Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think this is unacceptable of the school

437 replies

anerki101 · 09/01/2023 20:19

My DS has suspected ASC. We have been waiting ages for a meeting with the school to discuss - that's another thread!

But anyway, DS is 4. Started school in Septemeber. He is 100% toilet trained nothing day and night. Never has accidents. Accept at school. If he doesn't do his daily poo at home after school, then he poos his pants at school. Its becoming an almost daily occurance. This started at the beginning of December. In all that time the staff have only noticed ONCE that he has had an accident and changed him.

Today I found out DS had done a poo in his pants between 12 and 1. I picked him up at 4:15. He'd been sitting in his own poo for three to four hours.

AIBU to think this is totally unacceptable?

The school are aware of these accidents. I have had several discussions with his teacher about preventing, etc. Nothing has worked so far but the biggest issue is that they aren't noticing he's had an accident and leaving him to sit in it all day.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ThisGirlNever · 14/01/2023 21:58

rosiebl · 13/01/2023 23:31

This was my boy in reception class.
I trained his bowel to poo before school. He still does a poo before school now and he's much bigger. Just encourage him to try every morning. Increase his fibre in his breakfast and let him have a few days of leisurely toilet time (maybe an iPad with a cartoon in the bathroom?) to get used to that being his poo time.

OP considers this simple solution to be impossible.

JustKeepBuilding · 14/01/2023 13:53

There’s a process -get the child assessed - this releases funding for staff to do X job

A diagnosis does not result in more funding.

Poo is very different and parents are called to clean the child.

Calling parents to clean their DC isn’t lawful.

Goldilocksmother · 14/01/2023 13:42

They helped him change because he was wet and could clean and change himself.

Poo is very different and parents are called to clean the child.

In this case it wasn’t noticed.

If the class teacher is teaching 30 children - who do you think will take the class for one child to be cleaned?

There’s a process -get the child assessed - this releases funding for staff to do X job

Mamamia32 · 14/01/2023 13:32

Eyerollcentral · 13/01/2023 22:06

So many people on this thread just do not seem to comprehend this despite the fact they would not countenance being asked to do anything similar in their own job.

Thankfully when my child wet himself in reception his teachers were lovely and helped him change into his PE kit and bagged up his wet clothes. It might not be part of the official job description, but I don't think you should sign up to work with four year olds if you have no empathy for children, and would be prepared to just let them sit in shit all day.

The op has said that this is a problem exclusively happening in school, and so the school needs to work out why that is and how they can help this little boy. It is a school problem if it only happens in that setting.

Somuchgoo · 14/01/2023 09:37

@Eyerollcentral it's not preferable for there to be two members of staff present for changes, and it's not asking schools to abandon their safeguarding policies. I've checked the policy of my local school that my kids will eventually be going to, and it very clearly states that changes should be done by one person where possible, and that they should avoid having two people unless it is specifically necessary in that situation.

Whilst that's just one school, these policies are often very similar everywhere.

Patineur · 14/01/2023 07:11

MadKittenWoman · 13/01/2023 21:33

TAs are TEACHING assistants, not nursery nurses. It is not their job to clean up shit. When I was a TA/HLTA, we would give them a spare pair of pants and tights or trousers if they wet themselves and a plastic bag to put their wet clothes in. If a child was sick, we would see if there were any spare clothes in lost property and call the caretaker to clean up. We did not do personal care.

Again, what happened in your school isn't universal practice. What would they have done if the child was incapable of cleaning themselves? Or if it was written into the child's EHCP that they were required to have help with toileting and changing?

Patineur · 14/01/2023 07:09

Eyerollcentral · 13/01/2023 18:36

I have worked as a TA. Was never mentioned to me before I went in to a classroom 🤷‍♀️

You do know your experience isn't universal, right?

Faultymain5 · 14/01/2023 06:09

Seriously people it’s sht! A 4 year old kid’s sht does not smell of roses. They know. There is no way they don’t. If they can’t smell it, they themselves may need a health check.

ForgetBarbie · 14/01/2023 05:51

I’m a few days late to the thread but I’ve read all your posts OP and I’m not sure what it is you really want?

  • the teachers ask frequently if DS needs to use the toilet
  • he may deny it or isn’t able to respond
  • they’ve offered to let him use the year 6 toilets which are nicer however this still doesn’t work

So what do you actually want? If they’re making the effort to ask him, he says no AND they can’t smell it at the time, what do you want them to do? They can’t call you every 5 minutes to say ‘DS may have done a poo, do you want to come in and check?’ By reading the comments, it also seems like teachers/TA’s aren’t able to just go and randomly check a child’s underwear to see if they’ve soiled themselves.

You say you keep getting fobbed off in regards to the meeting. So email them every two days or even daily, asking for an update. Leave a paper trail. Obviously your child shouldn’t be sitting in poo for hours but you need to be a bit more aggressive with your communication techniques

autienotnaughty · 14/01/2023 05:48

My son was not toilet trained in reception. He had a one to one which helped but they would take him to toilet tho they encouraged him to clean himself rather then do it for him. What additional support has school put in place? Does he need one to one ? I'd meet with teacher/senco to discuss how best to manage this going forward. And everytime he has an accident tell them the next day.

JustKeepBuilding · 14/01/2023 05:35

An EHCP or diagnosis is not required.

Requiring parents to collect or making them feel they should isn’t lawful solution so shouldn’t be suggested as an acceptable solution.

I’m not angry. I am pointing out your posts don’t align with the law and how parents can challenge schools’ unlawful behaviour. Nothing I have posted is untrue. This is an open forum and I am replying to the thread, feel free not post if you don’t want to but you can’t police my posts.

Eyerollcentral · 14/01/2023 05:26

JustKeepBuilding · 14/01/2023 05:19

It depends on the circumstances, proceedings can be against a specific school/school body. For example, F-T v The Governors of Hampton Dene Primary School [2016] UKUT 0468 (AAC). It is upper tier rather than FtT but it is a disability discrimination case against a school rather than LA. The content of the case isn’t relevant to the thread, but it’s the first case to hand which proves a case can be against a school.

It you look at the upper tier disability discrimination cases online (FtT aren’t listed online) you will see it’s not the only one against specific schools. Some have other interested parties named in proceedings as well.

No, I won’t retract it. Throughout this thread you have posted the school shouldn’t have to change the pupil, the OP should collect her child at lunchtime and the school can only change pupils when there’s 2 staff members present.

I suggested that it was a solution for the OP to collect her son at lunchtime. Her son currently does not have an ECHP or diagnosis. I didn’t say that the school can only change students where there are two staff members present I said that it was in the best interests of staff and students to ensure there was. I am not sure why you are focusing your obvious anger at me, but I will not tolerate you saying things that are untrue based on what is in black and white. Stop messaging me about this now, thanks

JustKeepBuilding · 14/01/2023 05:19

It depends on the circumstances, proceedings can be against a specific school/school body. For example, F-T v The Governors of Hampton Dene Primary School [2016] UKUT 0468 (AAC). It is upper tier rather than FtT but it is a disability discrimination case against a school rather than LA. The content of the case isn’t relevant to the thread, but it’s the first case to hand which proves a case can be against a school.

It you look at the upper tier disability discrimination cases online (FtT aren’t listed online) you will see it’s not the only one against specific schools. Some have other interested parties named in proceedings as well.

No, I won’t retract it. Throughout this thread you have posted the school shouldn’t have to change the pupil, the OP should collect her child at lunchtime and the school can only change pupils when there’s 2 staff members present.

Eyerollcentral · 14/01/2023 05:11

You’d be badly advise to only issue against the school.
Please refrain from reckless accusations. I’ve said nothing of the sort. You should retract your last statement.

JustKeepBuilding · 14/01/2023 04:51

LAs may be named in proceedings, but proceedings can be against specific individual schools as well.

And yet you continuously excuse unlawful behaviour.

Eyerollcentral · 14/01/2023 04:45

JustKeepBuilding · 14/01/2023 04:38

However you are talking about discrimination claims against education authorities.

No, I’m not. I’m talking about disability discrimination cases against schools.

Nowhere have I said staff aren’t entitled to be protected, I have instead pointed out that it is unlawful to leave a child unchanged/call parents because schools have incorrectly deemed 2 members of staff are needed.

I’m glad you’re not going to keep discussing it because you clearly know very little about SEND law.

Education authorities are responsible for the oversight of schools and will be including in any proceedings against a school. I’ve not once said children should be left unchanged or that parents should be called. Goodnight

JustKeepBuilding · 14/01/2023 04:38

However you are talking about discrimination claims against education authorities.

No, I’m not. I’m talking about disability discrimination cases against schools.

Nowhere have I said staff aren’t entitled to be protected, I have instead pointed out that it is unlawful to leave a child unchanged/call parents because schools have incorrectly deemed 2 members of staff are needed.

I’m glad you’re not going to keep discussing it because you clearly know very little about SEND law.

Eyerollcentral · 14/01/2023 04:34

JustKeepBuilding · 14/01/2023 03:31

Any disability discrimination claim would be about proving a school is acting unlawfully. Yes I have supported more than 1 parent in a successful disability discrimination claim where part of the school’s unlawful behaviour was the school failing to act lawfully in their dealing with toileting/changing by asking parents to come in/sending pupils home/outright refusing to change DC because they claim not to have the staff to deal with it when that isn’t lawful.

I’m not going to keep discussing this with you. However you are talking about discrimination claims against education authorities. I have merely pointed out that employees have rights too. They are dealt with under two completely different areas of law. Staff are entitled to protection under the law as well

ASimpleLampoon · 14/01/2023 04:21

Iam4eels · 09/01/2023 21:06

Not sure why that posted multiple times.

I'm glad it did. A sensible and well informed answer with great suggestions. I hope the multiple postings will drown out the silly replies from people who know nothing about SEN\ Autism and what a school can / can not do but think they should shout their opinions anyway.

JustKeepBuilding · 14/01/2023 03:31

Any disability discrimination claim would be about proving a school is acting unlawfully. Yes I have supported more than 1 parent in a successful disability discrimination claim where part of the school’s unlawful behaviour was the school failing to act lawfully in their dealing with toileting/changing by asking parents to come in/sending pupils home/outright refusing to change DC because they claim not to have the staff to deal with it when that isn’t lawful.

Eyerollcentral · 14/01/2023 03:19

JustKeepBuilding · 14/01/2023 03:10

Convincing a Judge the school is acting unlawful is t that difficult. I have managed it before. If the school need more funding they should approach the LA, not act unlawfully.

But by your argument on this thread you want to persuade a Judge that staff at schools should abandon the safeguarding policies that are in place. As I have said several times they exist for benefit of the staff and the student. You are saying you want staff to HAVE to deal with intimate personal care on a 1:1 basis where they are not employed as a 1:1 assistant for special needs children. Have you been successful in Court on that argument?

JustKeepBuilding · 14/01/2023 03:10

Eyerollcentral · 13/01/2023 23:35

Good luck convincing a Judge that safeguarding standards should be abandoned. We can play this game all evening. The problem isn’t with staff. If children with an identified need require support then they need specialised paid assistance. Take the funding deficit up with the government. Stop asking workers to put themselves at risk to facilitate shortfalls in funding.

Convincing a Judge the school is acting unlawful is t that difficult. I have managed it before. If the school need more funding they should approach the LA, not act unlawfully.

Eyerollcentral · 13/01/2023 23:37

rosiebl · 13/01/2023 23:31

This was my boy in reception class.
I trained his bowel to poo before school. He still does a poo before school now and he's much bigger. Just encourage him to try every morning. Increase his fibre in his breakfast and let him have a few days of leisurely toilet time (maybe an iPad with a cartoon in the bathroom?) to get used to that being his poo time.

This is such a sensible solution. It might not work for the OP’s child but it’s really good advice

Eyerollcentral · 13/01/2023 23:35

JustKeepBuilding · 13/01/2023 22:52

Good luck defending unlawful and discriminatory behaviour when a parent stands up to your school.

No I don’t currently work in a primary school. I do however have DC with SEN and have supported many other parents to put an end to their school’s unlawful behaviour around toileting/changing.

Statutory guidance for supporting pupils with medical conditions also states it is unacceptable practice to “require parents, or otherwise make them feel obliged, to attend school to administer medication or provide medical support to their child, including with toileting issues.“

Good luck convincing a Judge that safeguarding standards should be abandoned. We can play this game all evening. The problem isn’t with staff. If children with an identified need require support then they need specialised paid assistance. Take the funding deficit up with the government. Stop asking workers to put themselves at risk to facilitate shortfalls in funding.

rosiebl · 13/01/2023 23:31

This was my boy in reception class.
I trained his bowel to poo before school. He still does a poo before school now and he's much bigger. Just encourage him to try every morning. Increase his fibre in his breakfast and let him have a few days of leisurely toilet time (maybe an iPad with a cartoon in the bathroom?) to get used to that being his poo time.