Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think this is unacceptable of the school

437 replies

anerki101 · 09/01/2023 20:19

My DS has suspected ASC. We have been waiting ages for a meeting with the school to discuss - that's another thread!

But anyway, DS is 4. Started school in Septemeber. He is 100% toilet trained nothing day and night. Never has accidents. Accept at school. If he doesn't do his daily poo at home after school, then he poos his pants at school. Its becoming an almost daily occurance. This started at the beginning of December. In all that time the staff have only noticed ONCE that he has had an accident and changed him.

Today I found out DS had done a poo in his pants between 12 and 1. I picked him up at 4:15. He'd been sitting in his own poo for three to four hours.

AIBU to think this is totally unacceptable?

The school are aware of these accidents. I have had several discussions with his teacher about preventing, etc. Nothing has worked so far but the biggest issue is that they aren't noticing he's had an accident and leaving him to sit in it all day.

OP posts:
JustKeepBuilding · 13/01/2023 23:00

Sending a child home is a last resort if staffing cannot safely be provided.

Clearly it’s not as in your opinion 2 staff members being present are essential, despite evidence demonstrating to the contrary. Sending a child home doesn’t put the safety of that child first. Holding your head up high wouldn’t help you defend the disability discrimination claim.

Sherrystrull · 13/01/2023 22:56

JustKeepBuilding · 13/01/2023 22:52

Good luck defending unlawful and discriminatory behaviour when a parent stands up to your school.

No I don’t currently work in a primary school. I do however have DC with SEN and have supported many other parents to put an end to their school’s unlawful behaviour around toileting/changing.

Statutory guidance for supporting pupils with medical conditions also states it is unacceptable practice to “require parents, or otherwise make them feel obliged, to attend school to administer medication or provide medical support to their child, including with toileting issues.“

Sending a child home is a last resort if staffing cannot safely be provided.

I'm honestly open mouthed that you think sending a child home is worse than not safeguarding children and staff against abuse.

If a parent complained about me sending a child home in this situation I would hold my head high knowing that I had put the safety needs of all the children and staff first.

Good night.

JustKeepBuilding · 13/01/2023 22:52

Good luck defending unlawful and discriminatory behaviour when a parent stands up to your school.

No I don’t currently work in a primary school. I do however have DC with SEN and have supported many other parents to put an end to their school’s unlawful behaviour around toileting/changing.

Statutory guidance for supporting pupils with medical conditions also states it is unacceptable practice to “require parents, or otherwise make them feel obliged, to attend school to administer medication or provide medical support to their child, including with toileting issues.“

Sherrystrull · 13/01/2023 22:47

Are you currently working in a primary school?

Sherrystrull · 13/01/2023 22:47

JustKeepBuilding · 13/01/2023 22:43

Having two members of staff is essential.

No it isn’t. To quote ERIC again: “So not only is there no need for two members of staff to be present, it is in fact discouraged unless the child needs two members of staff.”

Calling a parent and sending a pupil home is unacceptable and may well be classed as disability discrimination depending on individual circumstances. It is also “tantamount to abuse to force/allow a child to sit in wet or soiled underwear until their parent or guardian can come in to change them” according to ERIC.

I couldn't care less about ERIC, I care about keeping my staff and children safe.

JustKeepBuilding · 13/01/2023 22:43

Having two members of staff is essential.

No it isn’t. To quote ERIC again: “So not only is there no need for two members of staff to be present, it is in fact discouraged unless the child needs two members of staff.”

Calling a parent and sending a pupil home is unacceptable and may well be classed as disability discrimination depending on individual circumstances. It is also “tantamount to abuse to force/allow a child to sit in wet or soiled underwear until their parent or guardian can come in to change them” according to ERIC.

Sherrystrull · 13/01/2023 22:38

JustKeepBuilding · 13/01/2023 22:31

That's what school staff do to ensure children are safe and comfortable.

Sadly too many schools don’t, they refuse to change the child or call the parents. Neither of which are acceptable. If you find 2 members of staff fine, but that’s different to not changing the child due to there not being 2 members of staff which the school incorrectly believe are essential. It also goes against the guidance of not having 2 present unless needed for the child’s needs.

Having two members of staff is essential.

If a school can't safeguard both children and staff by providing two to support the child then sending them home to get cleaned up is the best approach to ensure the safety of everyone involved.

It's clearly not ideal but the alternatives of a class of children left alone, a child or staff member open to abuse, a child sitting wet/dirty and uncomfortable then that's what I would do.

We can't afford paper at my school. Funding is appalling. This is what it has come to.

Telling staff they should disregard safeguarding policies devised to keep everyone safe is not the answer.

JustKeepBuilding · 13/01/2023 22:31

That's what school staff do to ensure children are safe and comfortable.

Sadly too many schools don’t, they refuse to change the child or call the parents. Neither of which are acceptable. If you find 2 members of staff fine, but that’s different to not changing the child due to there not being 2 members of staff which the school incorrectly believe are essential. It also goes against the guidance of not having 2 present unless needed for the child’s needs.

Sherrystrull · 13/01/2023 22:25

JustKeepBuilding · 13/01/2023 22:22

You cherry picked the part of the quote that fitted your narrative but when you read the section as a whole it explicitly states 2 members of staff aren’t legally required and shouldn’t be used unless needed for the child’s needs.

I was responding to GCMM’s post about the problem being there are only 2 members of staff in the classroom in that school and they can’t both leave as that isn’t a problem - “schools should not refuse to clean a child if only one member of staff is available to leave the classroom.”

My narrative is keeping children and staff safe in school.

Two staff is essential to safeguard everyone but is problematic in terms of staffing.

Of course we would find two staff. We would put two classes together. We would not do intervention that day, we would not eat lunch. That's what school staff do to ensure children are safe and comfortable.

JustKeepBuilding · 13/01/2023 22:24

Eyerollcentral · 13/01/2023 22:17

Yes, but staff are entitled to protection as well. So if they work in twos there is always a witness. Barring religious reasons most women don’t require a chaperone to be examined by a male doctor but to protect both the doctor and the patient it’s good practice to ensure there are two people plus the patient in the room. Safeguarding policies have been devised for a very valid reasons. The government would also say one teacher could teach two classes if they could get away with it.

Yes safeguarding policies have been developed for good reasons, including to prevent the neglect of the child.

JustKeepBuilding · 13/01/2023 22:22

You cherry picked the part of the quote that fitted your narrative but when you read the section as a whole it explicitly states 2 members of staff aren’t legally required and shouldn’t be used unless needed for the child’s needs.

I was responding to GCMM’s post about the problem being there are only 2 members of staff in the classroom in that school and they can’t both leave as that isn’t a problem - “schools should not refuse to clean a child if only one member of staff is available to leave the classroom.”

Remmy123 · 13/01/2023 22:20

How do you know it was between that time you specified?

how would teacher know unless he told the teacher - did he?

how would a teacher know that one child (out of up to 30) has poo'd his pants?)

Sherrystrull · 13/01/2023 22:19

What? How is protecting my staff and children cherry picking? You can keep saying it until you're blue in the face but keeping children and staff safe in school is the only thing that matters.

Can you honestly not see how an adult providing intimate care to a child alone in a room that is behind two closed doors and not near anyone else is a problem?

Eyerollcentral · 13/01/2023 22:17

JustKeepBuilding · 13/01/2023 22:10

They do, but if you read the link from ERIC you will see the government ‘Guidance for safer working practice for those working with children and young people in education settings' states 2 members of staff aren’t necessary and shouldn’t be used unless the pupil’s needs dictate 2 are need.

Yes, but staff are entitled to protection as well. So if they work in twos there is always a witness. Barring religious reasons most women don’t require a chaperone to be examined by a male doctor but to protect both the doctor and the patient it’s good practice to ensure there are two people plus the patient in the room. Safeguarding policies have been devised for a very valid reasons. The government would also say one teacher could teach two classes if they could get away with it.

JustKeepBuilding · 13/01/2023 22:16

Sherrystrull · 13/01/2023 22:11

This is copied and pasted from the link you pasted...

For safeguarding reasons, staff who help with intimate care should make sure another member of staff is aware they are going to change a child and is in the vicinity and visible or audible ((see page 14 of the 'Guidance for safer working practice for those working with children and young people in education settings', 2015)

Our toilets are behind two closed doors. Two staff are needed to protect staff and children.

If you quote the whole section, rather than cherry pick the part that suits your narrative you will see it specifically states 2 members of staff aren’t legally required and 2 members of staff shouldn’t be present unless the care needs of the child require it.

“Do two members of staff need to be present to change my child?

There is no legal requirement for two members of staff to be present, so schools should not refuse to clean a child if only one member of staff is available to leave the classroom.

For safeguarding reasons, staff who help with intimate care should make sure another member of staff is aware they are going to change a child and is in the vicinity and visible or audible ((see page 14 of the 'Guidance for safer working practice for those working with children and young people in education settings', 2015)

It is good practice to ensure that all aspects of continence care in school are documented in advance, for instance using an individual health care plan making sure parental consent is obtained for named carers to meet the child's needs.

The guidance also states that "intimate or personal care procedures should not involve more than one member of staff unless the pupil's care plan specifies the reason for this."

So not only is there no need for two members of staff to be present, it is in fact discouraged unless the child needs two members of staff.”

Sherrystrull · 13/01/2023 22:11

This is copied and pasted from the link you pasted...

For safeguarding reasons, staff who help with intimate care should make sure another member of staff is aware they are going to change a child and is in the vicinity and visible or audible ((see page 14 of the 'Guidance for safer working practice for those working with children and young people in education settings', 2015)

Our toilets are behind two closed doors. Two staff are needed to protect staff and children.

JustKeepBuilding · 13/01/2023 22:10

Eyerollcentral · 13/01/2023 22:04

Schools devise safeguarding policies for the protection of students and staff.

They do, but if you read the link from ERIC you will see the government ‘Guidance for safer working practice for those working with children and young people in education settings' states 2 members of staff aren’t necessary and shouldn’t be used unless the pupil’s needs dictate 2 are need.

Eyerollcentral · 13/01/2023 22:06

MadKittenWoman · 13/01/2023 21:33

TAs are TEACHING assistants, not nursery nurses. It is not their job to clean up shit. When I was a TA/HLTA, we would give them a spare pair of pants and tights or trousers if they wet themselves and a plastic bag to put their wet clothes in. If a child was sick, we would see if there were any spare clothes in lost property and call the caretaker to clean up. We did not do personal care.

So many people on this thread just do not seem to comprehend this despite the fact they would not countenance being asked to do anything similar in their own job.

Eyerollcentral · 13/01/2023 22:04

JustKeepBuilding · 13/01/2023 21:28

The school need to read this as there doesn’t need to be 2 members of staff and unless necessary for the needs of the individual pupil there shouldn’t be 2 present.

Schools devise safeguarding policies for the protection of students and staff.

Redbone · 13/01/2023 21:34

It is not the teacher’s or TA’s job to check that your child has had an accident. A trip to the GP is required I think.

MadKittenWoman · 13/01/2023 21:33

TAs are TEACHING assistants, not nursery nurses. It is not their job to clean up shit. When I was a TA/HLTA, we would give them a spare pair of pants and tights or trousers if they wet themselves and a plastic bag to put their wet clothes in. If a child was sick, we would see if there were any spare clothes in lost property and call the caretaker to clean up. We did not do personal care.

JustKeepBuilding · 13/01/2023 21:28

GCMM · 13/01/2023 20:45

My niece is a primary school teacher and the policy in her school is that there must always be 2 members of staff to change an incontinent child. As there are only two staff in each classroom (the teacher and the TA) it's clearly a problem.

The school need to read this as there doesn’t need to be 2 members of staff and unless necessary for the needs of the individual pupil there shouldn’t be 2 present.

GCMM · 13/01/2023 20:45

My niece is a primary school teacher and the policy in her school is that there must always be 2 members of staff to change an incontinent child. As there are only two staff in each classroom (the teacher and the TA) it's clearly a problem.

Eyerollcentral · 13/01/2023 18:36

Patineur · 13/01/2023 15:49

Usually it is exactly what they signed up for. It is virtually inevitable that there will be some children with toileting problems in every average sized mainstream primary school, and when they recruit TAs that will be part of the job description. So it won't ever come as a surprise that it is expected.

I have worked as a TA. Was never mentioned to me before I went in to a classroom 🤷‍♀️

neverbeenskiing · 13/01/2023 16:32

ThisGirlNever · 10/01/2023 22:51

@PeacockMansion

That sounds awful.

Is the EHCP system being abused/misused?

I don't understand where all these kids are appearing from. Why are there suddenly so many kids needing so much support?

Are they kids that would have just managed in the past? Now the system is expected to accommodate them, rather than the kids fitting into the system?

"These kids" haven't "suddenly appeared". The specialist provision that would have accommodated them has been decimated over the last decade. I work in a mainstream secondary school and we have students who, 10 years ago would have been in Special Schools, without question. Now there are no special school places available, so we have kids on our roll whose learning levels are comparable with that of Reception age children and need an entirely bespoke curriculum, constant 1:1 supervision and support from multiple agencies. Sadly most of those agencies have had their funding cut to the bone and are massively overstretched. If a child has an EHCP that says they need 1:1 TA, then that TA's salary will be funded through their EHCP, it does not come out of our staffing budget.

You seem to be implying that EHCP's are handed out for no good reason and in the good old days these kids would have had to suck it up. This is nonsense. A huge amount of evidence is needed for the LA to agree to an EHCP, and many applications are turned down.

Swipe left for the next trending thread