Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wondering how to refer to my sister's daughter now?

237 replies

LoveMyPiano · 07/01/2023 20:56

I always referred to her as my niece - but she is going into a sort of non-gender stage..... Her name is a very neutral one now. But I still cannot stop referring to her (them??) as my niece. Relation/ships are usually gender specific, and a bit hard to avoid using I have found, but I really don't want to offend. It is the "non-gender" bit that is causing me some difficulty.
Help......

OP posts:
WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 07/01/2023 22:58

Antst - You seem very keen on calling people drama queens, but who is really causing the drama? Is it the women who know that they are women/female, the men who know that they are men/male or the people of either sex who believe themselves to be too special for ordinary words and pronouns to apply to them - even when they are not present?

Would you also #bekind if I identified as a cat and started pooing on your doorstep every morning? There are already people who identify as trans-species, as well as the transrace and transage lot, so it's not a ridiculous scenario that could never ever happen, as it already has.

You can be flippant, you can try to paint yourself as a victim, you can make other people's genitals and gender about you. But the world has changed and people won't accept it.

How do you feel about it when certain 'transwomen' make their genitals about other people and use them to rape and assault women - not infrequently in women-only spaces that they've identified themselves into?

Antst · 07/01/2023 22:55

@WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll, none of that makes sense. I just don't understand.

You're creating problems where none exist. You're using people's most personal problems (that have zero to do with you) to wage a war against society. It won't work. I'm signing off now. You have the information and you've been warned.

UWhatNow · 07/01/2023 22:55

Well said @WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll

This ‘old people don’t get it’ eye rolling is just so tiresome. Normal people know that people can’t change sex and some of us don’t want to be strong armed into speaking bollocks.

What’s worrying on the thread is the undertone of ‘better be safe’ and ‘don’t get into trouble’… that’s how insidious and unkind this movement is… we are all scared to death to say the wrong thing to children who’ve been given too much power and entitlement.

Please be a grown up and resist. She is your niece and always will be. Refer to her as that.

Scurryfunge12 · 07/01/2023 22:53

This gender neutral / non binary bollocks is getting utterly ridiculous now 😂😂😂. For Christ’s sake what had the world come to?

85sarah2005 · 07/01/2023 22:49

"my sister's child" - it's only 2 extra syllables than saying niece and 1 more than nephew 🤷‍♀️

Sux2buthen · 07/01/2023 22:46

@Livingbyariver I don't think fully functioning is a requirement

Just ask OP. It's respectful to your sisters child and if it's a phase cool, they will appreciate the support. Same if it's not a phase

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 07/01/2023 22:45

Thanks for the advice, @Antst, but you seem to want to perpetuate the #bekind narrative and suggest that it's a simple case of one nice person wanting to change the rules and dictate to others how they must validate and affirm their beliefs and one or more nasty bigoted people who don't want to be forced to go along with it. They are 'special' and unique whereas the rest of us are just (as a PP brilliantly put it upthread) walking stereotypes. Every single one of us is non-binary, but we don't need to find special labels to replace the standard grammatically-correct terms used to identify us by the sex we happen to have been born.

I would never go out of my way to upset somebody, but equally, I don't wish to be told how to think and expected to deny plain reality. As we've discussed on countless MN threads, somebody wanting to start dictating to others that they must use grammatically-incorrect pronouns to refer to them when mentioning them to others is frequently the first step towards claiming that they ARE that sex. Once you play along, it's taken as confirmation that you do acknowledge them as something that they are not and then we all see where it ends up.

Granted, a female identifying as 'male' and then expecting free access to opposite-sex spaces is not as damaging/dangerous to others as the opposite way around (although it can be to the person in question); but you can't really accept one without the other.

I'm happy for anybody to believe whatever they want to believe, but I take issue with being expected to share, affirm and endorse their belief, when I most certainly do not.

Incidentally, how do you stand on people questioning their race or age and wanting to be officially recognised as one that they are biologically not?

Livingbyariver · 07/01/2023 22:43

In the name of the wee man….

it doesn’t need to be complicated

if the person has a fully functioning fanny, it’s niece
fully functioning dick, it’s nephew

Luana1 · 07/01/2023 22:42

LoveMyPiano · 07/01/2023 21:01

I don't see them - this is for when I am in conversation with another side of and wider family (some of whom are very limited in their views [LDS/Mormon]).

You don't have to subscribe to compelled gender speak when she is not even listening or aware, why would you?

underneaththeash · 07/01/2023 22:42

I didn’t bother when both my nieces went through that stage.

Both are back to being female now and my older niece has taken up my offer of getting her horrendous leg tattoos removed.

both of them have absolutely lovely girlfriends.

I Think life is very difficult for teenage kids now.

Notateacheranymore · 07/01/2023 22:42

For all those questioning niebling or nibling, a previous poster explained what it means in LITERALLY 3 words - equivalent to sibling, which is a word no-one queries.

Language is always evolving, only those stuck in their ways have an issue with that.

DdraigGoch · 07/01/2023 22:39

LoveMyPiano · 07/01/2023 21:01

I don't see them - this is for when I am in conversation with another side of and wider family (some of whom are very limited in their views [LDS/Mormon]).

So she's not going to hear about it? Just use "niece" then. It's not like she's actually told you to use anything else.

randomusername666 · 07/01/2023 22:38

LoveMyPiano · 07/01/2023 20:56

I always referred to her as my niece - but she is going into a sort of non-gender stage..... Her name is a very neutral one now. But I still cannot stop referring to her (them??) as my niece. Relation/ships are usually gender specific, and a bit hard to avoid using I have found, but I really don't want to offend. It is the "non-gender" bit that is causing me some difficulty.
Help......

'My sister's child'

SapphireSeptember · 07/01/2023 22:37

'Nibling' is how most of the people in my home county pronounce 'nibbling'. So that sounds daft to me.

LDS people aren't stupid. Some of us are pretty hot on this gender stuff, at least in my ward. I talk about it openly. I don't know how your religious side of the family are going to react to your niece claiming this gender identity though.

As someone assumed my own niece is non-binary as she's gender non-conforming, I'd honestly just stick to niece, or just use her name.

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 07/01/2023 22:37

I don't see them

Well if they don't seer hear you, just refer continue to refer to them as your niece. This is a non-issue.

Antst · 07/01/2023 22:37

@UsefulChocReindeer, you're being a major drama queen and it won't end well. My father was the same. It will come back to bite you.

You can be flippant, you can try to paint yourself as a victim, you can make other people's genitals and gender about you. But the world has changed and people won't accept it.

In every single one of these situations I've encountered, it's the stubborn old curmudgeon who ends up losing out. People will not accept your attitude. Family members and friends will start hearing from their kids and relatives that you're not to be invited anywhere. By the time you wake up, it'll be too late. Do as you will with that information.

HelpNeeded7 · 07/01/2023 22:36

Denise?

And de nephew?!

NZBride · 07/01/2023 22:35

Whoops - didn’t realise I had done that 😂 first post! Apologies

FaceLikeCattle · 07/01/2023 22:35

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

UsefulChocReindeer · 07/01/2023 22:33

I do advise you not to be stubborn on this. If you insist on calling people what they don't want to be called, you could cause serious problems. Don't say you haven't been warned.

I do think it would help you to sort this out to consider that you might really hurt someone who is struggling if you insist your way is right. Just make an effort to respect what people want to be. It costs you nothing and can help alleviate suffering.

Wow. Just wow. Listen up vipers! We've been warned: our language must at all times, even when the subject is not present, be correct.... or there will be consequences, serious problems!!!!

Tell you the truth @Antst my feelings get really hurt when reality is denied and I'm forced to go along with other people's beliefs, to not only respect their beliefs but compelled to speak and act as though I share those beliefs. So actually, yes, it does cost me something every time that I am forced into a position to be kind and alleviate someone else's suffering: it costs me honesty and pain.

Why does the respect never run in both directions? Why don't people respect my faith in science and biology and keep their gender theory to themselves? For example, I don't force Catholicism on anyone else, so don't force gender theory on me.

ofwarren · 07/01/2023 22:32

NZBride · 07/01/2023 22:08

Hello, so my almost 16 year old son has been dabbling in weed and possibly other stuff. I am not at all happy, his dad is like he’s a teenage boy - he’s going to experiment; but what am I best to do about it? I obviously love him and want the best possible life for him but he thinks I’m nagging but I just couldn’t bare it if anything happened to him!! Does anyone have any advice from being in a similar situation? Have you had a teen who did and gave up and is fine? The other worrying thing for me is weed is seen as the gateway drug, but it’s also 3 times stronger now than it was when I was younger! Thanks for reading.

You will need to create your own post for this or you won't get any responses

ofwarren · 07/01/2023 22:31

ecosystem · 07/01/2023 22:08

OK. I'm prepared to be shot down now - Yes, ask her what she wants to be called and call her that. BUT NIEBLINGS/NIBLINGS hahaha

🤣
Agreed

Wetblanket78 · 07/01/2023 22:30

How about my sister's gender neutral child? They are instead of she/her.

user1471453601 · 07/01/2023 22:28

@LoveMyPiano id refer to them in the way they wished to be referred to. Why would I want to hurt my siblings child, when they have done nothing to me/mine?

I think being kind, including using pronouns that an individual prefers, is the thing to do. Unless or until my siblings children did/do something hurtful then they deserve the respect of their wider family. And deciding they no longer wish to be referred to in the sex they were born in and me accepting that, is, in my mind, part of the respect I owe my family.

NerrSnerr · 07/01/2023 22:17

LoveMyPiano · 07/01/2023 21:01

I don't see them - this is for when I am in conversation with another side of and wider family (some of whom are very limited in their views [LDS/Mormon]).

I would just call them by their name. If it's someone from another side of the family who wouldn't know them if you didn't say niece I just wouldn't talk about them- especially if they're judgemental.

There's a lot I don't tell my in-laws about my family as they're just massive gossips and I know it's all shared as soon as we leave.