Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why some men stay single?

258 replies

Tandees · 07/01/2023 12:02

i had one of those moments yesterday where you thank your lucky stars you didn’t leave the house looking like shit. I was stood in the queue at Pret when I bumped into an old ‘ex’ of sorts. I was 18 when I met him at Uni, he was a 24 year old postgrad, played rugby, absolutely to die for. We had a very intense ‘friends with benefits’ situation for years. Didn’t see anyone else, did a lot together and he was just wonderful. I never pursued a relationship because he always gave the impression he didn’t want one. I broke off the arrangement 5 years later, by which time I was head over heels and heartbroken. Messed me up for a while but I later married a lovely uncomplicated man and am very lucky and happy with 2 children.

Fast forward, he’s just as gorgeous, very successful and single. We had a coffee and a nice catch up. He suggested meeting again but I declined and wished him well. Frankly I wouldn’t trust myself and I was amazed at how wildly attracted I was to him, but I guess that’s nostalgia for you.

I am however baffled that he’s never committed to anyone, even for a short time. I’m curious about this. He was raised by a single mother (who was an incredible self made woman who I met a few times and was absolutely in awe of) and had a dad who really did the dirty on them and he didn’t have much to do with them. I don’t know what the point of this thread is but I suppose I’m just curious about people who remain single. I don’t think for a moment that ‘coupled up’ people are happier necessarily but he was an incredibly affectionate, kind and enormously charismatic man. I’m surprised he wasn’t snapped up.

OP posts:
sammylady37 · 08/01/2023 15:06

Squisageandmosh · 08/01/2023 13:03

Well I think health statistics confirm that being lonely in old age is as bad for you as smoking.

All power to everyone on here who prefers a single life - long term marriage is not necessarily an easy option - but being lonely in old age is something else.

There’s a vast difference between being alone and being lonely. I firmly believe that being in the wrong relationship is one of the loneliest places one can be.

OutsideLookingOut · 08/01/2023 14:58

SnoozyLucy7 · 08/01/2023 14:54

I think we need to stop thinking that meeting someone, settling down, buying a house and having children is the ultimate end goal in life, the ultimate achievement, because it’s not. I remember my mother calling me very selfish for saying I would never want children, when I was younger.

You are allowed to be single and childless and have an amazing life for it.

What is odd is that it has never been strange for a small percentage of the population to be single. I forget the percentage in medieval times but it isn’t some modern phenomenon.

SnoozyLucy7 · 08/01/2023 14:54

I think we need to stop thinking that meeting someone, settling down, buying a house and having children is the ultimate end goal in life, the ultimate achievement, because it’s not. I remember my mother calling me very selfish for saying I would never want children, when I was younger.

You are allowed to be single and childless and have an amazing life for it.

Westernesse · 08/01/2023 14:32

Ah, so you form your views from reading the creme de la crème and totally representative male websites.

for every lunatic posting in these places there are probably hundreds of thousands or ordinary people just going about their lives.

I wonder when this will sink in with people.
Twitter is a cesspit, but it has about 300m members and only about 3m actually tweet the stuff you are reading. It takes a certain personality type to actually be these people and they are rare in comparison to the herd.

when we form our social views based on the amplification of social outliers, we are being deceived.

someone made a comment about how reading Mumsnet would put young men off women for life. There is a truth to that (it verges on being a hate site at times) but you have to quickly remember that the lunatics posting the visceral hatred of “the other” are the tiniest subset imaginable of the group they want you to believe they represent.

Soothsayer1 · 08/01/2023 13:55

@Silverpining
So kind of you to single me out for special attention 🥰🥳

Silverpining · 08/01/2023 13:49

Some of these comments are awful, especially @Soothsayer1 - who hurt you?

butterfliedtwo · 08/01/2023 13:08

Many people are lonely in marriages and relationships but don't feel they can leave, as it's 'too late. ' Alone doesn't automatically equal lonely.

Squisageandmosh · 08/01/2023 13:03

Thepeopleversuswork · 07/01/2023 16:11

@ily0

we are social beings designed to want to form close relationships. Don’t try and act like it’s abnormal to want a relationship

Says who?

We are designed (in evolutionary terms) to procreate, that’s true. And most people do need close relationships of some sort. But who decides that everyone needs to be married or cohabiting? That suits some people, others find it claustrophobic and stifling. It’s as individual as people are. Plenty of people find the emotional bonds they need outside of a cohabiting relationship. It’s not for everyone and people shouldn’t be made to feel dysfunctional if it doesn’t work for them.

Society has historically pushed most people into marriage for reasons initially of morality (to control women’s sexuality and fertility), and more recently financial reasons.

That doesn’t mean it’s natural” for people to want to marry. It’s largely societal pressure.

Well I think health statistics confirm that being lonely in old age is as bad for you as smoking.

All power to everyone on here who prefers a single life - long term marriage is not necessarily an easy option - but being lonely in old age is something else.

jumpingbean1810 · 08/01/2023 12:55

Thank you @5128gap that was incredibly eloquently put.

5128gap · 08/01/2023 12:00

jumpingbean1810 · 08/01/2023 11:41

I have been single most of my adult life. Dated lots in my 20s but became less and less frequent as others settled down and I didn't. I would have loved to have experienced real, lasting love and have spent many hours wondering what's 'wrong' with me. The longer you are single the harder it becomes to adapt to a relationship and I've now reconciled myself to the fact (at 50) that its not going to happen for me and to make the most of my life which is v blessed in so many other ways. I'm not sure its that different for single men.

If people in long term relationships were brutally honest, I'm sure many would admit it's not 'real lasting love' that holds them in their partnership. That often tends to be a romantic euphemism for a practical, mutually beneficial, pooling of resources, sustained due to habit, convenience and responsibility for children. A lot of marriages are far less about something being 'right' as oppose to 'wrong' with the people concerned and more to do with meeting a satisfactory person with similar life goals at the right time, and an understanding that most of us can more easily achieve some of our life goals in partnership.
I'm not so cynical as to dismiss the notion of love, some people make us so happy and meet our needs so well we love them very much. My point is, not needing or finding this from another person is not a personal failing or a pathology, as has been implied on here, and is not unique to single people.

jumpingbean1810 · 08/01/2023 11:41

I have been single most of my adult life. Dated lots in my 20s but became less and less frequent as others settled down and I didn't. I would have loved to have experienced real, lasting love and have spent many hours wondering what's 'wrong' with me. The longer you are single the harder it becomes to adapt to a relationship and I've now reconciled myself to the fact (at 50) that its not going to happen for me and to make the most of my life which is v blessed in so many other ways. I'm not sure its that different for single men.

ForfuckssakeEXHstopbeingatwat · 08/01/2023 09:40

OP you mentioned that you were surprised he hadn't been "snapped up" like he's a great bargain in the middle aisle of Lidl. He has autonomy and choice. Maybe there were a queue of women, like you, who would have snapped him up but he chooses a different route. That's allowed. It only makes him shitty and selfish if he chooses that AFTER marrying and having children and then buggers off. Given that's what his dad did, yes it's entirely feasible that he didn't want to risk doing that.

ZenNudist · 08/01/2023 09:38

Lots of men like this. I can think of at least 5 range from 35 to 50+ anyone under 35 still single there is time to settle down but these men are just happy being single. They aren't players or damaged or from broken homes. They just prefer the single life.

I don't know as many single women. Seems to be more of a stigma.

BabyTa · 08/01/2023 09:30

I know many who are almost/over 40 when they finally settled down (some never have) so he still seems 'young'- they just wanted to do other things in life first and a relationship isn't a high priority. I think a lot of people are just settling down later now or recognising you can take many other paths in life than a traditional one. Maybe bump into him in 10-15 years and give us an update then!

JudgeRudy · 07/01/2023 23:23

This

Lost123454 · 07/01/2023 22:59

Because they want to do what they want, when they want

They don't want to have to answer to anybody else, they are totally free

Thirty three years ago my parents split up and my dad has been single ever since. His life is all about him, he just does whatever he feels like whenever he wants and I can understand that

Not everybody needs to be in a relationship

Persephoned · 07/01/2023 22:52

BriceNobeslovesMurielHeslop · 07/01/2023 12:36

Being married and having children isn’t the only way to make a happy life for yourself, maybe he’s just satisfied with his life as is.

This! I do find it extraordinary when people struggle to even conceive the idea that others may want a different life to the one they have chosen for themselves!

VisaGeezer · 07/01/2023 22:43

I think some things can have a huge impact on your psyche when you're a child/youth. Things shatter your world as such, they are traumatic and people end up with this rather extreme view; my family fell apart so families will always fall apart.

More moderate people might alter that viewpoint as they get more mature however.

If he has not avd that's a major reason for him not settling with anyone to date; it suggests a type of immaturity or inability to amend/moderate his thinking (?)

VisaGeezer · 07/01/2023 22:40

*It's a strange reaction because his Dad/theyir Dads i.e. their sex is the one that's done the cheating and abandoning

VisaGeezer · 07/01/2023 22:38

When I first met him, he used to say he’d never get married because he didn’t believe in it after what his dad did

Well you kind of have your answer.

I got to know a foreign student in a shared house who reacted like that too, to his father's infidelity and "abandoning" of him and his Mum. He wasn't old then and i have no idea if he's changed his mentality but he was utterly utterly opposed to/evasive of any commitment. He would never get into relationships, just take whatever romantic and sexual opportunities he got and be clear he was not one iota interested in a relationship. He even sought out/seemed to specialise in attached young women - because he didn't want them expecting a relationship from him and thought they were "safer" as such.

It's a strange reaction because his Dad/they'd Dad's ie their sex is the one that's fine the cheating and abandoning .... So you could say that they shouldn't distrust women ... It's up to whether they trust themselves, and surely they'd not want to act like their Dad .. so why are they so down on marriage/serious relationships.

Do they think noone had any self determination or self awareness and it'll always end up falling apart.

Tandees · 07/01/2023 22:33

Was just such a shock to see him again I think. Thanks for all the comments

OP posts:
Tandees · 07/01/2023 22:32

Really interesting viewpoints. I’ve read about avoidant attachment. Think I was a bit like that at one point on reflection actually 🤔 I think this is it. He hadn’t changed at all, perhaps I haven’t either and we actually always stay the same throughout our lives. He was very affectionate and considerate, was such a head fuck at the time and if I could go back I’d never have met him. Over it now (doesn’t seem like it I know 🤣) but hard to convey in writing on an anonymous forum.

OP posts:
SofiaSoFar · 07/01/2023 22:32

What a thread.

So many women on here are able to diagnose "men" (not some men, many men or a number of men, it's all of them apparently...) as having the same wants, desires and pleasures in life.

They are abusive, failures, ugly or cheats if they (all men, remember) don't want to be in a long term relationship.

We've also learned that "most men" want children, too. Contrary to what I, and DH, know of our friends, family, colleagues etc.

It's good to see how much MN, en masse, knows about men that apparently they don't know about themselves. It must be great to be so sure of your own opinions that they actually become 'fact' rather than, well, just opinions.

YouAreNotBatman · 07/01/2023 22:09

I forgot to write that if single people have something wrong with them and that’s why they aren’t in relationship, then by that lohic it would be fair to say that coupled up people are co-dependent.

See, doesn’t sound very nice, does it?
And it’s so rude also.

cheshirebloke · 07/01/2023 22:04

In my experience there are two types of long term single men. First there's the sort like this bloke who are good looking and know it, and because they are never short of options they never feel any need to settle. Then there's the other kind - the blokes who don't have casual partners or proper relationships of any sort, usually they have a lack of self confidence. Both types tend to be very independent, sometimes to the point of being solitary.