Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To send feedback to this church

65 replies

candlelightflora · 08/01/2023 18:43

Just interested in people’s opinions on this.

I used to go to church with DD when she was younger, but stopped during covid. Then we moved to a new area, too far from the old church to go there anymore. I’ve wanted to start going to church again for a while and DD was keen to go as she has good memories of the old church. So I found a church nearby which has a “family service” once a month.

For context, we live in a town with a very well-regarded state secondary school which is selective on faith grounds. DD is only 7 so too young for us to be thinking about secondary applications yet.

Having now been to a “family service” at the church, I think they should re-name it to “service for people who want to get their kids into [insert name of well-regarded secondary faith school]”.

When I arrived, people were queuing to get their “passports” stamped. I said it was our first time at the church and rather than receiving a welcome, how are you, what has brought you here (as I was expecting) I got a brusque “how old is your daughter? Ok she doesn’t need one of these then”.

DD said she’d like to collect the stamps so I asked if we could have a “passport” anyway just for fun (it was literally a folded piece of paper) even though we’re not applying for secondary school yet and was unapologetically told that was not allowed.

The service itself had zero family focus in my opinion, it just seemed like a shortened version of a normal service. The hymns were really quiet as nobody was really singing, I spotted a couple of adults on their phones, and I literally did not see one single adult there who didn’t have a child with them of late primary age (i.e. applying for secondary schools in the next couple of years). Our old church had a really interactive sermon aimed at kids, lots of opportunities to join in, colouring and toys for the younger ones but there was nothing like that.

DD left saying she thought it was really boring and doesn’t want to go again. I left feeling really annoyed that we’d been made to feel so unwelcome.

Is there any point in me diplomatically feeding this back to the church? Or should I just move on and try a different church. I guess it could be that they just don’t care - they know they need to provide a service for those applying to the secondary school and this meets that need. But the whole thing just felt so cynical and I’m annoyed that something billed as a “family service” wasn’t really that at all.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
UsingChangeofName · 09/01/2023 16:36

Agree with @zingally and @Flatandhappy

To me, this is a bit like going to a new bar or restaurant and finding you don't really like the food they are serving. You could give feedback and say you thought the portions were too small or the sauce to spicy or that you prefer your veg al dante and felt they cooked theirs for longer than you like, or you didn't like the lighting or the way they had set the tables out

OR

you could choose another restaurant to try and hope the next one is more in-line with your palette.

I know which I'd do.
Indeed, I have done, when finding a new Church that suits me.

zingally · 09/01/2023 11:05

By all means, give feedback. You could seek someone higher up if you wanted, such as the bishop.

But just try another church. I'm not religious, but have a number of friends who are, and they all say that it can take a while to find a new church that you gel with after moving to a new area.

Flatandhappy · 09/01/2023 02:27

The school thing isn’t relevant for you. You found the church unwelcoming. You are giving this way too much headspace, try somewhere else and move on.

NumberTheory · 09/01/2023 01:40

PurpleWisteria1 · 09/01/2023 00:29

That’s the case for all state church schools in England. But the church is responsible for knowing how frequently each family attends. The vicar / minister has to sign the form which gets handed in directly to the school separately from the application form which goes to the LA

Individual church’s don’t have to do this. They can refuse to certify attendance making the requirement fairly pointless. The secondary school, rather than the individual church the OP went to, sets it’s religious entry criteria, but that school will have places on its governing body reserved for Church appointments who could, if the Church wished, push for an open access approach.

PurpleWisteria1 · 09/01/2023 00:29

onepieceoflollipop · 08/01/2023 18:55

In our area it is the LEA who allocate school places and the faith schools set their criteria such as church attendance. So the church isn’t fully responsible for this imo

That’s the case for all state church schools in England. But the church is responsible for knowing how frequently each family attends. The vicar / minister has to sign the form which gets handed in directly to the school separately from the application form which goes to the LA

Testina · 09/01/2023 00:26

@NumberTheory “It is the church’s fault. They don’t have to insist on church attendance for the school. They could remove religious attendance from their entry criteria, it’s not something they are forced to have. “

What can I say, but amen to that! 🙏

Testina · 09/01/2023 00:24

candlelightflora · 08/01/2023 22:13

It’s a very large town, there are plenty of other schools!

And are those schools high performing and over subscribed, meaning they aren’t actually available to all locally?

And / or do those schools have lower results than the church school?

I don’t blame the parents for doing this, faith places in British state schools is an utter fucking disgrace.

That this church is just cynically signing/stamping it off? Hardly a surprise.

NRCOA · 09/01/2023 00:24

FeinCuroxiVooz · 09/01/2023 00:04

what a shame.
I don't blame the church for keeping it short and simple. if they know that all the families with kids are only there for the passport stamp and won't be listening, it would be soul-destdoying to put in loads of creativity and imagination every time only to have it all ignored.

find a different church. look for one that does "messy church" as one of their activities. your DD may be a bit old for messy church as-such but the kind of church that does that should have a thriving offer for all age groups.

That would be the wrong way to look at it though, surely.

If they put the effort in, got creative and made it a fabulous service, people would be more likely to stay!

NRCOA · 09/01/2023 00:23

MilkyYay · 08/01/2023 23:07

Churches need bums on seats.

They tolerate ~encourage~ this kind of stuff because christianity is in major decline in the UK.

This isn't true of my church!

We have no passport system, no points system and we dont allow people to abuse the system.

We simply welcome, encourage, and love.

Delectable · 09/01/2023 00:18

Absolutely. Write them and seek to discuss if no reply.

NumberTheory · 09/01/2023 00:15

candlelightflora · 08/01/2023 18:46

Oh and my favourite bit was a lady at the end who pushed past us saying (at totally normal volume) she didn’t need to get her passport stamped as she did that at the start “not that that’s the only reason I’m here or anything haha”. I know that’s not really the church’s fault but just to give an idea of the general atmosphere!

It is the church’s fault. They don’t have to insist on church attendance for the school. They could remove religious attendance from their entry criteria, it’s not something they are forced to have. Or they could not be involved in the school at all and instead concentrate on providing support for the faithful and whatever other services they feel compelled to provide for the local community or the needy.

BionicEar · 09/01/2023 00:13

FeinCuroxiVooz actually I think churches should rise to the challenge of trying to engage people rather than offering a dumbed down service.

It doesn’t matter if only one person out of ten takes notice, that is one more person who may find their way to a long lasting faith than one who has been put off because of how the church is currently run.

FeinCuroxiVooz · 09/01/2023 00:08

sorry pressed "post" too soon
on the feedback question, I would send a short message saying that you appreciate the difficult position they are in with so many families only coming to church for school applications purposes, but that you felt that there was no space made for the possibility that anyone might be there for any other reason.

FeinCuroxiVooz · 09/01/2023 00:04

what a shame.
I don't blame the church for keeping it short and simple. if they know that all the families with kids are only there for the passport stamp and won't be listening, it would be soul-destdoying to put in loads of creativity and imagination every time only to have it all ignored.

find a different church. look for one that does "messy church" as one of their activities. your DD may be a bit old for messy church as-such but the kind of church that does that should have a thriving offer for all age groups.

Isthisexpected · 08/01/2023 23:53

I would definitely send feedback. Not in relation to the passports. I would be focusing on the lack of family in the family service, that there were no children's activities or anything for them to take part in. So so different from a true family service!

UsingChangeofName · 08/01/2023 23:32

Everything you have written though, is a reflection of the people that are playing the system. People, it seems that do not even have the manners to pretend they are interested in attending Church.
That isn't the fault of the Church, it is the fault of the people behaving like that.

If you want to feedback that you were disappointed at the service you could, but there was a thread on here a couple of days ago saying how little that poster got out of what was described as "dumbing down".

Your most sensible next step would be to try other churches near you, until you find a Church that fits what you are looking for. Sometimes this takes a while. Many Churches don't have the same presbyter taking the service each week, so you might need to visit a few times. Some have Sunday School / Junior Church groups some weeks but not all, or at some services but not all.
If you want a particular style of worship, then try different Churches until you find what suits you. I don't think the Church is suddenly going to change its style of worship because of 'feedback' from one person who went to one service, and judged so many of the congregation there which seems to be your main dissatisfaction with the service.

candlelightflora · 08/01/2023 23:26

sunflowerdaisyrose · 08/01/2023 23:03

Oh, and I'd definitely feedback in a roundabout way by asking if there was a more suitable service for a younger child!

This is a very diplomatic approach, I like it!

OP posts:
candlelightflora · 08/01/2023 23:25

MilkyYay · 08/01/2023 23:07

Churches need bums on seats.

They tolerate ~encourage~ this kind of stuff because christianity is in major decline in the UK.

I guess I can see this angle, but I suppose it’s up to the church how they use this captive audience.

For example my last church did a lot of outreach work, they had a food bank donation point in the church and children were encouraged to bring a donation every week (but it wasn’t monitored or expected), they ran a homeless shelter/soup kitchen in the winter months and people could volunteer for shifts. Plus the services were family friendly and the children genuinely enjoyed them and wanted to be there (or at least my DD did). So some people - who perhaps did only start going to church because they wanted to get their child into the school - ended up staying because they felt part of the wider church community. And the whole thing felt like more of a force for good I suppose, and less cynical/transactional.

OP posts:
candlelightflora · 08/01/2023 23:16

Binfluencer · 08/01/2023 22:57

@candlelightflora

That's not the point. The point is no child should be denied entry into a school because the church's historic wealth, most of which was stolen, allows it to have a stronghold on the UK education system. It's absolutely corrupt.

Oh I see what you mean. It’s probably for another thread, but I actually agree with you that church attendance shouldn’t be a prerequisite for getting a place at a school (although I’m not opposed to faith schools in general).

You’ll have to take my word for it though that these particular parents really do have other local state options, they’re not being forced to attend church or else their child won’t get a place at any decent local school. I appreciate that may not be the case everywhere.

OP posts:
MilkyYay · 08/01/2023 23:07

Churches need bums on seats.

They tolerate ~encourage~ this kind of stuff because christianity is in major decline in the UK.

seriouslyjaded · 08/01/2023 23:06

Complain to the diocese, not the church itself.

sunflowerdaisyrose · 08/01/2023 23:03

Oh, and I'd definitely feedback in a roundabout way by asking if there was a more suitable service for a younger child!

sunflowerdaisyrose · 08/01/2023 23:02

Our town has a school like this and is doubling down on church attendance as an entry criteria and making even more stringent - our church is very against it for some of the reasons you mention above - it's becoming very transactional as we like attending specific child focused services (which are good and we have been going since my children were born) but are now having to go to ones less suitable as well just to get the tick. Along with plenty of other year 4 and 5 parents and children.

Binfluencer · 08/01/2023 22:57

@candlelightflora

That's not the point. The point is no child should be denied entry into a school because the church's historic wealth, most of which was stolen, allows it to have a stronghold on the UK education system. It's absolutely corrupt.

candlelightflora · 08/01/2023 22:44

I guess my rationale behind providing feedback would be to make them aware that there are some people (me) who take the “family service” at face value and aren’t just there to get into the school. For example I thought it was really odd that nobody said hello or tried to make us feel welcome when I said it was our first time. But it does feel a bit mean as the people on the door will have been volunteers and probably were feeling a bit harassed by all the parents trying to get their stamps ASAP.

I think I’ll just try out another church, it has been nice to air my feelings on here though and find that lots of you agree with me, I found the whole experience a bit bizarre!

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread