Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Secondary schools

33 replies

Jourdain11 · 08/01/2023 13:16

My DD10 is in Year 6 and came home from school in a state last week because the deputy head had been using "when you go to secondary next year" as a way of indicating things that won't be tolerated (forgetting items, not finishing work in the allotted time, etc.).

She has had a fair number of issues to deal with and gets anxious about school generally. I knew or suspected she was worried about the social side of secondary school (already!) but now she's getting in a stew over the academic/organisational elements too.

Obviously at present we have no idea of where she will be going... And it's a way off. But has anyone else had the experience of a child who was very worried about the prospect of moving up and do you have any tips on what might help to prepare?

I am fully prepared to be told that I'm unreasonable to be worrying about it this far in advance! I feel like it could go two ways: either she'll flourish and become much happier, or she'll really struggle. And I want to avoid the latter!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Jourdain11 · 13/01/2023 19:05

Malbecfan · 08/01/2023 15:20

OP I've been a secondary school teacher for 29 years and don't know of any kid who has been given a detention for not having a sharp pencil. In my school, detentions are mainly at lunchtime due to most kids coming in on special buses. If you get an after-school one, it's for persistent misbehaviour, not forgetting your h/w or having a blunt pencil. Both my DDs went through the school and never got any detentions - DD2 is outspoken and can push boundaries but knew when to rein it in. It sounds like the Deputy Head is using secondary school to "shock" the naughtier y6s into behaving. Sadly, that has backfired in the case of your DD.

When a DC is wobbling or has doubts or issues about their place, we invite them in for a visit before Induction, normally once the y11 and y13s have gone on study leave and things are a bit quieter. I teach Music and have had chats with several Hearing Impaired and Autistic children and their parents, showing them how the room is set up and looking at how particular bits of kit work with hearing aids for example. Once you know which school you have been allocated, I suggest contacting the SENCO and requesting a familiarisation visit to help reassure your DD.

I meant to say @Malbecfan, thank you very much for your post. It's really helpful and gave me some ideas to explore with DD. She actually loves music, although she doesn't play anything except a recorder (which she plays quite musically, I think, and is taking an exam this term). She loves singing in choir and is quite keen to take up an instrument like flute or clarinet when she goes to secondary, although I'm not expecting her to become the next James Galway or anything 😀

She's generally quite academically able but not fond of maths, and finds them difficult. Plus, when she gets anxious she finds it difficult to concentrate on anything. The school have been supportive this year, but I worry that in the wrong environment she will struggle and get more and more stressed, to the detriment of her happiness, health and schoolwork!

OP posts:
Jourdain11 · 08/01/2023 16:58

Thanks for all the tips and thoughts. I hadn't so much thought about the possibility of moving at a later date, but it is a good point! I would hope that she might settle down well in whichever school she ends up at, though.

Ironically, DD2 probably has a much better chance of getting a place at DD2's preferred school and I'm not sure she'll want to go there! (She's Year 5 currently, so we'll be doing this again next year 😭 )

OP posts:
Malbecfan · 08/01/2023 15:20

OP I've been a secondary school teacher for 29 years and don't know of any kid who has been given a detention for not having a sharp pencil. In my school, detentions are mainly at lunchtime due to most kids coming in on special buses. If you get an after-school one, it's for persistent misbehaviour, not forgetting your h/w or having a blunt pencil. Both my DDs went through the school and never got any detentions - DD2 is outspoken and can push boundaries but knew when to rein it in. It sounds like the Deputy Head is using secondary school to "shock" the naughtier y6s into behaving. Sadly, that has backfired in the case of your DD.

When a DC is wobbling or has doubts or issues about their place, we invite them in for a visit before Induction, normally once the y11 and y13s have gone on study leave and things are a bit quieter. I teach Music and have had chats with several Hearing Impaired and Autistic children and their parents, showing them how the room is set up and looking at how particular bits of kit work with hearing aids for example. Once you know which school you have been allocated, I suggest contacting the SENCO and requesting a familiarisation visit to help reassure your DD.

JustKeepBuilding · 08/01/2023 14:51

OP you should apply for an EHCNA ASAP.

We don’t get early confirmation in our area

Legally the LA must finalise secondary phase transfer EHCPs by 15th February.

I have no idea if an EHCP gives you priority for in-year moves

Unless the school is wholly independent if the school is named in section I it must admit, including in year, and the LA can refuse to name parental preference if they can prove:
-The setting is unsuitable for the age, ability, aptitude or special educational needs (“SEN”) of the child or young person; or
-The attendance of the child or young person would be incompatible with the provision of efficient education for others; or
-The attendance of the child or young person would be incompatible with the efficient use of resources.

LastTrainBeforeChristmas · 08/01/2023 14:43

My top tip is to have a designated place to keep all exercise books. We bought a stacked tray tidy that's kept next to the desk for them and the books are always either in her bag or in there. Never left anywhere else. It makes packing her bag easier and means if the book isn't in the tray the teacher must have it.

LastTrainBeforeChristmas · 08/01/2023 14:40

Should say as well that she didn't get any of the transition stuff as we got a waiting list place after the transition day and the secondary's summer school. It still worked out fine and we were really glad we took the late waiting list place to get her into her preferred school. Sounds like you might also end up in a similar situation.

NeedAHoliday2021 · 08/01/2023 14:37

Dd1’s teacher in Year 6 set absurd amounts of homework arguing it’s to get them used to it for secondary… secondary sets a lot less! (We’re now year 10 and she gets more bit at her age she can do it without my help so it’s less stressful than at age 10).

LastTrainBeforeChristmas · 08/01/2023 14:36

I agree with making sure you speak to the Senco as soon as the school is confirmed. And check with the primary what info they are sending over. Where I am the primary school and secondary school Senco will have a meeting and pass over all the documentation and chat about the parents going. I'm assuming even if your DD doesn't have an EHCP the primary at least have her on their SEN register and are supporting in some way?

My DD started secondary last September and was very anxious, she also has SEN but not EHCP. Secondary hasn't been as awful as she was expecting. The staff have actually been very nice and supportive and quick to adapt things to suit her.

Drivingbuttercup · 08/01/2023 14:34

We're starting to prepare, as I know dd will be a mess over the summer. All her friends will be going to other schools. Ive begun drip feeding the changes in expectation. Just dropping them into conversations nothing intense, most of the questions come from her. We're pretty sure which high school she will get a place, so ive been taking her for walks around the area, as the size of the building can be intimidating and walking home won't feel so scary. She's been talking to my friend's daughter who is in Year 7 and currently at the school. She went to the open evening and that has really helped as she got a feel of what it would be like. So far she seems positive and excited, a bit sad to be leaving primary but really up for the challenge. Im sure the visits to the school after sats will help too. It is scary but like pp have said it is 9 months away. I think mentally prepare them is important.

Sirzy · 08/01/2023 14:29

As soon as you know which school get in touch with the senco outlining her needs and what support she gets at school at present. They should be able to arrange things to help the transition - Ds and a small group of children did a whole half term of weekly visits when they where in year 6 because they needed the extra time to prepare.

make sure she has somewhere to go to if she needs to leave class - learning support department or similar.

Gymrabbit · 08/01/2023 14:24

RandomPerson42

Not sure why you find the term ‘low level disruption’ , ‘hilarious.’ It’s a perfectly normal term in education that most teachers will use every single day of their teaching career. It means chatting, calling out etc. It’s the kind of behaviour that massively impacts on the learning of the whole class but in each individual child’s case does not seem particularly serious. And if you’ve ever seen a child sent out of a room or returning to a room while spinning around or kicking their legs in the air you would know how disruptive a child who is ‘walking funny’ can be.

Jourdain11

I really wouldn’t worry, secondary teachers work out very quickly which children are lazy and can’t be bothered to bring the right equipment (while always having their phone and headphones) or do their work and which children are genuinely worried and doing their best.

Whycanineverever · 08/01/2023 14:21

Jourdain11 · 08/01/2023 14:11

It is a moot point, unfortunately, but I really wish we'd been more proactive from pov of the EHCP. Her first choice is the one she prefees about 10x over any of the others, and I feel that it would be a really good fit for her. But she's very unlikely to get a place because it's out of area and partially selective.

PM me if you want . I just posted below but my daughters school is a partially selective one. Not sure if it's the same - outer south London.

Whycanineverever · 08/01/2023 14:17

Speak to the secondary when you know which one. The Senco should be able to support.

My DD gets very anxious. She went to the summer school before starting to help ease into it. I also spoke to Senco who was fab - she said they have a more nurturing tutor group for children that need that.

I was also worried about starting secondary as she is quite young for her age - she made a great group of friends, many of them I think have their own quirks like her.

She has been getting a bit worried recently and she has a pass so she can go to the support room if needed, Senco has said she can come and see her any time.

Honestly I'm really happy with support she has been getting and it's been really positive.

Testina · 08/01/2023 14:16

I have no idea if an EHCP gives you priority for in-year moves, but I’d be finding out as another reason to get the process kicked off asap. If she starts in one school and a place becomes available in a school that’s a better fit later on, if there’s anyway to be higher up the list, you need to grab it.

Jourdain11 · 08/01/2023 14:11

It is a moot point, unfortunately, but I really wish we'd been more proactive from pov of the EHCP. Her first choice is the one she prefees about 10x over any of the others, and I feel that it would be a really good fit for her. But she's very unlikely to get a place because it's out of area and partially selective.

OP posts:
Testina · 08/01/2023 14:06

TakemedowntoPotatoCity · 08/01/2023 13:57

We have an ehcp here and still don't find out till mid February.

We don’t get early confirmation in our area, but we do know that with an EHCP and a specific first choice based with good read on that EHCP, you’re in the priority group for allocation.

It’s a moot point if there’s no EHCP - but I’d still recommend OP talks to current school about whether she should have one. With a history of OCD and panic attacks, I think her daughter will benefit from one.

RandomPerson42 · 08/01/2023 14:05

I’m sure different secondary schools have different systems in place but at DC’s school it’s like this…

Verbal warnings are given for minor infractions and basically have no consequences.

Written warnings are given for more serious infractions, such as homework not done / forgotten.

A detention is given if a student gets 4 written warnings in a week or two written warnings in a single lesson.

Also, if a student gets 3 written warnings in a lesson it is a removal from the lesson, and if they manage to get 4 written warnings in a lesson (gets a fourth before another teacher comes to escort them out) it is isolation the following day.

Now, where it gets tricky is that different teachers have different standards and reasons for giving written warnings. One teacher apparently often gives the reason of “low-level disruption” which I find hilarious, albeit my DC has never received a written warning. This teacher even gave a student a written warning for “walking funny” and gives out ridiculous amounts of written warnings each lesson.

Jourdain11 · 08/01/2023 14:03

Thanks for the replies... No EHCP, but we did speak to the SENCO at the three schools she prefers. The problem is that I'm not certain she'll get a place at any of them. We're in London, so it's not so straightforward, especially since the closest schools are in a different Borough to the one we live in/where the primary is.

A lot of her class mates will go to a particular Academy... but when we went to the Open Day she hated it and nothing I saw or have heard leads me to think it would be a good fit for her. So we didn't even list that one.

OP posts:
PuttingDownRoots · 08/01/2023 14:03

DD started Secondary in September. Its quite a strict school... but they don't set out to make the kids fail to meet the expectations. Like in the first week, some of the girls muddled up their PE kits. They helped them sort it out, and have spare kit to borrow if its just one or two list bits. Initial response to homework not being completed it a text to parents, and checking they knew how to lose the appropriate apps. Its repeated non compliance that gets detentions. The teachers listened to any problems... last week DD got a new seat on the seating plan when the teacher found out the boy she was sitting next too was making fun of her. Its a very supportive environment... as long as the pupils try their best.

Also in the second half of summer term (after SATs are out of the way) there will be transition days. These can alleviate a lot of worries.

AmyandPhilipfan · 08/01/2023 13:59

Sorry, I didn't read your second post before I answered.

My kids aren't hugely academic and don't always get work finished. They never get detentions when they've got on and been trying to do work. They've got detentions when they've refused to try or been chatting instead of working, or wasting time sharpening pencils etc.

If the teacher sees her working she's unlikely to get penalised if she doesn't finish. Plus I'm sure information about her struggles will be passed from the primary to the secondary before she starts.

TakemedowntoPotatoCity · 08/01/2023 13:57

We have an ehcp here and still don't find out till mid February.

Jourdain11 · 08/01/2023 13:56

“Obviously at present we have no idea of where she will be going..”

Why obviously? Surely you’ve already made your applications and must have an idea of whether they generally admit from your distance? So rather than no idea, you must have some idea?

Yes, we've made the applications but the schools are in quite different areas and admissions criteria are varied, so it's a bit all up in the air.

OP posts:
Testina · 08/01/2023 13:55

Does she have an EHCP, and did you speak to the SENCO when making your choices?
Actually I’m guessing no EHCP because they are high priority in school allocation and you would know where she was going.

Your OP sounded like she was a bit more of a worrier than average - but your later posts - severe OCD and panic attacks - are much more serious. You need a specific plan in place for her transition as soon as you get your place allocation this term. I would also ask current school about starting EHCP process.

When you made your school choices, did you talk to the SENCO at the schools? If not… Are you likely to have a choice once the allocations come back? (I.e. you’ll get one allocated, but do some of your other choices tend to have spaces?) If so I’d be getting onto the SENCO now to find out how they would typically support her. You may change your mind about the best school for her.

AmyandPhilipfan · 08/01/2023 13:54

I would just be matter of fact with her:

'I'll get a detention if I don't finish my work!'
' Then you'll have to make sure you finish your work. Teachers aren't meanies who give more work than children can do. They'll give an amount that's possible for you to do in the lesson. Get on with the work and don't sit and chat and you'll get it all done.'

'I'll get a detention if I forget my PE kit!'
'But you'll get a timetable telling you what lessons you have every day. We'll check it every night and make sure you have all the equipment you need for the next day.'

BungleandGeorge · 08/01/2023 13:52

Some teachers and schools forget that children are not all the same and tend to only cater for the disruptive, unmotivated ones. This approach can be really damaging for children who have anxiety/ perfectionism/ OCD etc. what they actually need is reassurance and not frightening out of their wits before they even get there!