Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does anyone here work with challenging young people? Advice needed!

88 replies

JMSAD · 07/01/2023 18:31

Hello. I have name-changed for this, in case it's outing.
I very recently took a job in a high school, working in a base for children who need some time out of class and/or some nurture.
The children can be a challenge but have their lovely points too. I'm struggling with one child who is particularly cheeky, and who thinks it's acceptable to make comments on my age, personal appearance, clothes, personality ... just about everything really!
I realise they'll be testing the boundaries as I'm new. I generally ignore, stay calm, breeze over it. I'd really like to form a positive rapport with the child, but I'm finding it hard. It will take time, I'm sure. I just have to keep reminding myself that they are a troubled and vulnerable young person.
For those who don't work with children like this, telling them off won't work. That's why they're being sent to us in the first place! They are likely to escalate and chances are, won't really care anyway.
But I feel like I need some strategies to help deal with the behaviour. My colleagues seem to be really good at taking it in their stride. I suppose I do outwardly, but I'm struggling a little on the inside. And it does kinda hurt sometimes, as well as being embarrassing when they comment in front of others!
Maybe I'm cut out for this, maybe I'm not. But I'd definitely like to give it a good try.
I'd really appreciate your pointers. Or maybe you know of some good links.
Thanks so much Smile

OP posts:
NeedToChangeName · 07/01/2023 19:25

I think it's important to be authentic eg if they criticise your shirt, you might say "it's unkind to make a mean comment" or "oh well I'll know not to buy it for your birthday!" Either might be ok, but be true to yourself

BenoitBlanc · 07/01/2023 19:24

Am mildly amused by the people on this thread who seem to think that everyone working with vulnerable young people should have a PHD in applied psychology on top of intensive training and decades of experience. That would be lovely! The fact is that it's often low paid work and they'll take anyone who'll give it a go with the right attitude. OP sounds like you're a great person for the job - you are thoughtful, aware of your effect on others, and seeking discussion when you're not confident of your own judgement.

My own tips are:

  1. Don't take it personally. It's a job.
  2. Be professional.
  3. Be honest - "that's not nice. We don't talk to each other like that." and move on.
  4. On bad days I imagine I'm in a fly-on-the-wall documentary. Cameras everywhere, and thousands of people watching to see how I handle the situation. Works for me.
daisyjgrey · 07/01/2023 19:24

I work with post 16 care leavers residentially. You have to develop a very thick skin and an unwavering work persona, it takes time.

Also remember, occasionally you get one you can't crack, and that's not your failure.

Shuttlesandspinners · 07/01/2023 19:22

Reflective practice- take 10 minutes every evening (driving home was always my time) to think through your day, what happened, what you wanted the outcome to be, how you reacted, what informed your reaction (ie if he’s called you a fat bitch and you were upset- is your weight an issue to you? Do you need to do some work toughening up around that specific issue?), what worked and what didn’t, what you would change next time.

Remember they are individuals and while you may build a brilliant rapport with lots of them, some of them won’t gel with you and that’s ok, just continue to be kind and professional.

Join in with the (usually dark) humour of your colleagues, it’s a great way to decompress.

exLtEveDallas · 07/01/2023 19:21

I have the same sort of thing in a Primary setting. At first I would deflect by saying something like “fat? Well yes, I am, but I just love chocolate cake so much that it’s worth it” and “Ugly? Oh I know, sometimes I wonder why my husband puts up with it” but eventually as I got to know the children more I’d say “That’s not very kind, why do you think that you wanted to say that? Did I do something to upset you?”

After some time (and in some cases, years) the child would open up and tell me that they were angry / sad / tired / pissed off etc. Or they were reacting to something done or said by someone else. I’ve moved sideways now, but still have a number of these children come to me when they are kicking off because I let them be themselves and get it out.

If you get to the stage that you can show that you are hurt, you also need to ‘repair’ as soon as possible after. Don’t let things fester on either side, you need to forgive (even if you don’t really want to) so that you can both move on.

You need to grow a rhino skin. It’s also fine to have a weep in the toilets. The longer you are there the easier it comes.

As for training, the thing that helped me most was Thrive. I work in a Thrive school, but you can sign up as an individual I believe.

Redblanky · 07/01/2023 19:20

JMSAD · 07/01/2023 19:16

I agree that 'how are you?' is a bit lame. And will invariably lead to 'fine' as a response Grin

Yes, but that's not the reason we don't use it, it can be triggering unless the purpose of the session is to get to the bottom of how they are. E.g. miss doesn't really care how I am, I'll tell her she's fat. Or if miss had any idea just how rubbllish my life is she wouldn't ask such a stupid question, I'll throw that chair at her.

JMSAD · 07/01/2023 19:18

Oh, and I should add that most of my experience is in the Primary setting. I've worked with some challenging children there and developed extremely positive rapports over time.
It's just the teenagers that will take a little getting used to!

OP posts:
caramac04 · 07/01/2023 19:17

please take on board that it genuinely is not personal. The child may not even remember some of their remarks, it’s just blurted out and can show a measure of their anxiety with a new person.
They may well want to get to know you better but lack the social skills to have conversations which would allow them to do so.
They may be testing you as you are new to their ‘safe haven’.
Acknowledge their remarks but in a down to earth way and move on eg ‘Yes I have got a large nose, I got it from my dad. Now what are we doing here with this work?”
If it’s derogatory about for example, your clothing say “ Oh I really like this, what don’t you like about it? What colours/styles do you like?”
Chances are as they get to know you, the remarks will be fewer and/or they won’t upset your Give it some time and if you are genuinely still feeling ‘got at’ then maybe look to move on.

neverbeenskiing · 07/01/2023 19:16

mylittleyumyum · 07/01/2023 19:02

You should definitely read up on ACE's and Trauma Awereness. NOBODY should be working with 'troubled young people' without any kind of training and at least some knowledge of brain development.

I agree but the reality is that it is getting increasingly difficult to find decent support staff. We are struggling to fill vacancies because most people simply cannot afford to live on a school support staff wage in the current financial climate, and we can't afford to pay them any more. A few years ago competition for these jobs was fierce and we would be in the position of struggling to choose between a number of experienced, well qualified candidates. Now we're so desperate we're having to take on people we know are inexperienced and try to train them on the job, which isn't easy as everyone is so overstretched.

JMSAD · 07/01/2023 19:16

I agree that 'how are you?' is a bit lame. And will invariably lead to 'fine' as a response Grin

OP posts:
Redblanky · 07/01/2023 19:15

One thing we get taught which iis very powerful is to say "good morning, it's good to see you" rather than "how are you?" Which is really just a reflex question, but the honest answer will in most cases will be pretty rubbish.

Also "are you feeling wobbly? " (depending on the situation) means they/you can acknowledge how they're feeling without having to put a name to the emotions.

JMSAD · 07/01/2023 19:14

Thanks for the support and constructive comments to those who have offered them. It is really very much appreciated.

OP posts:
Goodgrief82 · 07/01/2023 19:13

NeedToChangeName · 07/01/2023 19:12

If a nurse posted for advice about dealing with challenging behaviour from patients, I do not think people would pile in to say they were in the wrong job

I don't understand some of the responses here

And if a nurse asked on AIBU how to take blood?

Caken · 07/01/2023 19:12

*Positive, not possible

NeedToChangeName · 07/01/2023 19:12

If a nurse posted for advice about dealing with challenging behaviour from patients, I do not think people would pile in to say they were in the wrong job

I don't understand some of the responses here

Caken · 07/01/2023 19:11

Speak with colleagues who have a good rapport with the child and see what works for them. Get some 1:1 time with the child and level with them? Find out what works - positive attention, praise, subtle check-ins rather than being constantly there etc. It’s different for everyone.

Honestly I find humour usually works with young people I work with. Obviously within reason and always keeping it appropriate!

Look for small wins, take them aside at the end of the lesson if they’ve done something good and praise them separately - some of the YP I work with don’t like or appreciate praise in front of peers. Or make a phone call home and let parents/carers know you’ve just started working with their child and you’ve been working with them and wanted to let them know they did a great piece of work today (only if they actually did, obviously!). It’s always nice to make/receive a possible call, especially for some of those who are more challenging and probably get negative phone calls home. When the phone call gets fed back to the child later they might appreciate it, if it cuts them some slack at home I’m sure they definitely will!

JMSAD · 07/01/2023 19:09

I have always worked in Education, but in a more mainstream setting. I haven't had training but am very keen to learn and get it right.
Thankfully I already do many of the things recommended on here: I take an interest and chat to them, I never would shout, I respond to them very positively when I see them, I praise them in a targeted and authentic way. And humour is an amazingly effective tool where appropriate!

OP posts:
neverbeenskiing · 07/01/2023 19:09

The child never presents as being upset.

For a child who has had adverse experiences, presenting as being upset can make them vulnerable. Some kids have very valid reasons not to trust adults. They might test you to see if you really care, or if you only seem to care when they're being compliant. They might reject you before you have a chance to reject them.

Ask for a 1:1 with your line manager and be honest about the aspects of the job you find challenging. They can't help you if they don't know you're struggling. Ask them if they are aware of any training you can access through the Local Authority or local Educational Psychology Service. There are usually courses in ACE'S, Trauma Informed practice or Protective Behaviors schools can access for free. Read about Emotion Coaching and Restorative approaches to behaviour, these things will help you in your day to day practice.

middleeasternpromise · 07/01/2023 19:09

Absolutely you can be trained to do this work but there is often a lack of investment in good training because this type of service is often underfunded. I would suggest you stay connected to your feelings but get interested in 'your' emotions - why does a young person in a difficult situation affect you so much ? Get curious about why they might want to say the things they do are they inviting you into a conversation about age, weight, gender - and how can you make that appropriate whilst also being authentic and ethical. Always work from your own regulation - if you get dysregulated you will not be in the best place to help young people who may be living with traumatic historys. So show them kind boundaries - that sounds like a hurtful kind of comment, I wonder why a lovely young person like you might say that ? Turn the invitation into an opportunity to share a positive message. Most young people in this position will already have been mistreated by adults, they may think it makes sense to provoke you as much as possible to see if you are just another professional that can't cope with them. The invitation then is to show them you absolutely can like the person but dislike the behaviour. Always keep the two separate so the young person has a sense that you see their potential not just the negative story or presentation.

NeedToChangeName · 07/01/2023 19:08

I really hope you have had some training on trauma. If not, it's unfair on you or the young people you are supporting

But everybody has to start somewhere and experience doesnt happen overnight

Check out Bruce Perry, Betsy de Thierry, Sue Gerhart etc

Dont take the children's comments personally. They are testing you. Prioritise safety. Be kind and consistent, but firm and fair. Pick your battles. Seek support from colleagues. Good luck

MrsVeryTired · 07/01/2023 19:05

Good advice from @Curioushorse above

Redblanky · 07/01/2023 19:04

What's your background OP, how did you come to this job? What sort of induction and training have you had? Do you have any peer support?

I don't object to you asking here, but it's very wrong that you need to.

JMSAD · 07/01/2023 19:04

Curioushorse · 07/01/2023 19:01

Pffft. Ignore the haters on here.

We have around twenty adults working in our school inclusion unit (it's a big school). Yes, ideally, you would have had some experience- but you can also just pick it up with enthusiasm. It is absolutely appropriate (even, good), for you to ask others for tips. There should be strategies people can suggest.

As a teacher, the book that had the most influence on my classroom behaviour management was 'Getting the buggers to behave'. But there will probably be some copies of behaviour management books lying around somewhere.

The things that I've found though:

  1. Kids want to be liked. They are testing boundaries and being unpleasant often because if they do that first they can say it's their behaviour you don't like, not them
  2. Humour diffuses a lot. Having a joke or making them laugh can turn a negative situation away
  3. You're not their friend, and they don't want to be your friend. Make it clear you adhere to school rules and expect them to as well. If they're from chaotic home backgrounds this will actually be very reassuring.
  4. Separate the behaviour from the person. Always say things like 'your behaviour is bad today', rather than 'you're bad today'
  5. Model the way you want them to treat you. Honestly, this sounds crazy, but it works. My school is a 'no shouting' school. Adults are strongly advised not to shout, and the effect on student volume is incredible. We are advised to model politeness and respect to students- on the basis that they may genuinely have never seen this at home. It works. So, things like, 'it's not appropriate to comment negatively on somebody's appearance', would be useful.

But, honestly, it's just experience and kindness.

Good luck!

Really helpful, thank you.

OP posts:
MrsVeryTired · 07/01/2023 19:04

Its tricky but like others have said don't take it personally.
I used to get called a fat bitch by one lovely lad Grin, I would say to myself (and colleagues in staff room later) "I think you mean medium to slim bitch, right?".
Outwardly "Oi don't be horrid, I don't speak to you like that" in a light way and swiftly move on.

mylittleyumyum · 07/01/2023 19:02

You should definitely read up on ACE's and Trauma Awereness. NOBODY should be working with 'troubled young people' without any kind of training and at least some knowledge of brain development.