Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think trackers on a teens phone is just wrong in most cases?

436 replies

Roseberry1 · 08/01/2023 17:32

Had a call from my dcs school on Friday. They are 16 in year 11. The receptionist said my dc hadn't been marked as attended to the last lesson and asked if I knew why, etc. It turned out my dd had crossed wires with the teacher in a mix-up, was on site, and it was all legitimate reasons, etc. Anyway, that's not the point in the thread.

The receptionist asked me, "Do you have a tracker on her phone?" When I said no, she gave me the impression I should have one (not just my dc but all teens). I find this so odd! Surely, there should be a certain level of trust when your 15/16 + teens go out. I dated this guy who had a tracker on his 15 year olds phone, his kid was only cycling to his mates house and was tracked, which I thought was ott.

Reasons a parent might track:

They live in an area with a very high crime rate where safety is a real high-risk issue.

Their dc are known to be in lots of trouble a lot of the time, often breaking the law.

They go "missing" for long periods and don't appear home when they are supposed to.

Not for teens just hanging out with their mates in a fairly safe town. Surely, as I said, a certain level of trust has to come in somewhere, and even if they do make mistakes, that's part of learning as you grow up. The thought of being "tracked" all the time by your parents just sounds odd to me!

OP posts:
Roseberry1 · 08/01/2023 22:27

CurlyhairedAssassin · 08/01/2023 22:22

But how would anyone know it was a girl's place? It would just be a flat/room/house. They COULD be shagging a girl. Or they could just be sleeping on a mate's sofa cos they missed the last train or something. I mean, if you're going to start getting all nosey and phoning them next day "oh I noticed you didn't sleep in your own place last night!?" then that's bloody creepy and intrusive. But surely most parents would just shrug? Most of us who have been to uni have stayed out somewhere else overnight, it's really no big deal.

I see Uni as a time in a young person's life when they (mostly) live away from home, having fun and gaining their own independence. The thought of a parent being able to track them 24/7 is weird and unnecessary. Why would the parent even know they're on a night out? They're away at Uni doing lots of studying and having fun!

OP posts:
PollyEsther · 08/01/2023 22:27

Lol

I pay for the phone, I can track it. The DC can feel free to go out without their phones if they’re that bothered… but teens all track each other constantly on snap maps anyway. That’s far creepier.

MarshaBradyo · 08/01/2023 22:23

You are obsessed. Move On.

MajorCarolDanvers · 08/01/2023 22:23

kirwanco · 08/01/2023 22:20

Tracking your kids is creepy AF and the school receptionist should be sacked and put on a register!

part of growing up is dealing with freedom.

Consent and choice is neither creepy nor does it restrict or prevent freedom.

Chill.

Roseberry1 · 08/01/2023 22:22

MarshaBradyo · 08/01/2023 22:19

When you stop going on about the one event I talked about I’ll gladly be gone 🙌

Move on already and stop quoting me.

I'll quote whoever I like on a thread I started thanks. Don't flounce in a huff then creep back later on...

OP posts:
JassyRadlett · 08/01/2023 22:22

You do not need your partner to track you to see what time you’ll be in for dinner when you can just text them when you are leaving.

You must lead a charmed fucking life if the time between when you're leaving and when you get home is so predictable. 😂😂

CurlyhairedAssassin · 08/01/2023 22:22

Roseberry1 · 08/01/2023 20:05

Uni! Ffs! Can the poor boy not go back to a girls place without his mother seeing on the tracker app he's having a shag! I know you can't actually see per se, but if I were 19/20 years old at Uni and my mother could see I wasn't in my flat after a night out but somewhere else... let him go!

But how would anyone know it was a girl's place? It would just be a flat/room/house. They COULD be shagging a girl. Or they could just be sleeping on a mate's sofa cos they missed the last train or something. I mean, if you're going to start getting all nosey and phoning them next day "oh I noticed you didn't sleep in your own place last night!?" then that's bloody creepy and intrusive. But surely most parents would just shrug? Most of us who have been to uni have stayed out somewhere else overnight, it's really no big deal.

kirwanco · 08/01/2023 22:20

Tracking your kids is creepy AF and the school receptionist should be sacked and put on a register!

part of growing up is dealing with freedom.

toocold54 · 08/01/2023 22:19

Reading this thread has made me realise why so many people have unhealthy boundaries and relationships. There is zero need to track where a teen or adult is just call/text them if you need to know - people need freedom and privacy and it's absolutely crazy the absolute need for reassurance constantly. This can only lead to anxiety - if my partner suggested they track me, I'd run a mile, if my child needed to be reassured where I was as a teen, I'd get them therapy.

This thread is insanity but it seems so normalised.

Exactly!!

So many parents who have anxiety issues are passing it into their children.

I think WhyCantPeopleBeNice
post is very honest.

And as for adults tracking each other - well that is just insanity and no matter how much someone tries to deny it there is always an element of control/distrust etc.
You do not need your partner to track you to see what time you’ll be in for dinner when you can just text them when you are leaving.

Before these trackers were so readily available, my friend used to have to ring her DP from a house phone or work phone to tell him where she was because ‘he worried about her’.
He then got an actual tracker device and told her to take it wherever she went.
We all said how controlling he is and how it’s not healthy but now it seems an absolutely find thing to do for most people.

It’s so unhealthy!

Of course if someone has a medical issue or is going on a week long hike in the middle of the Amazon then it’s ok to track them.
But going about your every day life you should have freedom and it’s not normal for someone else to know your every move.

MarshaBradyo · 08/01/2023 22:19

When you stop going on about the one event I talked about I’ll gladly be gone 🙌

Move on already and stop quoting me.

MajorCarolDanvers · 08/01/2023 22:19

@Roseberry1

@MajorCarolDanvers
Still amazed at how others choosing to use a bit of tech sparks such levels of obnoxiousness in others

@Roseberry1
It just all ties in with there being so many young people out there whose parents are helicoptering them well into Uni and work where they can't problem solve themselves which flows into the work place. I see it first hand, literally from young people who still have their mum call in sick for them to ones who have no idea how to plan a journey for work purposes or have quick/logical thinking skills when something doesn't go to plan. I swear if they could call their mum, they would, but she's probably got them on the app waiting, so

You've just imagined a whole narrative and cast this upon every family who uses a bit of tech.

It's ridiculous and obnoxious hyperbole from your imagination

Roseberry1 · 08/01/2023 22:18

MarshaBradyo · 08/01/2023 22:15

Thanks I can’t reply to op as too frustrating but yeh it happened once. So Lesson Learnt and all that is just weird.

I thought you "were out" of this thread as you proclaimed earlier? 🙄

OP posts:
MarshaBradyo · 08/01/2023 22:15

JassyRadlett · 08/01/2023 22:02

Yeah but the PP you were responding to was talking about her own convenience and the convenience of the wider family.

Eg - just because you never had an issue having dinner ready at the optimal time doesn't mean it isn't an issue for anyone, ever. A PP has pointed out that it's safer/easier/less time consuming to check where in their partner's commute they are so they can have dinner ready at the best time. Better than calling someone when driving or packed on a busy train, no one is invading anyone else's privacy or anything. It works for them, it makes their lives a little easier. They managed before, sure. Is that a reason not to go for the thing than makes it slightly better?

I'm really not sure about your method of erecting arbitrary barriers to Make Teens Learn, which seems to be very technology-driven. Or are you really saying that if you were at the train station and saw your teen board the wrong train, you wouldn't shout out to them (or god forbid text them) to tell them 'you're going the wrong way, you numpty' because it was more important for them to be stranded at Leytonstone at 1am so they could Learn A Valuable Lesson?

Thanks I can’t reply to op as too frustrating but yeh it happened once. So Lesson Learnt and all that is just weird.

cotsma · 08/01/2023 22:13

"I do however, change my position to 'very limited' reasons to track teens/adults via phone."

@QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat
@Roseberry1

At the moment, yes he does take his phone, so it's easy to find him. When he starts forgetting this, I'll have no hesitation in putting trackers into his clothes and shoes.

But far from being "zero reason" I actually think it's a continuum, with those who have a definite need (adults with dementia, learning difficulties etc) through to those who have a fair amount of need (perhaps more vulnerable teens and adults, those with autism etc who struggle to cope in changing situations etc) through to those with a little need (E.g, rural living with limited phone reception / transport if plans go awry) to no need at all.

I agree that constantly checking trackers is probably not healthy, but having them there in times of need can actually be quite sensible (see my past posts for a variety of examples I have given when it has really helped)

There is a difference between having find my iPhone tracker and constantly tracking it. As I said in my first post, we have it but rarely use it (unless a need, like working out what time to leave to pick my child up from a school trip) and my children use it to track us far more than we use it to track them.

It's not black and white, there's a whole continuum of grey, with lots of valid (and some invalid) reasons in between.

Roseberry1 · 08/01/2023 22:13

JassyRadlett · 08/01/2023 22:02

Yeah but the PP you were responding to was talking about her own convenience and the convenience of the wider family.

Eg - just because you never had an issue having dinner ready at the optimal time doesn't mean it isn't an issue for anyone, ever. A PP has pointed out that it's safer/easier/less time consuming to check where in their partner's commute they are so they can have dinner ready at the best time. Better than calling someone when driving or packed on a busy train, no one is invading anyone else's privacy or anything. It works for them, it makes their lives a little easier. They managed before, sure. Is that a reason not to go for the thing than makes it slightly better?

I'm really not sure about your method of erecting arbitrary barriers to Make Teens Learn, which seems to be very technology-driven. Or are you really saying that if you were at the train station and saw your teen board the wrong train, you wouldn't shout out to them (or god forbid text them) to tell them 'you're going the wrong way, you numpty' because it was more important for them to be stranded at Leytonstone at 1am so they could Learn A Valuable Lesson?

There wouldn't be any need for me to be at the station in person or via a tracker, as if they are old enough to get the train by themselves, they are old enough to check they are on the right platform. And you only ever "end up stranded in Leytonstone" once!

Much like my dB who missed his coach from town to take him to the airport years ago, and he had to drive to the next town to try and catch it (luckily the coach stopped at different stops along the way so dB could get there first.) He only ever missed a coach ONCE though because from then on he was really conscious to plan and be on time/the correct place.

OP posts:
CurlyhairedAssassin · 08/01/2023 22:11

We have Family sharing on Find my Iphone for each other and find it useful. It's especially useful when I get home from work (time varies) and DH has a hot cup of tea waiting for me! Grin

DS1 is away at uni and always in lectures or labs or supervisions. If we want to facetime him I just check he's in his room first so I'm not interrupting him. He's not bothered. If he asked me to not "follow" him anymore I wouldn't but he's very laidback about that sort of thing. He's always out and about at different places and he and I just don't think anything of it, it's simply a useful tool to us and I'm not terribly interested in where he goes, it's just mainly handy for practical reasons. If he didn't leave his room for days and didn't answer our calls then that would be my cue to phone the porter's lodge to ask them to do a welfare check. When we visit and we meet up with him in town it's handy to know where he's waiting for us because I don't know the city very well yet. It's also useful when I've been to pick him up at the end of term etc and he can come and meet us at the car with some bags of stuff. Or know how far away I am and roughly when he needs to get ready to come and meet me.

For DS2 who is 16 he goes into the city centre to meet his mates and it's handy to know when he's on the bus home.

My mum shares her location too, v handy if she's visiting us as she's always later than she says she will be so if means if I need to nip to the corner shop I can do it without worrying I'll miss her arriving. etc etc

To be honest, I think this was probably an argument for not carrying a mobile phone when they first came out. Oh, there's no privacy - you're always contactable when you have a mobile phone!

For DS2 who is 16 he goes into the city centre to meet his mates and it's handy to know when he's on the bus home.

JassyRadlett · 08/01/2023 22:05

Like I say - my kids aren't at this point yet, DS1 will get a phone soon aged 11 and I'll have tracking enabled for at least the first few years. DH and I don't use it with each other but I'd have no issue if DH wanted to check whether we'd left football yet, or whatever.

But just because I only use it in a very limited way doesn't mean I can't see it would be useful for others.

JassyRadlett · 08/01/2023 22:02

Roseberry1 · 08/01/2023 20:31

It's making some teens lives easier but not in a good way...

Yeah but the PP you were responding to was talking about her own convenience and the convenience of the wider family.

Eg - just because you never had an issue having dinner ready at the optimal time doesn't mean it isn't an issue for anyone, ever. A PP has pointed out that it's safer/easier/less time consuming to check where in their partner's commute they are so they can have dinner ready at the best time. Better than calling someone when driving or packed on a busy train, no one is invading anyone else's privacy or anything. It works for them, it makes their lives a little easier. They managed before, sure. Is that a reason not to go for the thing than makes it slightly better?

I'm really not sure about your method of erecting arbitrary barriers to Make Teens Learn, which seems to be very technology-driven. Or are you really saying that if you were at the train station and saw your teen board the wrong train, you wouldn't shout out to them (or god forbid text them) to tell them 'you're going the wrong way, you numpty' because it was more important for them to be stranded at Leytonstone at 1am so they could Learn A Valuable Lesson?

Lordofmyflies · 08/01/2023 21:56

We have a family tracking app. We live rurally and the DC get a train to school with a walk either end. It helps me know when to drive to meet the train and the DC know that I’ve left home to get them. That’s all we use it for!

Roseberry1 · 08/01/2023 21:56

cotsma · 08/01/2023 21:51

Oh and btw, tracking devices is recommended with people with Alzheimer's

Invest in a GPS or similar wearable tracking device that makes it possible to monitor a person’s whereabouts and help you locate him quickly. Shoes, watches, necklaces, and ankle bracelets are being manufactured with these devices and can be purchased from vendor websites (see Resources section at the end of this brochure).

So far from there being zero reason to track an adult, there can be a wide range of very valid reasons.

I don't think anyone would argue that someone with Alzheimers wouldn't need a tracker. I'm guessing the poster who said "any adult" was referring to adults without severe memory loss/danger if out alone... but then I think you knew that...

OP posts:
QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat · 08/01/2023 21:54

Cotsma, does he remember to take his phone with him when he wanders? My friends parents with dementia/Alzheimer's have always wandered without anything, barely wearing clothes. If patients are at the latter stages of the disease I'd probably expect full time care and not a phone tracker.

I do however, change my position to 'very limited' reasons to track teens/adults via phone.

cotsma · 08/01/2023 21:51

Oh and btw, tracking devices is recommended with people with Alzheimer's

Invest in a GPS or similar wearable tracking device that makes it possible to monitor a person’s whereabouts and help you locate him quickly. Shoes, watches, necklaces, and ankle bracelets are being manufactured with these devices and can be purchased from vendor websites (see Resources section at the end of this brochure).

So far from there being zero reason to track an adult, there can be a wide range of very valid reasons.

cotsma · 08/01/2023 21:47

"There is zero need to track where a teen or adult is just call/text them if you need to know - people need freedom and privacy and it's absolutely crazy the absolute need for reassurance constantly."

@QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat

I do use the tracker to find my dad who has Alzheimer's and has a tendency to wander, and doesn't always know where he ends up. Should I just let my dad end up wherever and not able to get home. People with Alzheimer's have died from wandering and then getting exposure:

Are you really sure there is zero reason to track an adult?

Sometimes there is very good reasons for tracking adults, you know like keeping them alive.

www.brightfocus.org/alzheimers/news/staying-safe-wandering-and-alzheimers-patient

Roseberry1 · 08/01/2023 21:45

QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat · 08/01/2023 21:36

Reading this thread has made me realise why so many people have unhealthy boundaries and relationships. There is zero need to track where a teen or adult is just call/text them if you need to know - people need freedom and privacy and it's absolutely crazy the absolute need for reassurance constantly. This can only lead to anxiety - if my partner suggested they track me, I'd run a mile, if my child needed to be reassured where I was as a teen, I'd get them therapy.

This thread is insanity but it seems so normalised.

Yes, and the notion that your kid has independence and freedom but could also have their whereabouts tracked 24/7 is not freedom at all.

True independence and freedom is being enabled to go off and navigate your day, solving any issues that may arise and having the freedom to make the decision for yourself if you need help.

OP posts:
YetiTeri · 08/01/2023 21:43

My 15yo has one. She mostly uses it to track when I'm on my way home from work. It's no big deal as we're all happy with it.