Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does anyone here work with challenging young people? Advice needed!

88 replies

JMSAD · 07/01/2023 18:31

Hello. I have name-changed for this, in case it's outing.
I very recently took a job in a high school, working in a base for children who need some time out of class and/or some nurture.
The children can be a challenge but have their lovely points too. I'm struggling with one child who is particularly cheeky, and who thinks it's acceptable to make comments on my age, personal appearance, clothes, personality ... just about everything really!
I realise they'll be testing the boundaries as I'm new. I generally ignore, stay calm, breeze over it. I'd really like to form a positive rapport with the child, but I'm finding it hard. It will take time, I'm sure. I just have to keep reminding myself that they are a troubled and vulnerable young person.
For those who don't work with children like this, telling them off won't work. That's why they're being sent to us in the first place! They are likely to escalate and chances are, won't really care anyway.
But I feel like I need some strategies to help deal with the behaviour. My colleagues seem to be really good at taking it in their stride. I suppose I do outwardly, but I'm struggling a little on the inside. And it does kinda hurt sometimes, as well as being embarrassing when they comment in front of others!
Maybe I'm cut out for this, maybe I'm not. But I'd definitely like to give it a good try.
I'd really appreciate your pointers. Or maybe you know of some good links.
Thanks so much Smile

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
1982mommaof4 · 08/01/2023 14:36

Give it time OP, I work in residential care so get called a slag, cunt bitch and that's just to name a few... at first I felt like reacting but no reaction is better. They soon get bored if they aren't getting any attention

Good luck

BackAgainstWall · 08/01/2023 10:49

@JMSAD
I just want to thank you for this thread and to the posters that have really helped you by sharing their experience and techniques.

I’m a mum of a lovely 16 year old DS (still at high school), but he can be extremely hard to deal with at times (understatement) and this has really helped to guide and educate me.

Good luck with your career - I know you’ll be fine because you care.

SD1978 · 07/01/2023 21:17

If all to your college. Be honest about how you feel, how they appear to deal with it, and ask for strategies. You may find they feel the same but just ignore now. I'm a HCW- some of the names I've been called, and repeatedly,is foul. It appears not to bother me, but it's about experience and strategies- you learn them. It's different for you, and more intense, and you're at the beginning of your career. If you get on, your colleague is your biggest resource to learning how to strategies around the comments, because they will never, ever stop

FromTheFront2theBack · 07/01/2023 20:44

Ignore some of these comments op. Lots, probably most people struggle at first in this kind of.environmment. it's not indicative of not being cut out for this job. I don't think aibu is the best place for professional advice.

NotMeNoNo · 07/01/2023 20:41

I used to get a lot of negativity from my son. It's their low self esteem projecting out. I'd try and react with determined good humour so he'd say "your hairs awful" and I'd say something like bet your glad it's mine not yours! or yeah it's my superpower, awful hair. Really don't take it personally and lean on other staff for support. Try and build up relationship of trust with them and it will stop, hopefully. You need devious means to address the underlying issue not the superficial behaviour.

FrodisCapering · 07/01/2023 20:39

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request

Springblossom2022 · 07/01/2023 20:37

Springblossom2022 · 07/01/2023 20:33

Been where you are! It does get easier, I think I was easily upset in my first year but quite honestly they could say anything to me after that and it didn't bother me in the slightest 😂

Something I found helpful was joking about myself outwardly. Obviously be careful and do not take it too far. I'd just do it lightly so that they were aware that I didn't think I was gods gift and was quite happy with being the lady with the odd voice and poor fashion sense. For example if they made a comment on my outfit the next day I'd start with "am I dressed less like a granny today then? I really tried!" Or just embrace their comments (where appropriate, obviously!). Some girls once made a huge deal of me wearing socks over my tights in winter one day, so I deliberately did that every day going forward and used to say "when you get old like me you won't care how unfashionable it is".

Easier said than done when the comments are a bit worse than just about your outfit or something though, I totally get it. But having a bit of banter with some of them is okay providing it's what your setting supports. For example I'd often say "I might be x, y and z but I'm rather glad I don't go home and worry about keeping my Snapchat streak!"

Keep being keen to learn from others and you will find your own way. I left working with challenging young people a few years ago due to poor management from above but often miss it. Can't say I ever found it super easy, especially with some of the young people as there were some that were exceptionally clever and manipulative and really tried to get under your skin but you have to remember that it's not personal, if they weren't saying it to you they'd be saying it to another member of staff!

Quoting my own reply here! 😂 but just wanted to add that if they're being genuinely unkind to you then obviously don't laugh it off or anything, I used to say something like "hey, come on Alex, you know that's not nice, I wouldn't say that to you, would I?"

My reply was more for those silly teenager type comments and immature behaviour. If they're getting too much don't be afraid to seek support from other staff.

JMSAD · 07/01/2023 20:37

Fantastic tips, thank you Star

OP posts:
Grapewrath · 07/01/2023 20:33

It sounds like you’re doing great OP and your compassionate approach to this child shows you are more than capable of the job.
Ime, these kids are defensive as attack is the best form of defensive. Carry on being neutral and consistent- work eith unconditional positive regard for this child and try and connect with them on a one to one with no audience when possible anout something generic. Often, something like singling out a peice of work they’ve done well at helps- they are getting positive feedback but often handle it better than comments about them personally

Springblossom2022 · 07/01/2023 20:33

Been where you are! It does get easier, I think I was easily upset in my first year but quite honestly they could say anything to me after that and it didn't bother me in the slightest 😂

Something I found helpful was joking about myself outwardly. Obviously be careful and do not take it too far. I'd just do it lightly so that they were aware that I didn't think I was gods gift and was quite happy with being the lady with the odd voice and poor fashion sense. For example if they made a comment on my outfit the next day I'd start with "am I dressed less like a granny today then? I really tried!" Or just embrace their comments (where appropriate, obviously!). Some girls once made a huge deal of me wearing socks over my tights in winter one day, so I deliberately did that every day going forward and used to say "when you get old like me you won't care how unfashionable it is".

Easier said than done when the comments are a bit worse than just about your outfit or something though, I totally get it. But having a bit of banter with some of them is okay providing it's what your setting supports. For example I'd often say "I might be x, y and z but I'm rather glad I don't go home and worry about keeping my Snapchat streak!"

Keep being keen to learn from others and you will find your own way. I left working with challenging young people a few years ago due to poor management from above but often miss it. Can't say I ever found it super easy, especially with some of the young people as there were some that were exceptionally clever and manipulative and really tried to get under your skin but you have to remember that it's not personal, if they weren't saying it to you they'd be saying it to another member of staff!

JustAnotherManicNameChange · 07/01/2023 20:12

If possible, try and get as much information on the child's background as well. It will help you understand where they're coming from and possibly what's behind the behaviour .

If it's a mean comment just tell them it's unkind and move on.
If it's a rant, let them get it out and ignore.
If they're genuine /opinion comments that are simply rude then deflect with humour, or just acknowledge the comment with an "i know" or "ok", or if they're a manifestation of their lack of social skill explain that it's unkind and people can get upset by comments about their appearance, or disagree calmly and breezy "well, wearing cat shoes makes me happy even if you think they're silly". There are many ways to deal with it depending on the child and the circumstances.

It really isn't personal, it's a manifestation of whatever shit they're going through.

For example "fat" :

  1. They live in extreme poverty or an abusive/neglectful/chaotic household and are often starving. There's a jealousy/it's not fair anger element to the comment.
  1. They are bullied about their weight or often called fat (regardless whether they are or not) , but you are also fat and everyone seems to like you. Same as 1.
  1. Easy ,cheap shot because they're angry at the world, and hurt and in pain. It could also be ginger hair, glasses, freckles whatever. Whatever they can cling on.
  1. Testing you. Seeing how you'll react, if you'll give up, if you'll reject them,if you'll leave. This will happen a lot with children that have abandonment issues, that have had several caretakers /support people. No point in getting attached if you'll just fuck off like everyone else.
  1. Testing boundaries . Checking what they can get away with , your reactions , see what happens. This is used as a form of self protection/feeling in control and as a way to achieve a goal. Like the kids that piss off an adult and get sent away , which is easier than admitting they don't understand the work or find it too overwhelming.
  1. Genuine observation. Yes , rude but they don't necessarily understand that(at least not fully). They're just making conversation and weirdly, trying to engage.
  1. Actual concern . A really convoluted thought process where they're worried about your health and what that will mean for them.
  1. Actual anger at you or redirected at you. Because you're following school rules, because you've raised a concern , because you're getting too close to something they don't want to share , because they think you've wronged them in some way .

These are just a few examples of why I got called fat(and worse) even by kids that I have great relationships and bonds with. It happens.

JMSAD · 07/01/2023 20:11

Thanks again all!
I think @Goodgrief82 raised a fair point in that AIBU might not be the best platform to ask about this kind of thing.
However it is the busiest of the boards, and I am really glad I did ask. I am truly grateful for your responses. I can go in on Monday feeling a bit more 'armed' than before!

OP posts:
itsgettingweird · 07/01/2023 20:08

And even when you get used to it you'll still those days it gets to you.

I've been doing it 15 years. I'm actually in charge of behaviour management in my setting.

My mum died last year and a few months later I was dealing with something and a student said something that broke me.

I have an excellent relationship and I said I was sorry but I couldn't listen to it today.

Later on the came and apologised for upsetting me. I explained that their words upset me because I was having a sad day and talked about how I really wanted to react but didn't and it opened up a great conversation and realisation to the student that she isn't the only one with strong emotions she's dealing with.

No one expects you to be a robot - it's more understanding their behaviour is communication but there's nothing wrong with the, understanding others have feelings too.

IhateJan22 · 07/01/2023 20:04

I don’t agree with those saying you’re not in the right job. It takes time to become desensitised to comments made about you. Also takes time to work out what techniques will work, it’s not a one size fits all. I am talking from experience, I wanted to Jack it all in years ago but so glad I didn’t.

Volkswagenitalia · 07/01/2023 20:02

The challenging kids I work with are younger, but I remember not long after I started a colleague gave me the mantra 'there's a reason they are here'. It helped me to reframe things when things went wrong sometimes - if things were always perfect then they would he in mainstream. And you will learn to not take things personally!

The fact that you actually care is a big factor as well! Good luck, and ignore the idiots on this thread too, it's a tough job at times!

PurpleFlower1983 · 07/01/2023 19:56

You have to try and tell yourself that it is absolutely not personal. The more you react the more they will do it. Any attention is good attention for some of these children and they have barriers up that often prevent them from establishing positive relationships, usually because they have been let down badly in the past. They don’t trust adults because that’s what they know. You have to be the positive constant in their lives. Tell them calmly they you don’t like it when they speak like that but try and move on. Find out what their interests are and find some common ground. Good luck.

itsgettingweird · 07/01/2023 19:55

JMSAD · 07/01/2023 19:09

I have always worked in Education, but in a more mainstream setting. I haven't had training but am very keen to learn and get it right.
Thankfully I already do many of the things recommended on here: I take an interest and chat to them, I never would shout, I respond to them very positively when I see them, I praise them in a targeted and authentic way. And humour is an amazingly effective tool where appropriate!

Yes humour is an extremely useful tool.

One kid called me a geriatric fucking fat cunt once.

My response?

"I'm not that old I'll have you know" (neither was I fat but you get the idea of not being confrontational)

Thisgroupneverceasestoamazeme · 07/01/2023 19:54

20 odd years of working with challenging behaviour of various kinds and I would say the key bits of knowledge you would need are adolescent/children’s brain development, restorative practice and trauma informed practice.

key skills are:

  • ignoring button pushing behaviour like this. It’s intended to get a reaction and put you on the back foot. It can be driven by various things such as trauma, control, social and communication difficulties. Remember that all behaviour is communication, often for something the young person doesn’t have the words to articulate so it manifests in different ways.
  • validation: feeling/being heard, seen and understood will go along way
  • building a relationship/rapport. Be interested in them and get to know their interests, what they like to watch on TV, favourite sports players, musicians etc
  • being strength focussed with them and when speaking to them…frame things in the positive…say what you do want to see from them rather than what you don’t. Let them know what they can do rather than can’t.

I'm sure you demonstrated some fantastic skills just to get this job and get through the application and interview process. I went from working with SEND to children who have been abused and I felt like such a fish out of water at first. Some of the behaviour seemed shocking at first and now I’m more like your colleagues who have their Teflon coats on and the insults just seem to slide off. Good luck!

icelolly12 · 07/01/2023 19:50

Can you spend some one on one time with the child and explain why they shouldn't make personal comments to you? It sounds like they are showing off. If they do it again in front of a class I'd just say something like "we don't make personal comments in this classroom, lets get back to Shakespeare (or whatever) now" the worst thing you can do is let it get to you. Obviously if they are really out of line then go down the sanction route.

danni0509 · 07/01/2023 19:48

Goodgrief82 · 07/01/2023 18:48

Asking AIBU on mumsnet for advice re your job involving challenging young people
and fact you even comment your colleagues seem to stake in stride and handle

yes, because they are in the right job.

You, however, are not

I don’t think that’s fair.

She’s asking for advice on how best to deal with the situation.

Her colleagues were her once upon a time.

You learn through experience.

OP take some of the advice above. Can’t link back, but some good posts, particularly ‘whatmarbles’ post.

Don’t take it to heart (easier said than done, I know some comments can be utterly ruthless) stay professional and I’m sure they’ll get used to you and visa versa.

icanwearwhatiwant · 07/01/2023 19:40

For those who don't work with children like this, telling them off won't work. That's why they're being sent to us in the first place! They are likely to escalate and chances are, won't really care anyway.

So I do work with these sort of children and I definitely would challenge them.
There's a difference between being confrontational and challenge them to reflect on their behaviour though.

"James that's very rude, please apologise" will get you nowhere.

"I notice you are making a few comments about my appearance... I wonder why."

Said pleasantly and calmly may just get a better reaction.

Working with challenging young people is a balancing act, yes you need to build a rapport with them but you do also need healthy boundaries. They won't respect somebody who routinely lets them walk all over them.

That said, there's a world of difference between a child screaming and insult at the height of their crisis cycle... where challenging them will only worsen or prolong to cycle.

And a child who talks to you in that way even when calm, because nobody has put a boundary in place.

It's tough but worth it. Ask your school for training and for mentoring. Investigate courses for yourself that you would like to go on. Be proactive.

orbitalcrisis · 07/01/2023 19:39

Try not to think of the insults as being personal, they are honestly not about you, they're just trying to get a reaction. Ignore as much as possible, change the subject, a short joke then moving on can work. "That colour looks awful on you." "I'm an old woman, I'm pretty it's that and not the colour that's the problem. Now, back to...." Or even just letting them get it out of their system and saying "Finished? Now, back to..." And if you feel stressed and this would be allowed, stand up, leave the room, take a few deep breaths and then walk back in as if it never happened and start again.

Good luck.

JMSAD · 07/01/2023 19:32

Thank you so much for the kindness. I do care - like, really I do - and that's half the battle, surely.

OP posts:
Goodgrief82 · 07/01/2023 19:32

Am mildly amused by the people on this thread who seem to think that everyone working with vulnerable young people should have a PHD in applied psychology on top of intensive training and decades of experience.

yep, that is pretty much exactly what people are saying 🙄. Prone to hyperbole in every day life?

Redblanky · 07/01/2023 19:30

BenoitBlanc · 07/01/2023 19:24

Am mildly amused by the people on this thread who seem to think that everyone working with vulnerable young people should have a PHD in applied psychology on top of intensive training and decades of experience. That would be lovely! The fact is that it's often low paid work and they'll take anyone who'll give it a go with the right attitude. OP sounds like you're a great person for the job - you are thoughtful, aware of your effect on others, and seeking discussion when you're not confident of your own judgement.

My own tips are:

  1. Don't take it personally. It's a job.
  2. Be professional.
  3. Be honest - "that's not nice. We don't talk to each other like that." and move on.
  4. On bad days I imagine I'm in a fly-on-the-wall documentary. Cameras everywhere, and thousands of people watching to see how I handle the situation. Works for me.

All our staff get training in Trauma Perceptive Practice as part of their induction. The Deputy Head delivers it. Yes we take on inexperienced staff and don't pay them very well, but we do train them.