's another thread!

But anyway, DS is 4. Started school in Septemeber. He is 100% toilet trained nothing day and night. Never has accidents. Accept at school. If he doesn't do his daily poo at home after school, then he poos his pants at school. Its becoming an almost daily occurance. This started at the beginning of December. In all that time the staff have only noticed ONCE that he has had an accident and changed him.

Today I found out DS had done a poo in his pants between 12 and 1. I picked him up at 4:15. He'd been sitting in his own poo for three to four hours.

AIBU to think this is totally unacceptable?

The school are aware of these accidents. I have had several discussions with his teacher about preventing, etc. Nothing has worked so far but the biggest issue is that they aren't noticing he's had an accident and leaving him to sit in it all day.

OP posts:
neverbeenskiing · 13/01/2023 16:14

Pumperthepumper · 09/01/2023 21:25

How do they do that when there are 29 other kids in the class with their own problems needing strategies and additional work with parents? Keeping in mind that the job of the school is to provide his education, not his medical support.

Actually their job is to educate and support with medical issues. If this wasn't the case many children with physical health issues or learning disabilities simply wouldn't be able to access mainstream school. Although judging by some of the callous and ableist responses on this thread some people would clearly be fine with that.

I work in a school and we have written care plans, which are completed in collaboration with the school nurse or other health professionals, for any children with any toileting/personal care needs. Staff can and do carry out personal care for students who need it, in accordance with their care plans. We don't just throw up our hands and say "we've got other children to deal with, they'll just have to get on with it". These children have rights and they deserve to be treated with dignity. No one I know who actually works in education would think it was acceptable to leave a child sitting in their own excrement for hours every day.

OP, if you have repeatedly asked to meet with the senco and this has not happened then it would be reasonable to contact the Head directly.

Patineur · 13/01/2023 15:49

Eyerollcentral · 11/01/2023 13:39

Of course. But beyond that I simply feel it’s unfair. I don’t know what the solution to that is but a lot of people assume people should just suck it up. It’s not what they signed up for.

Usually it is exactly what they signed up for. It is virtually inevitable that there will be some children with toileting problems in every average sized mainstream primary school, and when they recruit TAs that will be part of the job description. So it won't ever come as a surprise that it is expected.

Sartre · 13/01/2023 15:47

Without being crass, shit absolutely stinks. If someone has done a poo in the room, it must be completely noticeable to everyone in that room. If my DS has pooed in his nappy then we all know about it. There’s just no way the staff don’t know, unless they all have covid and can’t smell? Surely other children would also point it out? Of course they shouldn’t leave him sitting in soiled pants for hours, it’s neglect.

Patineur · 13/01/2023 15:45

ThisGirlNever · 11/01/2023 09:54

But is that sustainable?

TAs earn around £12k.

If a class of 30 kids has 2 TAs, that's probably another £35k+ added to the class budget when you factor in pensions, employer's NI, admin overhead, etc.

That's a lot of money on a national level.

Making it a legal responsibility, doesn't magic money out of thin air.

Until very recently, I suspect that a lot of kids with minor ASD issues would have just gone to school and learned. Now they have a legal right to XYZ support. That money comes out of the education budget and can't be spent on other things.

Apart from Norway, I can't think of any countries that can afford to spend the money required to fulfill these legal obligations.

The local authority has an obligation to fund EHCP support. It can do that in part by delegated funding so that the school can use the funding to the best effect possible, e.g. by sharing TAs where possible, using economies of scale etc, but the bottom line is that it has an absolute duty to ensure that provision in EHCPs is delivered because it has been assessed that that is what the child needs in order to access education.

Just having minor ASD issues does not give a legal right to particular support. There is an overall duty on schools to use best endeavours to meet SEN, but when it comes to individualised support it is is necessary to have an EHCP, which no child will get if all they have is "minor ASD issues".

It makes plenty of sense economically to do our best to educate all children. Failure to do so will leave significant numbers unable to be economically independent, so that rather than being net contributors to public funds they will become lifelong claimants. Worst case scenario, they may end up in the justice system which is extremely expensive. The more we can do to minimise that possibility, the better.

JustKeepBuilding · 11/01/2023 16:34

JanusTheFirst it is a naive TA working in reception that doesn’t expect there to be some personal care as part of the job.


An acquaintance lost her DC's 1 to 1 at Christmas, as she found a job she liked more and paid better. The school has been unable to recruit another. This is not for want of trying, nobody wants the job. The school is very understaffed as it is.

Your acquaintance should contact the LA as it is them with ultimate responsibility for ensuring the provision is provided. LAs can fund the 1:1 at a substantially higher rate at whatever level it takes in order to provide the provision. LAs won’t do so unless forced, but parents can force the LA’s hand, via judicial review if necessary (if the EHCP is specified and quantified).

DS3’s 1:1s are funded at a higher rate, and I have supported many other parents both on MN and IRL to force their LA to fund the 1:1 at a higher rate where the school say they can’t recruit and every single time it has resulted in an appropriate appointment. Including one where the 1:1 was funded at the level of teaching main pay scale.

JanusTheFirst · 11/01/2023 16:16

I think the difficulty is that it's not what potential TAs expect when applying for a job in a mainstream school. In SEN schools it would be expected and applicants would know that.

Quite a few TAs are actually qualified teachers who have decided to step back from that role. To use them to clean up DCs is a waste of their skills. I would propose a specific TA with a role similar to a school nurse, more like that of a carer, to cater for all DCs with those specific needs in the school.

An acquaintance lost her DC's 1 to 1 at Christmas, as she found a job she liked more and paid better. The school has been unable to recruit another. This is not for want of trying, nobody wants the job. The school is very understaffed as it is.

There are times when the DC has to deal with accidents himself because there is literally no one spare to help.

inthekitchensink · 11/01/2023 14:31

I work as an LSA in reception and I do check regularly on the children whose parents have flagged toileting. There have been the odd incident where a child has wet themselves and not disclosed and I not noticed which I feel terrible about. If it was poo I would remind them to go regularly, ask them and have a surreptitious sniff in that part of the classroom. It would not be too much of an ask at all. Not sure why we are getting such a bashing on here!

Please pack spares - all our spare pants supplies went in the first half term and none have been returned. I’m sure it’s the same across all schools!

Eyerollcentral · 11/01/2023 13:39

x2boys · 11/01/2023 13:22

Well.it will be if they are employed as a child ,s 1:1 as part of their EHCP ,and personal.care is part of their role.

Of course. But beyond that I simply feel it’s unfair. I don’t know what the solution to that is but a lot of people assume people should just suck it up. It’s not what they signed up for.

JustKeepBuilding · 11/01/2023 13:25

Eyerollcentral · 11/01/2023 13:09

Being a nurse involves a huge amount of personal care though. Being a TA is supposed to involve helping the teacher manage and educate the class, personal care is not supposed to be a major element of their employment.

For many DC with SEN part of educating them is personal care.

x2boys · 11/01/2023 13:22

Eyerollcentral · 11/01/2023 13:09

Being a nurse involves a huge amount of personal care though. Being a TA is supposed to involve helping the teacher manage and educate the class, personal care is not supposed to be a major element of their employment.

Well.it will be if they are employed as a child ,s 1:1 as part of their EHCP ,and personal.care is part of their role.

Eyerollcentral · 11/01/2023 13:09

x2boys · 11/01/2023 12:35

But obviously there are people that will do it and if they apply for a job where personal care is a requirement than that will be part of their role
I was a dementia care nurse for years ,personal care wssent my favourite part of the job either ,,but it was an essential part of the job which nursing staff and health care assistants had to do

Being a nurse involves a huge amount of personal care though. Being a TA is supposed to involve helping the teacher manage and educate the class, personal care is not supposed to be a major element of their employment.

x2boys · 11/01/2023 12:35

Eyerollcentral · 11/01/2023 11:08

I’m just saying I wouldn’t want to change an older child and I wouldn’t want to do it for £12,000 a year either. Don’t think that’s a controversial point.

But obviously there are people that will do it and if they apply for a job where personal care is a requirement than that will be part of their role
I was a dementia care nurse for years ,personal care wssent my favourite part of the job either ,,but it was an essential part of the job which nursing staff and health care assistants had to do

x2boys · 11/01/2023 12:30

ThisGirlNever · 11/01/2023 09:54

But is that sustainable?

TAs earn around £12k.

If a class of 30 kids has 2 TAs, that's probably another £35k+ added to the class budget when you factor in pensions, employer's NI, admin overhead, etc.

That's a lot of money on a national level.

Making it a legal responsibility, doesn't magic money out of thin air.

Until very recently, I suspect that a lot of kids with minor ASD issues would have just gone to school and learned. Now they have a legal right to XYZ support. That money comes out of the education budget and can't be spent on other things.

Apart from Norway, I can't think of any countries that can afford to spend the money required to fulfill these legal obligations.

Not all children with autism will need an EHCP,and a 1:1
I think.my LEA is better than most ,we have two LEA,special primary schools and Two LEA special high schools and colleges ,we also.have two primary schools with ASD,Hubs and Two high schools with ASD,Hubs and.still not every child's needs are met.

User2346 · 11/01/2023 11:34

JustKeepBuilding · 11/01/2023 10:47

Making it a legal responsibility, doesn't magic money out of thin air.

And yet LAs can afford to spend large sums of money hiring barristers to defend indefensible cases against unrepresented parents. If the general public knew how much they were spending on this they would be aghast.

You are 100% correct most people have no idea the lengths the LA’s go to to prevent children getting Ehcp’s putting out awful experts reports not fit for purpose and spending 6 figure numbers on barristers and legal teams to fight parents also telling schools to discourage parents for applying. Google Mark Small from Baker Small and you will get a snapshot of what parents are up against.

JustKeepBuilding · 11/01/2023 11:26

ThisGirlNever · 11/01/2023 11:07

@JustKeepBuilding which suggests the money at stake is huge - or it would in the private sector. Whether local authorities have completed a thorough cost/benefit analysis is another matter.

Yes, the sums are large sometimes. But the LAs know they are going to lose the vast, vast majority of appeals, they just know a) not all will appeal or see an appeal through to the end, and b) it kicks the can further down the road. These DC often then need more support longer term, and thus more funding, than they would if support had been forthcoming earlier.

Eyerollcentral · 11/01/2023 11:08

Patineur · 11/01/2023 08:25

What do you mean? If a child needs help with toileting and does not have an EHCP, the school cannot ignore that fact.. Unless the school has a nurse or welfare assistant - which is unusual - helping such children will, in primary schools at least, be a normal part of TAs' job descriptions.

I’m just saying I wouldn’t want to change an older child and I wouldn’t want to do it for £12,000 a year either. Don’t think that’s a controversial point.

ThisGirlNever · 11/01/2023 11:07

@JustKeepBuilding which suggests the money at stake is huge - or it would in the private sector. Whether local authorities have completed a thorough cost/benefit analysis is another matter.

JustKeepBuilding · 11/01/2023 10:47

ThisGirlNever · 11/01/2023 09:54

But is that sustainable?

TAs earn around £12k.

If a class of 30 kids has 2 TAs, that's probably another £35k+ added to the class budget when you factor in pensions, employer's NI, admin overhead, etc.

That's a lot of money on a national level.

Making it a legal responsibility, doesn't magic money out of thin air.

Until very recently, I suspect that a lot of kids with minor ASD issues would have just gone to school and learned. Now they have a legal right to XYZ support. That money comes out of the education budget and can't be spent on other things.

Apart from Norway, I can't think of any countries that can afford to spend the money required to fulfill these legal obligations.

Making it a legal responsibility, doesn't magic money out of thin air.

And yet LAs can afford to spend large sums of money hiring barristers to defend indefensible cases against unrepresented parents. If the general public knew how much they were spending on this they would be aghast.

JustKeepBuilding · 11/01/2023 10:46

Patineur · 11/01/2023 08:49

It seems to me that the issue is that the EHCP system is underused. Schools tend to soldier on for too long without applying for EHCPs, encouraged by LAs that don't like applications and which fail to train SENCOs properly in what the relevant legal requirements are. All too often, teachers on these threads demonstrate that they don't know what the criteria are or how to frame evidence and the contents of EHCPs to ensure that the required support is properly specified.

If schools were more proactive about applying for EHCPs or supporting parents to do so, and also supporting parents with tribunal appeals where necessary, they could radically improve their own positions.

Completely agree. Along with the mess that is SENDIST because LAs are refusing to assess &/or issue and when they do issue an EHCP issuing an unlawful one because LAs know a) not all parents will appeal, and b) even if they do the waits are extremely long.

ThisGirlNever · 11/01/2023 10:04

anerki101 · 09/01/2023 23:49

Don't know about you but I need to go when I need to go. I can't shit on demand. It's ready when it's ready.

Strange.

I have control over my bowels and can squeeze out a poo (maybe not a big one) if I sit there long enough.

It seems incredibly defeatist (which others have already commented on) to just say it can't be done without even trying.

Given your son is shitting himself every day at school, I'd have thought anything was worth a try.

ThisGirlNever · 11/01/2023 09:54

Patineur · 11/01/2023 08:49

It seems to me that the issue is that the EHCP system is underused. Schools tend to soldier on for too long without applying for EHCPs, encouraged by LAs that don't like applications and which fail to train SENCOs properly in what the relevant legal requirements are. All too often, teachers on these threads demonstrate that they don't know what the criteria are or how to frame evidence and the contents of EHCPs to ensure that the required support is properly specified.

If schools were more proactive about applying for EHCPs or supporting parents to do so, and also supporting parents with tribunal appeals where necessary, they could radically improve their own positions.

But is that sustainable?

TAs earn around £12k.

If a class of 30 kids has 2 TAs, that's probably another £35k+ added to the class budget when you factor in pensions, employer's NI, admin overhead, etc.

That's a lot of money on a national level.

Making it a legal responsibility, doesn't magic money out of thin air.

Until very recently, I suspect that a lot of kids with minor ASD issues would have just gone to school and learned. Now they have a legal right to XYZ support. That money comes out of the education budget and can't be spent on other things.

Apart from Norway, I can't think of any countries that can afford to spend the money required to fulfill these legal obligations.

Patineur · 11/01/2023 08:49

ThisGirlNever · 10/01/2023 22:51

@PeacockMansion

That sounds awful.

Is the EHCP system being abused/misused?

I don't understand where all these kids are appearing from. Why are there suddenly so many kids needing so much support?

Are they kids that would have just managed in the past? Now the system is expected to accommodate them, rather than the kids fitting into the system?

It seems to me that the issue is that the EHCP system is underused. Schools tend to soldier on for too long without applying for EHCPs, encouraged by LAs that don't like applications and which fail to train SENCOs properly in what the relevant legal requirements are. All too often, teachers on these threads demonstrate that they don't know what the criteria are or how to frame evidence and the contents of EHCPs to ensure that the required support is properly specified.

If schools were more proactive about applying for EHCPs or supporting parents to do so, and also supporting parents with tribunal appeals where necessary, they could radically improve their own positions.

Sherrystrull · 11/01/2023 08:37

Of course not. When have I said that? But without funding it becomes a highly tricky task where all children lose out.

Patineur · 11/01/2023 08:32

GHRT · 10/01/2023 21:53

@anerki101 If you feel a EHCP is needed are you aware that you can apply without school support? Organisations such as Sunshine Support can help.

Sunshine Support is expensive. IPSEA and SOS SEN may be a better bet for many families.

Patineur · 11/01/2023 08:28

Sherrystrull · 10/01/2023 20:29

@x2boys

Funding in schools is abysmal. We are trying to get support for children with severe learning difficulties or mental health needs. A child with no educational needs and only toileting needs would not be top of the list.

I've got 4 children in my class waiting for an ADHD diagnosis. One has been on the waiting list for nearly 2 years.

No funding = no support

So are you prepared to leave those children with toileting needs sitting in their own urine and faeces all day?