Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think trackers on a teens phone is just wrong in most cases?

436 replies

Roseberry1 · 08/01/2023 17:32

Had a call from my dcs school on Friday. They are 16 in year 11. The receptionist said my dc hadn't been marked as attended to the last lesson and asked if I knew why, etc. It turned out my dd had crossed wires with the teacher in a mix-up, was on site, and it was all legitimate reasons, etc. Anyway, that's not the point in the thread.

The receptionist asked me, "Do you have a tracker on her phone?" When I said no, she gave me the impression I should have one (not just my dc but all teens). I find this so odd! Surely, there should be a certain level of trust when your 15/16 + teens go out. I dated this guy who had a tracker on his 15 year olds phone, his kid was only cycling to his mates house and was tracked, which I thought was ott.

Reasons a parent might track:

They live in an area with a very high crime rate where safety is a real high-risk issue.

Their dc are known to be in lots of trouble a lot of the time, often breaking the law.

They go "missing" for long periods and don't appear home when they are supposed to.

Not for teens just hanging out with their mates in a fairly safe town. Surely, as I said, a certain level of trust has to come in somewhere, and even if they do make mistakes, that's part of learning as you grow up. The thought of being "tracked" all the time by your parents just sounds odd to me!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Btjdkfnn · 28/02/2023 01:46

My teens have phones with the “find my” app. Me, dh, both teens and dm can all track eachother. Whenever we want. Used when necessary for practical purposes. If nobody in the family is a controlling weirdo, then it’s perfectly normal and sensible for people to be able to locate eachother.

CremeEggQueen · 28/02/2023 01:33

Roseberry1 · 08/01/2023 17:52

I appreciate you've said you don't use a tracker as standard, but how are kids ever going to learn responsibility if parents are saving the day every time. How old was your dc if it was first day of work?

Completely agree, that's just weird!
Surely a part of growing up is being allowed to make your own mistakes, otherwise how are you ever going to learn independence?!
Thinking back to when I was 17 -20 (ie old enough to go to work) if there was a gadget tracking me to the extent my mum was ringing/texting saying you're on the wrong train!
I'd be like WTF, pack it in and go to bed 😬😂
Seriously just no

TheaBrandt · 16/01/2023 21:38

My friends would kill themselves laughing at that analysis if anything I am seen as too far the other way in letting my teens do stuff on their own.

TheaBrandt · 16/01/2023 21:32

Mathanxiety please keep your dimwit armchair psychiatry to yourself 🙄. How dare you say that? I’m not flipping anxious but my 13 year old and another young woman WERE verbally sexually abused on a bus. I barely use the tracking thing my friend only showed me how to use it recently the bus incident was last year. I am actually at the liberal end of the parenting spectrum. My 14 year old is an independent minded young woman but knows she can ring me whenever she needs to. Bloody cheek.

Jourdain11 · 16/01/2023 21:23

All these people with their hot dinners prepared on the table perfectly timed to coincide with arrivals home! I got home at 8pm tonight and got to feast on scraps from the fridge. I don't think the lack of tracker is the issue either 🤔

CurlyhairedAssassin · 16/01/2023 21:17

Roseberry1 · 09/01/2023 09:25

I think this post really stuck out to me because it's the equivalent of my dm ringing my dd to see what I was doing if I hadn't answered. If my dd said, "She's sat on the sofa," that apparently isn't a good enough excuse in her mind, so I must be ignoring her. In this post, if the son didn't answer the WhatsApp, his location was tracked because apparently the only justified reason to not answer is that they are away from their room. Needing to know the location so they know if they will hear from dc that evening or they won't go to bed/sleep is making the assumption that the dc is available everytime they are in their room, which is a mental burden in the dc and most likely creating a sense of guilt if they don't call that evening. The son can turn the tracker off, yes, but if the situation is anything like my mum, that just creates a whole load of new issues, and when you're young and don't want to upset your mum, you just keep quiet.

Now I can say something to my dm as I've got older, mainly because she was getting my dd involved, but that still creates martr mode and silence while she sulks because everyone's "picking on her."

But a dc should be able to go off to uni and have it where a "hey, just calling for a catch up, call back when you're free. X" is enough.

I think you may be coming at this having been influenced by your own mother’s strange and nosey and possessive behaviour. You don’t know enough of me, my son or the relationship we all have as a family and nor will you understand that plenty of people such as myself grow up in families with decent boundaries and normal relationships , and whose family members are also easygoing and respectful of each other too with little conflict or disagreements about expectations (on both sides). Your mother’s behaviour sounds so alien to me and I’m sorry you don’t enjoy normal boundaries with her. I think I’d have to say something. Both my mum and my MIL have a key to our house I trust them that much to know how to behave, and not to just turn up and let themselves in. In 25 years they never have. But it’s been helpful when we’ve lost our keys or when I was in hospital having DS2!

My son and I are both very laidback with each other. I never said I DID fret if he didn’t answer his phone - YOU put that spin on it! And It’s such an over the top spin too. I think I already explained I might check his location to see if it’s the day he’d mentioned he might be at football (and so I know not to expect a call back any time soon, probably sometime in the next day or two.). I also think I said that even if it shows he’s in his room i know if he doesn’t answer my WhatsApp message that he is often just concentrating on a tough piece of work, or even just switching off and gaming before he goes to bed. so i certainly don’t stay up late waiting for his call/message back! Sometimes he messages back, sometimes he doesn’t bother. Sometimes he messages before he goes to bed, sometimes he doesn’t. Often if he DOES reply later on I won’t see it till next morning because I’ve gone to bed myself! Neither of us will be having a panic attack about it, reading something into it which isn’t there and worrying that the other one is dead or something dramatic. [shrug]. 😆

as always on MN people so often let their own background cloud what they see of situations that others may experience very differently.

CurlyhairedAssassin · 16/01/2023 20:36

I hate people just popping in. I don't want my partner to know exactly where I am for tea because what if I fancied popping in to see a friend or go for a drink after work randomly and I certainly don't want my children to track me and question where I am - I'm an autonomous adult who likes spontaneity some times and tracking seems weird to me.

this seems full of contradictions to me. You like to be spontaneous yet don’t like people being spontaneous and dropping in on you. But you’re happy to do it the other way round and drop in on a friend after work. What if they’re not a fan of people just dropping in either?

Re your partner, assuming that you live together, are you really saying that you don’t want to have to let him know where you’re going after work, if you’re going to be later home than usual? Because that sounds downright disrespectful to me if he knows you get home aT a rough time and you don’t appear till hours later and haven’t contacted him to say you’ll be later than usual. Also, it’s curious to me that you say “because what if I fancied popping in to see a friend or go for a drink…..”. Well, you tell us. What if you DO want to do that? How is it a problem if you want to do that and you use findmyiphone? Is it because he may be preparing the evening meal for a certain time and estimate when he needs to start prepping based on your usual arrival time home? If so, it’s not unreasonable of him to hope that you’d respect him enough to give him an inkling of the time you may show up, so he can delay or put your portion aside or whatever.

if you don’t live with him and he’a not a family member as such and you lead separate lives then yeah, there’s no need for him to have find my iPhone etc is there?

but for families who communicate and interact very closely it’s actually quite useful in a practical sense. If you are someone who has children who would question where you are or give you hassle you about when you’re coming home then you need to have a stern word with them. That’s not ok.

MissyB1 · 16/01/2023 14:54

Yarrawonga · 16/01/2023 11:12

If you have a phone then you can do everything that PPs have said they use a tracker for (apart from finding a lost phone or medical issues).

No you can’t. You would need to make a phone call or send a text. Both require a response which may be impractical or inappropriate to give. While at work or driving. for example. I don’t like receiving or making phone calls while I am driving as, even with hands free, I find them distracting.

Research suggests that I’m not alone.

www.brake.org.uk/get-involved/take-action/mybrake/knowledge-centre/mobile-phone-use

Totally agree! I can’t make or receive calls at work unless on my break. I work with kids, we can’t have our phones on us.

I refuse to make or receive calls when I’m driving, it’s a dangerous distraction in my opinion.

Yarrawonga · 16/01/2023 11:12

If you have a phone then you can do everything that PPs have said they use a tracker for (apart from finding a lost phone or medical issues).

No you can’t. You would need to make a phone call or send a text. Both require a response which may be impractical or inappropriate to give. While at work or driving. for example. I don’t like receiving or making phone calls while I am driving as, even with hands free, I find them distracting.

Research suggests that I’m not alone.

www.brake.org.uk/get-involved/take-action/mybrake/knowledge-centre/mobile-phone-use

Carpedimum · 16/01/2023 10:15

This thread just goes to show how different we all are as individuals and individuals within a family who have their own norms. There’s no right or wrong, it’s whatever the members are comfortable with. If my DS no longer wanted to see me and vice versa on the ‘marauder’s map’ then it wouldn’t be an issue at all. As it is, we like it, find it useful, find it reassuring etc. Btw, I have never asked him what he’s doing at X location, but he has asked me, e.g. “what on earth are you doing in church?!” when I was giving blood 🤣

mathanxiety · 09/01/2023 20:25

@TheaBrandt

Do you think that perhaps your anxiety over your daughter's safety is causing her to feel so strongly about being independent that she won't do the sensible thing and call you if she has a problem?

Does she fear that if she called for help even once she would never be allowed out again, or you would give her such a hard time over safety that it would cast a pall over her social life and make it not worth the effort?

toocold54 · 09/01/2023 20:16

I'm not unreachable for an emergency, and neither is my dc - we have phones on us that can give and receive calls.

This is what I don’t understand.

Having a tracker implant is going to be much more useful than having one on your phone.

If you have a phone then you can do everything that PPs have said they use a tracker for (apart from finding a lost phone or medical issues).

If you get kidnapped, chances are they’ll throw your phone away.
If they don’t then you can use the phone to ring 999.

If you’re being held hostage by your partner and you’re not answering your phone or replying to texts - then a loved one is going to grow suspicious and come to your home to find out if you are ok.
The tracker is irrelevant.

These trackers aren’t a secret thing and anyone who is going to try and hold you hostage is going to turn them off straight away.

Being kidnapped by a random person is much less likely that being controlled by an abusive boyfriend and one thing they are bound to do is track your phone and know where you are every minute of the day.

I’d rather run the risk of being kidnapped than I would allow myself to walk into a controlling relationship.

Roseberry1 · 09/01/2023 18:33

BrieAndChilli · 09/01/2023 18:18

We are semi rural and often not enough signal to make and maintain a phone call but every now and then data can get through so an aprox location can be seen even if phone doesn’t have recipe to on that exact second.

aending a text or making a phone call to someone who is already on the way is more bothersome than the kids just checking find my iPhone to see if I’m nearly there etc.

in fact when mine all started secondary school they were able to not be bothered by me constantly texting to see if they had made it home and I could just check they had got home and crosses the major A road ok!

Then if your ex is holding you hostage in you own home, which is what the post you quoted is in response to, having tracker is not going to help because the family will just see they are home and not realise there is a problem?

OP posts:
BrieAndChilli · 09/01/2023 18:18

Roseberry1 · 09/01/2023 18:07

Then surely their family would see they are at home on the app and not raise the alarm because there's nothing to be suspicious of? Whereas trying to call/text and getting no answer for days might just ring alarm bells?

We are semi rural and often not enough signal to make and maintain a phone call but every now and then data can get through so an aprox location can be seen even if phone doesn’t have recipe to on that exact second.

aending a text or making a phone call to someone who is already on the way is more bothersome than the kids just checking find my iPhone to see if I’m nearly there etc.

in fact when mine all started secondary school they were able to not be bothered by me constantly texting to see if they had made it home and I could just check they had got home and crosses the major A road ok!

Roseberry1 · 09/01/2023 18:07

WinnieFosterReads · 09/01/2023 16:25

Then you don't know about the many DV cases where usually an ex partner decides to keep his victim trapped at home whilst he attacks and murders them. Or ex offenders targetting neighbours - again keeping them at home until they can murder and dispose of them. That's a gap in your knowledge not proof that it doesn't happen.
And police getting permission to track a phone through cell tower pings takes much longer than looking at Find My Phone.
I understand. It's hard to look at the reality of male violence and the figures about how many women/girls are murdered after being restrained and imprisoned at home. But your lack of awareness and ability to look the other way doesn't make those risks and realities disappear.

Then surely their family would see they are at home on the app and not raise the alarm because there's nothing to be suspicious of? Whereas trying to call/text and getting no answer for days might just ring alarm bells?

OP posts:
QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat · 09/01/2023 16:54

Winnie, how would a tracker help in these situations though? If an ex has held a woman captive, surely people would look at the tracker and see she's at home and feel a false sense of assurance? And it is more than likely that the ex is tracking the woman's movements using an app.

A phonecall or text to police would help in this situation but I genuinely don't understand how a tracker could help anyone?

WinnieFosterReads · 09/01/2023 16:25

BradfordGirl · 09/01/2023 11:30

@WinnieFosterReads I have never known a kidnapping case where the kidnapper does not remove and throw away the phone. By the way the police can track phones without a tracker being on the phone.

Then you don't know about the many DV cases where usually an ex partner decides to keep his victim trapped at home whilst he attacks and murders them. Or ex offenders targetting neighbours - again keeping them at home until they can murder and dispose of them. That's a gap in your knowledge not proof that it doesn't happen.
And police getting permission to track a phone through cell tower pings takes much longer than looking at Find My Phone.
I understand. It's hard to look at the reality of male violence and the figures about how many women/girls are murdered after being restrained and imprisoned at home. But your lack of awareness and ability to look the other way doesn't make those risks and realities disappear.

TheaBrandt · 09/01/2023 11:48

I know a tracker won’t insulate against grim incidents but if I see my 14 year old waiting at the bus station for too long damn right I will go and get her as that is sadly that is where the vile incidents have happened and she is so keen on being independent she is likely to not want to bother me to ask for a lift.

Every situation and family dynamic is different but carry on digging in that we are all neurotic Big Brother type helicopter parents 🙄

BradfordGirl · 09/01/2023 11:30

@WinnieFosterReads I have never known a kidnapping case where the kidnapper does not remove and throw away the phone. By the way the police can track phones without a tracker being on the phone.

Roseberry1 · 09/01/2023 11:29

WinnieFosterReads · 09/01/2023 10:09

^All very acceptable reasons. It was never an emergency, she was just being nosey^

I think that's key to your attitude OP. You're so insulated from tragedies and emergencies that you can't even empathise with or understand when locating devices could avert or alleviate disasters.
As someone who has known four women/girls who have been kidnapped/kept captive/murdered, switching on Find My Phone is a very basic step that in all of those cases would have helped the women/girls be found sooner.
The big privacy concerns are with the apps abusing data not with parents consensually knowing their DCs' whereabouts. Apps like Life360 sell data including to companies that then provide data to governments. Anonymisation is much less robust when it's linked to identifiable locations ie if your name is replaced with a number but that number goes back to your home address every day then there is a real possibility of jigsaw identification. Since Life360 has now bought Tile and received funding from Facebook etc that risk and concerns about market share etc increase. Should you trust an app with arm's length connections to organisations that have sold data, breached data guidelines and worked with governments? That's the real question and there have been a number of interesting articles about those links and ramifications in relation to Life360.

I'm not insulated from emergencies or tragedies at all, not sure where that came from, from me saying with my dm it was noseyness. I'm not unreachable for an emergency, and neither is my dc - we have phones on us that can give and receive calls. I've experienced plenty of emergency situations, which is when I get the call or make the call.

OP posts:
flashria · 09/01/2023 11:23

yarrawonga presumably because the parents would go swooping in to rescue them. Because what's the point otherwise? Those situations are exactly what people are citing as a reason to have the tracker in the first place. Or at the very least someone would pick up on it and ask about it, and who would do something like that if they knew they would have to explain it later? Hence the tracker is changing their behaviour and enforcing 'good choices' while limiting options. That may or may not be seen as a good thing.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 09/01/2023 11:11

My (almost) 14 year twins and their 11 YO brother have trackers on their phones. They know.

The only time I've ever used it was when one of them kept pinging at me as having left school - it had never happened before. He was in school, no idea why that happened.

Otherwise it's just handy to know if they lose it we can find it, or if I'm expecting them from somewhere and they're late I can check. Although to date I don't think that's ever happened.

I don't share my location with them because it is part of a specific family safety app. I wouldn't mind if they wanted to though.

Yarrawonga · 09/01/2023 11:08

If they wanted to go and do something or go somewhere risky, do they not have the right to do that? Did you want that when you were teenagers?

How does having a tracker turned on take away that right?

BradfordGirl · 09/01/2023 11:07

And tracking family members does not protect them from incidents like the very unlikely danger of kidnap. The first thing any kidnapper does is remove the persons phone and throw it away.

BradfordGirl · 09/01/2023 11:06

@flashria I am with you. Trust and privacy matter. As do having healthy boundaries.

Swipe left for the next trending thread