Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be expecting more from the police than this?

239 replies

Whatshouldhappenhere · 09/01/2023 09:02

I did start a thread over in chat a few days ago and received some helpful responses but I’m just looking for some general advice about the police/legal system in general and hoping someone can help. Also wondering whether I’m expecting too much.

Background is: 12 yo DS was attacked on his way home from school last week by a boy he recognised from school but had never interacted with before and didn’t even know his name. DS overtook three boys from his year at school, one boy pulled his airpod from his ear as he walked past so DS snatched it back, shouted at them and ran away. After a short while, DS realised they weren’t chasing so stopped running but this boy then decided to start chasing, caught up with DS and punched him 4-5 times in the face. A woman who lived on the street intervened so the boy stopped and ran away (who knows how long the attack would have gone on for had she not intervened).

My first port of call was the school as soon as I found out, they said the student liaison officer would phone me back. Then I called 101 who took all of the details, gave me a crime number and said an officer would visit to take a statement. The SLO found out the boy who attacked DS was expelled before Christmas so the school had no jurisdiction and couldn’t act. He found the other two boys and had a chat with them but that’s the end of school involvement. The assistant head spoke to me on the phone last Thursday and promised he would have a chat with DS on Friday morning but never did. I believe this was simply damage control more than anything, he was acting like my best friend throughout the chat but didn’t follow through with the promise to chat to DS so I’m fairly disappointed although I do understand why the school can do very little else.

A police officer visited on Saturday. I thought he would sit and take a lengthy statement and be here a while but he was here for 5 minutes. He simply asked DS what happened and told me he would go talk to the boy and his parents now. I asked why it wouldn’t be taken any further and he said they don’t like putting children through the legal system over what was probably a heat of the moment thing. He said he’s sure I wouldn’t want DS’s life potentially ruined if he did something like this so I said DS wouldn’t do something like this though whereas this boy has and he’s already been expelled from school.

Basically police stance was they don’t like to charge children because it can affect their lives forever so deal with it. I contacted 101 later that day after mulling over it to ask to speak to the officer or someone else about it because I’m disappointed in the outcome. They said the officer would call me straight back but I’m still awaiting that call. Contacted 101 again yesterday to chase the call back and they said someone would call me but they’re unable to offer a timescale so I’m not hopeful anyone will.

Where do I go from here, if anywhere? Have the police done enough? Is a chat with the boy sufficient and I’m being horrible expecting anything beyond this? It’s just the fact it was a totally unprovoked attack and my DS is a really good boy, his only mistake was walking past the wrong person at the wrong time.

OP posts:
limoncelloo · 09/01/2023 16:33

Face2facet · 09/01/2023 16:32

I think if the kids involved has to pick up litter for one hour a week for 8 weeks it might make him think twice about punching someone next time.

Police also can't make anyone pick up litter.

Felix125 · 09/01/2023 16:33

Face2facet ·
I think if the kids involved has to pick up litter for one hour a week for 8 weeks it might make him think twice about punching someone next time.

great - an who enforces that?

And what happens if they don't comply to it?

limoncelloo · 09/01/2023 16:32

@Whatshouldhappenhere I noted you said further down somewhere that you would maybe have liked for the boy to do some sort of programme etc so he could understand his actions.

Unfortunately police can't impose something like this on anyone unless it's as part of a conditional caution, for which they need to admit the offence.

For example, let's say, the police decide to bring the boy in for a voluntary interview regarding what's happened (he can say no as it's voluntary, but he says yes). He has a duty solicitor. The neighbour has given a witness statement where she describes the incident and describes the boy in question. Your son has also given a statement and describes the boy in question. The hearsay from school doesn't count so this wouldn't be presented as any evidence but police have these two statements.

Any good solicitor will tell the boy to "no comment" or say it wasn't him. Even if the statements describe him, there is no video of the incident to confirm this. He could say it might be someone that looked like him, or say nothing at all. The solicitor will advise him to say nothing, as he knows regardless CPS won't touch the case for a youth anyway if he's not a prolific offender.

Hence we have the same result. We can't have a conditional caution or impose any conditions for him to do a programme on his behaviour as he hasn't admitted guilt.

I'm just trying to help you understand the system.

Face2facet · 09/01/2023 16:32

I think if the kids involved has to pick up litter for one hour a week for 8 weeks it might make him think twice about punching someone next time.

CockSpadget · 09/01/2023 16:31

@Felix125

To be expecting more from the police than this?
Felix125 · 09/01/2023 16:31

CockSpadget
Yes I know common assault doesn't need to make contact - the threat part is enough for assault. That's why its classed as assault & battery if contact is made.

But there is no way on earth that CPS would charge a scratch or minor bruise as ABH

I think you may be looking at criming standards as apposed to charging standards.

Whatshouldhappenhere · 09/01/2023 16:30

Gigglechop · 09/01/2023 16:25

But the bruising actually on his face has all but gone?

Yes.

OP posts:
Whatshouldhappenhere · 09/01/2023 16:29

Gigglechop · 09/01/2023 16:24

I’d be very very surprised if the the boys who witnessed it didn’t record it on their phones

Same tbh.

OP posts:
Bepis · 09/01/2023 16:29

CockSpadget · 09/01/2023 16:28

@Felix125 i got it from a legal website. I suggest you do some research, common assault doesn’t even have to include contact, and ABH can be even minor injuries that don’t require hospital treatment.

Correct as defined in my criminal law textbook.

CockSpadget · 09/01/2023 16:29

Felix125 · 09/01/2023 16:27

This ABH argument is crime recording standards as apposed to charging standards.

If its bruising to his face - the charge would be common assault

Wrong again.

CockSpadget · 09/01/2023 16:28

@Felix125 i got it from a legal website. I suggest you do some research, common assault doesn’t even have to include contact, and ABH can be even minor injuries that don’t require hospital treatment.

Felix125 · 09/01/2023 16:27

This ABH argument is crime recording standards as apposed to charging standards.

If its bruising to his face - the charge would be common assault

Bepis · 09/01/2023 16:26

Felix125 · 09/01/2023 16:24

CockSpadget

not sure where you have got that from, but CPS will never charge a scratch as a ABH. You will need medical evidence in any case and i assume the victim did not go to hospital

They may not charge it but they could if they wanted to as that is the definition within the law. It's the CPS picking a choosing what they want to prosecute.

Gigglechop · 09/01/2023 16:25

But the bruising actually on his face has all but gone?

Felix125 · 09/01/2023 16:25

Thereisnolight
OP probably wants the perpetrator to receive a penalty that makes him think twice about doing this again. She’s being highly unreasonable I know

Such as......?

Bepis · 09/01/2023 16:25

I agree with @CockSpadget definition of ABH. I studied this under criminal law for my LLB and it incorporates any injury to the body, whether that be bruising, scratches etc.

GBH is when it starts getting more serious.

You can assault someone without even touching them, if you place them in fear that immediate physical violence is going to be used on them. So someone going up shouting in someone's face with their first clenched and held up would still be an assault even if they didn't touch them.

Whatshouldhappenhere · 09/01/2023 16:24

Gigglechop · 09/01/2023 16:24

Sorry if clarified but no photos at all? You didn’t take any photos of the bruising and it’s already gone down?

I have now said twice that I got photos of his face and showed the officer the photos.

OP posts:
Gigglechop · 09/01/2023 16:24

I’d be very very surprised if the the boys who witnessed it didn’t record it on their phones

nothingmuchaboutjerry · 09/01/2023 16:24

@CockSpadget you describe it perfectly. My daughters attackers have been charged with Section 47 - otherwise known as ABH and the description you've provided is accurate to her injuries. The sentence you give though is different to what we've been told, we've been told to expect quite a poor sentence with it being their first offence. In my case everything initially was dealt with very quickly. In the OPs case the police seem to have already made a decision.

Felix125 · 09/01/2023 16:24

CockSpadget

not sure where you have got that from, but CPS will never charge a scratch as a ABH. You will need medical evidence in any case and i assume the victim did not go to hospital

Gigglechop · 09/01/2023 16:24

Sorry if clarified but no photos at all? You didn’t take any photos of the bruising and it’s already gone down?

Whatshouldhappenhere · 09/01/2023 16:23

Thereisnolight · 09/01/2023 16:20

OP your son should have videoed the incident (he should have known in advance it was going to happen). Otherwise he has no proof it happened.

Next, that woman should not have intervened. Thanks to her do-gooding busybodiness your son was not seriously injured, which is unfortunate as the incident now cannot be taken seriously. The other boy has every right to hit whomever he pleases as long as they don’t suffer life-long injuries or die. (Even then, see above re video).

This is police policy - what else did you expect them to do? Anyway boys will be boys.

May surprise you to hear this but my DS didn’t think to retrieve his phone from his pocket, bring the camera up and start recording because he is 12 and also a regular human being who was being punched in the face at the time.

I’m grateful the woman saved my son from any further harm personally, I don’t know many people who would resent someone for doing this. Your outlook is odd.

OP posts:
OwwwMuuuum · 09/01/2023 16:23

Igglepiggleslittletoe · 09/01/2023 09:34

I do not understand the attitudes on here. ANYONE lays a finger on my kids and I would want the pujnishment to be as hard as possible. This shite of 'ah your kid was ok in the end' does not wash with me. Kids like this need to be shown it is NOT ok to bully other kids. I would be livid and constantly contacting the police till something is done. I see some little chavvy kids around where I live and one of them touches my kids and I can assure you the little fuckers would not be getting away with it.

This, I totally agree. BUT wouldn’t expect the police to do anything about it. My trust/belief in the police is zero these days. So many reasons but the main ones are the lack of police support for minor crimes I’ve been victim of over the years (theft, damage to property) and obviously the institutional racism, sexism, Sarah Everard etc etc. I just wouldn’t expect anything at all, then you won’t be disappointed.

Felix125 · 09/01/2023 16:22

Whatshouldhappenhere

To ID a suspect, it has to be done via an ID parade - not just looking at someone on social media and identifying them

Thereisnolight · 09/01/2023 16:21

Felix125 · 09/01/2023 16:20

Whatshouldhappenhere

It depends what you are wanting as the outcome?

OP probably wants the perpetrator to receive a penalty that makes him think twice about doing this again. She’s being highly unreasonable I know