Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To send feedback to this church

65 replies

candlelightflora · 08/01/2023 18:43

Just interested in people’s opinions on this.

I used to go to church with DD when she was younger, but stopped during covid. Then we moved to a new area, too far from the old church to go there anymore. I’ve wanted to start going to church again for a while and DD was keen to go as she has good memories of the old church. So I found a church nearby which has a “family service” once a month.

For context, we live in a town with a very well-regarded state secondary school which is selective on faith grounds. DD is only 7 so too young for us to be thinking about secondary applications yet.

Having now been to a “family service” at the church, I think they should re-name it to “service for people who want to get their kids into [insert name of well-regarded secondary faith school]”.

When I arrived, people were queuing to get their “passports” stamped. I said it was our first time at the church and rather than receiving a welcome, how are you, what has brought you here (as I was expecting) I got a brusque “how old is your daughter? Ok she doesn’t need one of these then”.

DD said she’d like to collect the stamps so I asked if we could have a “passport” anyway just for fun (it was literally a folded piece of paper) even though we’re not applying for secondary school yet and was unapologetically told that was not allowed.

The service itself had zero family focus in my opinion, it just seemed like a shortened version of a normal service. The hymns were really quiet as nobody was really singing, I spotted a couple of adults on their phones, and I literally did not see one single adult there who didn’t have a child with them of late primary age (i.e. applying for secondary schools in the next couple of years). Our old church had a really interactive sermon aimed at kids, lots of opportunities to join in, colouring and toys for the younger ones but there was nothing like that.

DD left saying she thought it was really boring and doesn’t want to go again. I left feeling really annoyed that we’d been made to feel so unwelcome.

Is there any point in me diplomatically feeding this back to the church? Or should I just move on and try a different church. I guess it could be that they just don’t care - they know they need to provide a service for those applying to the secondary school and this meets that need. But the whole thing just felt so cynical and I’m annoyed that something billed as a “family service” wasn’t really that at all.

OP posts:
GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 08/01/2023 22:34

Sounds horrendous. The whole idea of the stamping passports thing.

I don’t think there’s a problem with there being faith schools but I think anyone who wants should be able to send their kids there, whether or not they belong to the religion, if they want them educated in that way.

Going to church doesn’t seem like any way to assess if people are following the actual principles of said religion.

ZenNudist · 08/01/2023 22:33

I'd just look for a better church. My school doesn't do passports or anything like that. You have to have proof of baptism to go to primary and you'd have to attend mass to get your child baptised (I didn't but that's a different story).

You also have to have proof of baptism to get into the secondary but there's no requirement to do first Holy communion or attend church in the previous decade.

People tend to show up at mass around first Holy communion and then stop again. Means many dc don't get as far as confirmation.

Whilst I think its a shame so many people are not interested in their faith my priest takes a lovely relaxed attitude and see the big picture that in these crumbs of religion lie seeds of future faith for anyone who wants or needs it.

It's not our place to judge people and I'm sure you weren't being judgemental just bummed out by the atmosphere.

Not much point saying anything to the priest. What can he do about it?

MissTrip82 · 08/01/2023 22:26

Perhaps just find a different church where you’re not so distracted by judging everybody. It’s a wasted trip if your whole time was spent looking around you and finding fault.

candlelightflora · 08/01/2023 22:22

welshrabbits · 08/01/2023 22:18

It’s a very large town, there are plenty of other schools!

There are so many secondary schools that people can still go to a nearby one that isn't affiliated with this church?

Yes! Maybe that’s unusual, I didn’t realise.

OP posts:
candlelightflora · 08/01/2023 22:20

BionicEar · 08/01/2023 20:22

Reading your post made me feel really sad as this is not what church should be.

Have heard of other churches like this. A friend went to one, which used a points system. You got more points for helping on the tea rota, attending Alpha Course etc. It didn’t take into consideration whether you were a single parents or has child with additional needs which would make it more difficult for parent to “earn the points”.

Take heart that not all churches are like this. The church I go, has a thriving children and youth ministry team and works towards including all in its services. The only way it notes if you’ve attended is from the register kept within the children groups and that would include if your child only ever attended the kids’ version of the youth group midweek and not church. They will countersign form you’ve submitted to school to verify that your child has attended there. A much better system and people actually feel welcomed and included in the church, rather than just turning up for “points”.

Please do feedback to the church and maybe to the Bishop of the area so that they are made aware of how this is unwelcoming and also not a way of bringing people to faith.

I agree with you, it made me feel really sad that some churches are set up in this way. So transactional.

I suppose I can just laugh it off and try a different church in a couple of weeks. I’ve had positive experiences in the past with other churches so I know that it can be a lot better than this. But someone attending for the first time might be completely put off.

OP posts:
QuillBill · 08/01/2023 22:19

Can you get a passport that makes sure your child doesn't get a place at a religious school?

welshrabbits · 08/01/2023 22:18

It’s a very large town, there are plenty of other schools!

There are so many secondary schools that people can still go to a nearby one that isn't affiliated with this church?

gogohmm · 08/01/2023 22:16

Please do give them feedback and find another church. Unfortunately a large number of people every year do "find religion" around 6 months before school applications are due, they often are "desperate" to have children baptised in September I find. I also seem to have a rush of engaged couples about now, all saying they do have a "strong connection" to our beautiful church despite living 15 miles away and I'm pretty sure never visiting the church before that day.

Might be on to something with the passports .... though we have a proper family service!

candlelightflora · 08/01/2023 22:13

Binfluencer · 08/01/2023 22:10

Well what do you expect? The church's preposterous occupation of the education system to the point where religious discrimination is allowed has forced people to behave like this. People should be entitled to a place at their local school, it's outrageous that lack of church attendance can prevent this.

You anger should be directed at the system and the corrupt behaviour of the church.

It’s a very large town, there are plenty of other schools!

OP posts:
Binfluencer · 08/01/2023 22:10

Well what do you expect? The church's preposterous occupation of the education system to the point where religious discrimination is allowed has forced people to behave like this. People should be entitled to a place at their local school, it's outrageous that lack of church attendance can prevent this.

You anger should be directed at the system and the corrupt behaviour of the church.

Untitledsquatboulder · 08/01/2023 22:10

Well churches have been forcing attendance for hundreds of years and this is just another example of it.

PetraBP · 08/01/2023 22:02

I’d go back to old Church if you can and let new Church know that you were real worshipers who were made to feel
unwelcome.

lap90 · 08/01/2023 20:54

What? I had no idea some Church's are doing this. I can't say i've seen it at the Churches i have attended and there are lots of kids and teens in my current one.

I would try a different Church.

pinneddownbytabbies · 08/01/2023 20:45

I can't help wondering whether the church specifically puts on this once a month service for this reason only, and all the other services would be where you'd find the regular congregation.

Maybe see what other services there are, and go to one of them instead.

BionicEar · 08/01/2023 20:22

Reading your post made me feel really sad as this is not what church should be.

Have heard of other churches like this. A friend went to one, which used a points system. You got more points for helping on the tea rota, attending Alpha Course etc. It didn’t take into consideration whether you were a single parents or has child with additional needs which would make it more difficult for parent to “earn the points”.

Take heart that not all churches are like this. The church I go, has a thriving children and youth ministry team and works towards including all in its services. The only way it notes if you’ve attended is from the register kept within the children groups and that would include if your child only ever attended the kids’ version of the youth group midweek and not church. They will countersign form you’ve submitted to school to verify that your child has attended there. A much better system and people actually feel welcomed and included in the church, rather than just turning up for “points”.

Please do feedback to the church and maybe to the Bishop of the area so that they are made aware of how this is unwelcoming and also not a way of bringing people to faith.

user1496262496 · 08/01/2023 20:03

I bet this sort of thing never happens at the Latin Mass Society…

Violinist64 · 08/01/2023 19:33

Try another church for sure. There is bound to be one that will welcome you and your daughter.

Herewegoagain84 · 08/01/2023 19:32

I guess it depends whether you want your DD to go to that particular faith school in the future, even if not now?!

daemonologie · 08/01/2023 19:23

YANBU but I'm sure the whole point of churches is to praise God. That's it.

NotMeNoNo · 08/01/2023 19:21

Maybe the church has been forced into this setup and knows from experience that the attending families will melt away in March or whenever the school places are awarded. You could try another church not connected to the school or a different week of the month. I'd contact the vicar and say straight up we actually want to attend church long term, we've moved from X town, do you have any ongoing children's church activities?

Patchworksack · 08/01/2023 19:19

I would send feedback - it sounds like whatever the actual reason for families being there they could be meeting their needs much better. However I’d also be looking for a more welcoming church !

dreamersdown · 08/01/2023 19:14

This sounds like our local church. To get into the attached primary school you need to prove you’re a regular church goer. Rather than take this on trust or get people to contribute to the community/ build relationships with the priest, they have this mad “weekly stamps” process where everyone has to queue at the end of the service to sign a piece of paper and get it stamped with the date. It’s terrible and transactional and doesn’t build any bond with the captive community!

FeedMeTiramisu · 08/01/2023 19:04

We go every week to the family service and attend the 10.30 service as it's the children's service.

What makes it different to the other services is that the children have the opportunity to go into the hall adjacent the church with the catechists and the service and readins are told in a simplified way that the kids will understand. The children can volunteer to do the readings and lead the prayers and then join the church again later ready for Communion. My kids (9 and 6) really enjoy going because they can understandand it. They also join in during hymns (but then their is a choir and everyone participates in hymns).

The priest doesnt sign or stamp anything every week. Every now and again he may say that attendance cards are available after mass for signing and should anyone wish to have any school paperwork signed, they usually have to see him during the week out of mass times.

I would definitely send feedback.

candlelightflora · 08/01/2023 19:04

SpaceMonitor · 08/01/2023 18:59

This is the same for all faith schools where I live. The entire local church congregation consists of parents with kids of a certain age. Why would you expect anything else? This country is increasingly not religious, especially amongst younger people.

It suits the churches because they would be empty otherwise.

I recognise this but I just wasn’t expecting the whole thing to feel so cynical. Our old church was attached to a school as well but it didn’t only cater for people applying to the school, even though of course a lot of the parents attending did have an eye on that.

OP posts:
SpaceMonitor · 08/01/2023 19:02

onepieceoflollipop · 08/01/2023 18:55

In our area it is the LEA who allocate school places and the faith schools set their criteria such as church attendance. So the church isn’t fully responsible for this imo

Except the church often owns the school building, sits on the board of the governors and generally has a lot of involvement in the running of the school. They are more intimately bound that you might think.