Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Blacker isn't better?

58 replies

Lougle · 09/01/2023 08:05

I had my eyes tested yesterday. Standard 'Is it better with 1, 2, or about the same?' stuff. The optician said that I 'chase the negative' so I always choose the option that is smaller and darker. I was puzzled and said that I thought the darker the black, the clearer it is, so 'better'. He said that some people 'chase the negative' so it's easy for an inexperienced optician to overcorrect their sight.

Why don't they tell you what 'better' means from the outset, and why isn't blacker better?

OP posts:
DoNotGetADog · 09/01/2023 09:31

Also - I would never say “better.” I say “clearer” or “clearer and blacker” or “clearer and rounder” depending on which bit I’m doing.

DoNotGetADog · 09/01/2023 09:29

Lougle · 09/01/2023 09:25

I think it might be a personality flaw on my part. I'm not very good at taking things at face value and like to understand the 'why'. That means that I can overthink and get in a terrible muddle. It's very stressful. DH loves eye tests.

Yes - people are all different! You explain things depending on relevance/need/interest of the patient/their ability to understand etc.

SamphiretheTervosaurReturneth · 09/01/2023 09:28

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 09/01/2023 09:17

It is a bit strange that they don’t explain what they mean at the outset

But they do. "Better" is a very personal thing. And some, like OP, my Dh etc, are the outliers, people who need more explanation because 'better' is too amorphous.

A good optician will catch them quite quickly but they can go for a while with overly strong prescriptions. It took a while for DH as it was his first time in glasses and he chose the clearer colours rather than sharper lettering. Optician caught him the second time.

Lougle · 09/01/2023 09:25

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 09/01/2023 09:17

It is a bit strange that they don’t explain what they mean at the outset

I think it might be a personality flaw on my part. I'm not very good at taking things at face value and like to understand the 'why'. That means that I can overthink and get in a terrible muddle. It's very stressful. DH loves eye tests.

OP posts:
GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 09/01/2023 09:17

It is a bit strange that they don’t explain what they mean at the outset

Lougle · 09/01/2023 09:16

Thank you! I'm hoping my migraines will decrease, although the optometrist said that it will take a couple of weeks to get used to the new glasses and that I might think they're worse at first.

OP posts:
DoNotGetADog · 09/01/2023 09:12

Basically with short sighted people if you add minus power until it’s clear, and then show them another -0.25 on top it will just start to look smaller and blacker (minus power lenses make things look smaller), which they may interpret as being clearer. Actually though they can see the letter just as clear without it.

If the person is quite young, being overcorrected won’t usually affect them, but usually the overcorrection will be dropped from the prescription as they get older and it’s too much hard work to look through it all the time.

To be honest, this is just something an experienced optometrist does without thinking too much and without really needing to highlight it to you, but maybe they just wanted to explain why your prescription decreased.

To the person asking how the optician can tell - it’s just a matter of judgement and experience. (Although you can get it wrong occasionally!)

FurryDandelionSeekingMissile · 09/01/2023 09:11

I've also been told myopes have to be reined in because we always want our vision over-corrected. It's that lovely crisp clear tiny sharpness 😍

underneaththeash · 09/01/2023 09:05

Op I’m an optometrist. With just the circles you want ‘rounder and clearer’ and with the red/green you want clearer and blacker.

We have alternatives for both of the tests and also a device called a retinoscope which we use for children and people who struggle with the tests. This combined with an autorefractor Mean we often have a good idea of what you’re going to say before you say it.

Usually, as you get older your distance vision gets less short-sighted/more long sighted. And close vision wearing glasses gets worse.

it does vary though, plenty of people get more short-sighted, just fewer as a percentage.

DoNotGetADog · 09/01/2023 09:04

Lougle · 09/01/2023 08:59

Yes! 'the individual circles are clearer, but now it's an oval, not a circle.'

The red/green screen with the 8s, too. The green side is a darker black, but I'm not sure if that's because the green shows a better contrast with the number, or if it's clearer. Give me two 8s, both on the same background, then I'll be able to tell you.

I so want to get it right, but never feel like I do!

The whole point of that test is the red or green background, so if you were shown two 8s on the same background it wouldn’t do anything!

If you have too much minus in your prescription they look clearer on the green, too much plus and they look clearer on the red.

CitronVert22 · 09/01/2023 09:00

I interpret blacker as clearer in that when the prescription is wrong, the fuzziness means that the black is duliuted because it's spread over a larger area, and mixed in with the white/green/red.

Lougle · 09/01/2023 08:59

SteveHarringtonsChestHair · 09/01/2023 08:56

I’m always confused when the circles are clearer but not so round! They say “better with or without?” and it’s like “it’s clearer but now it’s a square not a circle” Grin

Yes! 'the individual circles are clearer, but now it's an oval, not a circle.'

The red/green screen with the 8s, too. The green side is a darker black, but I'm not sure if that's because the green shows a better contrast with the number, or if it's clearer. Give me two 8s, both on the same background, then I'll be able to tell you.

I so want to get it right, but never feel like I do!

OP posts:
SteveHarringtonsChestHair · 09/01/2023 08:56

I’m always confused when the circles are clearer but not so round! They say “better with or without?” and it’s like “it’s clearer but now it’s a square not a circle” Grin

Lougle · 09/01/2023 08:49

'Chasing the negative' apparently means that when I'm given two options, I always choose the one that has more of a correction for short-sightedness, so a 'stronger' correction. I've always assumed that being able to read smaller text clearly is 'better' and that 'blacker' is 'clearer', but it seems that isn't the case.

OP posts:
itwasboundtohappen · 09/01/2023 08:37

i don't understand most of this.

  1. I alway say what is clearest
  1. when doing some weird test to press a button when I notice something, I stopped and asked them to clarify exactly what and when I was supposed to hit the button.
  1. my eyesight both shortsighted and longsighted has deteriorated 🤷‍♀️ they didn't tell me that's not possible.

I don't wear my glasses all the time. probably should but the optician is fine with me not.

Whatwhatwhatnow · 09/01/2023 08:36

To me, clearer and blacker are generally the same! I do notice text looking blacker when I put on my glasses. Confused now as I've never heard of "chasing the negative!"

Lougle · 09/01/2023 08:33

oudie · 09/01/2023 08:32

I'm autistic and I need things properly explained, it's fine now I'm aware of it but for years I had no idea what we relent being asked of me during an eye test. Now I tell them I need clear instruction, particularly when it comes to which is 'better'!

I strongly suspect I am, too. I did tell the optician that it felt like an exam with no mark scheme!

OP posts:
oudie · 09/01/2023 08:32

I'm autistic and I need things properly explained, it's fine now I'm aware of it but for years I had no idea what we relent being asked of me during an eye test. Now I tell them I need clear instruction, particularly when it comes to which is 'better'!

MillicentMargaretAmanda · 09/01/2023 08:30

Got told mine would stop deteriorating in my early 40s. 47 and one eye has nosed dived another -.75 in the past 2.5 years. 🙄 No comment on the blacker/clearer thing though.

knittingaddict · 09/01/2023 08:30

Kinnorafron · 09/01/2023 08:29

Yes I have in fact had an eye test recently - I had forgotten about the circles - but my Optician doesn't ask which is blacker, just the clearest.

You're right, they do say clearer.

knittingaddict · 09/01/2023 08:29

Other people are right, they usually ask which is clearer, not blacker. The clearer ones do usually appear blacker though, don't they?

My prescription is correct, so must be answering ok.

Kinnorafron · 09/01/2023 08:29

knittingaddict · 09/01/2023 08:26

O you have your eyes tested regularly?

It's not the shade of the letters. They have black circles and you are asked to say when it's blacker (clearer) with different lenses.

Yes I have in fact had an eye test recently - I had forgotten about the circles - but my Optician doesn't ask which is blacker, just the clearest.

knittingaddict · 09/01/2023 08:26

Kinnorafron · 09/01/2023 08:09

I don't know what you mean? I always try to find the letters at their clearest - I have never noticed any difference in the shade of the letters.

O you have your eyes tested regularly?

It's not the shade of the letters. They have black circles and you are asked to say when it's blacker (clearer) with different lenses.

NumberTheory · 09/01/2023 08:23

I get this too OP. Sometimes they’re blacker and a bit smaller. It feels like they’re more distinct. Took me a few tests to realise I couldn’t actually read them any better!

TerraNostra · 09/01/2023 08:22

I thought this was going to be a discussion about something someone had said about skin colour, I clicked with quite a lot of trepidation!

I always go by the crispness of the outline. I do worry sometimes that I answer incorrectly but I think they have ways of testing you that cater for the fact that some responses will be made too quickly- it does always feel quite stressful with the quick-fire questioning!

Swipe left for the next trending thread