Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be expecting more from the police than this?

239 replies

Whatshouldhappenhere · 09/01/2023 09:02

I did start a thread over in chat a few days ago and received some helpful responses but I’m just looking for some general advice about the police/legal system in general and hoping someone can help. Also wondering whether I’m expecting too much.

Background is: 12 yo DS was attacked on his way home from school last week by a boy he recognised from school but had never interacted with before and didn’t even know his name. DS overtook three boys from his year at school, one boy pulled his airpod from his ear as he walked past so DS snatched it back, shouted at them and ran away. After a short while, DS realised they weren’t chasing so stopped running but this boy then decided to start chasing, caught up with DS and punched him 4-5 times in the face. A woman who lived on the street intervened so the boy stopped and ran away (who knows how long the attack would have gone on for had she not intervened).

My first port of call was the school as soon as I found out, they said the student liaison officer would phone me back. Then I called 101 who took all of the details, gave me a crime number and said an officer would visit to take a statement. The SLO found out the boy who attacked DS was expelled before Christmas so the school had no jurisdiction and couldn’t act. He found the other two boys and had a chat with them but that’s the end of school involvement. The assistant head spoke to me on the phone last Thursday and promised he would have a chat with DS on Friday morning but never did. I believe this was simply damage control more than anything, he was acting like my best friend throughout the chat but didn’t follow through with the promise to chat to DS so I’m fairly disappointed although I do understand why the school can do very little else.

A police officer visited on Saturday. I thought he would sit and take a lengthy statement and be here a while but he was here for 5 minutes. He simply asked DS what happened and told me he would go talk to the boy and his parents now. I asked why it wouldn’t be taken any further and he said they don’t like putting children through the legal system over what was probably a heat of the moment thing. He said he’s sure I wouldn’t want DS’s life potentially ruined if he did something like this so I said DS wouldn’t do something like this though whereas this boy has and he’s already been expelled from school.

Basically police stance was they don’t like to charge children because it can affect their lives forever so deal with it. I contacted 101 later that day after mulling over it to ask to speak to the officer or someone else about it because I’m disappointed in the outcome. They said the officer would call me straight back but I’m still awaiting that call. Contacted 101 again yesterday to chase the call back and they said someone would call me but they’re unable to offer a timescale so I’m not hopeful anyone will.

Where do I go from here, if anywhere? Have the police done enough? Is a chat with the boy sufficient and I’m being horrible expecting anything beyond this? It’s just the fact it was a totally unprovoked attack and my DS is a really good boy, his only mistake was walking past the wrong person at the wrong time.

OP posts:
Felix125 · 09/01/2023 15:26

What consequences would you consider to be taken against him?

Whatshouldhappenhere · 09/01/2023 15:25

Felix125 · 09/01/2023 15:18

Whatshouldhappenhere
I had no idea the police only legally have to investigate rape and murder, that’s obscene.

That's not the case at all. All crimes have to be recorded and an outcome reached. This may be a charge, summons, insufficient evidence to proceed, evidential difficulty etc etc. There is a closure code for not being in the public interest to pursue - but the police have to justify this irresolution.

What would you son like as the outcome to this - what was he expecting to happen from the police?

There would be no point in obtaining a statement from him if its not being persued to court.

If the investigation is still open & ongoing it sounds like they are still waiting to speak to the other parties involved.

Bepis
The problem is - there are always two sides to the story. She may have had an injury from the punch and a witness to back her up. And they will give a different version of events. What can the police do in this scenario?

Sorry, I was just replying to someone upthread who said this was the case.

My DS is only 12 years old so he doesn’t know what he expected or wanted from the police. We both expected more than a 5 minute visit from an officer and I think I expected more than a little chat with the boy. No idea what, I just don’t think this boy will care very much about a police visit. I don’t think he deserves to be in prison or anything like that for it but I think there needs to be some sort of consequence beyond the police giving him a little telling off.

If my DC step out of line, they know there are consequences and have been taught this from a very young age. This boy is clearly being taught there are very minor consequences if he does very bad things. I don’t think assault is a minor crime personally so is deserving of something more than a quick telling off.

OP posts:
Felix125 · 09/01/2023 15:18

Whatshouldhappenhere
I had no idea the police only legally have to investigate rape and murder, that’s obscene.

That's not the case at all. All crimes have to be recorded and an outcome reached. This may be a charge, summons, insufficient evidence to proceed, evidential difficulty etc etc. There is a closure code for not being in the public interest to pursue - but the police have to justify this irresolution.

What would you son like as the outcome to this - what was he expecting to happen from the police?

There would be no point in obtaining a statement from him if its not being persued to court.

If the investigation is still open & ongoing it sounds like they are still waiting to speak to the other parties involved.

Bepis
The problem is - there are always two sides to the story. She may have had an injury from the punch and a witness to back her up. And they will give a different version of events. What can the police do in this scenario?

Whatshouldhappenhere · 09/01/2023 15:17

TattiePants · 09/01/2023 14:48

@Whatshouldhappenhere my DS is a few years older than your DS but he was assaulted by a group of boys in school just before Christmas and we’ve had a much better response from the police than you have.

School reported it directly to the police and we had a call from the police straight after they’d received the report. The incident was deemed high priority and we were told an officer would be with us within an hour. DS told the officer what had happened informally and we were told we had two options. If we wanted to prosecute than DS would give a formal statement and each of the boys would be questioned with legal representation. Alternatively, if DS didn’t want to prosecute, an officer would go to each of their homes and speak to them and it would stay on their record.

We were given an incident number and a phone number / contact. The police then contacted us a few days later to see if we’d made a decision but as we had a meeting at school the following day, we wanted to see what the school’s punishment was (obviously that’s not relevant to your situation). At no point did any of the officers try to influence us one way or the other, they just gave us the facts. We were then called again on Boxing Day where we said we weren’t prosecuting (in our case because school were taking it so seriously). The officer confirmed that she would visit the boys after the holidays and would update us when it happened. We also had a call from Children’s Services who would have supported us if we’d needed it.

From what we’ve experienced, you should have had more support from the police and given there were 3 witnesses, you should have had the same 2 options as us.

Amazing response, I hope your DS is doing ok and sorry it happened to him too. I don’t know whether the response was better because your local police are better or because your DS is older but this is the sort of thing I would have liked to happen.

Instead we have had a phone call from the assistant headteacher who seemed nice enough but promised to speak to DS the following day and never did. An SLO who had a 10 second conversation with DS the day after the attack where he said the school couldn’t do anything because the boy had been expelled. I had to chase the SLO myself to find out why the other two boys weren’t at least located and spoken to and also whether they could inform the boy’s new school because he seemed to think this response was adequate. Then a police officer who spoke to us for five minutes, barely asked for any details and said he would go have a chat with the boy because he didn’t want him to end up in the legal system. Not great, I’m just disappointed to say the least.

OP posts:
AhoyMaBuoy · 09/01/2023 15:14

It's not working though is it @limoncelloo this could have been research from years ago , times change
Assault should never be ignored

Bepis · 09/01/2023 15:07

@limoncelloo Do you really think it works now?

Bepis · 09/01/2023 15:07

Whatshouldhappenhere · 09/01/2023 12:43

I think it’s the fact we teach children that they should tell the police if something bad happens and that the police are there to help. Realistically, they seem to do very little unless it’s something truly heinous and even then it’s not guaranteed. Just feel enormously disappointed and let down.

It's a sad state of affairs that it's got to this. My kids have witnessed things growing up, with me asking the police for help with little success. My own children have no faith in the police and they have even said to me that they wouldn't be protected if something happened.

Someone mentioned about the police siding with the criminal and I have personally experienced that. My old neighbours came round to our house drunk and annoyed because we had asked them to keep their music down through the night. Female neighbour grabs me, so I punched her. No injury, it was more a warning to get off me as she had laid her hands on me first and I thought she was going to hit me. Anyway, despite explaining what happened, and having it on audio, the police said I was the aggressor and I was the one who assaulted her. You can't win 🤷🏻‍♀️

limoncelloo · 09/01/2023 14:58

@AhoyMaBuoy, a quick Google will show you the subject has been extensively researched over many years. What we were doing before didn't work, hence why things have changed.

@Face2facet you say criminalising is better than doing nothing, but no one here knows that nothing is being done.
If the child is a prolific offender and there is evidence to this incident there is no way the crime report could be written off by an officer as "words of advice/chat". Crime reports that are filed with no further action have to be done so by a supervisor, so they would review this. If he isn't a prolific offender then words of advice is proportionate.

TattiePants · 09/01/2023 14:48

@Whatshouldhappenhere my DS is a few years older than your DS but he was assaulted by a group of boys in school just before Christmas and we’ve had a much better response from the police than you have.

School reported it directly to the police and we had a call from the police straight after they’d received the report. The incident was deemed high priority and we were told an officer would be with us within an hour. DS told the officer what had happened informally and we were told we had two options. If we wanted to prosecute than DS would give a formal statement and each of the boys would be questioned with legal representation. Alternatively, if DS didn’t want to prosecute, an officer would go to each of their homes and speak to them and it would stay on their record.

We were given an incident number and a phone number / contact. The police then contacted us a few days later to see if we’d made a decision but as we had a meeting at school the following day, we wanted to see what the school’s punishment was (obviously that’s not relevant to your situation). At no point did any of the officers try to influence us one way or the other, they just gave us the facts. We were then called again on Boxing Day where we said we weren’t prosecuting (in our case because school were taking it so seriously). The officer confirmed that she would visit the boys after the holidays and would update us when it happened. We also had a call from Children’s Services who would have supported us if we’d needed it.

From what we’ve experienced, you should have had more support from the police and given there were 3 witnesses, you should have had the same 2 options as us.

Whatshouldhappenhere · 09/01/2023 14:26

I had no idea the police only legally have to investigate rape and murder, that’s obscene.

OP posts:
Whatshouldhappenhere · 09/01/2023 14:25

Homedeco · 09/01/2023 14:05

How old is the boy that attacked him? Might be relevant in terms of criminal responsibility.

Ultimately the police have no “customer service” aspect to their role. They might not call you back if they’re busy and the decision is final. They don’t have to, unfortunately.

one thing you need to remember is that legally, the police don’t have to investigate every crime reported to them. they only have a legal duty to investigate serious offences like murder and rape - so it could be the case that they refuse to investigate this and that decision can’t be appealed unless you make a formal complaint.

12/13. He was in the same year as DS but DS didn’t know his name and had never interacted with him before this, just recognised him from around school. No classes together or anything, literally no reason for the boy to target DS whatsoever. Just a random attack because DS happened to be walking past him on the way home. I think that’s what has got to me above all else. I could accept it more if they had some sort of ongoing issue with one another and DS provoked him in some way but DS is a really great kid who doesn’t get involved with drama of any sort.

OP posts:
Igglepiggleslittletoe · 09/01/2023 14:12

Soontobe60 · 09/01/2023 14:10

Yes, adults assaulting children is a really good look.

You have totally misread what I meant.

As I said before on this thread I do not condone violence and do condone police punishment and would hound the bloody police to get the bullies charged.

Face2facet · 09/01/2023 14:11

limoncelloo · 09/01/2023 14:00

@Bard6817

What about everyone else?

Research has shown that in short, criminalising children fundamentally and adversely affects their development in many ways. This creates adults who have M/H difficulties, struggle with unemployment, put pressure on health services just to name a few.

As well as this, criminalising children can reinforce to them that they are “bad” at a time when they are still developing. For those that have a difficult home life, or are being exploited in anyway, this basically just tells them that it is correct they are awful people who will never amount to anything. This is why intervention to change behaviour is the preferred method.

For those that say the age of criminal responsibility is 10, yes it is. However in the same breath we don’t let children vote, smoke, drink, have sex etc etc. because they are still developing. It has been proven many times over that criminalising children doesn’t have a good outcome for society as a whole.

Yes the ideal would be various sorts of interventions, but that doesn’t seem to be happening. If the choice was between criminalising and doing nothing, criminalising would be preferable because at least then they might have second thoughts about beating an innocent up again, and the innicest would see some for on justice.

Soontobe60 · 09/01/2023 14:10

Igglepiggleslittletoe · 09/01/2023 09:34

I do not understand the attitudes on here. ANYONE lays a finger on my kids and I would want the pujnishment to be as hard as possible. This shite of 'ah your kid was ok in the end' does not wash with me. Kids like this need to be shown it is NOT ok to bully other kids. I would be livid and constantly contacting the police till something is done. I see some little chavvy kids around where I live and one of them touches my kids and I can assure you the little fuckers would not be getting away with it.

Yes, adults assaulting children is a really good look.

AhoyMaBuoy · 09/01/2023 14:06

Research by who @limoncelloo ?

Homedeco · 09/01/2023 14:05

How old is the boy that attacked him? Might be relevant in terms of criminal responsibility.

Ultimately the police have no “customer service” aspect to their role. They might not call you back if they’re busy and the decision is final. They don’t have to, unfortunately.

one thing you need to remember is that legally, the police don’t have to investigate every crime reported to them. they only have a legal duty to investigate serious offences like murder and rape - so it could be the case that they refuse to investigate this and that decision can’t be appealed unless you make a formal complaint.

limoncelloo · 09/01/2023 14:00

@Bard6817

What about everyone else?

Research has shown that in short, criminalising children fundamentally and adversely affects their development in many ways. This creates adults who have M/H difficulties, struggle with unemployment, put pressure on health services just to name a few.

As well as this, criminalising children can reinforce to them that they are “bad” at a time when they are still developing. For those that have a difficult home life, or are being exploited in anyway, this basically just tells them that it is correct they are awful people who will never amount to anything. This is why intervention to change behaviour is the preferred method.

For those that say the age of criminal responsibility is 10, yes it is. However in the same breath we don’t let children vote, smoke, drink, have sex etc etc. because they are still developing. It has been proven many times over that criminalising children doesn’t have a good outcome for society as a whole.

Bard6817 · 09/01/2023 13:39

limoncelloo · 09/01/2023 09:50

The police very rarely criminalise children now, and the threshold to do so is extremely high. There is no such thing as "juvey" anymore. There are reasons why children are not criminalised which are evidence based and have been extensively researched.

The child would need to be a prolific, prolific offender for this to happen. By criminalise, I mean the highest this tends to go is a youth conditional caution whereby the child would be cautioned and would have to complete some rehabilitative conditions attach to this. It is not as simple as "charging" someone.

What I'm saying is the police will have looked at the history of the suspect, if he has no history of doing things like this it unlikely something like this would he touched by a youth offending team or CPS.

You could ask about the possibility of an out of court disposal/community resolution? For this to happen though the suspect would need to admit guilt. It would involve taking a statement from your son, and then some paperwork is completed with both parties, the offender would admit to the offence and sign to say they will not repeat the behaviour/will leave you son alone etc etc. This is kept on record and if there are any further incidents this can be used.

I'm sorry for what happened to your son, and it sounds like a very scary situation for him. I hope the information I've given you doesn't sound blunt, but just trying to explain how the system works.

Don’t forget to mention the youth offending teams based in courts who consider it a win when their gaming the system results in no criminal record for a young person.

Personally all i see it doing, is societally we have young people consistently going through the system, no consequences for their actions, their victims suffering, and when they turn into adults, they are in for a bit of a shock on their next incident.

The research might say it’s better for the young person, but…. what about everyone else?

Terven · 09/01/2023 13:38

Call social services and tell them. Hopefully they will act to safeguard both your son and the attacker. Possibly there’s a family situation that needs looking into. Kids don’t behave like that without a reason.

justasking111 · 09/01/2023 13:28

@lljkk turning the other cheek when her DS is used as a punch bag is seriously concerning. It's not her body, nor her pain, fear, suffering.

Igglepiggleslittletoe · 09/01/2023 13:21

So kids 14-16 who definitely know better were able to just get on with things because they beat up your child and you DID NOT want them to get into trouble? It is almost like you are siding with the bullies over your own child.

Nobody I can tell you will harm one hair on my kids heads without being punished. If you do not want a criminal record then you should not be commiting crimes to begin with.

Whatshouldhappenhere · 09/01/2023 13:18

DS (age 11-13) was twice innocently beaten up by other kid(s) at age 14/16

How is one ‘innocently’ beaten up, exactly?

I don’t want him to have a criminal record necessarily, I just think he deserves something beyond a short telling off by a police officer which he probably won’t take seriously anyway. I do believe in rehabilitation so perhaps this is a route the police could take with him but I guess he’ll have to commit more crimes before this happens.

OP posts:
euff · 09/01/2023 13:16

I'm so sorry for some of the comments you are getting on here. I can see now why parents resort to putting videos and information on social media when things have happened to their kids. At least it warns other people. Glad your son is okay.

lljkk · 09/01/2023 13:16

Making the lad into a criminal won't make him into a better nicer person. It will just teach him to confidently embrace a thug identity (since that's how everyone else sees him).

DS (age 11-13) was twice innocently beaten up by other kid(s) at age 14/16; over my dead body did I want the other kids to get criminal records from it. Was happy for police to handle situation in other ways.

If we had a criminal justice system focused on rehabilitation not punishment then maybe I could think like OP.

OneTC · 09/01/2023 13:16

Whatshouldhappenhere · 09/01/2023 12:57

Why? Because the police shouldn’t investigate an assault? Or is it ok for kids to assault other kids?

Not at all, I just have extensive experience dealing with the police so have low expectations