Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

More of a WWYD - regarding these Shares?

41 replies

BeachBlondey · 09/01/2023 17:05

Back in the early 2000's, me and my then DH were doing very well financially, and over the course of the previous 10-15 years, we had invested in staff Share plans with our employer Nat West. The schemes allowed you to pay monthly and then at the end of 5 years, the shares you received were usually worth way more than you had invested. Anyway, at one point they were worth circa £100k.

In 2008, there was obviously a market crash and me and DH also divorced. My half of the shares ended up being worth something like £5000, instead of the £50,000 they should have been worth.

I went through some really tough financial times after our split, because he was the high earner. I was only part time, on a low salary, and now my shares had crashed as well. I had 3 years of paying half of the mortgage on the old house (the marital home) that we couldn't sell, plus a new mortgage on a new much smaller home. All food was put on to credit cards and we had no treats. It was quite tough, but I held on to the shares, believing that they would bounce back eventually, and I might have to wait decades for this to happen.

Now we are 15 years on from that time. I have remarried and recovered financially. But, I still have these shares and I don't know what to do now. At one time I believed on this company SO much, because I worked there and the shares had been my only way of saving for so long. But I haven't worked there now for 10 years and maybe the blinkers are slipping.

The shares are now worth about £8,000 and I don't know whether to just throw in the towel, in case they fall again, or sit on them for the next 20 years hoping for some improvement (but can't see them ever getting back to their real value).

I am a risk averse person, and if I had £8k sitting in my bank account, there is no way in a million years that I would buy shares with that! The only reason I got involved in shares in the first place, is because they were staff plans and risk free.

WWYD? I do not need the money now. I would be selling them to avoid more losses. But of course, once I've sold them, I have to acknowledge that I have lost £42k, with no chance of changing that.

YANBU - sell the shares now in case you lose further

YABU - you don't need the money now, so hold on to them

Thanks for reading, sorry it was long!

OP posts:
BeachBlondey · 09/01/2023 17:30

Addicted2Kale · 09/01/2023 17:27

Very brave to ask people who aren't trained financial professionals/traders what to do with your shares.

That said, in my unprofessional, uncertified, feelings based, personal opinion, we're going into a recession. Do banks grow in a recession? I don't see any immmediate tangible growth moves from Natwest. Cut your losses, sell. Put the money into a smaller company with more growth potential.

Believe me, after this experience the money would only go into an ISA. I will never buy shares again!

OP posts:
BeachBlondey · 09/01/2023 17:28

HotToddyColdSauvignon · 09/01/2023 17:24

My dad had exactly the same situation with Lloyds Bank shares OP

They “should” be worth about £150k. I remember how devastated he was when they plummeted (well before the 2008 crash, must have been in the early 90’s) and they went down to about £2k

He’s held onto them all this time since, mainly because like you, he no longer needs the money, and says “one day” they may recover. I think he always said he’d sell when they hit £10 a share, and last time I looked they were 6.5p or something ridiculous - but he keeps the faith.

OMG, that's a loss! I didn't realise this had happened at Lloyds as well. This is the thing re hanging on, isn't it - once you sell them, that's it, game over. But realistically what am I hanging on for? They were in their hey day £20 a share they are now £2.79! Gah!

OP posts:
Addicted2Kale · 09/01/2023 17:27

Very brave to ask people who aren't trained financial professionals/traders what to do with your shares.

That said, in my unprofessional, uncertified, feelings based, personal opinion, we're going into a recession. Do banks grow in a recession? I don't see any immmediate tangible growth moves from Natwest. Cut your losses, sell. Put the money into a smaller company with more growth potential.

Ariela · 09/01/2023 17:25

I would look at future proofing your home - so, do you need double glazing? New thermal curtains, Solar panels etc?

BeachBlondey · 09/01/2023 17:25

TellMeWhere · 09/01/2023 17:20

Your shares aren't worth £50k. They're worth whatever they can be sold for today. How much did you actually pay for them?

I'm not sure I could even work that out. Multiple staff schemes taken out over decades. I could maybe work it out by going over old paperwork, which could make me feel better!!

OP posts:
HotToddyColdSauvignon · 09/01/2023 17:24

My dad had exactly the same situation with Lloyds Bank shares OP

They “should” be worth about £150k. I remember how devastated he was when they plummeted (well before the 2008 crash, must have been in the early 90’s) and they went down to about £2k

He’s held onto them all this time since, mainly because like you, he no longer needs the money, and says “one day” they may recover. I think he always said he’d sell when they hit £10 a share, and last time I looked they were 6.5p or something ridiculous - but he keeps the faith.

Deathbyfluffy · 09/01/2023 17:24

Pretty much as above, they're not worth £50k so you're not losing £42k.
I'd sell up and use the £8k for something like paying a chunk of the mortgage off - a much better use considering I doubt they'll go anywhere near their 'old' value.

BeachBlondey · 09/01/2023 17:24

Sophie1980 · 09/01/2023 17:19

You could use the money to pay off part of the mortgage.
ATM they are yours, mortgage is (I presume) joint.
Do you have children from 1st marriage that you need to provide for?
If you sell them, check tax situation of this year which ends April 3rd.

Can't pay any more to mortgage. The mortgage is in my name only, as I bought the house before I met 2nd DH. My children (from 1st marriage) are grown up and left home, both self sufficient in good jobs.

OP posts:
BeachBlondey · 09/01/2023 17:22

xyhere · 09/01/2023 17:10

I presume they peaked some time before the 2008 crash?

Highly unlikely that shares in a bank are going to jump by 500% in any reasonable timeframe, and NatWest's shares have been reasonably stable over the last five years (ignoring the lockdown period where everything went a bit weird). Given inflation etc, stable == losing money.

You're far better off taking the money and doing something useful with it, IMO - like paying a chunk off your mortgage. That'll be worth more in the long run than the hope of a boost in the share price.

Yes, they were worth so much more before the crash. Fred Goodwin also hoodwinked staff in to buying more shares, when he knew the Company was going under - this is why he got the sack, I think (memory a bit hazy).

I can't pay a chunk off the mortgage, as I already over pay as much as I am allowed to without penalty.

OP posts:
theGooHasGone · 09/01/2023 17:21

You need to disavow yourself of the notion that you've "lost" £42k - you haven't. You never realised the gain. The world is full of people who have 20/20 hindsight saying that they should have sold when something was worth more. Coulda woulda shoulda.

If they're causing you concern then sell them, take the money and never look at the stock price again.

If you want to speculate a bit more then hang onto them and accept that the price can go down as well as up.

TellMeWhere · 09/01/2023 17:20

Your shares aren't worth £50k. They're worth whatever they can be sold for today. How much did you actually pay for them?

Sophie1980 · 09/01/2023 17:19

You could use the money to pay off part of the mortgage.
ATM they are yours, mortgage is (I presume) joint.
Do you have children from 1st marriage that you need to provide for?
If you sell them, check tax situation of this year which ends April 3rd.

Gemstar2 · 09/01/2023 17:14

I am no expert and in your shoes I’d seek proper financial advice, but from what I’ve read you should keep them from the long term to ride out the market. If you already have a sufficient emergency fund and a pension and you genuinely don’t need the money I’d be tempted to keep them. But try to reframe it in your mind about them being “worth” £50k otherwise you’ll always feel like you’ve lost out. Shares always have the potential to fall as well as rise, so they were only “worth” £50k if you’d sold them at that one point in time. So try not to see it as £8k versus £50k but rather £8k versus potentially more, potentially less. Only you know what level of risk you’re comfortable with.

Burnamer · 09/01/2023 17:13

Let go of the idea that their “real” value is £50k. It isn’t. Their really value is £8k at the moment but that could change. They are volatile and if you hold them you are gambling. No-one really knows what will happen to share prices (this is why traders get paid big money but they aren’t infallible) so no one can really answer this for you. It really comes down to your risk appetite

xyhere · 09/01/2023 17:10

I presume they peaked some time before the 2008 crash?

Highly unlikely that shares in a bank are going to jump by 500% in any reasonable timeframe, and NatWest's shares have been reasonably stable over the last five years (ignoring the lockdown period where everything went a bit weird). Given inflation etc, stable == losing money.

You're far better off taking the money and doing something useful with it, IMO - like paying a chunk off your mortgage. That'll be worth more in the long run than the hope of a boost in the share price.

DrManhattan · 09/01/2023 17:08

If you don't need the money definitely keep them and see what happens