Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to take kids out of school for a ski hol in March?

145 replies

Nurserymumm · 08/01/2023 00:41

Midterm is ridiculous, so expensive. DH has a week off the start of March so thinking of taking them out & going skiing for a week then. It's educational right?

OP posts:
Testina · 08/01/2023 21:57

@NoKnit “Resorts will be closed come March”

Apart from the ones that aren’t. Val d’Isère, Val Thorens, Saas Fe…

NoKnit · 08/01/2023 21:55

March 2023? Don't waste your money. Honestly if there is any snow it will be rubbish. Just come back from ice and slush and it's January. Resorts will be closed come March

Sarah061991 · 08/01/2023 21:12

You'll all always remember the holiday. They'll never remember a specific week at school. Go on the holiday, it's a no brainer I'd say, it's only a week!

donteatme · 08/01/2023 21:00

Yes but your 11 y/o can't do that for many
More years imo

Jimboscott0115 · 08/01/2023 18:31

I've done it several times OP, for the same reasons, though generally around May half term and somewhere warmer.

At 9&11, despite what others say, it really won't have much of an impact on their education in the longer term, school isn't that intense until GCSEs where you can't catch up on a handful of lessons over a few weeks. In fact, even GCSEs aren't that challenging for a lot of bright kids.

They'll get much more out of a family holiday, but let's not pretend it's educational, it's about experiences, family time and memories.

snowtrees · 08/01/2023 18:25

Exactly. We can't afford all of us to go skiing never mind in in half term. Hopefully might go one year but not in near future. Holiday costs have escalated. We can afford to save an send them on good value School trips

Nurserymumm · 08/01/2023 14:32

snowtrees · 08/01/2023 13:01

It might be less of an education for wealthy kids who go abroad or skiing a lot. But for mine is was massively educational. They'd not left the country since tiny. And yes lots of state schools do all trips in term time to keep costs affordable. The costs would prob double at 1/2 terms. (Private schools near us go in holidays)

We did price the Feb midterm & it was more than double unfortunately

OP posts:
Coasterfan · 08/01/2023 13:10

I would. My DS has missed most of the autumn term of year 8, (no school places available, had to wait for fair access team to get involved etc ) he started his for the last week and a half and he’s catching up just fine. We did a bit of homeschool but I work full time so it was limited.

I can’t see a week or two doing any harm and education is not just in the classroom!

PlusLaMeme · 08/01/2023 13:01

Even if you set aside the exact definition of education (and I dispute that it's as narrow as maths worksheets), it is of great value to the development of a child to travel and have new experiences. Skiing is a physical activity conducted in fresh mountain air, and could set off a lifelong passion. And what about family bonding? Our family, especially the children as siblings, bond on holiday in a way that we never would at home with all the pressures of work and school.

So let's forget about this being 'educational'. It cannot be argued that it is not of developmental benefit.

Heck, forget about skiing. Going abroad to visit family and meeting up with aunts/uncles/cousins/grandparents who live in a different culture perhaps, is of HUGE developmental benefit

snowtrees · 08/01/2023 13:01

It might be less of an education for wealthy kids who go abroad or skiing a lot. But for mine is was massively educational. They'd not left the country since tiny. And yes lots of state schools do all trips in term time to keep costs affordable. The costs would prob double at 1/2 terms. (Private schools near us go in holidays)

TheKeatingFive · 08/01/2023 12:36

You'd have to have a very narrow definition of education to decide that exposure to news skills, culture, language, people, experiences doesn't 'count'.

creamcoffee · 08/01/2023 12:22

speak the local language op,
job done as regards education

Notjustanymum · 08/01/2023 12:18

We did this when our DC were 10 and 7. We asked the school (circumstances had forced us to miss out on a place for half-term) and while the HT was not willing to say it was perfectly OK, she indicated that she wouldn’t prevent us from taking them out of school for it. Both DC’s class teachers, however, said that they WOULD learn more in a week abroad than at school, as any trip abroad, learning a skill, would be educational!
So for all PP who pooh-poohed the idea that it’s educational, that was the response we had from the professional teachers at the time! I can’t believe it will have changed much, even though our trip was 20+ years ago…

PuttingDownRoots · 08/01/2023 12:11

We ski at Christmas as its cheaper than February. Also go to cheaper places like Andorra rather than France.

Its fun. Its family time But not educational.

(We have taken them in terms time but they were 5&7... and permitted as their father is in the Forces... we had a great time.)

PlusLaMeme · 08/01/2023 12:05

We took our kids out a week before school broke up for Christmas to get cheaper tickets. I feel not an iota of guilt over it. Teachers unions fought tooth and nail against reopening schools during 2021/21, saying it isn't the be all and end all. They can't now turn around and say attendance is super important to the life chances of children. We all know by now that it isn't connected
(In reality, the teachers I let know were all supportive and wished us a happy holiday)

TheMousePipes · 08/01/2023 11:36

There’s more to education than maths and English - do it! Factor in the fines in your costings though.
We take dd out for the week before Easter pretty much every year. I couldn’t give a shit what the law says, life is for living and they grow up and go so quickly.

Nurserymumm · 08/01/2023 11:18

@Megan1992xx thank you I feel the same.. They'll be doing plenty of reading in the evenings to relax. We missed two years of travel due to covid so don't feel so bad now after reading the comments. The dc can also check with their friends to see what was covered & I am very friendly with some of the parents who absolutely wouldn't mind divulging & sending on the homework, I have done it myself for other parents it's absolutely no big deal to do that. I absolutely wouldn't approach their teachers.

OP posts:
Megan1992xx · 08/01/2023 10:49

Nurserymumm · 08/01/2023 00:41

Midterm is ridiculous, so expensive. DH has a week off the start of March so thinking of taking them out & going skiing for a week then. It's educational right?

Absolutely they will gain far more from the exercise and fresh air than dreary school.
Covid showed that school is not always the first priority. Hope it snows a lot, at night!

HaroldsPeen · 08/01/2023 10:40

Be prepared for that to be thrown back at you when they want to slink off to Glastonbury or something else in years to come.

This made me laugh. What a reach. Kids throw a whole load of things back at their parents but it isn't going to be a ski trip during term time.
Of course go ahead and do it @Nurserymumm . And of course it is educational. Every life experience is educational.

cakeorwine · 08/01/2023 10:35

Life is for living. And, the evidence is actually really poor on term time holidays and educational loss. Like, non-existent. There is a correlation between significant time missed over a school year/ career and poorer outcomes but this is not causation and also doesn't account for confounding factors

True - the stats do show a link between attendance and attainment. However, they don't drill down into causes of absence. In the Government's mind, 5 days absence due to a holiday is equivalent to 5 days over a year because of truancy and not wanting to go to school - which are 2 very different reasons.

Babetti · 08/01/2023 10:34

Absolutely do it!

My mum took us out of school for holidays during term-time in both primary and secondary school. I brought books and took some time out to study when we went in my teens but not in primary school.

As a single parent, she couldn't afford it during midterm breaks and I'm grateful that I had some amazing experiences that I wouldn't have had if she hadn't taken us out of school.

She puts huge value on education but she probably defined it more broadly than school work. Less so for skiing but she'd encourage us to keep travel journals, learn the language etc while we were away. No significant impact on our education - we all went to uni, have careers in our chosen fields etc.

If the alternative is your children not traveling and experiencing new things, absolutely take them out of school.

Nurserymumm · 08/01/2023 10:33

God no, their teachers have enough to be doing with the rest of the class. But I will research & print off extra resourses for them to add to the homework in the weeks leading up to the holidays.
They are flying at school & haven't missed a day yet this year. They are huge readers so they will be bring plenty of books to unwind in the evening, they'll be exhausted after ski school & spending the afternoon with DH & I on the piste..

OP posts:
MrsMiddleMother · 08/01/2023 10:31

I would absolutely take them out for holiday whatever the holiday unless they were studying their gcse's

Bluevelvetsofa · 08/01/2023 10:29

School trips are usually February half term. I went on one during the Easter break. So not during term time.

Abraxan · 08/01/2023 10:26

Murdoch1949 · 08/01/2023 00:44

You'll certainly save money but you'll also give a message to your children that attendance at school is unimportant. Be prepared for that to be thrown back at you when they want to slink off to Glastonbury or something else in years to come.

But most likely it would make any difference and the kids won't through it back at you at all.

Due to factory shut downs I and my siblings missed 1-2 weeks of school annually ti have a family holiday.

Every one of us continued to treat education seriously. We all stayed in in school to do further and higher Ed. We all have good degrees and value education. I teach and have done for several years, and installed good values into my own child - who is also training to teach within the U.K. school system.

My parents also valued education and although we missed school for holidays once a year we were expected to always value our education and try our best. We did and it had no negative inspect whatsoever. We do also all value our holiday time and family time too. And we all know that school is only one part of education , albeit a large part at times.

So we can say oh they can't miss x y z at school but reality is that, for the vast majority of children, missing a week or two once a year for a family holiday isn't going ti cause then any issues. 🤷🏻‍♀️