Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That there is a lot of judgement in pregnancy and motherhood?

43 replies

MRSDoos · 09/01/2023 14:31

I’m 23 weeks pregnant and a first time mum.
Because this is our first I love hearing helpful advice from other parents and I’m happy to hear recommendations on items or what to do once baby arrives.

I’ve noticed that a lot of people can be judgemental about personal things that you decide to do in pregnancy for example names, colours of nursery, items that you buy for baby. I’ve also had a lot of snarky comments on what I should and shouldn’t do during labour to the point someone told me I “should never” have a caesarean - as if some woman have a choice! I want to breastfeed, but it still annoys me when people ask “You’re obviously going to breastfeed, right?”.

I’m sure the comments and judgements will be worse once baby is here - how do you deal with them?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Whiskerson · 02/01/2024 14:56

I think some women just like the matronly bossy feeling of 'imparting wisdom' whether you asked for it or not. Having a child is such a universal thing and you don't need any qualifications to be able to achieve it, so I think it's the one thing some people can feel knowledgeable about. I'm choosing to take the stuff that feels helpful and politely tune out the rest.

Yes, I think it's exactly that, and I think you're taking exactly the right approach to it. I think there are two types of person (or at least two ends of the spectrum):

A) those of us who love the feeling of imparting wisdom, and don't mind humouring other people when they impart theirs, even though it's clearly inferior to ours (I am this type and this is basically why I'm on MN)

B) those who are less comfortable with the whole shebang and more sensitive about it.

For those of us in group A, the group B people can actually have an unnerving and irritating effect with the reluctance to share their thoughts... I always found it more annoying to have a lot of tiptoeing around and "now, you mustn't listen to what anyone tells you, and I'm sure it's all changed since my day and so you mustn't listen to me either...". Just tell me what you think, I can handle it, and if I don't like it, I'll change the subject or politely disagree! (Unless it's an absolute pointless horror story about a friend of a friend, in which case nobody needs to hear it)

muggart · 02/01/2024 14:43

I felt the opposite, that I didn't know what I was doing and would have loved more women to share their experiences with them. Instead I had to google everything.

That's why I first joined Mumsnet in fact.

March2024baby · 02/01/2024 14:40

Yes, I am 29 weeks and have experienced a couple of unsolicited silly opinions offered already. Actually mine were from people I don't really know (hair dresser and dental receptionist randomly!), so it kind of made it easier.

Direct quote - 'Oh why are you finding out the sex of the baby? Ooow don't do that?!'
And just general doom-mongering - ' Oh there is so much they don't tell you about childbirth...' - and then proceeds to tell me about her own horrific experience as if it's universal. Oh she also told me that I should have as much coffee and caffeine as I like and ignore the guidelines, cause she did and her kid is just fine.

I think some women just like the matronly bossy feeling of 'imparting wisdom' whether you asked for it or not. Having a child is such a universal thing and you don't need any qualifications to be able to achieve it, so I think it's the one thing some people can feel knowledgeable about. I'm choosing to take the stuff that feels helpful and politely tune out the rest.

Lotrehin · 02/01/2024 14:33

No. It's just banning abortion. A minor matter.

Westernesse · 02/01/2024 14:31

None of those organisations are entirely male. Is it the US Senate making snide little comments and digs in people’s homes about how women should handle y and motherhood?

Lotrehin · 02/01/2024 14:21

Really? You think that for eg the Catholic church (an entirely male organisation), the US Senate and just about every other political and religious group in the world is disinterested in women's fertility, sexual behaviour and parenting?

Whiskerson · 02/01/2024 14:21

I think we are all interested, because it's pretty much the most important and universal thing on Earth. We have all been children, and most of us are or will be parents, and it affects us all. It would be antisocial if nobody cared how the world's children are being raised, or how new and expectant mothers get on.

That's not to say that all opinions are sensible or should be broadcast, but of course we all have our thoughts.

Does anyone think this would be any different if men didn't exist and we got pregnant by divine intervention?

Westernesse · 02/01/2024 14:17

I don’t think so.

Lotrehin · 02/01/2024 14:10

Oh I think men are extremely interested in women's fertility and parenting decisions.

Westernesse · 02/01/2024 14:03

What’s the Patriarchy got to do with women’s competitive pettiness towards each other and weird hang ups they have regarding pregnancy and motherhood? Men are not involved in that and completely disinterested.

Lotrehin · 02/01/2024 14:01

Of course you can. Women also participate in patriarchy.

LemonLight · 02/01/2024 14:00

YANBU, I'm also pregnant with our first and it's astounded me how many people have given their unsolicited snotty advice. But what's been worse is how many people have tried to make DH and I feel miserable about the whole thing by sharing birthing horror stories, how crap life will be once baby arrives etc. I've started avoiding the subject or just people all together because I'm just fed up of the constant onslaught.

Westernesse · 02/01/2024 13:57

Mostly the weird judgment, comments etc around pregnancy and motherhood come from women. You can’t pin this one on the Patriarchy, I’m afraid.

Whiskerson · 02/01/2024 13:28

It's never bothered me, but I'm not usually much ruffled by other people having opinions. I can't say I ever remember feeling "judged" - about anything, really. It's quite possible everyone has been judging the hell out of me for years and I've never bothered to notice 😂

Lotrehin · 02/01/2024 13:17

Oh god OP welcome to the jungle. Congratulations!

Patriarchy exists because women have babies, so it is at its fiercest when you make any decision involving your fertility or your parenting. This is because you are at your most dangerous, as far as patriarchy is concerned, if that makes you feel any better.

pottypotamus · 02/01/2024 13:06

It's a shame but it's true. Judgement for me started while I was pregnant on when I chose to reveal my pregnancy to certain people in the family. And it's the same, whether you choose to bottle-feed or breastfeed, someone is going to have an opinion. And don't get me started on the comments and judgements about your body.

Just the start of it I'm afraid. Agree with PPs. You just gotta learn to ignore.

Etincelle · 02/01/2024 13:03

milkymeg · 09/01/2023 14:38

Get used to it. It's your life now. It's absolutely fine to just say "thanks, I'm happy with the decision we've made for our baby" and don't discuss it further. My top bit of advice to any mum to be is... "I'm going to offer you the only bit of advice you need as a new parent. Don't listen to advice from anyone else. You and your baby are unique and your instincts are good."

I agree with saying this. No need to quietly accept what they say.

lieselotte · 02/01/2024 13:00

whattodo1975 · 09/01/2023 14:36

I hate to say it but think you need to toughen up, as this is only the start of the judgement that will be incoming. If its getting you down now just wait till the baby arrives and everyone gives you their opinion.

I'm not saying its right, but its what women do to validate their own choices they made with their children.

Yes, this. Sadly everyone think it's fine to police womens' choices in pregnancy and then it continues until the child is 18 (and beyond). Of course, dads are not judged in anything like the same way!

You have to develop a thick skin, ignore the advice you don't like and take account of the advice you do.

Within reason, a happy mum = a happy baby, so do what suits you and your child.

Westernesse · 02/01/2024 12:19

I’m sorry to say that it won’t stop. You will just need to ignore it/roll with it.

Women are just dreadful to other women on the matters of pregnancy motherhood. They judge, judge, judge and it will never change.

entirely competitive and entirely toxic. Why evolution does this, I just do not know.

lieselotte · 10/01/2023 15:12

I hate to say it but think you need to toughen up, as this is only the start of the judgement that will be incoming. If its getting you down now just wait till the baby arrives and everyone gives you their opinion

Unfortunately this. But just ignore the "advice" you don't like. And also think about whether you actually care about what a lot of people think. If people say something you don't like, think about what they are to you, and why and if you should care about their opinion. Mostly you shouldn't.

Sceptre86 · 10/01/2023 15:09

I am on a group for women who had babies at the same time as me. Some were first time mums and had very idealistic views on giving birth, following hypnotherapy and didn't want to hear any 'negativity'. My first birth everything that could go wrong did and I felt I couldn't share any of it because that would have been seen as negativity. Said women didn't get the birth she wanted and couldn't let go of that. I couldn't help but feel had she been open to hearing about people's experiences she wouldn't have held on to the perfect birth thing but she held a natural birth with no interventions as the only positive way to give birth. I don't volunteer the information unless asked as my experience was very much down to a series of issues.

I'd avoid asking for people's opinions if you don't want to hear them because they won't always align with yours. Also I did things differently with each of my children because they are all different. For instance first child didn't have a dummy, second did and so has current baby.

You'll find your own way and learn as you go. No harm in asking for weaning recipes, advice re breastfeeding, nap schedules etc.

ISaidDontLickTheBin · 10/01/2023 13:15

Totally agree, though I found it happened to me so much that I wonder if sometimes people were just trying to make conversation and had no idea how judgemental they were actually coming across.

Hopefullyupwards · 10/01/2023 13:12

You'll get used to it and pick your battles and let the rest of the comments slide. It's bloody annoying though. Also, in baby groups etc, people aren't always judging - they're sometimes letting off steam, saying what works for them or justifying decisions they secretly feel judged by. I found the hardest thing was conflicting advice between different health visitors and different consultants. Congratulations on your pregnancy!

StridTheKiller · 10/01/2023 04:27

Only if you seek it out and are looking to be offended.

SykesLane · 10/01/2023 04:19

MRSDoos · 09/01/2023 15:57

@Bizzyone congratulations! I definitely did expect some opinions but I just can’t believe the amount of judgement you get. Everyone wants to tell you how bad labour is and how bad being a mother is too 😂 I just think everyone tells you different opinions or looks down their nose at you

There’s honestly nothing you can do to be ‘right’.

I am childfree, my oldest sister has 1 child, my youngest sister has 2 children, my middle sister has 2 children, one sister in law has 3 children, one sister in law has 5 children. Do you know which of us is ‘wrong’? All of us. From how many children we do, or do not, have, the sex of the children, their names, their schools, their routines, their toys and more! - they’ve all been criticised.

Also the being told bad things about labour and being a mother thing, absolutely ridiculous at my workplace there’s three women who do nothing but complain about their children, they always tell me I have to have children because it’s amazing, joyful, a love like no other and all kinds of things about how my life is pointless. What do the pregnant women get told by these three women? How awful it is, they’ll have no life, no time, no money, they’ll never feel safe weeing ever again. I have no idea why people do it.

No matter what you do it will be wrong to someone but as long as your child is safe, happy and loved and you and the other parent are happy with your choices that’s all that matters. Congratulations on your pregnancy 💐