Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it reasonable to tell DC that "most people don't enjoy going to work"?

161 replies

raisinsarenottheonlyfruit · 08/01/2023 10:12

DP thinks most people would rather be doing something other than their job and it's not unreasonable so say this to DD, aged 9.

I feel that the aim is to find a job you enjoy doing, and although it's true that loads of us are in jobs we don't particularly enjoy, at 9 years old, the world is still DD's oyster and we should be encouraging her to follow her interests in the hope she will find a career she enjoys, not giving her the idea that work is shit.

I think it's fine that DD knows the reality that many people have to do jobs they don't like to get money, but I think giving her the idea that work in general is something most people don't want to do isn't a good message for a 9 year old.

AIBU?

OP posts:
LolaSmiles · 08/01/2023 10:43

At 9 I think it's needlessly negative to tell a child most people don't like their job. What does a 9 year old gain from that? Nothing. Unless there's a backstory, an adult saying that is venting to a child rather than deal with their own adult situation.

When selecting GCSE/A Levels/further or higher education, then it makes sense to discuss career options, and the likelihood of making it in a field you really want to, especially if that field is highly competitive and often viewed with rose tinted glasses eg sport, drama, music.

UWhatNow · 08/01/2023 10:43

If you are from a privileged background then the chances of getting meaningful and fulfilling work is higher. Unfortunately the reality is that for the majority of ordinary people, work is a tedious drudge to pay the mortgage and that’s why people dream of a lottery win to release them from that enslavement.

So not withstanding those lofty ideals to teach children that enjoyable forms of work are possible, YANBU to say that most people hate work because that is actually the truth.

Citylab · 08/01/2023 10:42

Oysterbabe · 08/01/2023 10:20

I talk to my DD about not enjoying my job. If I can prevent one person from choosing law as a career path then at least some good has come out of my misery. DH is a graphic designer and he likes his job.
I talk to her about how lots of people do enjoy their job and it's important to try and find something you love.

Why don't you change career? Plenty of people leave law to do other things.

girlmom21 · 08/01/2023 10:42

What was the context of the conversation? I think that matters.

raisinsarenottheonlyfruit · 08/01/2023 10:40

I'm not hiding the reality of work from them. I've WFH for years and the DC have seen me do jobs I've loved and jobs that have been a real struggle (for terrible bosses). I work longer hours than I'd like as I have to, to support the family. The DC know this, they see the reality in their own home.

Yet, I do enjoy many aspects of my work, and I want the DC to at least try to find a career they enjoy. Both DC are smart - if they apply themselves, they should have a good chance of finding a career they enjoy.

But the idea that most people don't enjoy work seems so negative, I worry it'll work against their chances of getting a job they enjoy. Why work hard to get a career you like if you've been given the idea that most jobs are shit anyway?

OP posts:
Chersfrozenface · 08/01/2023 10:40

Look at any of the threads on MN where the OP asks "Would you still work if you won the Lottery?"

The overwhelming majority answer "No".

Nothing wrong with telling children that they will need an income, to pay for necessities and with any luck pleasures. To do that they will need someone to pay them for their work. So they will need a good rounded education and to find what their strengths are. Then they stand a chance of doing work they either enjoy or don't mind.

cosmiccosmos · 08/01/2023 10:39

The thing is surely most people like some things about their job but not all. Some days are great, others crap. Just like normal life. If you didn't work some days would be great, others crap.

I think the important message is for DC to get themselves in a position where they have choices. Get good qualifications and as much experience as you can. This gives you more control, once you have control you are much better placed to make decisions and have options. You won't get trapped in a job you hate because you can leave and get another job.

honeylulu · 08/01/2023 10:38

I like and enjoy my job. But I still moan about and dread actually having to go to work especially on a Monday or after a long break (though once I get stuck in I remember I enjoy it lol). Plus the hours are often long and exhausting and I get fed up with pointless admin/IT being crap and I moan about that.

I do try to give my kids a balanced impression. That if you do a job you enjoy and find interesting it makes it seem less of a drudge (although getting qualified and successful in a role like that is in itself hard work) but it's still "hard work" and leisure time is both necessary and welcomed. It's an important balance.

I've made it quite clear that if I came into money and didn't "need" to work I still would want to use my skills and experience but I would cut back on the hours.

user8912 · 08/01/2023 10:37

No I really don't. I think at this age when they have the world at their feet it is so, so important to get them to aim to find work they will enjoy and get fulfilment from. Most of us will have to work, life is too short to do something you really don't like. Whilst few of us will work in jobs we love all the time and get enjoyment from everyday, I think it is completely achievable to aim for a job you won't hate or begrudge! Hopefully enjoy most of the time. But I do also think it's important to discuss lifestyle and money too, I was pushed too far to follow my passion and went into a field that paid poorly and as such my "home" life wasn't what I wanted it to be (managed to rectify to find a balance!)

So I will be encouraging my children to think about what they enjoy and what lifestyle they want outside of work. And it's never too early to talk about it, because the sooner you start thinking about these things, the better you can prepare and develop.

ZenNudist · 08/01/2023 10:37

I think a note of reality is a good idea. My 12yo knows that there are realistic jobs people actually get (and to aim high) but there are other jobs that are unrealistic and likely to result in you actually not doing that job but a different poorly paid job.

He said he wanted to be an actor recently and I had to explain how hard it is to get into.

Then again hopefully your dc are clever enough to realise that adults are not teachers doctors accountants and shop workers because we love it. We do it out of necessity and try and enjoy life regardless.

Unhappymumma · 08/01/2023 10:37

This is a problem that we have in our home and extended family & I have been trying to encourage positive discussions with about work.
I have always been a sahm so my kids have never known me working. My mum, her mum, and the kids other grandmother have also always been housewives. So they've never seen a woman go to work in our family. Im very conscious of this regarding my daughter.
On top of that, even though my husband has a senior level professional job, it's quite an easy role, mostly delegation, and since covid he's worked from home. So again this is what they have seen from him. That he gets paid a lot to stay home & not do much. This is not reality for most people & I don't want them to think that.

raisinsarenottheonlyfruit · 08/01/2023 10:34

JaninaDuszejko · 08/01/2023 10:22

Middle class women with plenty of money fought for the right to an education and to paid work. Working gives you money and choices and purpose and allows you to socialise with people who are not your family. It's vitally important that we encourage our daughters to view paid work as a positive in their life.

I think it's fine to say all jobs have their downsides but it depends why he's saying it to your daughter. At best it seems an unnecessary adult detail, at worst it's creating a narrative that will destroy her ambition.

I hadn't thought of it like this but yes, I totally agree.

OP posts:
Baxdream · 08/01/2023 10:33

I think at 9 it's too young. But once considering GCSEs etc you need to be honest. I'm public service so shift work, working Christmas/weekends/nights. I saw the worst part of humanity and death far far too much. But my job is secure and I should be able to retire younger.

For us, both of working has given the children a good life. But it comes with sacrifices and not always happiness.

I feel similar about being a tradesperson. You earn great money but by the time you're 50, you might struggle physically and pension plans aren't necessarily as good.

I think as parents we need to be honest. Do you want good money or happy with a simple life? Do you want to work weekends? If you want to be happy, what does happiness mean to you? It's individual to everyone but it's important to discuss with children as they're entering the workplace

Campervangirl · 08/01/2023 10:33

I told DSS that most people don't like their jobs when he was 10.
It partly stemmed from his dm being jealous of my "wonderful job" and constantly telling him that "it's alright for her, with her wonderful job and all her money"
Dss dm had her 1st DC at 16, now has 4 DC and has never worked, lives on benefits (no judgement) but we have different life experiences, she doesn't understand mine and I don't understand hers, walk a mile in someone else's shoes kinda thing.
My reality is that I hate my job, trapped in it due to my experience, been in my industry nearly 30 yrs, niche industry, difficult skill set to transfer.
Dss is working hard at college, looking for an apprenticeship funnily enough in my industry and is working part-time in the fast food industry and hating every second of it which in turn is spurring him on in his job search.

raisinsarenottheonlyfruit · 08/01/2023 10:32

Some great food for thought here, thanks :)

DP said it because he's fed up with his own work situation and thinks he's simply saying the truth.

OP posts:
Eleganz · 08/01/2023 10:31

A more balanced approach would be a variation on the old adage:

"Some work to live, others live to work"

Happiness is a good pursuit in life and some people find it through work, and others find it through other things.

JustAnotherManicMomday · 08/01/2023 10:30

When my son tells me he doesn't want to go to school as its boring, I tell him I don't want to go to work bit I'm still going. He says to me that I get paid to go to work so I that makes going OK, I point out had I not gone to school they wouldn't pay me to go to work and that at least at school he gets play times with his friends.

Life isn't all sunshine and roses. When he tells me he wants to be a football player or youtuber I always ask him what his back up is. Not to crush him but because in reality he needs to learn that is very unlikely to happen and he will still need money to survive in life.

Mushroo · 08/01/2023 10:29

I like my job overall, it’s well paid, I have lovely colleagues and a lot of autonomy.

Ive had jobs where I dread each day and the difference now is extraordinary.

However, it’s still work! If I won millions I wouldn’t do it. To me, it’s a mechanism to fund my life outside of work. I think it’s fine to have the message that you might not love everyday, and to find something you can see yourself doing day in day out.

I think the ‘find a job you love’ can be hard to deal with in the real world, as I think most people given the choice wouldn’t seek out paid employment. The difference I think could be owning your own business, which whilst stressful, probably has a bit less of the boredom element.

SpongeBob2022 · 08/01/2023 10:28

Actually I think most people I know enjoy working to a degree. I mean I don't love my job at all times but I'm generally pleased with my career choice and I would hate to not be working at all.

I think in the context of 'work isn't alway easy but it's essential and you'll need to do it, so try hard at school and you'll have more options to choose something you enjoy' it's ok.

But overall I'm with you. Seems a pretty negative message to give for no real purpose.

StephanieSuperpowers · 08/01/2023 10:27

And thats something to be embraced not looked down on, that is how the majority of us live, its ok.

This is largely what I believe. I'm far from perfect. I'm a bit overweight, I'm grey, I'm not particularly excited about my job, but I have a good and happy life overall. We don't struggle financially, we are surrounded by loving family and friends, we have plenty to enjoy. Life has balance. It's important to accept that life has its share of drudgery and frustration and you aren't just being victimised by unseen forces if your life isn't perfect.

ProceedWithOptimism · 08/01/2023 10:26

God, what a negative view!

I get so much from my work; confidence, skills, growth, friendships, etc. Especially as a mother I love having something that's just for me.

I think work that challenges and satisfies you is incredibly important. I don't like the attitude that work is a shit sandwich you have to swallow to live; it's a hell of a low expectation to set for your child.

whataboutsecondbreakfast · 08/01/2023 10:25

I think it's a bit of a depressing attitude to pass down to a nine year old. It's also not necessarily true - lots of people do enjoy their jobs, it's just you generally only hear from the people who are struggling and who have something to complain about.

I spent a decade in a job sector that made me miserable. If I'd been raised to think hating your job was normal, I may never have had the guts to leave and find something more suitable.

I now run my own business and I can genuinely say I love my job. Yes, of course there are days when I'm tired or stressed and can't be arsed, but those days are hugely overshadowed by the ones where I come home beaming because I've had such a good day.

Would I do it if I won the lottery tomorrow? No, probably not, but that doesn't mean I don't enjoy it now and I'm hugely grateful I can spend my days doing what makes me happy while earning the money needed to pay the bills.

bigbadbarry · 08/01/2023 10:25

I like my job. I wouldn’t carry on doing it if I won the lottery, and most days I’d rather be doing something else. I think that is normal.

bellac11 · 08/01/2023 10:23

I think its a huge luxury to be in a job that you absolutely love. Most people are in a job that they can tolerate or just about manage to face up to.

People work in the best job they can find to put food on the table and afford to live, thats the reality

I think the focus on everyone looking like film stars, their homes looking like something off the telly, having a job that 'doesnt feel like work', having things without saving for them or building up to them is causing young people and younger adults to feel completely dissatisfied with life and not understanding the facts of life.

The reality is most of us tolerate our jobs, have flawed relationships with people, have bog standard homes that might be a bit rough round the edges or need work on them, dont have huge incomes and dont look like supermodels.

And thats something to be embraced not looked down on, that is how the majority of us live, its ok.

Alexandernevermind · 08/01/2023 10:23

I enjoy my work. I certainly wouldn't tell my dc that most people don't enjoy theirs jobs, as it paints such a bleak future and give them nothing to aim for. I tell mine to study hard at school and choose the subjects they enjoy most for further education, to give themselves the best chance possible to do a job they love. We can choose our own future by making sensible decisions and putting the work in for our future.