Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think trackers on a teens phone is just wrong in most cases?

436 replies

Roseberry1 · 08/01/2023 17:32

Had a call from my dcs school on Friday. They are 16 in year 11. The receptionist said my dc hadn't been marked as attended to the last lesson and asked if I knew why, etc. It turned out my dd had crossed wires with the teacher in a mix-up, was on site, and it was all legitimate reasons, etc. Anyway, that's not the point in the thread.

The receptionist asked me, "Do you have a tracker on her phone?" When I said no, she gave me the impression I should have one (not just my dc but all teens). I find this so odd! Surely, there should be a certain level of trust when your 15/16 + teens go out. I dated this guy who had a tracker on his 15 year olds phone, his kid was only cycling to his mates house and was tracked, which I thought was ott.

Reasons a parent might track:

They live in an area with a very high crime rate where safety is a real high-risk issue.

Their dc are known to be in lots of trouble a lot of the time, often breaking the law.

They go "missing" for long periods and don't appear home when they are supposed to.

Not for teens just hanging out with their mates in a fairly safe town. Surely, as I said, a certain level of trust has to come in somewhere, and even if they do make mistakes, that's part of learning as you grow up. The thought of being "tracked" all the time by your parents just sounds odd to me!

OP posts:
toocold54 · 08/01/2023 23:00

I do, but I also live rurally and traffic can be very unreliable - Windy A roads with few places to overtake.

I live in Cornwall so completely understand but if you only have a narrow window to eat your dinner then surely it’s better that it’s cooked and ready for when you to come in.
Even if you are late you can warm it up.

If you ring/text to say you are leaving then I can’t see how the tracker makes much difference and it ends up being an inconvenience as your DH is having to check it every 5 mins to see if you are stuck in traffic or not.

Roseberry1 · 08/01/2023 22:57

Pleasebeafleabite · 08/01/2023 22:48

OP lives in the dark ages

you crack on with your mangle OP

Na, a mangle is far too advanced for me... I still use the river... 😉

OP posts:
cotsma · 08/01/2023 22:56

So why can’t you text and say you are leaving now?
@toocold54

I do, but I also live rurally and traffic can be very unreliable - Windy A roads with few places to overtake.

Get stuck behind a tractor can add 25 mins to my journey, on Friday a burst water pipe meant a several mile detour, living in a tourist area can mean that a road that takes 5 mins to get down in winter can take up to 40 in height of tourist season. Doing the same journey can take anywhere between 30 mins and an hour... I explained this in my first post. I ideally, I like to have time to prepare for the lesson, so it works to have tea ready. But as I have already said, phoning before I leave makes no difference it is the length of the commute that's unreliable and it's not safe to call whilst driving,

JassyRadlett · 08/01/2023 22:56

So why can’t you text and say you are leaving now?

Surely if you have a very narrow window it’s better that the dinner is ready, rather than him keep needing to check the tracker to see where you are.

I mean I don't have a window into PP's life but I imagine the answer is something like 'she could, but they find this easier' and 'your surelys are not the same as other people's surelys.'

EarringsandLipstick · 08/01/2023 22:54

@MarshaBradyo has said everything I believe / do, too! (And shown admirable restraint in dealing with an irritating OP)

OP, like others have said, families & life circumstances differ. You have made sweeping assumptions - and also refer to 'trackers' as if they are some nefarious & illicit device, when the term is really used to refer to phone features that can be used in various ways to check location - mainly that anyone using a tracker inherently is raising a child they don't trust, who is pathetically lacking in independence & has an over-controlling parent.

None of this can be gleaned by a family's decision to use certain apps / phone features.

In my family, the eldest two DC have phones & I use Find my iPhone with the eldest (as she has one, my second DC has an android phone), and Snapchat location sharing for both. I don't often need it, especially with my eldest who is quite predictable about where she goes. With my 2nd DC, he's a nightmare with answering his phone so I might use it if he's with pals & I'm not reaching him, and I'll see he's down at our local GAA grounds playing sports, and hence no answer.

They can equally see where I am, helpful if I'm busy at work & they are checking if I have left yet.

Why are you so strident about other's choices?

toocold54 · 08/01/2023 22:54

God I'd find it so tedious to have to do that all the time. That feels more controlling to me, that expectation that I should do that.

No of course you don’t need to do that and most couples have no idea what time their partners are getting home.

But my reply was to a poster who said she needs her dinner on the table as soon as she gets home as she needs to leave again soon but her finish times vary.

So in that situation you would send a text as that means your DH needs to keep checking his phone to see if you’ve left work yet or not.

Roseberry1 · 08/01/2023 22:53

CurlyhairedAssassin · 08/01/2023 22:40

Well, precisely! Why WOULD they even know they're on a night out? I can guarantee that if any families still use Find My Iphone with each other when one has gone to uni, then unless they're an abusive and overprotective parent, they aren't going to be using it to check their whereabouts constantly. There is no need for the most part- they are at uni doing uni things and hopefully having fun.

Most times with DS I haven't got a clue where he is, it's not like I constantly track DS obsessively and check he's in his own beddy-bo's every night - what an odd and creepy thought. As I said earlier, if I DO want to contact him (usually once or twice a week for a quick catch up) I generally check his location first (if I haven't had a response from whatsapp) as usually that would tell me that he's not in his room and so off doing something and it's not a good time to call. Occasionally I might notice he IS out, but do you really think I then sit fretting over him all night till I can see him back in his room?! Grin He usually just whatsapps back a few hours later/next morning "Was out at football".

If you've tried to contact him via WhatsApp and he hasn't responded, why would you then check his location? What if he was in his room, but just didn't want to chat? Would you call him if you saw him in his room? What if he didn't answer?

Sorry for the questions but if someone's tried to contact and no answer, you wait until they get back to you (within reason.) You don't then track their location, they might not want to talk at that moment, wherever they are.

OP posts:
CurlyhairedAssassin · 08/01/2023 22:51

So why can’t you text and say you are leaving now? God I'd find it so tedious to have to do that all the time. That feels more controlling to me, that expectation that I should do that.

CurlyhairedAssassin · 08/01/2023 22:49

GelPens1 · 08/01/2023 22:29

I’m in my 20s and I’m so glad phone trackers weren’t a thing when I was a teen. My parents trusted me so I always told them where I was going and who I was with. This builds trust and independence. If a teen misses their bus or train then they can wait for another. They can text their parents to let them know they’ll be late. Why is a tracker needed?

I’ve heard that couples do this too and I think it’s strange and very intrusive. Each to their own I guess.

But if you are a family that uses trackers there is no NEED to text home and say you'll be late. There is no need to even have a time as a parent to expect them home - what if they haven't decided what time train they're going to get and don't want to be pinned down to having to tell their parents whaat their intention is. Let them go out and come home when they've had enough. If you have a tracker you can see where they are if it's getting late, there is no need to even HAVE a conversation about train times or missing one. There is no bothering them, they can actually be much more independent in their decision-making because you can just leave them to it and if you have any concerns that they are out much later than you thought they might be you can just check their location. You can see that they're still in McDonalds or heading towards the bus stop or about to get off the bus etc.

toocold54 · 08/01/2023 22:48

Maybe one is cooking so they can eat as a family, before they go off to work?

I gave the example of my husband tracking me so he can have my food ready when I'm home because on certain nights I do tutoring in the evening. I have a narrow window in which to eat before I start tutoring, so we can eat as a family.

So why can’t you text and say you are leaving now?

Surely if you have a very narrow window it’s better that the dinner is ready, rather than him keep needing to check the tracker to see where you are.

I’m not having a dig but it takes more effort for him to use the tracker, especially if your finish times vary, than it would for you to text him so he can put it on and it’s guaranteed to be ready for when you walk through the door, even if you ran late.

Danni7297 · 08/01/2023 22:48

We have life 360 too. My daughter has a 10 minute walk to the bus that goes into town and then 15 minute walk to school and back again. Sometimes she gets the bus home alone.
She also does a lot of sports after school, with the school. They aren’t allowed their phones on or to use them but I can see how far away she is when she heads back and when to pick her up because timings they give can be an hour difference either way depending on how the competitions go.

If me or her dad are on our way to pick her up she can see where we are, especially if we get stuck in traffic (she has friends who live 30+ minutes away in normal traffic) as obviously we can’t use our phones whilst driving.

also got a call one morning to say she hadn’t arrived at school. I checked the app and could see her ‘running’ in to school and that her bus had been late to her stop. So I didn’t panic and worry about her.

same when her bus was late and I had text her but had no reply and she didn’t answer my call (silent mode from being in school) I could see her at the bus stop. Although she knows she should contact me.

It may not work for some people but it works well for us as a family. My daughter feels safer having it and we feel more at ease when she is off out incase we do need it. I don’t check it often, only when I need to. She has more than enough freedom and independence.

Pleasebeafleabite · 08/01/2023 22:48

MarshaBradyo · 08/01/2023 20:44

I‘m with you. Maybe the op lives in a small town and their dc don’t really venture far or work.

Whatever it is they sound stuck in their ways.

OP lives in the dark ages

you crack on with your mangle OP

cotsma · 08/01/2023 22:43

"OP, you really do seem to imagine that other people might live different lives to you."

That should be

OP, you really do seem to have difficulty imagining that other people might live different lives to you.

Roseberry1 · 08/01/2023 22:43

toocold54 · 08/01/2023 22:35

but teens all track each other constantly on snap maps anyway. That’s far creepier.

Exactly!
Because they are being raised to think that this is ok and that it’s normal.
That is my issue with it.

My DD has a bf and told me he asked her to turn her location on so he knows where she is.
I asked her what she said and she said she told him that she already told him where she is and she doesn’t need to turn on her location to prove it and he either believes her or he doesn’t.

Unfortunately, if your parents tell you that things like this is ok, then you’d have no issue with allowing your bf knowing your location at all times - which is not ok.

How can you teach your children boundaries and how it’s healthy to not tell someone your every move, if they are being raised to think it’s ok?

This.

Whilst some relationships would be fine to track each other for dinner, etc, a lot of people, especially men, unfortunately would happily use this as a control method.

People aren't always where they say they're going to be for several different reasons. Not necessarily to be deceitful, but because plans change. Are they going to have to justify every change of move they make because they aren't where they are "supposed" to be in someone else's head, especially in relationships.

Also, teens do lie, because they are testing boundaries, and it's healthy to do so. Who hasn't said they're at Xs house when really they're at Ys. It's part of growing up.

OP posts:
cotsma · 08/01/2023 22:43

"Each to their own, but I don't think I'd want my dinner the second I walked in the door. I like to get in, get in comfy clothes, decompress, then think about eating. But I guess some like to eat straight away, but still, like you say, they could heat it up, and it's still hardly a reason to track someone! If being late was a constant issue, you could just both agree to start eating a bit later."

OP, you really do seem to imagine that other people might live different lives to you.

Maybe one is cooking so they can eat as a family, before they go off to work?

I gave the example of my husband tracking me so he can have my food ready when I'm home because on certain nights I do tutoring in the evening. I have a narrow window in which to eat before I start tutoring, so we can eat as a family.

Is it really so difficult to imagine that different people lead different lives and have different needs and desires?

CurlyhairedAssassin · 08/01/2023 22:40

Roseberry1 · 08/01/2023 22:27

I see Uni as a time in a young person's life when they (mostly) live away from home, having fun and gaining their own independence. The thought of a parent being able to track them 24/7 is weird and unnecessary. Why would the parent even know they're on a night out? They're away at Uni doing lots of studying and having fun!

Well, precisely! Why WOULD they even know they're on a night out? I can guarantee that if any families still use Find My Iphone with each other when one has gone to uni, then unless they're an abusive and overprotective parent, they aren't going to be using it to check their whereabouts constantly. There is no need for the most part- they are at uni doing uni things and hopefully having fun.

Most times with DS I haven't got a clue where he is, it's not like I constantly track DS obsessively and check he's in his own beddy-bo's every night - what an odd and creepy thought. As I said earlier, if I DO want to contact him (usually once or twice a week for a quick catch up) I generally check his location first (if I haven't had a response from whatsapp) as usually that would tell me that he's not in his room and so off doing something and it's not a good time to call. Occasionally I might notice he IS out, but do you really think I then sit fretting over him all night till I can see him back in his room?! Grin He usually just whatsapps back a few hours later/next morning "Was out at football".

Sometimeswinning · 08/01/2023 22:40

I'll track my kids until they can pay for their own phone. I really couldn't careless that someone on here thinks its creepy. There maybe that day when you wish you had it.

I personally think its very short sighted not to have an idea where your children are. I'll be honest I've probably watched far too many real life crime series. But, again I won't be questioning my choice!

WordtoYoMumma · 08/01/2023 22:36

We just use Google maps. We can all see each other on there. Kids all know we can see it and are free to turn theirs offline if they want. They do go offline sometimes, though usually from lack of internet service.

It was very useful when my (now in recovery, thank goodness) alcoholic husband got drunk and went missing as I was able to see where his phone was and go scrape his drunken arse off the pavement where he had collapsed...

And when DS fell asleep on the bus on the way to school and ended up miles away I could go find him.

It's not really about mistrust or spying 🤷🏻‍♀️

Roseberry1 · 08/01/2023 22:35

toocold54 · 08/01/2023 22:28

You must lead a charmed fucking life if the time between when you're leaving and when you get home is so predictable.

Of course not but if I text saying I’m leaving now and I’m home later than expected due to heavy traffic, then I can just warm my dinner up - hardly an excuse to track someone is it.

I can’t imagine how that conversation would even go!

”Dear, I need you to have a tracker on your phone”
”why?”
“So I know where you are at all times”
”Why?”
”Ermm… so I can plate up your dinner for the second you walk in the door”
🙄🙄

Each to their own, but I don't think I'd want my dinner the second I walked in the door. I like to get in, get in comfy clothes, decompress, then think about eating. But I guess some like to eat straight away, but still, like you say, they could heat it up, and it's still hardly a reason to track someone! If being late was a constant issue, you could just both agree to start eating a bit later.

OP posts:
toocold54 · 08/01/2023 22:35

but teens all track each other constantly on snap maps anyway. That’s far creepier.

Exactly!
Because they are being raised to think that this is ok and that it’s normal.
That is my issue with it.

My DD has a bf and told me he asked her to turn her location on so he knows where she is.
I asked her what she said and she said she told him that she already told him where she is and she doesn’t need to turn on her location to prove it and he either believes her or he doesn’t.

Unfortunately, if your parents tell you that things like this is ok, then you’d have no issue with allowing your bf knowing your location at all times - which is not ok.

How can you teach your children boundaries and how it’s healthy to not tell someone your every move, if they are being raised to think it’s ok?

JassyRadlett · 08/01/2023 22:33

toocold54 · 08/01/2023 22:28

You must lead a charmed fucking life if the time between when you're leaving and when you get home is so predictable.

Of course not but if I text saying I’m leaving now and I’m home later than expected due to heavy traffic, then I can just warm my dinner up - hardly an excuse to track someone is it.

I can’t imagine how that conversation would even go!

”Dear, I need you to have a tracker on your phone”
”why?”
“So I know where you are at all times”
”Why?”
”Ermm… so I can plate up your dinner for the second you walk in the door”
🙄🙄

God what a grim relationship that sounds. Is that really how you think it would happen?

Like I say, I don't use them at all. But I have a mild amount of imagination and I can see how they might work in other relationships.

But this entire thread is just an excuse for those who like dramatic pearl-clutching to engage in some highly enjoyable hyperbole and drama with talk of 'excuses' and 'incessant monitoring'. It's quite entertaining to watch people so determined not to see another point of view because it would just ruin their enjoyment.

GelPens1 · 08/01/2023 22:29

I’m in my 20s and I’m so glad phone trackers weren’t a thing when I was a teen. My parents trusted me so I always told them where I was going and who I was with. This builds trust and independence. If a teen misses their bus or train then they can wait for another. They can text their parents to let them know they’ll be late. Why is a tracker needed?

I’ve heard that couples do this too and I think it’s strange and very intrusive. Each to their own I guess.

toocold54 · 08/01/2023 22:28

You must lead a charmed fucking life if the time between when you're leaving and when you get home is so predictable.

Of course not but if I text saying I’m leaving now and I’m home later than expected due to heavy traffic, then I can just warm my dinner up - hardly an excuse to track someone is it.

I can’t imagine how that conversation would even go!

”Dear, I need you to have a tracker on your phone”
”why?”
“So I know where you are at all times”
”Why?”
”Ermm… so I can plate up your dinner for the second you walk in the door”
🙄🙄

QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat · 08/01/2023 22:28

Has anyone seen the black mirror episode when the mother was tracking her daughter? - it's extreme but it does highlight the issues of tracking, anxiety and the need for privacy. Like I said earlier, we are sleep walking into crazy territory where being tracked as adults is normalised and our need for constant reassurance is bizarre and anxiety driven.

It's made me want to turn my phone off, but I'm on MN at the moment so will refrain.

kirwanco · 08/01/2023 22:27

If you suffocate something, one of two things will happen. It will run away or it will die.

It’s not healthy for us to be tracked at every interval. No wonder kids these days are so horribly anxious when they have big brother on their tail.

It’s normal for kids to push boundaries, to say they’re going to Sarah’s when they’re actually going to a field to drink. We have to stop coddling children and allow a small element of risk and danger enter their lives.