Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think trackers on a teens phone is just wrong in most cases?

436 replies

Roseberry1 · 08/01/2023 17:32

Had a call from my dcs school on Friday. They are 16 in year 11. The receptionist said my dc hadn't been marked as attended to the last lesson and asked if I knew why, etc. It turned out my dd had crossed wires with the teacher in a mix-up, was on site, and it was all legitimate reasons, etc. Anyway, that's not the point in the thread.

The receptionist asked me, "Do you have a tracker on her phone?" When I said no, she gave me the impression I should have one (not just my dc but all teens). I find this so odd! Surely, there should be a certain level of trust when your 15/16 + teens go out. I dated this guy who had a tracker on his 15 year olds phone, his kid was only cycling to his mates house and was tracked, which I thought was ott.

Reasons a parent might track:

They live in an area with a very high crime rate where safety is a real high-risk issue.

Their dc are known to be in lots of trouble a lot of the time, often breaking the law.

They go "missing" for long periods and don't appear home when they are supposed to.

Not for teens just hanging out with their mates in a fairly safe town. Surely, as I said, a certain level of trust has to come in somewhere, and even if they do make mistakes, that's part of learning as you grow up. The thought of being "tracked" all the time by your parents just sounds odd to me!

OP posts:
EarringsandLipstick · 08/01/2023 23:54

Saying there "must" be is not stating absolute fact.

I'm not sure you understand how language works ...

It's a discussion

I don't see much discussion from got you - just endless repetition of your point

nothing to get so worked up over

Not worked up. Irritated a bit. Bad making my points. That's allowed, right?

or dramatise the needs for links and evidence, we are on a discussion board, not in court!

Are you new to MN? Mostly here, discussion is characterised by posters linking to evidence (might be research, articles or interviews) where they are making very bald & definitive statements, especially.

Jourdain11 · 08/01/2023 23:54

Calling people Bagshot luddites is a bit rude! Let's say I track my DH and he's still at school. Okay, I know where he is, but I don't know how much longer he'll be there and what he might be doing / where he might be stopping off on the way back. Which is what I'd really want to know rather than where he physically is RIGHT AT THAT SECOND. And all of which I could find out in a WhatsApp or 30 sec phone conversation. Plus, interaction is sometimes nice 😊

EarringsandLipstick · 08/01/2023 23:51

Getoff · 08/01/2023 23:50

I think its the anti-trackers who seem to have some real issues.

Why are they assuming the person being tracked is being opressed? They seem to just assume that the people being tracked don't want to be? Just because you have controlling or oppressive peole in your life doesn't mean all families work like that.

Having a tracker has in itself fuck-all effect on the person being tracked. DD aged 12 has been told several times I can see where she is, it's so irrelevant to her that she doesn't even bother to remember the fact! Consequently, it has fuck-all effect on her independence/decision making.

The most batshit comment of all is the idea that, for some reason, it would be better to call or text. Why bother someone when in less time than it would take them to answer you can see their location on a map? And if the exact location did matter, for some reason, how long is it going to take them to convey the amount of information you can see instantly from an icon on a map? What is better about getting far less information far more slowly while inconveniencing someone who doesn't need to be involved at all?

If you're such a luddite, why are you advocating texting or calling, surely it would be even better for cultivating independence and resourcefulnees if they went without a phone at all?

👏👏👏👏

Getoff · 08/01/2023 23:50

I think its the anti-trackers who seem to have some real issues.

Why are they assuming the person being tracked is being opressed? They seem to just assume that the people being tracked don't want to be? Just because you have controlling or oppressive peole in your life doesn't mean all families work like that.

Having a tracker has in itself fuck-all effect on the person being tracked. DD aged 12 has been told several times I can see where she is, it's so irrelevant to her that she doesn't even bother to remember the fact! Consequently, it has fuck-all effect on her independence/decision making.

The most batshit comment of all is the idea that, for some reason, it would be better to call or text. Why bother someone when in less time than it would take them to answer you can see their location on a map? And if the exact location did matter, for some reason, how long is it going to take them to convey the amount of information you can see instantly from an icon on a map? What is better about getting far less information far more slowly while inconveniencing someone who doesn't need to be involved at all?

If you're such a luddite, why are you advocating texting or calling, surely it would be even better for cultivating independence and resourcefulnees if they went without a phone at all?

Roseberry1 · 08/01/2023 23:49

MrsDooDaa · 08/01/2023 23:41

I'm wondering if those who are very anti location apps had very strict parents who didn't trust them? Or were very rebellious teens?

I was an average to good teen and my parents were of average strictness. There was a lot of respect on both sides.

I'm anti tracking apps - no way will I let another human track me and i wont track my teens. Both my sisters use tracking in their families. We respectfully agree to disagree on this topic.

I was an average teen too, my mum was laid back and not strict at all. We could have probably done what we wanted but didn't do anything too rebellious. I was out working from 16 so didn't do the student life/nightlife scene, although we did go out, but it was bar/club/dance/food/home.

My teenage life was very much built on trust and mutual respect for the house we lived in. We had our moments but were free to do what we wanted.

OP posts:
Jourdain11 · 08/01/2023 23:49

I'm very surprised that I am in such a minority here.

I don't like it, I can't see too many situations in which it would be helpful, and I can't understand why a quick phone call or text is more intrusive/time-consuming/disruptive than checking and checking again a tracker app.

I have nothing to hide from my DH... but I wouldn't want him tracking me. Nor do I have any particular desire to know where he is when I can't see him. If he was going to be particularly late, he'd let me know. If he hadn't let me know, then I'd start to be concerned and would follow up... but I wouldn't rely on what some tracker app says, because if he has gone missing, who says he's with his phone?

I do think it's important to allow kids space to figure stuff out for themselves, and if mummy is tracking them and able to swoop in whenever they mess up slightly, they ain't never gonna learn.

TiptoeThroughTheToadstools · 08/01/2023 23:46

I have a tracker on all 3 of my DCs phone, for their safety and my sanity. They can equally track me.

CurlyhairedAssassin · 08/01/2023 23:45

Yes, exactly, it’s just handy sometimes. Like if one of the person is on their way home and you know they have to pass a supermarket, if you check their location and see they’re right by it you can give them a quick call to ask them if they could pop in and pick up some milk or whatever.

B1rds · 08/01/2023 23:43

It gives more freedom in some ways. If you can see someone's roughly where they're planning to be, you don't need to ask questions. If you don't want people to know, you switch it off. In the old days I'd be asking did you go to X friend's house (because that means I need to pick up by car) or did you go to the next town instead, meaning doesn't need dinner as going out for meal. With tracker you look and see. No need to interrupt them or ask. They can see where you are too so KO when you're getting home and where their dinner is.

Roseberry1 · 08/01/2023 23:41

EarringsandLipstick · 08/01/2023 23:38

@Roseberry1

Stating views like they are absolute fact, while refusing to even consider anyone's viewpoint and using 🙄 emojis aren't the markers of polite discourse.

You've written nonsensical statements, like that a link between tech that can enhance contact & anxiety / poor MH exists. But you can point to any evidence.

Saying there "must" be is not stating absolute fact. It's a discussion, nothing to get so worked up over or dramatise the needs for links and evidence, we are on a discussion board, not in court!

OP posts:
CurlyhairedAssassin · 08/01/2023 23:41

Can I just point out agai , OP, that people CAN have their privacy even if they use location apps. They can simply switch them off temporarily. It is only when the other person then starts getting paranoid or quizzing them on why they couldn’t see their location that there is a problem. And unless you obsessively checked someone’s location many many times a day then how would you know if they’d turned their location on or off?

and anyway most location services are not terribly accurate, they just give you a rough location. And even if they DID pinpoint someone exactly in a city centre, venues often close down and something else opens up in their place, and I think people are generally sensible enough to realise this - no-one should be jumping to any conclusions if your person seems to be in a Thai massage parlour. 😆

MrsDooDaa · 08/01/2023 23:41

I'm wondering if those who are very anti location apps had very strict parents who didn't trust them? Or were very rebellious teens?

I was an average to good teen and my parents were of average strictness. There was a lot of respect on both sides.

I'm anti tracking apps - no way will I let another human track me and i wont track my teens. Both my sisters use tracking in their families. We respectfully agree to disagree on this topic.

Maya678 · 08/01/2023 23:40

I track my tween. I turned off the feature so he can’t tack me so I know it is possible. I trust him completely. He’s a very mature, sensible boy. I track him because of others behaviour, not his. Will I when he’s a teenager? Very probably. He’s aware of this and understand it’s about safety.

EarringsandLipstick · 08/01/2023 23:38

@Roseberry1

Stating views like they are absolute fact, while refusing to even consider anyone's viewpoint and using 🙄 emojis aren't the markers of polite discourse.

You've written nonsensical statements, like that a link between tech that can enhance contact & anxiety / poor MH exists. But you can point to any evidence.

Roseberry1 · 08/01/2023 23:36

CurlyhairedAssassin · 08/01/2023 23:33

Do you not like Ring cameras either? Or CCTV?

It's not quite the same thing. I know we are filmed constantly every time we go outside, but that just doesn't seem the same as your parent/partner knowing your location constantly. I agree it's an odd thought, because big brother is always watching one way or another!

OP posts:
ElspethTascioni · 08/01/2023 23:34

YANBU

Roseberry1 · 08/01/2023 23:33

EarringsandLipstick · 08/01/2023 23:32

Lol I think that might be wise as you're getting a little wound up there!

You're funny 😂

Given that you've engaged in hyperbole throughout & attacked every poster who's held a different view to you!

I've given my opinion, not got worked up over it or resorted to name calling 🙄

OP posts:
JassyRadlett · 08/01/2023 23:33

Roseberry1 · 08/01/2023 23:24

No weaker than you saying there isn't a link.

I think you might need to do a bit of reading on where the burden of proof for an argument generally sits....

CurlyhairedAssassin · 08/01/2023 23:33

Roseberry1 · 08/01/2023 23:29

I don't mind tech and apps. Use them every day in and out of work. I just don't like the thought of being able to track someone at any point in time you want to as I like my privacy and my dc are entitled to theirs.

Do you not like Ring cameras either? Or CCTV?

EarringsandLipstick · 08/01/2023 23:32

Lol I think that might be wise as you're getting a little wound up there!

You're funny 😂

Given that you've engaged in hyperbole throughout & attacked every poster who's held a different view to you!

Roseberry1 · 08/01/2023 23:31

EarringsandLipstick · 08/01/2023 23:29

No weaker than you saying there isn't a link.

You're quite offensive as well as not so bright.

You started the thread with a dramatic premise, clearly understanding little about tech options.

You are baldly & hysterically stating that 'tracking' teens is absolutely linked to anxiety & MH issues - but you've no evidence.

I didn't ever say there was no link between tracking & anxiety - I imagine if some unwell parent obsessively stalked their child every.single.minute there would be some anxiety - but that's not what happens is it?

Time to leave you & your tin hat to it.

Lol I think that might be wise as you're getting a little wound up there!

OP posts:
stopthebarking · 08/01/2023 23:31

I don't see it as an invasion of privacy, no. Whether or not a teen learns responsibility is unrelated to the use of tracking apps, imo.

EarringsandLipstick · 08/01/2023 23:31

My own teens are absolutely no bother either. They go out and live their life, we all use the find my iphone tool simply as a tool. We respect them, they respect us and we are mutually supportive and discuss and compromise if we disagree.

That's so great. And well-put.

I broadly have the same with my teens, tho my 13 yo DS needs to work more on sticking to agreements!

Roseberry1 · 08/01/2023 23:29

CurlyhairedAssassin · 08/01/2023 23:23

But then again we all like our tech in our family. We have a shared family calendar which we find a useful planning tool when arranging appointments/holidays/school or work events and need to plan around each other's commitments. Maybe some people don't like using those either?

Some people are not big lovers of tech and really don't like facetime or zoom as they feel it's too intrusive. In our family we find it useful at times.

Maybe it all depends on how much you enjoy using tech and different apps as to how you view tools like location trackers.

I don't mind tech and apps. Use them every day in and out of work. I just don't like the thought of being able to track someone at any point in time you want to as I like my privacy and my dc are entitled to theirs.

OP posts:
EarringsandLipstick · 08/01/2023 23:29

No weaker than you saying there isn't a link.

You're quite offensive as well as not so bright.

You started the thread with a dramatic premise, clearly understanding little about tech options.

You are baldly & hysterically stating that 'tracking' teens is absolutely linked to anxiety & MH issues - but you've no evidence.

I didn't ever say there was no link between tracking & anxiety - I imagine if some unwell parent obsessively stalked their child every.single.minute there would be some anxiety - but that's not what happens is it?

Time to leave you & your tin hat to it.